Why Losing Can Be More Dangerous Than Winning

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE What happens when someone refuses to accept defeat? Losing a competition can create resentment, sabotage, and lasting consequences that extend far beyond the original contest.

Henning Piezunka, Associate Professor of Management at the Wharton School, discusses the psychology of competition and why some people struggle to defer to the winners.

Using Formula One racing and workplace dynamics, Piezunka explains how past rivalries influence future behavior and why managers need to pay attention to what happens after someone wins.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Competition is a very important part of our society in a variety of different forms, but
  2. when a competition ends, you normally see the losing individual defer to the winner about
  3. their success. But what happens if that individual does not win and does not defer
  4. to the other individual? Henning Piezunka is an Associate Professor of Management here at the
  5. Wharton School and has taken a deeper dive into this, both in the realm of sports, but also
  6. in the world of business as well. Henning, great to talk to you again. How are you, sir?
  7. Thanks for having me. Great to be here. This is a very interesting piece of research. Where did the genesis
  8. of looking at competition in this perspective come from? You know, Dan, it's a great question, right? Like your society is full of competition,
  9. right? Not always on the surface, right? We are not kind of say like, hey, you and I,
  10. we compete against another, but we often do, right? You compete with a colleague for promotion.
  11. And we have all kinds of areas in life where competition is like very salient, most notably in sports, right? And you see, sometimes you see this kind of, you have a
  12. look at the person who has clearly lost the competition and you observe their behavior,
  13. right? So this can be a colleague who doesn't get promoted. This can be a politician who
  14. doesn't win an election. This can be an athlete who loses a race, right? And you know, like,
  15. I kind of saw all of these kinds of actors and see like, look, what are they actually doing
  16. after they've lost a competition? And in many ways, and we tend to forget about this,
  17. is how the loser behaves is actually quite important for the whole system to work, right?
  18. Like imagine everybody was lost, would kind of just refusing like, hey, I didn't lose,
  19. I just keep on going, right? That wouldn't, society would kind of fall apart. And so this
  20. was very much like, hey, we saw these people and you know, like some people just like, okay,
  21. I lost, let's move on. And other people are like, eh, I'm going to relive this kind of
  22. competition on an ongoing basis. Right. And it just continues to be something that circles back
  23. into either the relationship with the other person or just kind of around their culture as well,
  24. correct? So you're absolutely right. You see, like, so what may happen, so let's imagine like
  25. an intra-organizational context, right? So you have a competition for who gets promoted. And at
  26. some point, like some person gets elected and say like, okay, you're the new boss. Right. And so,
  27. but what are the others are going to do? Right. Like the others also wants to be the boss and
  28. they're not necessarily going to immediately say like, okay, let me support you now in this new
  29. role that I would like to have. Right. But they may say instead, it's like, you know what,
  30. this is your problem. Now you are the boss, right? They may actually shirk. They may actually work a
  31. little bit less hard. They may be less willing to collaborate. The other thing that may actually
  32. happen is, I mean, that gets worse. They may actually sabotage the other person, right? Like,
  33. okay, you won. Well, it's not only that I stopped collaborating. I actually start bad mouthing you
  34. over your boss boss, right? You say like, you wouldn't believe what that person does. Like,
  35. how could you give that promotion to that person implicitly saying you should have given that
  36. promotion to me? Yeah. I can imagine that it really takes a turn if the two individuals involved
  37. are either friends or at least have been friendly in the past. Dan, you couldn't be, you couldn't
  38. be more spot on. This is the very, this is the very topic of the book I'm working on,
  39. on like how you compete with people, because very often you say there's a very rich relationship,
  40. right? You see, like very often you compete with like some distant person, but very often the
  41. people you compete with are like your colleagues, or it could be your friend or so, right? And so
  42. you see, like, this is a bunch of implications, Dan, right? Like the most salient for me, right?
  43. If you just compete against someone you're not particularly close with, whatever, that person
  44. moves on, you move on, you forget about the competition. But imagine you lose that fight
  45. for the promotion against your colleague. You see that person every single day. You get reminded of
  46. that loss every single day, right? So it really feels like, okay, not only like you keep on kind
  47. of stabbing me with this knife, thank you, right? Like this road is still open and you kind of keep
  48. on going, right? Like every day I'm reminded of the fact that I didn't win the competition.
  49. Especially if that person becomes your boss, right? And Dan, we just have, we have a fantastic PhD student at Wharton who's working on that very
  50. topic, who's actually asking the question, what happens if you get promoted within your team?
  51. Okay. What does this mean for yourself? How do other people going to support you?
  52. And so on. You're absolutely right. I know that you are somebody that has studied and looked at Formula One racing.
  53. And this can actually, I guess, play out in Formula One as well, because you're talking about teams that are racing in Formula One of two individuals.
  54. And if one has the success, could there be an impact on the other member of the team?
  55. So you're absolutely right. Like, let me kind of say why we did study this in Formula One,
  56. right? The kind of behavior we just talked about, Dan, is kind of difficult to observe,
  57. right? You see, like, we can't run a survey and say like, did you ever not get promoted and then
  58. sabotage the person who got promoted, right? Like that's nothing you can do. Nobody will admit to
  59. this, right? So, and this is the kind of behavior, which is very often subtle. It's not necessarily
  60. documented in databases. And so we wanted to kind of, where could we see this kind of behavior?
  61. And there's an interesting phenomenon in Formula One, right? Like everybody knows,
  62. like what a takeover is, right? You're like racing and, you know, like you're fighting
  63. for positions and then one takes over the other. But there's also this phenomenon,
  64. which is called lapping. And what lapping is, is if you're one round ahead, okay? And then you're
  65. kind of taking over the person you're already like one round ahead of. That's called lapping
  66. because you're now really like one full round ahead. That person is completely done, has basically
  67. no chance anymore to win against you, if you think about this as a kind of duel between the two.
  68. And so there are special rules in Formula One. It's to say like, look, if you're lapped, so if
  69. somebody else is about to take you over, who's a lap ahead of you, you're just supposed to literally
  70. go out of your way. Okay. The sociologist would say like, you have to defer that to that person,
  71. but you get out of the way. Okay. That's what you're supposed to do. These are the rules. And,
  72. you know, you could also just say like, you know what, this is just what decent behavior should
  73. look like. If you're not really kind of competing anymore, but the other person is kind of fighting
  74. hard for the victory, you should just get out of your way. Right. And what we studied is,
  75. do people actually get out of their way? Is that actually what they do? Can the results of one competition between two individuals have impact on future competitions?
  76. Like does that, does that impact carry on down the road, six months, 12 months beyond that point?
  77. So then you're absolutely right. This is exactly what happens. Okay. So imagine the following
  78. situation. You are kind of leading this race and I'm kind of a laggard. Okay. So I'm kind of here
  79. behind and you're about to lap me. Okay. And now obviously it's embarrassing and humiliating for
  80. me if you, if you lap me, right. There's, there's no way around it. Right. And now, but you see,
  81. like, it may have been, you see, like, maybe I've been used to this. Maybe you've lapped me a few
  82. times and then I'm going to be like, okay, whatever. This is not a duel I'm even going
  83. to fight anymore. But you know what? It could have been that you and I were actually like in
  84. really close competition in the past. Right. Maybe it was like, you know what, Dan and Henning,
  85. we used to be rivals and now kind of, you're really kind of leading this. And it's super
  86. embarrassing for me because I'm constantly thinking like, oh my God, like this was a fight
  87. I was kind of able to have. And then I really do not go out of my way. And the way we see this,
  88. it's kind of, I should say, it's kind of a funny measurement. We actually looking at your speed
  89. to detect my behavior. Okay. So how far that you're on a lap is informative of my behavior.
  90. And that's exactly what we're picking up on this. What do you think this particular research,
  91. what important takeaways does this have for business culture moving forward? So you see, you know this, Dan, I've done a lot of research on like successions, leadership
  92. development. Right. And I think what's often neglected is that these moments are very often
  93. a moment of competition. And if you are in charge of one of these processes, you can't stop in just
  94. kind of picking a successor. You can't just say like, okay, who's going to win this competition.
  95. But what you really have to do is you have to moderate what happens afterwards. You have to
  96. work with the loser, find a way that that thing doesn't fall apart. You also have to be aware of
  97. it. You see, like, like you would be surprised about some of the origins. For example, if two
  98. Formula One drivers are very similar in their social media presence, like in terms of like,
  99. how many followers I have, they are more likely to sabotage each other. So you actually have to
  100. pay attention to like, okay, who's likely to sabotage whom? Who's likely to kind of not get
  101. out of other's way? Because if you're not aware of it, you can't manage it. And managing these
  102. inter-organizational conflicts is, like it or not, an important part of what a good manager does.
  103. Henning, great to have you with us today. Thanks very much for your time. All the best.
  104. Thanks so much for having me. Thank you. Henning Piezunka, who's an associate professor of management here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Henning Piezunka explains how losing can fuel workplace sabotage and Formula One rivalry, and why managers must manage the aftermath of promotions.

Key points

  • When the loser refuses to move on. A loss can keep reverberating through relationships and workplace culture. Some people accept the result; others keep reliving the competition.
  • The colleague who becomes your boss. Losing a promotion to someone you see every day can make the defeat impossible to forget—and may undermine support for the new boss.
  • A Formula One test for lingering rivalry. Because workplace sabotage is hard to observe directly, the researchers studied whether lapped drivers get out of the way—and how past rivalries affect that behavior.
  • Managers must manage what happens after the win. Choosing a successor is only part of the job. Managers also need to work with the person who lost and anticipate where conflict or sabotage may emerge.

Tension

28/ 100Low tension

Related episodes