AI and Creativity: How Generative AI Helps Create Ideas but Yields Similar Outputs

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE AI tools like ChatGPT are reshaping creative work, offering individuals a boost in generating novel ideas—but also raising concerns about originality at scale. Wharton Professor Gideon Nave discusses his research shows that while these models can enhance personal creativity, they often lead to more uniform outputs across groups, reducing diversity of thought. This "sprinkler effect" highlights the tradeoff between efficiency and true innovation in competitive environments. Companies already experimenting with AI-driven creativity may find short-term gains, but long-term challenges in maintaining unique perspectives.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#ArtificialIntelligence #AI #GenerativeAI #GenAI #Innovation #AIFuture ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney: We obviously have seen a rise in the use of things like ChatGPT in the last couple of years, but one of the
  2. questions now being asked is, can you use AI to help with the brainstorming of ideas? Gideon Nave was part of a research
  3. project done on the topic. He is an Associate Professor of Marketing here at the Wharton School. Gideon, great to talk to
  4. you again. How are you, sir? I'm well, Dan. It's really hot outside, but we are in a nice
  5. fresh air-con here at Wharton. So. Absolutely, absolutely air conditioning is nice at this
  6. time of the year. Hey, let's start, I guess, with the genesis of the idea. And is part of this kind of the transformation
  7. we're all going through in understanding just how much we can use things like ChatGPT, and in what areas, and maybe
  8. what areas we can't use them? Well, you know, the work we've been doing recently was about
  9. creative tasks. Our creative task, I would say the goal of them is to come up with something that is novel, unlike
  10. more routine tasks of, you know, just maybe translation, right? Translation, you have a sentence, you will translate. It
  11. doesn't have to be surprising in any way. It doesn't have to be novel. You know, finding new ways to do translation is a
  12. creative task. And when we talk about creativity, we talk about things that are novel and useful. That's— you know, people
  13. don't seem to agree on the definition, but when people see something that is creative, they do seem to agree that it is
  14. creative. I've been teaching creativity at Wharton for a while. Even during the time when ChatGPT came out, I was in the
  15. middle of class, and I even got to do like a live demo of it at the time. And actually what I remember in this class, I
  16. actually demonstrated to people, to my students, how you can use GPT to just write an email to your professor. And I wrote an
  17. email where you write an excuse to the professor, like, why did you— why did you not submit your homework in time. And one of
  18. the students said, "Hey, ask it to write a creative excuse." And GPT did it well. It came out with the idea that, you know, my
  19. project turned out into something that seemed like a product, and I was working very hard to do it, to get it
  20. into market, and I missed the deadline, right? That's very, very creative. And that's the old GPT, the first one that
  21. came out. So— and we know that these models have a tendency to hallucinate. Meaning, to come up with new stuff when— and pretend
  22. that they know it. So for this, for creative tasks, it's actually pretty useful and cool. And these models are trained on
  23. a lot of human thoughts, expressions, emotions and whatnot. So we definitely see a great potential here. And some
  24. companies have been doing it too. Coca Cola, for example, used the AI to come up with, you know, a new flavor that is like
  25. the year 3000 and so on. The thing is that as scientists, we— what we want to do is go beyond these anecdotes and try to
  26. systematically understand what's going to happen if all of us are going to start using AI for our creative processes.
  27. And realistically, when you're talking about the link between creativity and what companies look for, in many cases, that's
  28. a core element of their operation. They have to be creative in order to be able to take that next step in their
  29. success level. - When you're in a competitive market, obviously, like, creativity
  30. is key. You want to do something that your opponent cannot do, and you want to— you want to beat your opponent,
  31. whether it is as a company that tries to compete with others, whether it is an employer that competes for promotion, and so
  32. on. And in this sense, creativity is an ever-moving goalpost, right? If I tell you a joke now that you've already
  33. heard, that's not going to be funny. If I tell you a joke that has the same principle that you may have already heard about,
  34. maybe, maybe it has a chance. And in this sense, you know, maybe getting the principles of a joke like, sometimes you kind
  35. of build something, and then you break a pattern, that will be— maybe a joke like this could work.
  36. So you mentioned Coca Cola, Gideon, about how they use it. How much expectation should we have that companies are already
  37. using AI to enhance the creativity that they have? You know, many companies are using it already. And what
  38. we as scientists try to do is to try to go beyond these anecdotes and get into real science and see, what is going to happen if
  39. everybody is going to use the same model, such as ChatGPT? It's very possible that the new AI is going to give you an edge. But a
  40. non-specific AI is kind of the very start. And that's where we come to the study that we recently published. So a study
  41. published in <i>Nature Human Behavior</i> about four or five months ago did an experiment where they gave people various
  42. creative tasks, such as coming up with a novel use for a garden hose and a rocket, or coming up with— with ideas to
  43. buy for an 80-year-old birthday. And they did— they randomized people into groups that either could use Google searches or
  44. ChatGPT, and they just compare the creativity of the people who used the former versus the latter. And they found that the GPT
  45. increased the creativity, overall, of every person. What we did, though, is, once we reanalyzed their data, we found that GPT
  46. indeed increased the creativity of every individual, but it made also everyone more similar to one another. And if this is the
  47. case, we actually end up with less new ideas as a group. Okay? So it's kind of like a prisoner's dilemma, where it's
  48. the benefit of everyone to use the GPT. They, on average, become more creative. But then, as a global company, as a society,
  49. we're going to become more similar to one another, and then we're going to actually smother creativity.
  50. And do you potentially end up losing, you know, the individual creativity? Because how one person is creative compared to
  51. another is most likely different. And you're coming now with a more kind of steady path, straightforward path, of the
  52. same types of creativity if you're relying on ChatGPT. Exactly. On the long run, I think that once all of the ideas
  53. are available to everyone, I'm pretty sure that, like— we call it the sprinkler effect. Like, the one use that GPT came up as—
  54. for garden hose and rocket ball, is to make sprinklers from it. It's an idea that is great. It's useful, it's novel, and it's
  55. rated highly. But if I'm a manager, I'm going to get 50 different proposals of what to do with that. And 20 of them are
  56. sprinklers. I'm probably not going to judge the people that came up with the sprinkler as more creative, even though, you know,
  57. if I get one sprinkler it seems like a great creative idea. So I think we need to be careful here.
  58. So this is very much like a lot of things around AI right now. We're kind of testing where it's taking us, but we still have to
  59. be wary as to where it's going to take us down the road. I think that one— you know, initial promise of studying AI was to look at the
  60. individual and how it makes the individual more X, Y or Z. When it comes to— when it comes to productivity in maybe routine
  61. tasks, it makes sense. When it comes to creativity— but creativity is always measured against the prior art, against
  62. what everyone else is doing. Using GPT in a conventional way is going to make you look conventional, because everybody
  63. is going to use it the same. Even though, you know, if you're the only one using it, it will make you look like a superstar
  64. creative person. But we're talking here about technologies that is available to everyone. So there are risks here. And one
  65. of the emphasis in my class— my creativity class, I fully endorse AI. So I wouldn't say that, you know, don't use AI.
  66. But there are ways to use it, and there are smarter ways to use it than just asking it, "Hey, come up with a creative solution
  67. to me, for my problem." Gideon, great to talk to you again. Thanks very much. Always, Dan. Thank you.
  68. Thank you. Gideon Nave, Associate Professor of Marketing here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Gideon Nave discusses AI's role in creativity, highlighting its benefits and risks of homogenizing ideas.

Key points

  • The Role of AI in Creativity. Gideon Nave explores how AI tools like ChatGPT can enhance creativity but also homogenize ideas.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes