Analyzing Tariffs' Economic Effects – Penn Wharton Budget Model

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

The White House's plan to implement higher tariffs aims to generate revenue for the U.S. economy, but it could have adverse effects on GDP and wages. Kent Smetters, the faculty director of the Penn Wharton Budget Model, highlights the overlooked impact of tariffs on capital flows, which could make it harder for the U.S. government to manage its growing federal debt. Over time, the tariffs could reduce GDP by as much as 7.5% by 2054 and decrease wages by over 6%, significantly affecting investment and long-term economic growth.

This interview was recorded on April 11th, 2025.

ABOUT THE PODCAST The Wharton Business Daily podcast features interviews with top business leaders, innovators, and renowned Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#tariffs #tariffsimpact #useconomy #tradedeficit #economicpolicy ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Well, the plan of instituting higher tariffs by the White House has been designed, as they say, to raise revenue
  2. that can help out the US economy in other areas, but there are potential negative impacts to things like GDP and
  3. wages. Kent Matters is faculty director of the Pen Wharton budget model. They have come out with a new paper looking
  4. at that side of the tariff story and he joins us right now. Kent, great to talk to you. How are you, sir? Good to be
  5. here. Thanks. I'm glad to be back. Yeah, this is obviously a very important part
  6. of the story and correct me if I'm wrong. It feels like it's one that's maybe not getting as much attention
  7. right now, right? I mean, uh, part of the issue is that a lot of the analysis that's being done is really kind of
  8. using fairly simple trade models that really are not, uh, capturing kind of the full impact of tariffs on the rest
  9. of the economy. In particular, there's a whole capital flows uh part of the economy as well. As uh as trade falls,
  10. uh capital flows typically will fall as well. And that means um uh foreigners are buying uh less uh
  11. of of government debt. And so in particular are it's not just that we are you know buying more goods and services
  12. of foreigners than they're buying from from us that's known as the as the trade imbalance everybody likes to focus on.
  13. It's what really drives that is government debt in the United States is quite large and what happens is that
  14. foreigners typically borrow uh are the lenders I mean to the federal government and that creates a demand for the
  15. dollar. It makes the dollar stronger. That makes our trade uh uh of goods and services look less competitive because
  16. they become more expensive. Uh and so what happens when you try to reverse that just by trying to tackle the trade
  17. deficit. Um what you're also doing is you're going to limit um how much of capital flows come into the United
  18. States uh uh as well. And so, uh, in effect, that is going to, uh, make it just harder for the government going
  19. forward to float its federal debt at kind of a cheap, uh, at at, uh, essentially higher prices, but a cheaper
  20. interest rate. And so, given that we're on this explosive path of federal debt, it's just going to make the federal
  21. government hard, it's going to make it harder for the federal government to continue work this debt policy that
  22. we're we're on. And so it's that it's it's that capital flows are are currently being missed. So take us
  23. through the GDP and the wages component uh that could be impacted here. Yes. And
  24. it's not going to certainly happen immedi immediately um in the in terms of the full egg impact, but there's still
  25. it's not small. in particular um in over the next five years, we're expecting that uh the economy relative to not
  26. having the tariffs would um uh shrink by about 1.1%. So the GDP still continues to grow with population, technology and
  27. so forth, but um relative to where otherwise would be by 2030 we project that it'll be about 1.1% uh a little bit
  28. lower. Um that is not necessarily terribly uh surprising. Some of the trade models will get up to there, but
  29. then they don't really distinguish between times. They're just all stating that as a longer period um outcome. But
  30. the problem is is as you go down the line and particular as you go further uh years from now 2034, 2039 and so forth
  31. the impact becomes bigger and bigger. Um in particular we're predicting by 204 you know roughly around 40 I'm sorry
  32. roughly around 30 years from now um that GDP will be about 7 uh 5% less at 7 and
  33. a half% less maybe 8% less depending on some assumptions in our model and as the
  34. result of that is that um we're talking about significant reduction in GDP relative to say other policies one way
  35. thinking about this. And by the way, wages uh will fall by over 6% over time. Again, by 2030, we're talking about 1%
  36. reduction of wages relative to where they otherwise would have been. Um by uh over time, the wages will fall uh even
  37. more. Um so there'll still be wage growth, per se, but we're not going to have the same wage growth. It will be
  38. lower than where we otherwise would have been. So I think it's you know it's one
  39. of those issues that you know you you say okay if this is that distorting what are some alternatives what else could we
  40. have done and so we basically say let's look at the like what's kind of like the
  41. most distorting way of raising revenue and that basically would be to increase the corporate income tax alone nothing
  42. else I mean you might believe in that for progressivity reasons but it's in terms of economic damage by far the most
  43. distorted and so this is equivalent in terms of revenue of raising the corporate income tax from 21 to
  44. 36%. But in terms of economic damage is actually twice as damaging as that increase in the corporate rate. You
  45. mentioned about uh the impact on wages. Just how much does the consumer bear the
  46. brunt uh on on these tariffs? And I guess there is this report looks at it over like a 30-year window that there is
  47. some difference in terms of what impact will be now in comparison to what we might see 30 years ago and that can
  48. impact people of different ages in different ways. That's right. So in the short run uh the main mechanism that
  49. drives things for the first couple of years is actually just the uncertainty. uh that's been well quantified now in
  50. the economics literature is increase in uncertainty um lowers investment. So we're projecting that this increase
  51. uncertainty is going to lower investment by about 4 and a.5% um over a year or two. So that that's a
  52. pretty significant uh drop. Now obviously if the uncertainty gets resolved fairly soon that will change
  53. but for now it's a fairly significant uh shortrun effect. Um but that we project
  54. that that uncertainty itself kind of wears off by 2027ish that might be optimistic. Um but
  55. what could actually happen are things that are not captured by our model. um in particular we're capturing a lot of
  56. things that haven't been captured but there's still a lot of things in the short run. The way I describe short run
  57. versus long run in these trade models is that you know use a physics analogy. You
  58. know you have classical physics and then you have quantum physics which is really
  59. the superset of all you know of classic physics plus more. You know in the short
  60. run the entanglement between societ between economies is so complex nobody understands nobody has a
  61. good model of it just because the proprietary data um that data sets that we even have access to they they don't
  62. have a lot of the descriptions for example we don't know you have a business in the United States it may use
  63. 30 different parts or a car 30,000 different parts for lots of different places um and just one of those parts
  64. being disrupted did could actually lead to you just not being able to to produce. Now eventually you might say
  65. well that all that production will come back to the United States. And we actually assume um a lot of that will
  66. happen and we even assume a lot of that will happen very smoothly. Um but even with that, you just have this lower
  67. demand for government debt and that drives up um uh that just makes things a lot more challenging because now all the
  68. investment has to in the United States can't depend on foreign uh dollars as much anymore. Um and as a result of
  69. that, that's going to make just the our government debt path even more uh uh challenging. Kent, great to have you
  70. with us. Thanks very much for your time. For those that want to wa uh see the report, they can go to the Pen Wharton
  71. budget model website. Thanks, Kent. Thank you, Kent SMEs, who is faculty director of the Pen Wharton budget
  72. model.

Brief Summary

Kent Matters discusses how higher tariffs may shrink GDP and reduce wages over time, impacting investment and capital flows.

Key points

  • Impact of Tariffs on Economy. Kent Matters reveals that tariffs could shrink the economy by 1.1% by 2030.
  • Wage Reductions Due to Tariffs. Wages are projected to fall by over 6% as a result of tariffs.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes