Adam Alter on the Business of Keeping Us Hooked

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

More: http://knlg.net/2mQYUHL

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] hi everyone thank you very much Adam for inviting me thank you to Wharton for
  2. hosting me so uh my name is Adam alter I'm a professor of uh psychology and marketing at NYU at Stern and this book
  3. is about addictive Tech and the rise of addictive Tech and the role that's playing in our lives the outsized role
  4. and I became interested in this topic about 3 years ago so when two things happened the first thing that happened
  5. was I read about this guy this guy's dong win he's a Vietnamese game developer and he designed a game that I
  6. could not stop playing um this is the game I don't know if any of you have played this game anyone having
  7. flashbacks this is Flappy Bird it's the simplest game in history all you have to
  8. do is make the bird not fly into walls it's incredibly straightforward but it's also massively addictive so nen designed
  9. this game and it was it was very very popular it took a little while to take off but when it did take off it did very
  10. well at its peak he was earning $50,000 a day in ad Revenue which is not shabby if you're an independent game designer
  11. so he designed the game and I started playing it I found it very hard to stop and I got curious about it and I
  12. wondered if there was something about the game that made it hard to resist so I started to read some of the reviews
  13. for the game and they were really interesting so they there were this interesting mix what you see here
  14. is it's it's a it's a glowing review five stars is what you're looking for but it also is killing this person
  15. person which is a weird it's a really weird tension so this person says Flappy Bird will be the death of me let me
  16. start by saying do not download Flappy Bird keeping in mind this person gives it five stars um and they basically go
  17. on saying I went to the App Store I downloaded it that was my first mistake I played it once and said okay just one
  18. more time uh that one more time never ended I don't sleep I don't eat I'm losing friends all because a Flappy Bird
  19. so tremendous game um and what happened in the end was n had a conscious he grew a conscience and he
  20. felt so bad about it that despite the massive ad Revenue he pulled it from the App Store it was the number one game on
  21. the App Store he pulled it and he basically tweeted I'm sorry Flappy Bird users I will take Flappy Bird down I
  22. cannot take this anymore it is not anything related to legal issues I just cannot keep it anymore I also don't sell
  23. Flappy Bird please don't ask people were desperate there was like a black market
  24. for Flappy Bird so something here was going on with this this game and I'd played it for hours and hours on my
  25. iPhone now the second thing that happened paired with this suggested that there was something systemic going on
  26. here and what that was was I started to read a little bit about how Steve Jobs thought about the iPad as a delivery
  27. device and when he introduced the iPad in 2010 he said what this device does is extraordinary it offers the best way to
  28. browse the web way better than a laptop way better than a smartphone it's an incredible
  29. experience so that's obviously a glowing review of the product but at the same time when he was asked in 2012 what he
  30. thought about the iPad with respect to his kids this is Nick Bilton a tech writer for the New York Times Bilton
  31. said to him so your kids must love the iPad and job said they haven't used it we limit how much Tech our kids use at
  32. home so on the one hand he thought it was a wonderful device that's what he was telling the world but on the other
  33. he was really concerned about having this device in his home he didn't want to give it to his kids which is
  34. concerning perhaps because he knew that if they got hold of Flappy Bird it would
  35. be the end of them so something is going on here and what's interesting is beyond
  36. Steve Jobs other Tech Titans have said similar things so this is a school called the waldor school school of the
  37. peninsula which is uh in the Bay Area and there's something really interesting about this school it's one of the few
  38. schools around the country now that mandates a complete Tech ban no computers no iPads no iPhones nothing
  39. but what's really interesting about the school is that 75% of the kids there have parents who are SE Silicon Valley
  40. Tech execs so these are people producing Tech and yet saying that their kids should go to a school where there is no
  41. Tech they realize that something is going on here and you know they're right to have those
  42. concerns there's a lot of research suggesting that these concerns are well founded here's one of my favorite pieces
  43. of evidence a whole lot of people of roughly your age in their 20s and 30s were asked if you had to choose between
  44. a broken bone and a broken iPhone which one would you choose this is what they said
  45. 54% said a broken phone which left 46% saying broken leg and what's really interesting about this is when you watch
  46. them make the decision even the people who say I'd have a broken phone agonize they spend time it's not like a snap
  47. decision where it's easy for them to make because these devices are so instrumental in their lives they know
  48. that not having them will be a really massive psychological pain for them um and so you you have this crazy statistic
  49. one of the reasons people say this by the way is they say while I'm recovering from my broken bone at least I'll have
  50. my phone to keep me company so that's concerning but let me give you a sort of bigger more reliable
  51. data set uh this is a program called moment you can all download moment for your phone some of you may have it
  52. already it's designed by a guy called Kevin Kevin holes from Pittsburgh and he designed it because he felt that he was
  53. spending too much time on his phone it measures how long you spend on your phone every day and how many times you
  54. unlock your phone so basically he AB tested it with his friends and he asked them how long do you think you're
  55. spending on your phone and his friend said about an hour and a half on average turns out they were spending an average
  56. of 3 hours a day on their phones which is pretty striking and and what that means is if you look at the waking hours
  57. in the day for the average person the dark blue is the hours we spend at work the light blue is the
  58. hours we spend doing survival activities like eating and bathing which leaves the
  59. white bit and that's the bit that you can do lots of interesting things with or you can fill it with the black bar
  60. which is how long we spend on average on our phones now so that's we're left with
  61. that little sliver of white to engage with other people to have social interactions to talk to our loved ones
  62. to do the really important things in life we're not leaving ourselves much time to do that stuff because phones get
  63. in the way 3 hours a day on average for people so this is a problem now all of this falls under the banner of
  64. Behavioral addiction behavioral addiction is basically the drive to engage in some Behavior that's rewarding
  65. now but that has really strong negative consequences in the long run and they can be in a lot of different spheres
  66. they can be physical mental So Physical if you do say you play games for 45 days
  67. straight as one person I'm going to tell you about did that was bad for him he put on 40 pounds of fat because he
  68. didn't move um mental social Financial social because our relationships break down and financial obviously because
  69. people overshop and they don't work as much as they should and there are a lot of different kinds of experiences that
  70. fall under this Banner there are things like um compulsive use of phones emails social networks uh video games overwork
  71. OV exercise compulsive shopping gambling and what's interesting about this is if
  72. you want to know how many people in the population at large have at least one of
  73. these issues you may feel that you have one of them there was a study published in
  74. 2011 U Mark riffi British researcher found that as of 2011 41% of all adults have at least one behavioral addiction
  75. and he predicted that number would rise and I'm sure now six years later that it
  76. has risen significantly it's probably over the 50% mark because now iPads have really taken a hold and when you ask
  77. people who work in behavioral addiction treatment they all say the biggest thing
  78. to happen in behavioral add ition was first the Advent of the iPhone and then second the Advent of the iPad so I think
  79. that number is probably risen so let's talk about what you can do about this um there are a few things that probably
  80. won't work cold turkey is one of them if you search cold turkey there actually is a cold like a a cold turkey
  81. you have that option there on Google Images which is nice um so cold turkey doesn't work for a lot of reasons one of
  82. them is that you can't function in the world and not use Tech it's just very hard you can't work or it's very hard to
  83. work it's very hard to travel it's hard to just go about the business of everyday life not to mention the social
  84. consequences of not using Tech so cold turkey is tough also um if you stop using Tech the motives that that Tech is
  85. is dealing with for you so let's say you are looking for social connection if you
  86. don't get that social connection through Tech you're going to need to find it somewhere else or soothe yourself some
  87. other way so there's some evidence that if you try not to use Tech just going cold turkey you end up developing other
  88. forms of addiction to compensate so that's dangerous the other thing you can't do in the long run is one of my
  89. favorite techniques this is min SEI and uh he's a tech entrepr entrepreneur who lives in New York and he went on
  90. Craigslist and he advertised for a position that he paid uh a significant sum of money this woman was paid to
  91. follow him around and when he did something he didn't want to do she was paid to slap
  92. him so so she punished him every time he opened his Facebook or his email and here you can see that that form of
  93. punishment in action he ended up designing a device that I he sent to me it costs $500 you wear it on your wrist
  94. and you can program it to give you a zap when you do something you shouldn't be doing it is so incredibly powerful that
  95. I hit the roof when I first use it so I've never used it since but people who do use it swear that it works really
  96. well but I don't think that's a long-term solution either so here are some things you can do one of them is
  97. basically a series of techniques known as behavioral architecture the that just as an architect creates a building or
  98. designs a building you can design your own life in such a way that you can minimize harm and maximize good so here
  99. are some things you can do with respect to tech one of the things you can do is for part of the day remove it from your
  100. life completely so what I've tried to do is between 5:00 p.m and 8:00 p.m. I put
  101. my phone in a drawer and I Don't Go Near it same with my iPad I try not to use the
  102. TV um so I try to remove Tech Al together for part of the day that's one option but some tech is going to be with
  103. you and so you need to make sure that you do whatever you can to minimize the pull of that text so here's one thing
  104. you can do I don't know if you heard that it was subtle but there was the ding sound that a lot of us have when we
  105. get a new email and that for us ignites a set of responses that makes us feel really good most of the time it's a sort
  106. of reward response so one thing to do is to turn that sound off that's pretty effective another thing you can do is
  107. turn off all notifications on your phone because what you're doing then is your resting control from your phone and
  108. you're you're taking it yourself you're deciding when to go to the phone because
  109. if you have push notifications your phone is guiding you which is the opposite of what you want to happen
  110. another thing to do is to make sure that your homepage on your phone doesn't have
  111. any of those addictive apps for you if it's Twitter or Instagram or Facebook or whatever it is remove them put them in a
  112. folder in the third or fourth page and make sure that you type in the search bar the name of that app because that's
  113. a willed behavior that basically means that the only time you will go to this device is because you you've willed it
  114. you've decided that it's something that should happen it's not that the the app or the icon is reminding you to check it
  115. which you'll do reflexively uh and the fourth thing you can do this is a little small but if you look at the bottom
  116. there this is a Facebook post you can see this person has 10 likes three shares and seven comments there's a a
  117. program now known as a the Facebook demetricator which removes all the numbers so if you look at what happens
  118. when you activate the demetricator it doesn't give you numbers it just tells you that these things have happened but
  119. not how much and so you don't obsessively return to check over and over and over again it's proven to be
  120. pretty effective so those are some things you can do um also at the cultural level there are some things we
  121. should do and this is a bigger conversation obviously one of them is exemplified in the behavior of this
  122. design firm in Germany they have tables that are Tethered to the ceiling and at 6 p.m. every day no matter what you're
  123. doing the tables rise to the ceiling and the place the place turns into a yoga studio so You' better be finished with
  124. your work you have no option so that's one thing we could do is sort of mandate that work ends at a particular time or
  125. do our best to do that another thing we can do is you know a lot of businesses when I tell them this say we obviously
  126. want our programs to be addictive because that's how we compete in the marketplace well here's one solution
  127. these 100 calorie packs in the food industry are very popular people will basically pay more to buy less food
  128. because what they're paying for is self-control they're Outsourcing self-control to the companies that make
  129. the food now if if social media platforms offered are slightly more expensive I guess they're currently free
  130. but if they said for 10 bucks a year you can get a version of this platform that
  131. has fewer of the hooks that will addict you effectively you're resting they're resting self-control from you and doing
  132. it for you people would pay more for that so the businesses might be happy and you would get a better version of
  133. the program that's one option and finally there are people who are known as design ethicists at these big
  134. companies and a lot of them believe there should be a hypocritic oath for Designing Tech that just as doctors are
  135. supposed to do no harm when you're designing Tech you should make sure that you consult with behavioral experts who
  136. explain to you what you should be doing to minimize the addictive hooks that are
  137. conveyed in these products and the last thing is to understand what it is that makes you addicted in the first place
  138. because addiction isn't just about that rise in dopamine it's not just about taking the drug or doing the behavior
  139. it's what it does for you it's what it soothes and this is Isaac viberg he's uh a gamer from way back he's a straight A
  140. student he did very well in school he played football he was kind of the the All American guy
  141. and things went wrong for him when he started playing World of Warcraft there 100 million people who've
  142. played this game and signed up for accounts half of them have developed addictions it's probably the most
  143. addictive experience in the world um and Isaac had a real problem with this he's
  144. the guy who spent 45 days playing and the key for him was to work out what it was that was driving that so some people
  145. play World of Warcraft because they're bullied and it allows them to choose a really dominant Avatar and so they do
  146. really well they feel better because they've got a dominant Avatar That Conquers missions and does does really
  147. well on missions um other people are lonely and so they form Guilds of friends on the platform and for him that
  148. was the main thing and so he realized that if he could cultivate social a social life outside of the game he that
  149. addiction would would wither away and that's what happened for other people it's about low self-esteem and
  150. conquering quests it makes them feel efficacious and so the key is to work out what is the underlying psychological
  151. issue that you soothe with these behavioral addictions and the biggest thing I think of all is nature it's the
  152. anti- behavioral addiction it's the perfect place to go it's sort of anywhere where you go where you have no
  153. idea what year it is is a good solution and so I think that's that's the biggest
  154. cure of all thanks very [Applause] [Music] much

Brief Summary

Adam Alter discusses addictive technology, focusing on Flappy Bird and strategies to combat tech overuse.

Key points

  • The Addictive Nature of Flappy Bird. Flappy Bird, a simple game, became a massive addiction for many players.
  • Steve Jobs' Tech Dilemma. Despite praising the iPad, Jobs limited its use for his children.
  • Behavioral Addiction Statistics. A significant percentage of adults struggle with behavioral addictions, predicted to rise.
  • Tech Addiction Solutions. Strategies to combat tech addiction include removing notifications and limiting device access.
  • The Role of Nature in Healing. Nature serves as a remedy for behavioral addiction, providing a necessary escape.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes