The Truth About Immigration: Why Successful Societies Welcome Newcomers

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Immigrants have long been cast as outsiders who take jobs and damage the economy. Exequiel (Zeke) Hernandez, the Max and Bernice Garchik Family Presidential Assistant Professor at the Wharton School, dispels these stereotypes and others in his new book, "The Truth About Immigration: Why Successful Societies Welcome Newcomers."

This episode is part of the Ripple Effect's “Meet the Authors” series, in collaboration with the Wharton School Press. Learn more about Hernandez's book: https://whr.tn/4cjpiSV

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Zeke Hernandez: [in progress] is that it's not that natives are losing at the expense of
  2. immigrants. They're both better off because of those— those differences, and that variety.
  3. Dan Loney: You talk a little bit in the book about the connection between immigration and job creation and investment, and
  4. maybe even more so the investment side. Tell us about what you see there. Yeah, that's such an important question, because that's one of
  5. the most misunderstood aspects of what immigration does to the economy. So let's do a simple example. You know, we're sitting
  6. here in Philadelphia. Just a few miles from here, in a place called Hometown, Pennsylvania— small town, 3500 people. Last
  7. year, EMD Electronics announced the expansion of a facility that would create 200 high-skill manufacturing jobs. These were
  8. jobs to create parts that are really critical for chips, right? So this is the kind of jobs that everybody wants
  9. in America. - And welcome to a special edition of Ripple Effect: Meet the Authors.
  10. authors. I'm your host, Dan Loney. In each episode this month, the podcast will feature Wharton faculty authors in
  11. lively, fast-moving conversations about their latest books and research. We're going to be covering a diverse range of
  12. topics, bringing you the latest insights and knowledge that you can apply to your life and to work. Hello, and welcome to The
  13. Ripple Effect: Meet the Author series. I'm your host, Dan Loney. Today, a pleasure to speak with Zeke Hernandez about
  14. his book, <i>The Truth About Immigration</i>, that book about why successful societies welcome newcomers. Zeke, great to see you
  15. again. How are you? I'm good. Thanks for having me, Dan. You make the case in the book that we need to kind of broaden
  16. the conversation on the economic benefits of immigration. You say that— that most people are stuck on this perennial issue of
  17. whether immigrants take jobs or lower wages. Give us a sense of what you're trying to bring forward with the book.
  18. Yeah. You know, I've been researching this for nearly 20 years, and also speaking to a lot of audiences about this. And what
  19. I've observed is that the big problem in the way that we talk about immigrants in the economy is that we never get past
  20. questions that are about whether immigrants are harmful to us, like do immigrants take jobs or lower wages? And that's an
  21. important question. But when you look at the data, you realize that immigrants not just don't do harm, but they are net
  22. positives in a very, you know, in a very extreme sense. They bring a lot of good. And it's very-- so it's very different to say
  23. that something is not bad than to say that something is — is good, right? Like below zero versus above zero. And so we
  24. just need to broaden the lens to see the big picture. And then those questions that people commonly ask, we'll kind of
  25. understand them in the right perspective. So let's kind of start very high level. What goes into a successful economy,
  26. what goes into a successful business, since this is a Wharton audience, right? Well, just think of the inputs you need.
  27. You need, of course, people and talent. But you need investment, you need ideas and innovation. You need customers, you need new
  28. technologies, you need all kinds of things that are inputs into a successful economy and a successful business. The short
  29. of it is that the research tells us that immigrants contribute positively to all of those ingredients, right? And so we
  30. have to broaden the conversation by thinking about that. And a successful economy and a successful business doesn't just
  31. have a lot of those ingredients, a lot of those inputs, but it has a great variety of those. And the way we get both a higher
  32. quantity and a higher variety of those two things is because of the movement of people. People that come from different
  33. backgrounds bring more and a greater variety of those two things. So that's— that's the big picture. And if we— if we frame
  34. the conversation that way, then we can really understand the economic effect immigrants have.
  35. So to a degree, there's been somewhat of an underselling of the value that immigrants have on an economy. - Completely,
  36. right? Because typically, if you— if you read the headlines, or the popular conversation, or especially the political
  37. conversation, the most positive we tend to get is "Oh, immigrants fill job shortages." Right? There's a shortage in this
  38. particular industry, we need foreign-born talent. And so whether it's nurses, construction workers,
  39. manufacturing workers, people with STEM skills, immigrants fill those shortages. And so they kind of plug holes in the
  40. economy. And that's, of course, a really important function. But we never get to, like, the win- win, in that immigrants create
  41. all these incredible innovations. Immigrants bring more investment. Immigrants do all these things that are not
  42. just plugging holes, right? And so yeah, we're totally underselling the issue. And I'm sure we'll have a conversation
  43. about what those positives are. - Well, exactly. And so let's continue there. Because I think you can
  44. look at a variety of different avenues right now of where the value of immigration can be in this country. And I guess when
  45. you even think about the dynamics of who is— makes up the workforce right now, a lot of conversation about the older
  46. generations, who are moving closer towards retirement and will be in the workforce in the next few years. Well, you have to
  47. replace those people. And part of that will be around immigration. Yeah, yeah. And it's even more than that. Because it's not just
  48. people that are retiring. We— we lose 700,000 people in prime working age to death every year in this country. 700,000. Right?
  49. Working age people. We don't even replace that many through our— through our legal immigration system. Right? And
  50. so you have to plug in the holes left by retirees and people who are working age who are leaving the workforce for, you know, for
  51. tragic reasons. Right? And— and that's just the beginning. This sounds somewhat similar, I guess, to the debate about
  52. diversity in the office, or on a board of directors. That the more options you present in that situation, the better the final
  53. product can be. In this instance, the more options you have in a workforce, potentially, the better the
  54. bottom line will be for companies moving forward. Yeah, absolutely. Right. This is not just an economy wide thing,
  55. but a business thing. We— we have evidence that when firms hire people from different national backgrounds, they perform
  56. better. They're also more innovative. But here's the— I think the part that is really insightful is that those people
  57. from different international backgrounds make native workers more creative and more productive. Here's one example.
  58. Immigrants in the US are 18% of the inventive workforce, meaning people who patent. Okay? 18%. But they account for 36% of all
  59. patents in the United States. Now, that number you can break it down in two in a way that's really interesting. 23% of
  60. patents are patents where the immigrants are directly the inventors on record. - Right. - But the other 13% is native
  61. inventors patenting more because they work with immigrant inventors. Why? Because the immigrant inventors bring new
  62. ideas, they bring new networks, they bring new ways to solve problems. And so that's what I mean by a win-win, right? Is— is
  63. that it's not that natives are losing at the expense of immigrants. They're both better off because of those— those
  64. differences and that variety. You talk a little bit in the book about the connection between
  65. immigration and job creation and investment, and maybe even more so the investment side. Tell us about what you see
  66. there. Yeah, that's such an important question, because that's one of the most misunderstood aspects of what immigration does to the
  67. economy. So let's do a simple example. You know, we're sitting here in Philadelphia. Just a few miles from here in a place
  68. called Hometown, Pennsylvania— a small town, 3500 people. Last year EMD Electronics announced the expansion of a facility that
  69. would create 200 high-skilled manufacturing jobs. These were jobs to create parts that are really critical for chips,
  70. right? So this is the kind of jobs that everybody wants in America. And Hometown seems like a weird place, right, for a high-
  71. tech facility to grow and create 200 jobs. - Right. - Okay. But then you realize that EMD Electronics is a subsidiary of a German
  72. company. And you're like, okay, what does that have to do with anything? Well, it turns out that Hometown, a long time ago,
  73. was founded by German immigrants, right? And it's not a coincidence that today, a German company is investing and
  74. thriving and creating jobs in Hometown, Pennsylvania. So we have a lot of research showing that where immigrants go, firms
  75. make investment. Okay? And this— and these effects last for generations. So where there's a lot of, say, Germans,
  76. historically, a lot of German investment will follow. And it's true for Mexican firms. It's true for Korean firms. It's true
  77. for every nationality. And so this is what I call the investment-immigration-jobs triangle. Immigrants arrive,
  78. they foster investment from their home countries, those investments create jobs. The other link between immigration
  79. and investment in jobs is that immigrants are 80% more likely than natives to start businesses of all kinds. From
  80. the high-tech Google and Zooms of the world to the mom and pop restaurants that we all love to eat in. And at— regardless of
  81. size, regardless of type of business, immigrant-founded businesses create more jobs than native-founded businesses. So
  82. whether it's through pulling capital from their home countries, or investing their own capital in new businesses,
  83. immigrants create jobs through that triangle I just mentioned It— it's been a big part
  84. of the story. But all that you've laid out right there really again does highlight the need for proper
  85. policy around immigration. And that obviously has been a debate that's been going for many, many years now without
  86. enough of a— of a true conclusion. - Yeah. So I think that another reason that I wrote this book is that
  87. not just in the United States, but in every country that's having the debate that we're having, there's an obsession
  88. with how immigrants come into our countries. You know, legally, you know, illegally. For work, for family reasons. And of
  89. course, it's important to know that. But we're not obsessed enough with what immigrants do once they're here. Right? And so
  90. we have to separate immigration, which is what people do when they come, which is what we've been talking about— they create
  91. all these economic benefits and cultural benefits that we haven't spoken about. And so once you understand what
  92. immigrants do, it gives you more clarity on what our policies be for how many and how people should come in, is kind of the
  93. point. And so, you know, if immigrants are just not bad, policy is very different than if immigrants are net positives and
  94. bring all the benefits we just talked about. And so, in the United States, the analogy that I often use is that our
  95. immigration system is just really outdated. The last time we updated our system here was in 1990. The economy was $9
  96. trillion in size back then. Today, it's $25 trillion in size. Okay? - Yeah. So we have an economy that's more than double
  97. the size, operating with a— a system, a speed limit, if you want to think about it, that is just too low. Right? Not only do
  98. we not replace the number of working age people who die, which I just mentioned, but we're not even providing enough
  99. people for all the growing businesses that we need. And so— so we just need more and a greater variety of pathways in.
  100. So then with this being a topic that obviously is playing out in other countries as well— - Yeah.
  101. — this becomes a global problem that you're talking about, longer term, with the expansion you just
  102. kind of alluded to not only needing to happen here in the US, but places like Australia, the Far East, Europe,
  103. wherever, you know, this is becoming an issue. Yeah. Yeah. And I'll make a bold prediction here, right, is that a
  104. lot of rich countries so far have been what I call immigration choosers, meaning they've had sort of their pick
  105. of the litter because there's a lot of people who want to— who want to move to those countries to make a living and find a
  106. better life and contribute. But because of demographic trends in most of the world— birth rates shrinking, people aging, new
  107. people coming from fewer and fewer countries, I think there's going to be a lot more geopolitical competition and a
  108. lot of countries are going to become immigration beggars, right? They're going to be desperate for— for the talent
  109. and the people they need. So I think we— you know, we better get our act together before we become immigration beggars.
  110. You mentioned the element of innovation. What other areas do you see as important when you think about the benefits of
  111. having immigrants coming into a country? Yeah, so I gave the example earlier of patents, right, and the
  112. 36%. And that's— that's what I call highbrow innovation, right? And we're aware of that. Not just patents, but we think
  113. of high-tech startups, right? So— so, you know, Zoom, Google, Intel, like, you name a high tech startup, it— you know, there's
  114. about at least a 50% chance that it had an immigrant co- founder. I think the part that gets underappreciated is what I
  115. call the lowbrow innovations, meaning the things that we do, we eat, we spend our time on every day that we completely take for
  116. granted, that we don't realize were brought by new people. I'll give just— just, you know, a few examples from kind
  117. of throughout a normal day. You wake up, you brush your teeth, right? Colgate toothpaste, you know, immigrant. You go check your
  118. email, right? On your smartphone. Well, that smartphone wouldn't exist without the contributions of
  119. immigrants. Maybe you want to have— you know, what, Mexican food, Italian food? A pizza, a hamburger for— you know, for
  120. lunch? Well, all of those are immigrant contributions. You want to go to the movies to see your favorite movies? Well, you
  121. know, a lot of— a very high proportion of the actors, actresses, directors, makeup artists that made that movie
  122. really good are foreign-born. Walk through your supermarket aisle. Okay? Think of the items you buy regularly and remove
  123. from the aisles the items that were brought in by immigrants. And your cart will be at least half empty. Right? And so
  124. sports, right soccer? - Sure. - You like to do karate, you like to do yoga, you'd like to go to the gym to do— you know, Zumba, I
  125. think, right? All of those are things that were introduced by immigrants. So the point is, like, a huge proportion of what
  126. you spend your time and money on, that makes your life richer and more interesting, was brought in by foreign
  127. contributions. And those are innovations just as much as a patent is an innovation. - Right. - That's my point. - Obviously
  128. with all of those areas you just touched on, you're talking about a potential significant negative impact from an economics
  129. perspective of not having enough of the right focus, so that you can push forward in a lot of those areas as well. - Yeah.
  130. Yeah. I mean, and we have historical precedents that show that very clearly. We hit the 100-year anniversary of the 1924
  131. National Origins Act in the United States. It was a biggest restriction of immigration in US history. It dropped immigration
  132. by over 90% for four decades in this country. There's good evidence, we have very good evidence now, to show that this
  133. was really damaging to the United States. For example, native-born scientists, who were less exposed to immigrants,
  134. patented nearly 70% less permanently. - Yeah. - Right? Places in the US that lost the most immigrants due to those
  135. restrictions, to this day, 20— you know, 100 years later, receive less investment than they did before and invest less overseas than
  136. they did before. Businesses in those places. American workers lost jobs and got lower quality jobs. So, you know, we know what
  137. happens, because it happened before. And— and I think we're at a historic moment where we need to be really clear about what
  138. immigrants do so that we make better decisions about— about our policies. And this is not just in a macro sense. This— again to
  139. the— to the business-minded people that are listening to this, this— this affects the everyday running of your
  140. business. Where are you going to recruit talent? Where are you going to get good ideas? How are you going to find customers? How
  141. are you going to find new markets? That's all going to be in— to a great degree. Not only, but to a great degree,
  142. because of foreign-born talent. Here is the book, <i>The Truth About Immigration</i>.
  143. Where can people pick it up right now? Everywhere you buy books. Everywhere you buy books.
  144. Zeke, great to have you with us today. Thanks very much for your time. - Thank you so much.
  145. Zeke Hernandez of the Wharton School. The book again, the title, <i>The Truth About Immigration</i>.
  146. - Thank you for listening to The Ripple Effect. We hope you found this episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to
  147. subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Zeke Hernandez discusses the economic benefits of immigration and the need for updated policies in this episode.

Key points

  • The Truth About Immigration. Zeke Hernandez discusses the economic benefits of immigration and the misconceptions surrounding it.
  • Investment-Immigration-Jobs Triangle. Hernandez explains how immigrants foster investment and create jobs in their communities.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes