Offshoring, Automation, and Job Cuts

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Companies conduct collective layoffs for many reasons—but how do consumers react when the reason is offshoring versus automation? Wharton School Professor Stefano Puntoni explores new research showing that people respond more negatively when jobs are moved overseas. Using social media data and randomized experiments, the study highlights the role of social contracts, public sentiment, and labor expectations in shaping firm reputation.

#Layoffs #Offshoring #ConsumerBehavior #BusinessEthics #JobCuts ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney: Companies do layoffs at a variety of times and for a variety of reasons, but collective layoffs come when a
  2. firm lays off a significant number of their employees. Recent research looks at how these moves are perceived for
  3. those different reasons, offshoring of jobs being one of the most important areas of focus. Stefano Puntoni is a
  4. Professor of Marketing at the Wharton School, as well as Co- Director of AI at Wharton, and he joins us right now to discuss
  5. this topic. He has been part of research on this. Stefano, great to talk to you again. How are you? Stefano Puntoni: Thank you for having me.
  6. - This is obviously a very interesting topic, especially the offshoring part. What was it first that spurred the interest
  7. in doing research into this? - Yeah, we were interested in understanding how consumers
  8. react to learning that a firm has decided to lay off a significant amount of workers, what we call a collective
  9. layoff. And I think it's interesting, because while, obviously, companies don't go necessarily around advertising
  10. this, they often have press releases, things are talked about in social media, people talk about such things on Reddit
  11. and other platforms, and clearly, civic society organization, including labor unions and local news and other
  12. institutions, also talk about it. So increasingly, people learn about these things, and they hear discussion about it.
  13. And we were interested in understanding whether people were affected by this and the liking of firms as a function of
  14. engaging in such actions, and also whether, and that's maybe the more interesting part, whether it mattered to consumers
  15. why these collective layoffs were taking place. - So you mentioned Reddit, so obviously there is a social
  16. media component that you used in order to do this research. - Yeah, so one of the studies -- we have a lot of data actually, a
  17. lot of randomized control trials conducted on different populations, and then also some observational data. And one of
  18. the observational data is social media data we scraped from Reddit, where we basically searched for discussions, threads
  19. that were about collective layoffs. And in particular, we were searching for collective layoffs discussions that related
  20. to two different reasons for collective layoffs, and we focused on automation and offshoring. Now, those two are
  21. interesting, because if you think about the way that business can pursue efficiency, typically, they can leverage one
  22. or two forces to shape business. One is technology, and one is globalization. So if they leverage technology, typically
  23. that means, I am going to replace my expensive variable cost in the shape of labor with, you know, capital investments in the
  24. shape of technology, and that makes work more efficient, increase the productivity, reduces the need for labor.
  25. But the other picture is, another way I can do it is basically to lower my variable cost by moving my jobs from a high cost country
  26. to a lower cost country so I can lower my labor cost that way. And so what we did basically was to scrape all of
  27. this data, run a big regression model where we were looking at consumer online sentiment when they were talking about these
  28. collective layoffs to the function of whether the layoffs were attributed to automation and offshoring, and we found
  29. significantly more negative conversations about collective layoffs when they were about offshoring than were about
  30. automation. - And that sentiment you mentioned in the paper plays into the fact that, I guess, there is a perception by a lot of people
  31. that companies should be looking out for their employees and maybe not necessarily sending jobs to another country. - Yeah,
  32. the angle that we take to explaining this phenomenon is basically building on a very long tradition of social science
  33. research and philosophy and political economy, going back to the Enlightenment, on the notion of social contracts. And what we
  34. argue is that companies and societies or citizens and voters and consumers, they hold a implicit social contract with
  35. one another. These are basically expectations about what are we, you know, thinking the other part is going to do. And the
  36. expectation on the side of society and consumers and citizens is that we are going to, you know, pay the
  37. taxes that are training your workers, we're going to buy your products, and so forth. But on the other side, the biggest
  38. contribution, in a way, in the social contract by the side of the firm, is providing employment opportunities. So the
  39. problem with the collective layoff is that it is clearly a violation of that social contract, and that's why people
  40. don't like it. And what we find in our data is that people don't like it, especially when that social contract violation is
  41. attributed to offshoring. That makes it even more severe in the perception of people.
  42. Does the potential product quality play a role in that perception as well? - Yeah,
  43. so consumer reactions to firm decisions to offshore are complex. And so there are a bunch of different things that can be
  44. going on, and product quality is one of them, is an account that we test in our studies, and we do find some evidence for it.
  45. People might be reducing the liking of a company because they also believe that the products are going to be shoddy, or
  46. something like that. So that's one element. But controlling for that, we find that people feel more negatively about firms that
  47. decided to lay off workers when they attribute that layoff to offshoring. - That
  48. component of layoffs versus offshoring is a unique one, and I find it interesting that, maybe to a degree, people are more
  49. understanding of the component of layoffs, that it's part of what happens kind of in our country, in our cycle right now.
  50. - You know, a lot of people in the literature and also in popular press have written about the fact that consumers don't like
  51. it when companies are offshoring production. The problem is that all the tests in the literature that we could find were
  52. basically comparing the status quo to a situation where now we're offshoring production. And the problem with that comparison is
  53. that now you're comparing apples and oranges, because basically what you're doing is that you're comparing a firm
  54. that is not laying off anybody to a firm that is comparing layoff -- that is laying off workers and offshoring. So we
  55. did not know, based on the evidence in the literature, whether the negative reactions that people were talking about
  56. with offshoring were really about offshoring, per se, or simply about layoffs in general. And so what we needed
  57. to do is to construct our studies in a way where, in all conditions in our RCTs, there is a constant number of layoffs.
  58. And now we vary the reason for the layoffs, and when we get an effect here, then we know that is really an offshoring effect,
  59. it's not just a general reaction to layoffs. - Is there then -- doing this research and talking about it
  60. now in kind of the landscape we are, is there an element that makes this research even more important to bring it out now,
  61. because of some of these components that maybe we're seeing going on around the world? - Well, clearly, I mean, there's been a lot of
  62. conversations around, you know, where production should take place. And I would say that a lot of the conversations have
  63. been around bringing production back to countries where maybe the production used to be, and where, over the last maybe four
  64. or five decades, much less of it took place. Now, the thing is, what motivated me to study this topic, and we've been
  65. studying this for about 10 years now actually, is that I believe that a lot of support for policies that are meant to bring
  66. back production, for example, tax breaks for corporations, that is sure, or, you know, whatever, are predicated on a
  67. mistaken understanding of modern production. You know, the factories that might be coming back will look
  68. nothing like the factories that left. Adidas, for example, is again making shoes in Germany after 50 years of making shoes
  69. in Southeast Asia. The thing is, the factory that Adidas built in 2020 is very different from the factory that they used to have
  70. in Germany in the 1960s. Basically, it's an entirely automated production line. And there will be jobs. I mean, there will be
  71. security guards, and someone has to build the buildings on construction. There will be some engineering, obviously. And
  72. then maybe it's good for the economy that we have production and consumption closer to each other, and maybe
  73. it's good for innovation cycles. It's also good maybe for, you know, the high end robotics industry in the country,
  74. whatever. I mean, there are a lot of reasons why that that move might be -- you know, might produce joy in Germany. On
  75. the other hand, it is not going to produce large numbers of the well paying jobs for unskilled workers.
  76. - Do consumers then have their opinions on being with and shopping from a corporation that makes maybe their favorite
  77. product change because of some of these decisions around labor and offshoring? - It depends a lot on whether they know about these things. It
  78. also, you know, matters a lot how much they like the company. I think if you really love a company, you'll probably, you
  79. know, protect those beliefs by constructing arguments for why it's okay they're doing something. I would say that what
  80. our research shows is that an environment where such production decisions are highly politicized, where there is a
  81. discourse in society revolving around where companies should make stuff, and that we are taking very dramatic steps to
  82. force companies to behave a certain way, I think consumers are clearly not oblivious to these conversations. This is
  83. something that, we hear about it in the news all the time. And so they're bound to shape how they react to companies behavior for
  84. better or for worse. That's something that you'll have to think for yourself, whether you like how people think about it
  85. or not. But I think at least from our point of view, it's interesting to study. - Stefano, great to talk to you again. Thanks very much
  86. - Great talking to you. Thank you. - Thank you. Stefano Puntoni, who's a Professor of Marketing here at the Wharton School and
  87. Co-Director of AI at Wharton.

Brief Summary

Stefano Puntoni discusses consumer reactions to layoffs, focusing on the negative impact of offshoring compared to automation.

Key points

  • Consumer Reactions to Layoffs. Research reveals that consumers react negatively to layoffs, especially when attributed to offshoring.
  • The Changing Nature of Factories. Adidas is bringing production back to Germany, but the factories will be automated and different.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes