Show Me The Money: Who Will Fund Future Real Estate Deals?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Highlights from a panel discussion at the recent Knowledge at Wharton Real Estate Forum.

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so thank you all for joining and i'd just like to start with fred have have a question about
  2. how the present financial situation has evolved if you look at the last downturn
  3. and there was a reference to this that will barry sterling talking about the rtc rather than the fdic
  4. if you look at the last downturn the rtc was a relatively efficient way for bad loans to move from banks to
  5. investors whether they were financial players or developers what do you see happening this time
  6. well um as bob told mentioned earlier we started seeing the weakness in the housing market you know after katrina 05
  7. so it's been real we're really entering the fifth year now of a housing downturn and um i
  8. think that uh the the the banks disgorging of distressed assets that we would have expected to have occurred a
  9. long time ago really hasn't happened there's not really a roadmap for them um you have a lot of banks that probably
  10. are insolvent that if they really had to discourage would be um you know the 500
  11. bank number that was tossed out was um probably uh maybe a soft number um in terms of the capital markets you know
  12. last year at this conference we were looking at the demise of the american financial system
  13. basically we were surprised but by april of own 9 toll brothers became the first of the
  14. big public home builders to actually tap the debt markets we issued 400 million dollars of senior
  15. debt at about nine percent and then uh five months later we were able to go back to
  16. the markets and issue another 250 million this time below seven percent first deal was eight and a half years
  17. this is ten years so so from the public capital markets they've opened up a lot um the banks are uh
  18. still pretty clogged up i would say in terms of providing new money to the industry um you know credit facilities
  19. those builders that have had to go back to the banks for for revising their credit facilities have found them
  20. getting chopped 30 40 percent prices are going up and there doesn't seem to be a particular
  21. motivation or intensity among the banks to really want to provide capital as opposed to sort of the public
  22. markets which i think are responding more quickly and then based on what don said are you
  23. revamping your whole strategy we are no we're we're still you know i mean we're we're bidding on properties
  24. we're we're being a little more conservative than some others and um you know i think what what don said when
  25. when he said our rrrs are out the door i think you can't i think you need discipline in the market i think dubai
  26. for example is a is an example of sort of that vision that may not necessarily have been um
  27. disciplined by some of those uh analyses and i think over the long term dubai you know has
  28. some fundamentals that will have a research it will have a resurgence but i think you still need to
  29. have discipline because especially in real estate um you know you can be very visionary but at some point the music
  30. stops and if there's not the base of users for your properties everybody loses right i mean one thing that struck me
  31. this morning when people were talking about the number of times the reits have gone to the market and raised money is
  32. is show me of the money the issue at all right now is it uh is there a kind of duality in the market where on the one
  33. hand it's tough to refinance on the other hand for for uh it is possible for companies uh to go into ipos look i mean
  34. there is money the problem is applying today's new money to existing situations i mean that's really the bottom line
  35. right now so sorry i missed this early morning panel so if i repeated some of the comments that came in
  36. earlier you know this year globally there's been about 78 billion of equity raised roughly in that number by global
  37. property companies 32 billion in the united states there's been about 12 billion of unsecured bonds
  38. that have been effectively raised this year by public by public reits and that really
  39. only is from a standing start really in april to now so if you sort of think about that and annualize that there's
  40. tremendous amount of capital out there the problem is there's been very few acquisitions uh you know simon property
  41. i'm sure you all saw announced you know the acquisition of prime retail outlets company
  42. that was a company prime could have easily gone public it's a very capable very good business
  43. that was clearly an option for them uh although they chose to in effect sell the company
  44. um so so the problem is is actually there's really no issue getting capital it's it's very fluid i mean there's lots
  45. of investors that want to deploy more capital into companies like berries like david simons
  46. all over the world but that brings up a good point i'm not so sure that there's no issue getting capital there's no
  47. issue with the big guys getting capital and you know the question is even with the bank bailouts have we bailed out the
  48. big banks at the expense of all other banks and in so doing have we missed an opportunity uh because what i've seen
  49. and you know i think it's great that we we finally have a banker on the panel so you know but but let me tell you
  50. here's a good example like there was uh there were two ipos priced this week if you sort of just stopped but step back
  51. and said okay um proven ceo he's going to go out and start a new company he's sort of left his recent his old
  52. company has a great track record he has no office space he has no office equipment you know all
  53. he does is he's got a a group of maybe five or six other people that are quote willing to start a
  54. company well he raised 400 million this week to basically go out and set up a company
  55. go buy hotel properties but in fairness i'd say that's more the exception or the
  56. exception but i'm just saying the money is out there for it but i think the point
  57. you're raising is it's it's sort of a small minority of people that will actually get the capital and there's a
  58. big obviously a big issue out there in terms of yeah i would say that there's sort of
  59. a tale of two cities in our industry you know you've got the big builders uh i think by now many would have
  60. thought given the length of the severity of this downturn that more public home building companies would have busted and
  61. really very few have um for various reasons they were able to get able to get a net operating loss uh
  62. extension let me give you my card um but but the smaller builders who were more dependent on
  63. regional banks our star you know are crumbling and you know we're in the philadelphia market there's probably
  64. eight or nine of the builders the small private guys that we compete with because the big guys don't
  65. really go into the luxury market that um just are out of business right now and that's most of our competition and they
  66. just can't get capital and they you know they're really hurting i agree with with
  67. al i i think that the availability of capital is the exception not the norm you

Brief Summary

The episode examines the financial landscape, capital access issues, and the struggles of small builders in the current housing market downturn.

Key points

  • The State of the Housing Market. Experts discuss the ongoing housing downturn and its implications for banks and builders.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes