On Energy Issues, Candidates' Funding Priorities Are Fueling the Debate

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

U.S. presidential candidates John McCain and Barak Obama offer only subtle differences in their approaches to the nation's energy challenges. Obama emphasizes renewable energy to reduce dependence on foreign oil, while McCain puts more faith in drilling. Obama is less enamored of nuclear power than McCain. Obama supports subsidies for ethanol production while McCain would cancel them and open the market to foreign competitors. But no matter who wins, energy prices are likely to climb. πŸ“‚ Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. this podcast is brought to you by knowledge at wharton please visit knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu
  2. for more information there are a lot of similarities between the two candidates so
  3. mccain has had a long history of being in favor of a climate change statute in fact he
  4. was one of the first co-sponsors of a climate change regulation statute in the united states
  5. and has fairly consistently supported new generations of those of those kinds of those kinds of
  6. approaches and also obama has committed to a climate change regulation the target for the obama campaign is
  7. slightly more ambitious than for the mccain campaign but i actually think that what voters probably should focus on the
  8. most is who is going to be the most likely to provide the necessary leadership if you're in favor of climate
  9. change regulation i think both of the campaigns are uh are supportive of developing alternative energy
  10. sources so knew uh both sides have committed to significant increases in and funding uh probably subsidies of
  11. certain kind of mix both candidates have said at least in their campaign that they're in favor of
  12. developing new alternative energy technologies technologies such as solar wind geothermal
  13. both are in favor of nuclear for example so i think the question the difference there
  14. depends on what you would what you would see as a as emphasis so for example the
  15. mccain campaign seems to be much more strongly pro-nuclear there's been a commitment of 45 new
  16. nuclear power plants in near-term building up to 100 nuclear plants that's a fairly significant shift from a
  17. situation where we've had zero new nuclear power plants built in the next in the last 30 years
  18. now the obama campaign is also in favor of nuclear power development as a part of a mix of other alternative sources
  19. but i think it's it's fair to say that the mccain campaign seems to rely on uh more heavily on nuclear as well as the
  20. everyone knows about the bil the drill baby drill claims in the argument that we're
  21. we'll increase significant supplies of petroleum domestically i think there's a significant difference
  22. between the two campaigns in terms of developing oil resources i think the obama campaign is in favor
  23. of some some limited development of oil resources that we have here there is a position to put additional pressure on
  24. oil companies to exploit resources that have already been allocated to them mccain seems to be very strongly in
  25. favor of drilling almost as much as you can opening the arctic it seems to be at least a potential
  26. uh a potential approach um so i think that the the more general question is how much is that really going to matter uh
  27. if you look at even if you maximize your your the drilling capacity in the united
  28. states and all of our resources i think the best estimates are you don't really make much more of a dent and you don't
  29. make a very big dent maybe two percent uh of of total supply would be affected so you're still going to be if you don't
  30. change the overall mix of your energy supply you're still going to be fairly heavily dependent on overseas oil
  31. both campaigns have made a commitment to becoming independent uh of the of of overseas overseas petroleum resources
  32. but uh it it it doesn't there's some question about how each one of those each side would would try to achieve
  33. that well i think some people raised this issue and and suggest that the commitments that both campaigns have
  34. made to to new energy resources and in particular the the obama campaign's uh a commitment of of funds to energy
  35. resources would somehow be somehow be compromised by the current crisis and i'm not sure that really uh that that's
  36. really going to happen you you're going to have uh you're going to have significant challenges economically
  37. and those challenges depend directly on energy supplies so the extent to which your economy runs is quite directly
  38. dependent on energy supplies and so i don't think you can sidestep this issue it may be that will be more somewhat
  39. more expensive you may there may be decisions taken that you would not be able to balance the budget
  40. as fast as you might otherwise try to do it i think one of the reasons for that is uh is to understand energy also in a
  41. geopolitical context uh that the question of energy independence isn't just a question of economic viability or
  42. growth in the united states it's also a question of who has most of fossil fuel resources in the world
  43. yeah it's likely that both sides will will be developing policies on energy and then the question is which
  44. i think for voters is which one do you think has a better uh version of how to develop
  45. my own estimate and as as we've discussed i'm in favor of the obama campaign and
  46. so i'm a i'm a volunteer and have offered offered advice to the campaign although i'm not a i'm not a spokesman
  47. for the campaign but my feeling is that the obama campaign is more persuasive and has a
  48. better strategy about about how to go about doing that my sense again this is partisan but
  49. my sense of the mccain campaign basically has an old-fashioned idea of how you're going to advance in this area
  50. you know ideas of really expanding nuclear drilling more these are really traditional kinds of
  51. approaches to the problem that i don't think are going to do it i think what you really need is
  52. the commitment to to to fund and to provide good economic incentives for the development of new kinds of energy
  53. supplies you can't really force the development of new technology very easily now at the
  54. same time there have been times in history where there has been a specific kind of technological problem
  55. say going to the moon or developing a manhattan project in a weapons sense or or other kinds of other kinds of
  56. examples where there was a very high strategic priority identified and that the government decided that there should
  57. be investments across maybe an array of different possibilities to try to achieve a strategic objective
  58. and i think that those have been those have been successful in in history but i think it's also true that you need
  59. to try to get the economic incentives right and i think one uh one area one place in which to start is to look at
  60. the subsidies that are currently available already to you know available to traditional fuels so there's a lot of
  61. oil subsidies for example that are being paid and there's a lot of there's a lot of implicit subsidies that
  62. are given to the coal industry etc so i think one question is to let's first get
  63. the economic playing field uh level uh and then it might make sense to provide certain kinds of subsidies for
  64. uh for for different for different proposals but i agree that it's very difficult to
  65. select the winners in advance in this way but another basic way to encourage innovation that is not a
  66. government-centered approach is to provide the right incentives so and what that means in the environmental
  67. area is that you would have correctly caught correct costs so there's a lot of externalities and the
  68. use of different kinds of fuels and if you can uh you can provide the accurate accounting for those costs
  69. in the use of those fuels then you start to level things out now politically that's been very difficult neither
  70. campaign has uh has actually said that they would be in favor of attacks for example on
  71. coal carbon oil now many economists would say that's the best approach because what you do is you
  72. provide the correct incentives that way for someone else to develop alternative methods of fuel
  73. the other thing that you do with that sort of approach is that you encourage efficiency measures energy efficiency is
  74. one area where there's a lot of gain that we could have and it wouldn't take a lot you the
  75. technologies are known uh government policies would not be that difficult to uh to implement uh you'd have clear
  76. gains and so the the the potential for energy efficiency to solve a number of these problems is something that that i
  77. think is going to be important i think that i think the price of oil has has shown a lot of volatility and
  78. one of the reasons it's shown a lot of volatility is that it's geopolitically uh there's there's a lot of sensitivity
  79. to what exactly is happening there so i think a a short-term fluctuation in the price of oil if it goes down a little
  80. bit uh or uh uh if it if it radically spikes really should not determine policy over in the long run now i think
  81. we made a mistake in the united states where during the carter administration there
  82. was a a spike in oil prices because of opec and there was a push to realize you know it should be energy efficiency etc
  83. and we basically forgot that lesson and we fell back into a complacency about energy resources
  84. we uh i think even george bush somewhat ironically said that we got addicted to oil uh it was he was a little bit of a
  85. late convert on that particular issue and i think some of the policies suggest that that's somewhat um
  86. as i said ironic but um but the but the point is that we've i think now learned our lesson and we see that the
  87. geopolitics of oil are are extremely difficult um where the united states is in a much weaker position if we don't
  88. develop alternative energy sources that are not dependent and so i actually think
  89. that for from a long-term perspective and from the point of view of policy that that will not affect
  90. the commitment which is emerging that we need to develop new energy sources for more information please visit
  91. knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu

Brief Summary

McCain and Obama differ on climate policies, energy sources, and oil resource development in their campaigns.

Key points

  • Climate Change Regulation. Both McCain and Obama support climate change regulation, but with different emphases.
  • Nuclear Power Development. McCain's campaign is strongly pro-nuclear, proposing 45 new plants.
  • Energy Independence. Both campaigns commit to energy independence, but their strategies differ significantly.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes