How Summer Job Programs Can Help Save Lives

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton professor Judd B. Kessler and his co-authors looked at the New York City summer youth employment program to learn if it delivered the hoped-for outcomes. More: http://knlg.net/1IBTbxG 📂 Health Care Management;Public Policy 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. the paper is about the Summer Youth Employment Program in New York City uh we have data from 2005 to 2008 and one
  2. of the nice things about the program is that applicants who apply get lotteri in
  3. to have access to a summer job this is great for research purposes because we can compare basically identical people
  4. uh one of whom happened to get access to a summer job and one of whom did not uh
  5. and we can follow them uh from the year that they participate or don't participate uh up through 2014 and we
  6. match the data from the Summer Youth Employment Program with tax data IRS administrative data uh and data from the
  7. a New York State uh Department of Corrections and Community Supervision we're able to see the outcomes both for
  8. earnings College enrollment incarceration and mortality for the Youth who participate and who do not
  9. so there's three rationals to have summer youth employment programs and many cities have these uh New York the
  10. one we analyzes the biggest one in the country um but the three rationals that people give one you want to give youth a
  11. leg up uh give them better access to jobs in the future uh the second one is that um you want to transfer money
  12. directly to youth in the year of the program so basically put money into the hands of low-income kids and the third
  13. is that you want to keep you out of trouble and putting them in a job uh might might help that so we analyze uh
  14. the data to see if we could answer is the program doing each of accomplishing each of these three goals and the
  15. takeaways are it certainly is transferring money to low-income youth because in the year of the program the
  16. people who get access to the jobs earn significantly more than people who don't so it's it's not as if the program is
  17. giving jobs to people who would have gotten jobs otherwise the second uh rationale that we're putting youth on a
  18. better path so that they can earn more money in the future we actually don't find any evidence of that in the 3 years
  19. following the program the youth earn a little bit less if they had participated in the program so we investigate that uh
  20. in a little greater detail because it was a little bit surprising to us um and basically we find that what what matters
  21. is what job they get placed in in the summer of the program because the job that they take in that summer that they
  22. get in that summer tends to be sticky they take similar jobs like that so the youth who end up being Camp counselors
  23. or working in daycare centers they tend to gravitate towards those kinds of jobs
  24. in the future and those jobs uh on average earn a little bit less than other jobs we find no evidence that the
  25. summer job lets them or uh helps them go to college at higher rates so we don't see any effect on College enrollment um
  26. but by the fourth year after the program they're earning the same as the people uh who did not participate um so we
  27. don't find great evidence on helping them uh earn more money later on but we find very strong effects uh on keeping
  28. the youth out of trouble and we actually find that the youth who get lottery into
  29. to participate are more likely to be alive in 2014 and less likely to be incarcerated in New York state
  30. prison so one of the most surprising things for us was uh the mortality and incarceration results because that was
  31. something that we were able to analyze because we had so many youth applying over the course of four years and we
  32. could follow them for a long time other papers that study similar programs hadn't been able to look at so many
  33. people for so long uh so we were particularly surprised about the mortality results that in essence the
  34. program saved about 20 lives per year over the four years that we studied um that turns out to be quite important
  35. when you think about is the program uh are the social costs of the program and the social benefits of the program how
  36. do how do we compare those uh because when you save lives there's lots of value uh social value that you're
  37. creating uh from the program the great thing about this project is that it is the real world uh
  38. the youth uh that these programs exist in New York City and and cities across the country and so the results of the
  39. paper I think help give a sense of of what the programs are actually achieving and
  40. maybe you know should they be expanded which groups should they Target in the paper we go through and show the
  41. mortality incarceration and earnings results for different subgroups maybe it's worth uh targeting the programs or
  42. trying to reach out to youth uh For Whom the benefits are are greater when people think about the
  43. summer youth employment programs that exist they often think that the main contribution of the programs is helping
  44. people get jobs uh one of the things that we find that's that was so surprising to us is that in fact a lot
  45. of the benefits acrew on these other dimensions of keeping youth out of trouble uh keep putting them on a safer
  46. path so they uh might have a different group of friends because they participated in the program and those
  47. friends might uh keep them out of trouble and and keep them alive uh and so thinking about all
  48. the ways in which the summer youth employment programs can help uh these youth is something that people policy
  49. makers and others should keep in mind one of the nice things about the uh data that we have to analyze is just how
  50. many people we're able to look at so we actually are following 200,000 Unique Individuals uh do submitting 300,000
  51. applications some people apply in multiple years and having so much data allows us to talk about very rare
  52. outcomes like mortality which thankfully is quite low in this population but it allows us to make statistical uh claims
  53. about the lowering of the mortality risk from people who participate in the program we're following up on this paper
  54. with uh trying to better understand the incarceration results and uh merging in data on uh arrests and convictions in
  55. New York state to try to get a better sense of what's driving that effect there's also lots of other summer youth
  56. employment programs across the country and one of the things that's on the horizon is helping other cities identify
  57. the strengths and weaknesses of their programs by doing similar evaluations uh on what is happening to the youth that
  58. get to participate in in their City's Summer Youth Employment Program [Music]

Brief Summary

The episode analyzes the Summer Youth Employment Program's impact on earnings, incarceration, and mortality rates among participants in New York City.

Key points

  • Summer Youth Employment Program Impact. The program significantly increases earnings for low-income youth but has mixed long-term effects.
  • Surprising Mortality Results. The program is linked to saving lives and reducing incarceration rates among participants.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes