Advertising in the Digital Age

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Marketing

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we are here today with colum Murphy the group strategy director for droga 5 and advertising agency based in New York
  2. City colum thanks for being here you're very welcome when you begin working with
  3. a new brand or on a new campaign what are the first questions you ask what kind of data do you need to get started
  4. yeah so the way that we like to think about things it's uh it's actually a pretty simple um construct but then
  5. there can be a lot of depth within it um is we look at the world through uh through four lenses we call them the
  6. four seas which is um uh the company the cat the consumer and culture and within
  7. each of those there's different amounts of research that you might need to do depending on what um uh what you already
  8. have available and then what new new questions you need to answer um but you know we get a lot out of um digging
  9. really deep into what the company's all about what the DNA and soul of the the the organization might be about like
  10. what the brand really stands for not just what it's selling um what people's Ambitions are where they want it to go
  11. um that's the that's the first part of it and the second part of it is the category so what else is happening
  12. around um around the uh the business that this brand is in what what white space might there be what other
  13. opportunities what are the tropes and things that you want to avoid uh what are the category Dynamics um then the
  14. third part is consumer Insight which is probably the one that most people are uh
  15. would can um would be familiar with um but what we like to try and do there is try and try and get a little deeper
  16. trying and get into something that maybe um hasn't been uncovered by by normal research um and uh but then because
  17. consumers are really good at telling you where they are now what they're thinking
  18. about at the moment the fourth is is often the most interesting to us which is the the cultural piece so um uh which
  19. is where are the uh what's happening in the culture that surrounds the subject matter that you're thinking about
  20. because what's happening there is where the customers will be in the future so um we also do a lot of research there
  21. very um very qualitative research often with um cultural leaders and experts that can um uh help us unlock a little
  22. bit about where things are going to go rather than where they are now now and it was actually it's interesting because
  23. it kind of ties in with my next question is I was reading an article about the agency and an executive from ker had a
  24. really interesting quote about droga 5 when they said that droga 5 they don't ose their brand on the they don't impose
  25. their brand on the brand and so I was curious like what does that mean to you in terms of I mebe not making it about
  26. Drogo 5 and making it more about the brand but also I mean you want people to know it's you in some sense yeah I think
  27. I think the the thing that's consistent about what we do is um is the the influence that we're trying to achieve
  28. so it's more about the the way that it performs rather than the content of the work I think the um the process I was
  29. just talking about with the four C's is going to be different for every brand in
  30. every different situation because it has different customers um and and they deserve a go a fresh start every time so
  31. every every brand should have its own um totally unique point of view its own purpose and its own um whatever
  32. executional um elements and style are are right for that situation um I think what what we try and do is we have a set
  33. of um a set of values that we hold um that are always the same uh in how we work so we're always um creatively LED
  34. strategically driven um digitally native and Humanity obsessed uh which is just it's a it's just a
  35. um a a set of principles that I think will always apply and they they will always get us to the right product for
  36. the problem at hand um but I think the the similarities work in terms of philosophy more than um strategy or or
  37. or execution for for any particular brand now I mean these days I mean I guess when I someone like me would usly
  38. think of advertising you think of maybe just a commercial or an ad but today it's just I mean it's about a full
  39. campaign I mean it's about multiplatform and one of those a big one of those is social media and I wondered when you're
  40. planning for campaigns these days how do you determine like the right content for
  41. each platform and then also how do you plan for I guess verality I mean droga 5 has been lucky enough to have campaigns
  42. yeah that have gone viral so for example you guys were behind the Newcastle ale this is not this was what our Super Bowl
  43. commercial would have been campaign for example and that did go viral but you can't really plan for virality so how do
  44. you how do you how do you kind of walk that type of I think that's right I mean verality is something that you are
  45. rewarded with if if you create something that people really really uh get value from so um you know if something's very
  46. entertaining or very useful you have a chance of it becoming viral but you you plan for being entertaining or useful
  47. not for being viral um that's that's something that you have the the privilege of of being the benefactor of
  48. if uh if if you create something that people genuinely want um so I think that's that's the first part of it but
  49. more more generally um we have after we've done the brand strategy um part of what I was talking about U with the four
  50. C's uh there's a just as robust Communications planning uh process where we um uh we we think about what are the
  51. tasks that Communications need to achieve what are the right channels for uh achieving those tasks um and then
  52. what is the right content to fill those channels so um it's all part of a of a plan which is far broader than than any
  53. one particular piece of content um and you just pull the right levers at the right time so I wanted to talk a little
  54. bit more in depth about a campaign that I think you recently worked on now this was a campaign by Dixie which is they
  55. make cups they make plates and this was a campaign that was planned around the message of #g go dark for dinner and
  56. what it was is encouraging people to take a dinner take a meal with their family but without their devices and
  57. this was a partly based on I think a a survey that Dixie helped do which showed that most people don't do that which I
  58. know from my own experience it's really hard to do even no matter how much you want to now can you take me through a
  59. little bit about how you work with a brand to decide like this was the right matchup for the brand in terms of this
  60. is you know want to promote the brand but we also want to promotee this particular message to people this sort
  61. of thing going on in the culture and how do you kind of strike that balance of you know obviously in the end Dixie
  62. wants people to buy Dixie Cubs but at the same time you're also sort of encouraging this more altruistic message
  63. of we also want you to spend time with your family yeah so I mean I I think they're they are two branches of the
  64. same thought for the brand which is that what we really wanted to do is find a different way of thinking about what
  65. disposable products can do for people so um there is uh you know it's a fairly common to talk about this disposable
  66. products as things that can save you time but we thought it was really interesting to think about actually what
  67. if it's about making your time better you know and and one thing that we found when we were doing doing our research uh
  68. into what we thought the brand could the the position the brand could take was we
  69. were finding out about um the people were really really um looking for more emotional presence in the moments that
  70. they had around their around their meal times um and we actually thought that the the the the plate was a a tool that
  71. could help you do that um so once you had established that that's what we wanted the brand to stand for it then
  72. became a fairly natural evolution of it to then think about so what are the enemies of emotional presence and the
  73. biggest one that we found from doing the survey and from other other sources were
  74. mobile phones it's the one thing that just like punctures the little bubble that you really want to try and create
  75. around mealtimes own bubble exactly and you know and and people um people love those moments and Dixie has a place in
  76. that in that moment um and so it's totally right I think for that brand to stand up for protecting that moment and
  77. I also find it interesting um with some of these campaigns like with the Dixie campaign and then also with the one that
  78. you guys have the the ones that you have done around honey m g crackers which has
  79. looked at kind of various different types of families the one I watched actually was about um non-traditional
  80. families and they were Blended families so parents who gotten divorced and then gotten remarried and it focused on the
  81. child who is spending time in both households and also has siblings in both households it was interesting to me
  82. because I'm a stepmom right but um what was interesting to me is just with that and with Dixie it's these longer kind of
  83. documentary length yeah I don't I wouldn't even call them ads and it was interesting I guess how do you take
  84. would you start with that and kind of break it down into the smaller pieces that then become the commercial the
  85. social media or do you start with the small and take it to the big or is it somewhere in the middle yeah that's a
  86. good question I mean I think the the the way that we really think about it is you
  87. know what do we want the the brand to be known for and then what's the right way
  88. of telling the story and and often with the um with the examples where we're we're getting into quite big cultural uh
  89. discussions it deserves a longer format um way of bringing it to life so um it'll be more about what's the right way
  90. of telling the story that we're that we're that we're wanting to tell and then um you know commercial there's a
  91. media plan to fill as well so then you know if if it requires breaking down into smaller segments then then you do
  92. that but I definitely would think about it more in a top down way um which is you know what's the story we want to
  93. tell what's the best way of telling it and then and then uh what's what are the right executions to do it and now that
  94. brings me actually to another campaign so you guys recently launched um I think it's under armour's first Global
  95. campaign around soccer or football as we call or football as most people call it
  96. soccer as we call it exactly so we're probably wrong but um how do you when you're working on a global campaign I
  97. mean I guess even just the wording sort of shows the differences right there between culture the culture here and
  98. culture and other places when you're working on a global campaign I mean how are you able to kind of keep that
  99. balance where you're reaching out to such I mean it's such a derse group of people just in one country def in the
  100. world that that's you know expanded that's expanded on by two or three or four or five or a million times so how
  101. are you able to kind of how do you strategize for a campaign that's Global how does that make it different how does
  102. that change things it's it's really difficult I think when you start getting into it you realize quite how much of
  103. the discussion that we have with one another um movies music advertising anything like how much of it does rely
  104. on local nuance and and and local context um but what you're looking for I think in in that particular example is
  105. well you're always looking for what's the highest the highest common factor that unites everybody that you're trying
  106. to speak to about the subject that you're trying to speak to them about so um you know luckily I think with that
  107. campaign we had a very specific audience which was um um young football players and and and they are united by football
  108. and actually there's an attitude that you that really um brings all those guys together um which is um you know about
  109. about the mental strength that it takes to just keep on like getting up and facing challenges over and over and over
  110. again which is what you can see in the work um and actually it was it was great we use our our um Global Network to to
  111. validate that that was a thought that we had and we we um we we spoke to actually
  112. um uh Scouts and coaches and people who were involved with um with with teaching
  113. young kids soccer uh and that's what they that's what they thought it was and then we tested that hypothesis in
  114. different countries to see if it was a thing that held true um uh and it did and that was that was great so that came
  115. from that came from the sport itself was the thing that United all those people at that time but yeah you're you're you
  116. have to find something that's Universal and that could be that can be challenging now with um you're saying
  117. you do a lot of cultural research in terms of trying to bring campaigns to life now with um so we're in sort of a
  118. period right now where Millennials are becoming the dominant consumer group and then behind them we have I guess what
  119. people are calling either Generation Z or MTV is calling them the founders how does as they become kind of the majority
  120. among consumers how does that change the way you approach campaigns I mean you're
  121. doing it differently than you would for say the majority baby boomer audience or
  122. even the greatest Generation before them all of that was definitely I mean the the inputs that you take I mean I don't
  123. think there's anything specifically we we would approach it with the same specificity as with any audience you
  124. know I mean the fact that they're that they're um Bound by an age group is is is is true but it's it's by the by
  125. really like we you know in like for example with the Under Armor campaign we were looking at um at kids of a certain
  126. age that play football but football was the thing that was uniting them so you know we will always um from both an
  127. insights point of view and a especially from a media point of um point of view look at how the group of people that
  128. we're thinking about um behave and how they think uh I I think specifically for for the groups that you're asking about
  129. I think there are there are certain um brand behaviors that are becoming more important as time goes on but I don't
  130. even think they're necessarily isolated to um to to to gen Z and Gen Y um but you know I think there there're things
  131. like um transparency for example I think that we're we're um in a an environment
  132. where people demand transparency from from Brands um it's uh the the interaction that a brand has with with
  133. it with its audience is so direct now that there's there's an expectation from customers and particularly from you from
  134. Young Ones um that they will have a transparent and honest relationship with with the the brand that they're talking
  135. to um and and and they're also fine with having relationship with Brands you know
  136. I think they they expect there to be discourse and they expect it to be honest but they're fine with having
  137. relationship with brand I think is is something that may be more true of that group than than others um some other
  138. examples I think are um personalization I think there's a lot of um room now there are a lot of tools available to to
  139. brands to personalize messages and I think that's another thing that's becoming an expectation um from um from
  140. people standards standards can be set outside of advertising you know like the the kind of personal service that's um
  141. the standard that's set by companies like Uber or um or something else where people are using um very personal data
  142. to um to provide a better service that's setting the standard now that brands are
  143. expected to live up to um and so I think personalization is another really big theme I'm curious and wondering if you
  144. when you're working with a brand on a particular campaign I mean what do you do if coming to you with something that
  145. maybe is the opposite of what you're coming at them with I mean how do you arrive at kind of the middle ground of
  146. what you're what what it's going to be in the end I mean I think generally we want to work as closely as possible um
  147. uh with with our clients and with everybody else who's involved in uh in the creation of the work and I think um
  148. there shouldn't really be surprises you know I think if you're if um the the the
  149. iteration of U of progress towards whatever it is you're going to do um should mean that you're you're really um
  150. more together than than apart on most decisions um I think generally it's better to pick pick a path and do it
  151. properly than it is to water it down with compromise um but yeah really I mean those are decisions that you should
  152. be making together and informing with um with strategy and with research so that
  153. uh you should you should rarely be too many million miles away from one another so we have my final question is one that
  154. we actually ask of a lot of people that come here to our studio which is what gets you up in the morning and
  155. conversely what keeps you up at night yeah I mean I think what's great about what we're doing at the moment is uh
  156. we're doing like the the world's best creative work on bigger and bigger canvases so I get really excited about
  157. that about seeing if we can know maintain the same level of uh of creative Integrity but do it on on the
  158. biggest possible scale and then for um in terms of what keeps me up at night I think um you know
  159. a big part of what what we've got to manage not just in terms of media but in terms of messaging and audiences and is
  160. is about simplifying complexity and I think that's the hardest part of our job and in every everything we do it's about
  161. trying to make very complicated things very simple and I think that that's that can be the thing that keeps you up at
  162. night great thank you so much for being with us you're very welcome thank [Music]
  163. you

Brief Summary

Colum Murphy discusses brand strategy and cultural insights in advertising, focusing on the four Cs approach and evolving consumer expectations.

Key points

  • The Four C's of Brand Strategy. Colum Murphy explains the four lenses through which they analyze brands: company, category, consumer, and culture.
  • Dixie's #GoDarkForDinner Campaign. A campaign encouraging families to dine without devices, promoting emotional presence during meals.
  • Global Campaign Challenges. Colum shares insights on strategizing for global campaigns, focusing on universal themes.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes