The MLB Rule Change Putting Calls in Players' Hands
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
ABOUT THE EPISODE A close ball-or-strike call can change an entire at-bat. MLB's answer is giving players the power to challenge it.
Joe Martinez, MLB Vice President of On-Field Strategy, explains the automated ball-strike challenge system, why teams receive two retained challenges, and how MLB is balancing accuracy with pace and strategy. He also discusses personalized strike zones, the pitch clock, larger bases, and what may be next for the game.
ABOUT THE PODCAST Sports is a game of numbers. Wharton experts Eric Bradlow, Shane Jensen, Cade Massey, and Adi Wyner team up to tackle the world of sports, from current events to longstanding issues such as: What sports streaks are the most impressive? How do you rank the best players? Can athletes be compared across sports? Moneyball Highlights explains how decision-makers in the game can avoid the common mistakes and embrace the data. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.
----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.
Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:
- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox
Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- Welcome. Welcome to Wharton Money Belt. Welcome to another full hour of sports analytics
- here on the Wharton Podcast Network. This is Cade Massey hosting this week with the whole crew.
- Delighted to have everyone in here already. Eric Bradlow is in here coming from his
- home office. Otte Weiner on campus just across the way. Shane Jensen, home office, and rarely I'm in
- the office as well. Huntsman Hall, West Philadelphia, here for the hour. We're going to follow our typical schedule.
- That means a guest in the first half hour. We'll go open lines in the second half
- hour. Curious what the guys have been thinking as these various sports have been playing out the
- last week or so. Our guest, we are delighted to have Joe Martinez in here from Major League Baseball.
- Joe is the MLB's vice president of on -field strategy. He works with baseball ops departments around the
- league, on-field personnel, and involved in all kinds of things, but we're really pulling him
- on here to talk about ABS. He's been intimate with that innovation in baseball this year.
- Importantly, and interestingly, Joe, he ain't just playing with stats like we are.
- The man has been a major league pitcher. He threw for a number of clubs in the late aughts and tens.
- He threw for the Giants, the Pirates, the Diamondbacks, and the Cleveland Indians, God bless their
- 19, I mean their 2026 season. He's been working with the league since February 2021.
- Joe, thanks for being here, man. Appreciate it. Yeah, thanks for having me, kid.
- What is your day-to-day like during this playoff time of year? Yeah, kind of nice because no two days
- are quite the same, but we get to watch a lot of baseball, which is great. I think at this point in the season,
- like you said, I'm kind of involved with rules and most specifically, I guess, as it
- relates to this conversation in the season, ABS. Things are up and running operationally.
- There's not a whole lot to do other than monitor something if it goes wrong, but
- there's a lot of folks smarter, more capable than I am that have already kind of
- made sure we don't have issues at this point in the season. So mostly just back and enjoying the games
- and like everybody else, cheering for the teams to play well. All right. So it's nice when the operations are kind
- of running smooth and you get to just monitor. That's a good situation. Before we dive into it, give us a
- little bit more on your background. How did you transition from being a ballplayer
- to front office? Are a lot of people trying to do that? What got you that edge? A little background on Joe.
- He threw for Boston College, I think, a finance degree. So you're kind of geared up this way,
- but did you always know you wanted to do that? No. I wanted to play and make millions of
- dollars and never have to work again. That was the first plan. I just wasn't quite good enough to do
- that. You got a lot farther towards it than we all did. Yeah. That was my dream too.
- Money. It was just playing baseball for a living. Yeah. Yeah. To be fair, there was really playing first.
- Actually, my parents always said that the first goal was to, when they realized I was
- kind of good, was to get my education paid for by baseball, right? By using baseball, which was something that I
- was extremely lucky to do, at least mostly, right? Not a whole lot of full scholarships for
- baseball players, at least back then. Right. And had the opportunity to play. And I think once I realized that I
- wasn't going to make millions and be able to not work the rest of my life, I started to think about what was next
- and would like to have stayed in baseball, found it difficult, as many people do who
- are trying to work in baseball, whether I'm on the business side or baseball operation side,
- and realized that I had a big gap in my resume where I had played a lot. So I knew a lot about baseball and
- about the inner workings of the game, but I hadn't worked, right? I'd gone to school.
- I was kind of 10 years out of school, albeit a good one, right? Boston College is a great place, good education.
- And I actually went to work at a couple of different places, but my longest amount
- of time I spent at PWC as a mergers and acquisitions consultant and kind of thought
- that that kind of, well, I had the baseball kind of experience. This kind of gave me the professional experience.
- And once I had that, or at least had a good amount of that, I was there for about five years.
- I tried to sell myself to someone here at the commissioner's office as kind of a
- person who could provide unique value, having both of those things, both kind of the baseball
- and the professional knowledge and combining those skill sets made me what I hope to be
- an attractive candidate. That is awesome. Were you always aiming to come back or
- was there a moment there where you thought, I'm just going to go do this, and then you got homesick and wanted to come
- back? It's, you know, baseball is kind of a gravitational pull to it. I think that always pulls, that always kind
- of makes you want to go back. You know, I had a great time at PWC, the people there were really good to
- me and helps me grow quite a bit. But I don't really know that world quite as well as I know baseball.
- I don't kind of care about it quite as much as I do baseball either, which maybe is bad to admit, but I think
- some people care about that a lot more than that. So you have to know who you are.
- And honestly, I was trying to think of where I would provide some unique value. I never thought I really provided much unique
- value there other than, you know, working hard and doing some of the things that other
- people could do, where kind of in baseball, I think I had some experience and some
- background that very few people have. So I was always looking for opportunities.
- I kind of tried to stay in touch with some people, networking, you know, sometimes even
- just reaching out to people that I saw on LinkedIn or something and found my way
- back. And I think I was fortunate too, but it wasn't, it wasn't a straight line.
- It certainly wasn't an easy journey. And, you know, I probably thought I would get, I would give up a couple of
- times, but it just kind of kept pulling me back. Well, it's impressive broadening that you did for
- yourself to qualify back into it. Eric wanted to question here. And then I know Shane has some ABS
- questions for sure, Eric. Well, mine, mine was related to that. You were saying you were watching a lot
- of baseball, which we all are right now. How much do you guys play the counterfactual
- since you have played a big part in the ABS system where, you know, you think about redesigning it, like instead of two, let's
- not go all the way right now to Robo umpires, although we could think about that.
- But I just mean if teams had four challenges instead of two, and then, you know,
- you kind of replay out what they may have done or even certain ones you just said, he's going to be automatically called.
- I'm just wondering how much counterfactual thinking you do while watching the game.
- Sure. I think, you know, I think it's natural during the game. If you see a situation, you know, for
- example, that a pitch is called incorrectly, um, right. And we all have that box on the,
- on the screen that shows us great. Oh, I see. I hate it, but we'll talk, we can talk about that another time.
- That would be good to know why you, yeah. Um, but you know, then you sit there and you think like, oh, if this team
- had a challenge, they could have challenged there. What would have that done for the count?
- And you start thinking about like, you know, uh, you know, what, what can happen from
- there, right? Obviously, certain counts have different kind of expected, uh, values and all that stuff.
- But, uh, we, uh, we do a little bit, I think, but not as much like formally. I think we did a lot of it
- proactively in a way, right? We, we have the benefit of testing in the minor league.
- So we've used ABS challenge in thousands of minor league games before it ever got to
- the major leagues. So we had tested with different numbers of challenges, you know, different frameworks in terms of
- like retention versus non-retention, even different strike zones. So we kind of know a little bit
- what to expect from my kind of larger sample, you know, if certain things were changed,
- right. If dials were tweaked. Um, and I think we're, we're pretty happy with where we're at right now in terms
- of, you know, how many challenges teams get, how it works. Um, but yeah, there's, there's always, I think
- that, um, uh, you know, that, that inclination to kind of like think in that way.
- And then, and I'm sure like once the world series is over and particularly as we
- prepare kind of for our off season and looking forward to next season, we'll do a
- lot of that analysis to understand like where could this potentially be better. Let me, let me ask one related question.
- I sometimes ask the Mars question. Cause I, I watched the least baseball year girl planet love, love planet, but I watched
- the least the Mars question is, man, two doesn't seem like a very big number two
- out of however many pitches are thrown in a game 200 or whatever it must be to the, to the outsider.
- It's like, wow, how did you even decide to consider something so, so small? Yeah, I think it's, it was, you know,
- a lot of what we've done has been guided by fan feedback. Um, so I think it's hard to get
- there with math, like what the optimum number, number of challenges is, um, optimal number of
- challenges. Um, so we use fan feedback, like what do they like to see? Right. Cause there's other kinds of considerations, not just,
- um, having the amount that provides like the fairest outcome, right. We could, we could use the system for
- all pitches, right. Which you would probably argue is the fairest. Um, um, but you know, there's an entertainment
- value aspect to it as well. Right. We don't want the game slowing down too much.
- Um, and even though we've worked very hard at making sure these challenges are, are adjudicated
- quickly and clearly and in an entertaining way, um, you know, a lot of them starts
- to become like, especially you're sitting at a game like, all right, enough's enough.
- Let's just play baseball. Plus our umpires are really good too. Right. They only miss, you know, a handful of
- pitches a game miss. Right. I mean, it's 97, you know, a quarter of an inch off the plate, but like,
- you know, a handful of pitches a game anyway, 7% the current league average, 7 % of pitches are wrong.
- Right. So 7% they're up to 93% accuracy and that's way higher than they were 10 years ago.
- Right. And given, you know, 300 pitches a game, not, and not all of them are called.
- So right. 150 called per game. Right. So you're looking at 11 ish, right. Or whatever it is, um, called incorrectly.
- But so I think we wanted to make sure it was, it was entertaining. It was quick.
- It wasn't too many challenges, but we still allowed teams the tools to get the most
- important pitches, correct. Particularly those in the most, in the most high leverage situations.
- Um, so having two each, but also being able to retain them if you get them correctly, right.
- We don't want them using them, um, you know, in a way that they're just, they're
- being wasteful, right. You have to make sure that they're used in the right places.
- And that, and that creates kind of a strategic element. I think that fans kind of like engaging
- with as well. Shame. I totally understand why you would restrict the number of challenges just in terms of time
- in the game and everything like that. It does, I think, create a little bit of an asymmetry that it, I mean, maybe
- you don't mind this, but it benefits pitchers, I think more than hitters in its current
- implementation because the cat, I mean, it looks like success rates are for, are much higher
- for pitchers and catchers in terms of the challenge system than hitters. They have the better vantage point.
- And so kind of having it be a challenge system as opposed to, you know, kind of all on, on every pitch kind of,
- I do think kind of creates a subtle advantage towards the defensive team. And I don't know how, how, how, how
- I'm at least thinking about that or whether there's some way that that can kind of
- be mitigated. Yeah, it definitely does. And for that reason, I think that you said it's, it's because of the vantage point
- of the catcher. Now, if you ask pitchers, they might argue with that even given the data.
- But yeah, we, I don't think we've considered giving a different number for those at Pat
- versus, you know, the team when they're in the field. There's also kind of an issue to rules
- that, or, or an element to rules like simplest is best. Right. And, and making sure the fans can understand
- the rules is, is always kind of best. Again, when you, you have to balance, I think a lot of times like a format
- and a structure that's optimal for competition and what's, what's best for entertainment.
- And sometimes those things don't exactly work together. Although I think, you know, we try to
- find as much, you know, where those kind of circles and that Venn diagram overlap the
- most and, and kind of focus on those areas. Just to be complete, Joe, what was the
- thought about not allowing managers to, or people from the dugouts? Of course they can watch video and challenge
- a call at first base or something else. So why not the pitches? One, we thought it was most interesting and
- entertaining. I think there's kind of a goal of ours in general to put as much of
- the game in the player's hands as possible. So this decision is theirs. Speed was, was also a factor, right?
- If the umpire has got to be kind of looking over to the manager after every called pitch, like that, that's not great.
- So I, and again, through testing and, and, and reps that we got, it just became pretty clear to us that this was a
- better, a better format. And honestly, if you went back to the beginning of replay, maybe we would have done
- that differently, right? And had the, had the players challenge those calls on the field as well, instead of
- having the managers do it from the dugout. But you know, that's, that's, that's something that
- we didn't do at the time and, and it still works very well. I think we do replay really well.
- Um, but you know, a little different, a little different, um, rule there. All right.
- Um, I, uh, Joe, so I've actually written my first paper on ABS. We just finished it.
- Oh, congrats. And, uh, because the, the question that occurred to me is why, I mean, anyone is,
- what's the optimal policy for player pitchers and catchers and batters to decide, right?
- Because one of the things that's so fun about is, are these horrible decisions that some
- of the players, because they don't like what happened to them and they, they, they tap
- their heads, hoping for something else to happen. And it just doesn't work. It's like the first inning with like one
- out or something like that. It happens sometimes. It's quite treacherous. So I, I actually have some numbers for
- you and I'm curious to know what, what, what, I mean, I could throw them out to the group and, and wonder.
- So I'll start with, of the total that's available. So imagine we, the way we describe it
- as an Oracle. So there's an Oracle who knows, knows what the right call would be.
- Um, how much could, could be recovered of the total that could be recovered? How much is being recovered now?
- Do you have anyone who might want to make a guess? Just to be clear, what fraction of pitches
- that are actually called incorrectly? Not pitches. I'm going to do it in run value.
- Run value. So in other words, I know that's, that's the, that's the, that's the, that's the unit.
- Yes. Because you're going to call, you're much more interested in pitches that, that are three and
- two count. You're going to, you're going to be much more interested. They have much more bigger impact on the
- game. You have to baby, baby step your audience, man. I should have brought Tom Tango with me.
- He probably knows the answer to this one. I'm sure you guys are familiar with Tom.
- There's a, there's a, I'm sure the players are, I know they're taught this, that if
- a decisive pitch is way more important to get right than one that is, that is irrelevant.
- So an OO pitch has a very different, well, OO pitch can be important, but if you're already up three to nothing and, and
- I mean, if it's a decisive, it turns you an out from a, from a, from a strikeout to an opportunity or all these
- things are, they're much more valuable. So when we judge your, your, the value of an overturn, it's not just all treating
- all pitches equally. We do them by the predicted run value of making the flip. So that's the unit that I use, which
- how much more runs on average, would you be either saving or costing if you had gotten it right?
- And so I have the number, which is the fraction. Before I answer, I have an answer before
- I, I'm sure all our listeners want to know this too. Let's imagine you assume a pitch would have
- flipped. Okay. How do you simulate or estimate the number of runs saved? Because for example, maybe the pitcher would have
- done something different under a different count, or maybe the batter would have changed his swing
- under a different count. So what do you assume is staying the same when you flip this pitch?
- So we just flip. So if it's a strike, we just turn it into a ball and then we use
- the table that says how many expected runs given the game state, game out base situation
- is predicted to come in. Okay. So there's, okay. So none of the secondary effects of what
- that would do. Not at all. You know, we have to be simple too. We have to solve our problems rather than
- make too many of them. That's the advice I always give to my students is solve a problem, make your problem
- as easy as possible so that you can solve it first rather than be the ideal problem that is going to keep you busy
- for too long and you'll graduate and never get anything done. This is one of those almost impossible questions
- to answer. I don't know. Do you want me to go first? I mean, it's a nice round number.
- That's it's a fraction, but it's a nice round fraction. I'm giving you a hint. Well, I have no idea, but here, isn't
- there roughly approximately nine runs scored in an average baseball game? Yes. Okay.
- So my first thought was I'm going to take a percentage of that nine runs. So I'm going to guess 5% cause
- I don't think it's a massive effect, but that could change things. So I'm going to guess it's somewhere around
- whatever that would be half a run, a little less than half a run. That's my guess.
- I will tell you that I'm going to, I can't, I'm going to have to cut him off. That was brilliant.
- It nails it. Their total combined for both teams is just under a half a run. What?
- It says how much they're recovering. It was just too good to not. Eric, that's your best performance.
- Just so you know, this may wipe out 12 years of me talking about momentum on the show, but go ahead.
- Here's the interesting thing. It's actually about 0.45. I said 5 % of nine, that's 0.45. That's exactly
- right. Exactly 0.45. All right. Then you know what academic journals are going to say, this result is obvious.
- Do not publish. No, but, but no, but that's not my question. My question is what fraction of, so now
- we know 0.45 is what they recover. What could have they recovered if they were perfect, if they had an Oracle and, and
- so take, find the denominator. So 0.45 divided by the denominator is really, is the interesting part.
- Right. And I mean, we, again, we've only got like, like about 7% inaccuracy over entire
- games and, and some, and, and so. And key ones make a huge difference. So, right, right, right.
- Wow. Right. Okay. I'm right. I'm going to give you the answer. The answer is about a third.
- So in other words, they're still living, leaving two thirds of the run value that would,
- I mean, it balances out. So it doesn't change the, I mean, each team is low. You think that's low?
- No, I'm not sure. I think it's low, but there's a lot out there. But the, the, what our paper says is
- most, most of that's not recoverable. And the reason why it's not recoverable is
- that we are assuming that everybody around them are not better than umpires and making decisions.
- And so you can't start challenging things because you'll run out of challenges if they're too
- close too often. But we do have an algorithm that increases it by about 25%. So that's, that's our paper.
- The algorithm presumably is a game state. It's a game theory. It's basically a game theory where you have
- to sort of decide whether the future, because you only get two. So if you, if you use one and
- blow it out, you're losing everything that happens. Once you blow it out, you're losing everything
- in the future. So it's game state. It's how many have left, what the inning is. It's late in the game.
- You're going to be much more aggressive. Hey Joe, for our one billionth of 1 % stat nerds that attend the game, can
- you guys put the expected number of change in runs up on the major league, on the board that would appear?
- That would, that would be an excitement. That'd be exciting for me. That's probably in baseball savant somewhere.
- It's actually kind of a question since we're already really in the weeds anyway.
- But it's, it's a little bit tangential. Like talking about like the personalized strike zones
- that kind of, that is part of this ABS system. I mean, and maybe this is something that
- more would be a tontangible, but does, does the system struggle more with kind of the
- extremes of this, like the Aaron judges and all two bays of the world, just because,
- because, because I would assume there's some kind of model underlying this, that's doing some kind
- of estimation. And I would, I would, I would, I would assume that some, some of the more
- extreme players would be kind of tougher to calibrate and make consistent. Is that the case or am I, you
- know, I may have to ask a clever question. First of all, audio, I'd love to read
- that paper at some point if I'm ever able to, because it's, these are some things
- that we like actually try to figure out internally. I'm not sure we have a great answer
- for what, like the optimal challenge strategies, but anyway. So Shane, we incur, I'm curious.
- So what do you mean by the system struggling with calibration based on like the extreme
- kind of, you're talking about like the judges and L2 bays of the world, I assume.
- Yes, that's right. Yeah. Yeah. Like basically like, because the strike zone is personalized and they have a kind of a
- rather, a rather extreme one are, is, is kind of, you know, whatever, because the setting
- is based on some kind of cal, is trying to keep, is calibrating between all these
- cameras and keeping things, you know, like does, does the system or the estimation procedure use
- struggle kind of with kind of extreme outliers basically. So, so I guess to like start, you,
- you guys are familiar with how we come up with the strike zones, right? So we, we measure everybody and, and there's
- the top and bottom is just based on how tall they are standing wise. Right. If Joe that's, you're saying like independent before
- they walk up to the plate sometime in the season, you got every, everybody's measurement and
- they call somebody up from the minors. They have to go through the measurement process.
- It's just tight. It's just tight. So we, we measure everyone during spring training
- and we use kind of a two-step process. We have a manual measure of some, some of these folks who help us.
- They're typically like strength and conditioning coaches that have gone through a certain certification program that
- actually do manual measurement with kind of standardized equipment. And we also have a group from a
- place called Southwest Research Institute that brings cameras and they take pictures and they have kind
- of like a markerless motion capture program that evaluates posture for any kind of like, you
- know, slouching or bent knees and things like that. That's what I was going to ask you.
- Yeah. And I guess that's, that's, this is the part where I thought, I thought maybe kind
- of more extreme people would. Yeah. So, so we're, we're very kind of, we try to be very precise with getting heights
- and we're strict, right? If that, if we see some slouching or that, that program flag, something we'll remeasure until
- we get acceptable measurements. We measure as many position players as we can during spring training.
- And we tell the clubs kind of anybody has a chance at playing in the big leagues.
- We'd like to get them measured then. And then we have a process for those people who we haven't measured in spring training,
- when they get selected to the major league roster, they're measured at the ballpark before the
- game with oversight from a major league representative who's at the ballpark, things like that.
- So, yeah. I have a question to this. One is, let me go to the first one and then I have a second one
- too, but the strike zone is based on height is independent of how the player happens
- to stand. Like I was, you know, Yankee fans in the 1970s, we remember Mickey Rivers who had
- a crouch stance as opposed to someone. So it's done independent of how the person
- bats. Right. So if Paul O'Neill, who stood kind of pretty tall, kind of like Cody Bellinger
- ask, right. And Jeff Bagwell, right. Who's spread out, right. If they were the same height, they would
- have the same exact strike zone. Obviously the width is just the width of the plate, but the top and bottom is
- just a percentage of their height or percentages of their height. So regardless of stance, independent of stance, those
- settings are the same. And of course it works great because the stat cast data, you can just look at
- where the pitch effects are and you can find exactly where there was a strike or
- not without looking at the, you know, doesn't mean anything. As a pitcher, is that not confusing?
- Didn't you grow up thinking about throwing to the body that you were looking at in
- the stance as opposed to like the abstract notion of how tall he was? Yeah, this is a complicated one.
- We spent a lot of time on strike zones as you can imagine. It's almost philosophical.
- Yeah, kind of, right. A strike is, you know, it's kind of a strike when you know it, when you
- see it kind of deal, you know, that saying. I think just like from, I think it's
- a combination of like experience and reps, right. And kind of identifying what's a strike and
- what's not, what's not, how the catcher catches it. You know, a lot of things kind of
- go into, I think, people's understanding of a strike zone. I think for the first time we have
- a actual defined definition of the strike zone, even though the kind of rule book has
- tried to do it in the past, I'm not sure that's how it was used. Actually, I know it's not, that's not kind
- of how it was employed, right. The strike zone was almost like a living, breathing thing.
- It got a little bigger when the pitcher was behind in the count. It got smaller when the pitcher got ahead
- in the count. If it was a close game, it was small. If it's a blowout, it's huge, you know.
- So like all of those things, you know, kind of ceased to be. And I think some fans would argue that
- that's not necessarily a positive thing, but I think on the flip side, you know, Aaron
- Judge or Altuve or, you know, the big league average size hitter like Bryce Terang or
- somebody, you know, has the same strike zone for every pitch and every at bat, regardless
- of score. Which they're provided, obviously. They know exactly, I mean, they know how
- tall they are, so they can, they can, and by the way, if they're going up against, you know, we talked about this, I
- think last week, where, you know, the reason we don't see as much batting practice anymore
- is they're in the back, you know, hitting against this. They know that can be programmed to have
- their strike zone. So they can perfect, I mean, if they could learn a hundred percent, they have a
- fixed strike zone and they could figure, they could do the best they can to maybe
- even change their stance or do something. Yeah, I suppose they could. You know, I think there was less probably
- variance in strike zone based on like batting stance than you would expect anyway.
- You know, if you look at kind of historical calls by umpires. So yeah, I think this allows them to
- use those tools you're talking about, which are, I think, so much more advanced than they
- were, particularly when I, like even when I was playing, you know, to learn more and
- more about the strike zones. It's still really hard to know if a pitch that's close to a strike zone boundary
- is a ball or a strike, particularly how hard guys throw, how much it moves, you know, all that stuff.
- So I don't think anyone's ever going to get this down perfectly. Even catchers who are sitting right behind the
- plate, right, or right about 60% of the time or so, you know, and that's by far the best out of, you know,
- catchers, pitchers or batters. So they, I think they'll do, they do a lot of work to understand their personal
- strike zones and it's good. I think that it's consistent, but especially for those guys that really command the zone, but
- it's still a challenge to know like when a pitch is a strike or a ball, particularly one that's very close.
- Joe, have you guys had any unintended consequences of this change or is it pretty much
- rolled out the way you expect? Again, you had the minors to trial it so much or any knock-on, good or
- bad, just anything you didn't fight. It's hard to anticipate all the second order
- effects. Yeah. Again, you know, I think for the most part, we were pretty good at knowing what's
- going to happen just because we have so much, you know, data from testing that, that
- we kind of know what to expect. There's certain things we thought may, may go a little different, but for the most part,
- it's, it's, it's pretty close to in line with, with what we thought was going to
- happen. I think like the fan reaction has been really positive. That's been a bit of a pleasant surprise.
- I mean, I thought we, we thought it was going to be positive, but maybe not as positive as it has been.
- I think the player reception has been positive as well. They like having this tool at their disposal.
- And I mean, we knew the umpires were good. Right. So I think there was a lot of noise about all this puts the umpire umpires
- in an unfair position and all this, and it is difficult, right? We're not saying that job's already super difficult.
- Right. But you know, I think most fans have come away from this with even a greater
- appreciation for how good the umpires are than they probably had before. So I, you know, I think, you know,
- if anything, maybe that like little bit of like umpire appreciation might be the surprise, but
- in a good way. Yeah. That's great. I just point out, I went to a spring training game in February, one of the
- early spring training games, Marlins Cardinals. And I think the Marlins overturned like five
- calls in a row. And I, and I'm thinking this is going to be a disaster because it's delaying and
- it's so many of them. But by the time the season rolled around, it was way, way, way in line with
- what we're seeing. And by the end of the season, it's even more efficient. And you really see that it's effective.
- And when you go to a game, it's a great moment where it flashes on the board and everyone's excited.
- And, and it's, I can't tell you, it's, it's rare for me as a conservative traditionalist,
- I'm going to confess, to see an innovation being introduced that I really, really like.
- So yeah. Thanks for saying that. I appreciate it. Yeah. I'm glad I'm, I'm a little bit more
- like that too. So I think I can understand that. Guys, I want to give before to let
- Joe go in a minute. We're curious if there's anything coming next, but real quickly, the last innovation, the last big
- innovation, I want to give you a little love for, and that the pitch clock sitting
- down to watch the playoffs this year in the middle of football season, I run a little bit more college football, Joe.
- So in the middle of football season, I plunked down to watch, it's been such a great playoffs.
- I've watched some baseball and I'm like, I genuinely think the baseball games move faster than
- the football games. And that, that has never felt that way in the past. Now it may be the elongation on football,
- but baseball is like moving through it. Even the commercials are shorter. It's just like a better paced thing.
- It is leagues better than it was a few years ago. Major props to major league baseball for the
- pitch clock. Yeah. Thank you. That was, that was a fun one too. Um, and I, you know, I appreciate you
- saying that and I'm glad, I'm glad you like it. Hopefully you all do. It's, you know, it's something that I think
- surprised a lot of people. I know my dad, when we were talking about, uh, implementing, this is like, this is
- going to be a disaster. I'm like, dad, I think it's going to be okay. You know, it's kind of like someone talking
- him off the ledge. Um, and then, uh, you know, a couple of weeks in, he's like, this is great.
- I sit down and watch the game. You know, I go to bed at a reasonable time. Like, yeah, it's, it's thanks dad, you know,
- glad you came around. But, uh, it's, so you guys are on a roll. What's, what's, what's going to be next?
- Next. Yeah. I don't know. Um, good ones, the line and fruits you picked up now. Yeah.
- Yeah. You know, I didn't think we knew there to begin with. I think the pitch clock was a pretty
- obvious one, right? But the, the pace, the pace thing was an issue. Um, but, uh, I'd love to see a
- limitation on the number of pitchers on the roster. Yeah. I mean, we have that. It's just on, you know, it's at, uh,
- you know, 13, I guess right now. Yeah. Um, that's a tough one because there's always
- the, you know, how does that impact like player health? Um, you know, pitchers throw so much harder
- now than they ever have before. Um, you know, so that, that's a, that's a difficult one.
- It's something that we've looked at a lot, right? The whole kind of question of a lot
- of questions about pitching, including like the role of the starting pitcher, right?
- You see a lot more innings covered by relief pitchers now, not maybe something fans like,
- you know, again, it's an entertainment product. The more you can have main characters in
- your movie, the better. Um, and when you don't have kind of strong, uh, you know, five starters for every
- team that that can be a little bit difficult, but, um, I'm not exactly sure it has to make sense.
- Right. I don't think anything is, on the cusp, ready to go. Um, you know, we're, we're, we have some
- things in testing that, that we, you know, continue to do our diligence on. And I think, you know, it's a, it's
- a fairly like involved process to make that decision that this is something that belongs in
- the major league game because obviously like the, the bars will settle at a lot higher
- there. Well, we didn't like the man on second to start extra innings. Wasn't me.
- All right. Well, we didn't like that. So, you know, two out of three ain't bad as me.
- Yeah. I will say from the player perspective, players do not like extra innings.
- Right. Cause it, it, it does a lot of things, right? It's longer, right? You have to cover more innings as pitchers.
- So now you're a lot of times you're stretching guys beyond what they want and it
- messes with the roster, right? Like you got to send someone down and get someone up, you know, like it's, it's
- tough. So, um, while I know that came about because of COVID and all that, and some
- fans don't like it, I do think players appreciate it. I will say, I mean, even with that
- extra runner there, the extra innings in baseball, probably more closely emulate the actual game than
- any of the other sports. I mean, every one of the other sports is pulling in shenanigans in their extra, extra
- time as well. Basketball doesn't just short basketball, just shorter, but yeah. Hockey drops a player and they go to
- a shootout, right? Football, I guess they play, but it's kind of bad. Yeah. Well, it's not anymore, right?
- It's possession and then, yeah. Can I ask one more while we got you, what about the bigger bases?
- How, how, how have they played out? Has it mattered? Um, yeah, I think like maybe around the
- edges, it's, it's hard to say, right. Um, one of those things is just a little bit safer because players are just bigger
- now than they used to be. And if you can, you know, help people avoid running into each other, that's always a
- good thing. Um, so I think there is some like encouraging data there. Um, the other thing is more stealing.
- I think there's probably a larger impact from limiting the number of times pitchers can pick
- off and step off than just how, how big the bases are. But I think that's probably, there's probably a
- modest impact there as well. Okay. All right. We should let Joe go. I'm delighted to have you for the conversation,
- Joe. Thanks for making time for us, especially in the playoffs. Enjoy this world series, man.
- We're excited about it. Yeah. Thanks for having me on. New world champion coming down.
- I know it's crazy. It's gonna be exciting. I can't wait to watch what you guys do too.
- Great. Sure. Joe Martinez, Major League Baseball's vice president of on-field strategy, former pitcher, delighted first time
- visitor here at Wharton Moneyball. We still have half to go. Come back and join us after the break.
- Welcome back. Welcome back to Wharton Moneyball. Welcome to the second half of this week's
- show. The second half of a full hour here on the Wharton Podcast Network. This is Cade Massey with the whole crew,
- Shane, Adi, Eric, everybody's in here. This mid-October show we're recording on a
- Tuesday afternoon, as we usually do. Show will go up Wednesday. Been doing it for a while, 12 years,
- 12 and a half years, something like that. Joe Martinez, VP of baseball. What was it?
- On-field strategy. On-field strategy. On-field strategy. How fabulous was that discussion?
- That was great. That was great. Good lord. They've got the right guy in that job,
- huh? I mean, experience, savvy, communication ability. He was patient with us chumps.
- It was great. Let's keep talking baseball, guys. Tragically for me, the Guardians went out over
- the weekend, but Razor's still an interesting club. I think Eric pooh-poohed my Guardians love
- last week. I think it was because he likes for the best teams to advance in the playoffs.
- It wasn't right for this barely made it in team to beat the team with the best record.
- Eric, you must be very happy. These are the two teams with the best record from- I was going to say,
- I was going to start this off with an observation. This is a really bad year for my
- coin flip playoff model. I got to say, it's gone completely chalk, I think. Team with the highest regular season record has
- won basically every series. Well, you got one of those wild card. We had that conversation about the team coming
- back from 0-2 11% of the time, and then we had a team come back from 0-2. So you got a coin flip there.
- That's true. That's true enough. That's true. No. The thing that's been remarkable about these teams,
- and I know it for me and Adi, it always goes back to comparing it to the Yankees, but even when these guys on
- the Rays or the Brewers make outs, might be an eight pitch out, 10 pitch out, 12 pitch out.
- They're not wasting at bats and pitches. Rarely do you see really bad swings from
- these two teams on really bad pitches. And so that's made a difference. I mean, even when the Brewers were playing
- the Dodgers, I mean, even when the Japanese... Jake Bowers with those 12, 14 pitch at
- bats. Yamamoto. He was going to be at 90 pitches plus after five innings. I don't care how many runs he gave
- up. He wasn't going longer than five innings. There's no chance of it. Matter of fact, when Bowers batted against him,
- they took him out right after the at bat. I think he was exhausted. He had like 30 pitches that inning because
- like 17 of them in that one at bat were to Bowers. Well, the amazing thing about Bowers is that
- we had that conversation. Everyone had that conversation. And then the next game or two games
- later, he put another 11 pitch at bat with the home run in there. I mean, the guy just cemented his legacy.
- It's unbelievable. I know. When's the last time there's been... I don't know. I think I could look this up while
- you guys are talking. When's the last time there's been a World Series? Didn't both these teams won 100 games?
- Did the Rays? I don't think the Rays were 100. They were close. Did the Leafs 100?
- That I don't know, but I know the Yankees were not... No, they were at 98. When was the last time that the two
- teams with the best regular season records met in the World Series? That must be relatively rare as well, especially
- if... I think Red Sox might be rare because they don't have to be in different leagues.
- Right. Yeah, you know, right. Red Sox, Dodgers. I meant the best in both. Yeah, best in both.
- Red Sox, Dodgers 2018, I think was one of those. I just remember because that was one where
- the Red Sox had to beat three 100 -win teams going kind of through those playoffs.
- So I'm pretty sure the Dodgers were the top best team in all that year. Do y'all have preferences in this Little
- World Series? Yes, the Brewers. Brewers. Because you're a guy, you're a former student
- there? Well, okay. Yes, but also they really love baseball in Milwaukee. And Tampa, I mean, I just feel like
- the Floridians, it's just not deep in their blood like it is in other locales. Even though they've got spring ball down there?
- Yeah, I mean, it's just, I mean, it just always felt to me that Florida baseball
- is very sensitive to how well the team is doing. And Milwaukee Brewers, the people, they breathe it.
- Are you sure this isn't just an American League East rival bias? I mean, I'll admit to some of that
- too. Sharing for the Rays is something I've had to adopt slowly. I did adopt it this playoffs, but it
- doesn't feel natural for me. But I mean, I'll agree with Adi that I think the Brewers kind of have a
- more passionate, longer-suffering fan base. I mean, they've obviously gone longer even winning
- it all than Tampa has. By the way, the last time the two best teams from each league met in the
- World Series was actually 2014. Yankees-Dodgers two years ago. And then Rays-Dodgers five times since 1995.
- Right. Obviously, I have to have a slight preference towards the Rays just because of my relatives
- in the Tampa area. For the same reason, I like the Buccaneers. It's interesting.
- I've asked them recently, all of my relatives and all the friends I know down there
- in Tampa, forget that the Bucs stink this year, forget that. If you could have a Bucs championship or
- a Rays championship, it's sort of to the point of Adi, do they really care about
- baseball at all? Every one of them would take a Rays championship. Now, part of it is because they've never
- won one. And the Bucs just recently won one thanks to Tom Brady. And so, I think for that reason, they
- would take it. Like, for example, if you would ask New Yorkers, I'm a native New Yorker, which one
- you would have taken, they would have said Knicks by far. Yeah, but now that the Knicks have won,
- now I'm sure they'd shift to saying, well, we want another Yankees one because the Yankees
- have won in whatever, the last 25 years. I know, I've seen you smile. It's hard to imagine.
- What a life I've led where the Yankees have somehow in my lifetime become this long
- suffering fan base. It's not how I grew up. It's not how I grew up. The crazy part is they play in the
- playoffs just about every year and just get eliminated rarely. I saw a random stat here that I
- think it's the, I popped in the rundown that the AL, this is the fourth consecutive
- year in which the AL pennant winners had missed the playoffs the previous year. That's kind of an interesting stat.
- I feel like that's baseball. I mean, maybe I'm stuck on the Giants' yo-yo and the Sox' yo-yo.
- We've just seen some pretty distinct yo-yos in the last 20 years. And certainly, I think easier to like, like
- you've seen teams go worse to first and these types of things, between season variability can
- be quite high. Shane's point's interesting. That means that the Rays, I mean, we
- know obviously it means they didn't make the playoffs last year, but they went from not
- making the playoffs to the best team in the AL. Now that's different than a yo-yo where
- you speak in and then all of a sudden, I mean. Yeah, this is winner of the AL pennant.
- So this is the AL World Series representative for the last four years has missed the
- playoffs the previous year. But in this case, it happens to be the team that also ended up with the
- best record. Yeah. Yeah. No, that's right. Yeah. I guess that's that. Yeah. Guys, help me understand one of the most
- stunning things I've heard about this World Series, which is that it's the only the second
- time in the last hundred years of baseball that neither team has won a championship before.
- And it's the first time in 46 years. The stupid Yankees weren't in like every World
- Series for about 60 years in a row. Okay. So let's work out the factors that generate
- this rarity. That's, that's a part of it, huh? Okay. Yeah. Well, I mean, and also not that many
- teams up until like, uh, up until the 60s or whatever, right? The Brewers have all been around since like
- 60 or so, but like you, you go to any other sport and I haven't done this yet, but the number would be very
- different in other sports. I've got, I've got to believe that we've just had more new must not speak to.
- We, I guess maybe, maybe it's just chance because we've had plenty of new winners.
- They just haven't played each other or the potential new winners haven't played each other.
- Yeah. I think that I have to kind of think about across the sports because, you know,
- it's certainly common enough for one of the participants to not have won it before, but
- for both of them, I think that's pretty rare. There's only five teams. I just looked it up.
- There's only five teams that have never won a world series. So the Rockies is one Brewers Padres Mariners
- raids. So some really new teams and some moderately new teams by baseball standards.
- Okay. So it's just a low, it's a low denominator issue. Okay. How many in the other leagues, Eric, while
- you're fiddling with your keyboard, they're tiring football, right? There's I think there's at least eight or
- nine teams that haven't won a super bowl. Okay. I mean, God bless the Buffalo bills.
- I've never won the super bowl. Let's see here. Wow. 12 teams have never won a super bowl.
- So let's think about the Cleveland Browns, the Detroit Lions, Houston, Texas, and Jaguars have never
- appeared in a super bowl. And then here are the eight teams that have appeared, but never won.
- Well, two of them, we know painfully the Buffalo bills, sorry, Cade, the Minnesota Vikings, the
- same, they predate it. Exactly. Bengals. Shane's going to smile when I say this one, the Falcons, the Panthers, the Cardinals, the
- chargers and the Titans. So there's 12 teams have never won a man. Some of those things lost painfully Titans, lost
- painfully Cardinals, lost painfully. The Falcons lost painfully. The bills have lost painfully, man.
- Those are some brutal. I saw it's interesting, actually, uh, kind of an ancillary kind of, uh, observation.
- I saw the NFC South and West are the only two divisions where every team has reached the super bowl in the last 20
- NFC South and NFC West. Yeah. That's not surprising. South panthers last 20 years.
- Yeah. The bucks, the Panthers have been there twice. Bucks have been there twice.
- Saints have only been there once. Falcons have only been there once, but they've
- all gotten there since you just asked. Okay. It's up 10 NBA teams have never won
- the title. So, um, the following five have never made the finals, the Hornets, the Clippers, the Grizzlies,
- the T wolves, and the Pelicans. And then here are the teams that have made it, but never won the sons, the
- nets, the Pacers, the magic, and the jazz. Okay. So all these interesting though, there's so look,
- it's not, they roughly the same number of teams. It's interesting that there's a lot fewer MLB
- teams that have never won then NBA or NFL. They roughly all roughly have 30 to 32
- teams and the last 60 years, or, you know, the, and you know, the, uh, Superbowl
- has been around for 60 years. NBA, they're basically counting the last 60 years,
- you know, et cetera. It's interesting that it's five for baseball, 12 for the NFL, 10 for the NBA.
- Has the expansion been about the same across the three leagues? I mean, the NHL is a 10 and
- I think a lot of that is fueled by expansion. You know, like, like, you know, I, I
- think, you know, the, the, the NF there's been only, there's only like say two teams,
- historical teams in the NHL that have never won, which is the Vancouver Canucks and the
- Buffalo Sabres ones that kind of have been around for our whole, most of our whole
- lifetimes. All the rest that have not won our expansion teams, you know, recent or not, you
- know, the jets are in there and the wild and the predators, et cetera. So it's, it's, it's, I feel like the
- expansion dynamics, I think are a big part of the story, at least in the NHL. Yeah.
- Yeah. Yeah. Remind me of the recent, the team, the most recent expansion, um, baseball teams.
- Was it the Rockies and the, um, Marlins that came in? Yeah. That was late before that.
- Right. Yeah. It's been 30 years or more than that. I don't, I can't remember exactly how baseball
- in a long time. I think it's the Rockies and the Marlins. Maybe the expansion teams in the baseball, in
- baseball, assuming expansion is roughly similar across the three leagues, expansion in baseball across four leagues.
- Maybe they, those they've had more success sooner. Um, that there's something about baseball that allowed
- them to get there quicker. God knows, um, hockey. So what do you guys think? Someone, I guess Shane put in the rundown.
- Kolshy has it's 62, 38 brewers. Does that seem about right to everybody? Yup. Definitely.
- I mean, it's hard for me to argue 50, 50, given what's going on, what's happened,
- uh, like, uh, in the playoffs so far, I w I would probably shrink a little bit more towards 50, 50, just because I
- haven't totally given up. I mean, that means every game is about what, what, I mean, what do you think
- the probabilities are on an individual game, Eric? 50, I mean, assuming no Hill and field,
- assume a home field advantage, but not a big one, something like 56%, maybe most.
- Probably. Yeah. Yeah. Something like that. Give me the, give me the breakdown on
- why you're not surprised, uh, that the brewers are that, that big of a favor. That's not a huge favorite.
- It's still a pretty big one. First of all, it's Kolshy. So it's a betting market.
- It's not, no one's sitting with a model. I mean, although underlying, there's probably something the
- way they've just manhandled the Dodgers. I mean, the fact of the matter is matters is Cleveland is not a good team.
- And by any real absolutist measure, um, they took care of the Yankees pretty, pretty easily,
- but the Yankees are a weak team in many respects as well. And Brewer is just at the best record
- in baseball. And they, they be the Dodgers who were favored, I think going in. No, or, or, or you just, uh, to
- kind of expand on that, I do feel like kind of going into the playoffs, I felt like, you know, like probably the five,
- the four best teams were all on the NL side. And then it was maybe the Rays and the Yankees where I would have even maybe
- put the Yankees ahead, the Rays, like going, going into the playoffs. But, but I, I do kind of feel
- like it's the NL has just been kind of the, where most of the really good teams have been the last couple of years.
- Well, let's use that to pivot to another sport that is notable right now because the
- NBA is kicking off tonight and going back to Kolshy and talking about this afternoon, not
- tonight, today, this afternoon, Kolshy gives almost half the probability of the championship to two Western
- teams, the Spurs and the Thunder. So one, just the dominance of one conference like that, but 46% likelihood on two
- teams. I mean, would you take, I'm assuming you'd all take the field against that.
- Even a little bit of big. Okay. Um, but also that it does speak to how open the East, I mean, let's think
- about, no, no. How would you get to that? I think most people would say there's a,
- at least a three quarters chance. The Western conference champion is either the Spurs
- or the Thunder. I don't think that's too far out of line. I felt like people really do under that
- team, having a 60% chance to win the finals. Then you're at 45%, 0.75 times 0 .6. I just think that we tend to
- overestimate randomness in basketball and underestimated in, in baseball and hockey.
- Really? Would you refute those numbers that, that the models probably say either the Spurs or this,
- or the Thunder, I'm about a 70, 75 % chance to win the Western conference. And then a 60% chance roughly to
- win the finals, which gets you to 45%. It's not that miscalibrated. Those are two teams to win at all.
- Not, not to make it to the, yeah. No, no. But I'm trying to say why I'm adding the two of them to get to 40
- something percent to win the finals. One of them has to win the, only one can win the Western conference.
- I'm saying it's not, it's not unbelievable. Are you claiming that there's a, what is
- their probability of winning the finals if one of the two teams makes it? I'm saying, I'm guessing about 60.
- I'm, I'm giving, being conservative and I'm going to say 60%. And then there's a 75% chance that
- one of them will make the final. It's not crazy. Everybody, it was a shootout. It's not crazy, but it was the same
- thing last year and they lost. That's what I'm going to say, Shane. Last year it was.
- But you can't condition on a crazy, crazy outcome and imagine that's typical. Adi, I think your, your summary is too
- cute to, because I just, you said, I think people overestimate uncertainty in basketball and under
- everywhere else. I'm just going to say under everywhere. It's one of the biggest biases in human
- judgment. All right. But they underestimate more. It's more. You get what I mean?
- Okay, fine. But I do think one sort of like, I think again, like key injuries and stuff
- like that. I don't, I, I'm still not sure that these types of things are kind of built
- into model based approaches or anything like that. That like really, you could lose your quarterback
- to an Yeah. For example, in football or when Benyama has some kind of, I would never wish that
- on any specific person, but that specific person that would change the odds dramatically.
- Which two let's, let's take the NHL finals, the NBA finals, the world series and the
- Superbowl. Which of those sports would you give the greatest differential to one team over another?
- Like we just talked about MLB being 62, 38. Let's say the Superbowl was this year.
- I don't know. Let's make it up. Let's say it's the chiefs against the 49ers. You're certainly not going to go over 60
- % for either team. I mean, come on. Right. I was actually just wondering about this because
- the baseball playoffs, like we talk about the sport at a game level and we talk about the season level.
- We don't often talk about it at the knockout level, the difference in randomness across sports
- between a seven game playoff and a one game knockout. We've never, I've never seen that analysis.
- I just asked chat GPT to do the calculation you just asked for. Yep. It's 55.9%. Hey, you said 56%.
- Do you know, that's a very difficult expansion to do in your head, by the way, that's another victory for human intelligence.
- I did not use, I did not. I was, no, you didn't. I did though in the background and it
- came out with 55.9%. Mazel tov. Congratulations. Thank you. Great. Well, I'm going to have to leave on
- that note. So guys have a see you all next week. Well, let's stay with Eric's question for a
- second. Cause I do think it's an interesting question about the across sport comparison of knockout probabilities
- in the playoffs because it's you're now you're comparing two differences, sports and number of games.
- And we're saying 6238 is a modest favorite in baseball. And you're trying to compare that to other
- sports. So say a super bowl. Yeah. And I mean, we're also conditioned like, like
- thinking across like the finals of each of these different sports, you're also kind of trying
- to factor in how probable it would be that you'd get a dramatic mismatch. Right.
- And, and I think basketball, maybe we've seen the most dramatic mismatch conference conferences.
- Yeah, yeah, exactly. I feel like it, or, or, and, and just the, I think basketball, at least my,
- my theory would be that it consult, it's still consolidate so much of its talent on
- a small number of teams. Um, it's, it would be easier for that small number of teams to, for example, find
- themselves all in the same conference, but Shane, it's hard. It's like you said earlier, it's hard to
- hear these arguments now in the wake of last year's finals. No, no, for sure. For sure.
- No, I mean, that's why I said that would be the theory. I'm not sure I even believe in that
- particular narrative myself, but. Okay guys, before we go out of here, let's that's, and while we're challenging markets, I'm
- curious to your reaction to one market line this coming weekend in the NFL, by the
- way, I think it's the first weekend in football where I would say the NFL slate looks more interesting than the college slate.
- We're a little spoiled after an incredible college football weekend last weekend, but this coming weekend,
- look, there'll be good stuff that happens Saturday, but there's a pretty decent slate on the
- NFL side. But one game really jumped out to me. The Sunday night game is chiefs going out
- to Seattle. And look, I'm not, I'm not running numbers this year. I'm just the, the Rube on the sidelines
- looking at the lines, but I was surprised to see Seattle favored with Casey because Casey
- has been on such a tear so far. I'm guessing y'all aren't y'all play coach retention this to me than me.
- No, I mean, I would, I would, I would favor Casey in that too. So the fact that the line does seem
- to, even if Seattle's at home and it, you know, they probably have as big a home field advantage as one can have in
- football, but no, I would take, I would take Casey. Can you explain it to us? I probably would too, but shockingly, that wasn't
- the game. I love that game. That wasn't the game that caught my eye. The Thursday night game, new England and Chicago,
- that game has, you know, that's battle battle, the number one and the number three pick
- in a couple years ago. What an intriguing game that is just that they're both playing extraordinarily well right now.
- And I, I, I have no idea who's going to win that game. They both have in my view in the
- next 10 years, it's not obvious. Either of those teams would trade their quarterback
- for anybody in the NFL. I think those are two really good teams. That's the game that caught my eye.
- But of course, we're fortunate. We have a great Thursday night game. We have some interesting Sunday slates.
- We have a great Sunday night game. We have a dog of a Monday night game because, you know, I'm quarterbacking for the
- Eagles on Sunday, on Monday. So who knows, but we have a great - Yeah, I feel, I guess we're not
- at the flexing part of the schedule, right? Because I feel like that, that Monday night
- game would probably get, if it was later on, would get- Well, it's division rival.
- You're going to ride the division rivals, Cowboys and Eagles. Man, that's just brutal.
- What, what brutal week news for the Eagles this week? No, no. I mean, absolutely devastating.
- It's like, you know, I guess it's, there's a lot of promise coming into the season,
- I feel like. No, but you go back to, you go back to Shane's point on your point earlier,
- just Kate, about injuries. So, you know, if all of a sudden you told me tomorrow that, I don't know,
- Brock, I don't even know who their backup is now at San Francisco. If Brock Purdy goes out or if Mahomes
- goes out, or if, you know, Caleb Williams, who knows how long he was going to be out, or if Drake May goes out.
- Those, Josh Allen goes out. Forget 75, 60 anymore. That's all gone. And so, you know, the Eagles, I don't
- want to say, I think they have 0 % chance to win the Super Bowl. They're not winning the Super Bowl now.
- They're not, maybe they could make the playoffs because the division stinks so bad.
- But I mean- And somehow it's, but also somehow it's worse than it's an off -field thing.
- And you're also like worried about his health and all that stuff. So it's just this odd, it's all of
- that drama with on-field consequences from an off-field- No, but your point is well taken, which is why don't we make
- the assumption that every time we make a probabilistic statement about the NFL or any sport,
- we have to model it as a mixture distribution and we have to make it, that already raises variance, but we have to make
- an assumption that there's even a small to medium-sized probability that there's a spike at
- some very low number. And then what happens is, then you don't get Kaoshi. I mean, even in the NBA, there's, you
- know, Wemba Nyama had bought blood pots, by the way. He gets injured or someone on the Thunder
- gets injured. They're not going, they're not 75 anymore. There's zero. So why don't we at least mix that
- in? That I think would be, you know, a more model-based approach, like a filter you
- could just apply to Kaoshi somehow and just add that in there. Yeah, it's a mixture distribution.
- As a matter of fact, I'm confident that if you did a statistical test of the fit of a mixture distribution, as opposed to
- any flexible unimodal distribution you want, I think the mixture is going to fit better.
- And I think we should- You need a big sample to get enough of those tail events, but in a big enough sample,
- you're going to get it. All right, guys, why don't we end on that note for the whole crew here, Shane
- Jensen and Eric Redlow through the whistle, Audie Weiner, almost, Joe Martinez, our guest, for Jacob
- Grodnick, our producer, and Deep Patel, the boss lady. Thank you guys for listening.
- Come back and join us next time. Between now and then, enjoy your sports.
Brief Summary
Joe Martinez explains MLB's ABS challenges and strike zones, then Wharton Moneyball debates playoff odds, NFL lines, and injury-driven uncertainty.
Key points
- From the mound to the front office. After realizing a playing career wouldn’t mean never working again, Joe Martinez combined his baseball experience with years in consulting to find his way back to the game.
- Why only two ABS challenges?. Joe says the limit balances fairness with entertainment, game pace, and the need to save challenges for high-leverage moments. Keeping the rules simple matters, too.
- The challenge system’s hidden advantage. The hosts point out that catchers may have a better view of pitches than hitters, potentially giving the defensive team an edge. Joe acknowledges the asymmetry but says the league has not considered different challenge l
- A surprisingly accurate guess. The group estimates how much run value teams recover with ABS challenges. Eric guesses the total is just under half a run—and the hosts say he nailed it.
- A strike zone that no longer breathes. The group contrasts the old, shifting strike zone with a consistent zone based on each player’s measured height. The change brings clarity, though some fans may miss the human variability.
- The pitch clock wins over skeptics. A traditionalist says baseball now moves faster than football, and a guest shares how his dad went from predicting disaster to loving the pitch clock.
Episode highlights
- From the mound to the front officeAfter realizing a playing career wouldn’t mean never working again, Joe Martinez combined his baseball experience with years in consulting to find his way back to the game.“Baseball is kind of a gravitational pull to it.”2:42Oct 21, 2026
- Why only two ABS challenges?Joe says the limit balances fairness with entertainment, game pace, and the need to save challenges for high-leverage moments. Keeping the rules simple matters, too.“Let's just play baseball.”9:08Oct 21, 2026
- The challenge system’s hidden advantageThe hosts point out that catchers may have a better view of pitches than hitters, potentially giving the defensive team an edge. Joe acknowledges the asymmetry but says the league has not considered different challenge l10:22Oct 21, 2026
- A surprisingly accurate guessThe group estimates how much run value teams recover with ABS challenges. Eric guesses the total is just under half a run—and the hosts say he nailed it.“That was brilliant. It nails it.”16:52Oct 21, 2026
- A strike zone that no longer breathesThe group contrasts the old, shifting strike zone with a consistent zone based on each player’s measured height. The change brings clarity, though some fans may miss the human variability.“The strike zone was almost like a living, breathing thing.”24:23Oct 21, 2026
- The pitch clock wins over skepticsA traditionalist says baseball now moves faster than football, and a guest shares how his dad went from predicting disaster to loving the pitch clock.“I go to bed at a reasonable time.”29:07Oct 21, 2026
- Why players appreciate the extra-inning runnerExtra innings can stretch pitchers and disrupt rosters, so players appreciate the runner-on-second rule even if some fans dislike it.“Players do not like extra innings.”31:32Oct 21, 2026
- Bowers wears down YamamotoJake Bowers’ long at-bats pushed Yamamoto’s pitch count up, and he followed up with another marathon plate appearance that included a home run.“The guy just cemented his legacy.”35:48Oct 21, 2026
