401k Savings Hit Record High as Workers Prepare for Retirement

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton’s Olivia Mitchell joins This Week in Business to discuss new Fidelity data showing U.S. retirement savings rates hitting a record 14.3%. They explore what’s driving the increase—like automatic enrollment, fears over Social Security, and rising life expectancy—and why 15% savings may not be enough. Mitchell emphasizes generational differences in saving habits, the impact of public debt, and the risks of short-term financial strain from higher retirement contributions.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#RetirementSavings #401k #FinancialPlanning #SocialSecurity ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney: New data from Fidelity Investment, showing that Americans may be setting aside enough money towards retirement,
  2. or at least are getting close to those levels. The average savings rate, according to their data, for the first three months
  3. of the year with their accounts, was 14.3 percent. Analysts now say you should have at least 15 percent, but that 14.3 percent number is a record
  4. high according to Fidelity. Pleasure to be joined once again by Olivia Mitchell, who's a Professor and Director of the
  5. Pension Research Council here at the Wharton School, and someone we go to when we're talking all things retirement savings.
  6. Olivia, great to have you back on the show. Thanks for a couple of moments. Olivia Mitchell: My pleasure. Thank you. - You and I have talked so
  7. much about this over the years. When you see this data, though, what does it say to you about where we are, but maybe where
  8. we're headed? - Well, it is true that the data from Fidelity show that people are saving more in their 401(k) plans than ever before, that is
  9. in their retirement plans usually offered through the employer. And this is good news, because it shows that more
  10. workers are prioritizing their retirement savings, bringing them closer to the 15 percent that financial advisors recommend.
  11. Personally, I think 15 percent is a bit low, but we can come back to that. And I think part of what's driving it is some of the
  12. developments in the retirement space, including automatic enrollment, where people are immediately engaged in their
  13. retirement saving, even if they don't do anything themselves, they're defaulted in. Automatic escalation, that's also been
  14. helpful. I think it's also the case that people are saving more for retirement because they're concerned about higher potential
  15. future tax rates and the possibility of Social Security going insolvent, on top of which we're living longer, prices are
  16. rising. There are a lot of good reasons to save more for retirement. - So a couple of questions off of what you just said there. First,
  17. the automatic enrollment and the fact that, seemingly, I guess, companies realize how important it is to go ahead and make that
  18. move when a new employee comes on, or if an employee is transferring in funds from another account so that they
  19. really don't even have the option to not be a part of that. - Well, automatic enrollment is -- automatic escalation is typically offered
  20. to new hires, could be offered to existing hires, existing employees as well. Employees usually do have the opportunity
  21. to opt out if they decide that the saving is really burdening them, but the reality is, most people just go along with the
  22. flow and stay in the plan and save more, so it's to their benefit. - But there's something also to be said from this report, they
  23. mentioned the fact that more companies in general are using 401(k) plans. Now, part of that may be in some sectors switching
  24. over from a pension to a 401(k), but the fact that companies realize that they want to have this as part of their mix.
  25. - It's very attractive, especially for the younger generations that see the problems that face all of them with Social Security
  26. facing insolvency. It's very attractive for employers to offer plans that automatically enroll their workers into
  27. retirement saving. But there's some caveats that we should think about. There is emerging evidence that higher default
  28. saving rates in retirement plan can also precipitate workers to take on more debt because they have less cash to pay for the
  29. bills of daily living. - Now, if memory serves me, your number that you believe is the
  30. number that people should be at is more like 20 percent, correct? - I have tried to shop that number to many people, including my two
  31. daughters. I think we had to compromise at 18 percent. But the other issue, of course, that one could consider is that if you're not
  32. able to save that much, you could delay retiring, and every year you delay claiming, that boosts your Social Security
  33. benefits. So there's a couple of different ways to try to confront that problem. - So
  34. that 14.3 percent number is the headline number, but as you mentioned, there's a generational component that
  35. needs to be factored in here as well, in how maybe the baby boomer generation didn't save as much early, but they're saving
  36. more now getting ready for retirement. And then you have to look at how Gen X and millennials are responding to
  37. this, because you've mentioned it, they're the generation that really can take advantage at a younger age, if they start early,
  38. to be able to set themselves up to have enough for retirement. - It's absolutely true. So if you step back from 401(k)
  39. plans and just tally up total household saving across all different assets that people might have, there has been a
  40. generational change. So baby boomers, my generation, saved about five to six percent of our income over time. Gen X, only about four
  41. to five. Millennials, two to four percen. And now the Gen Z generation, the people born 1997 to 2012, are estimated to have be saving,
  42. they're still young, but about three to five percent of their income. So the long term trend since the '50s has been for Americans
  43. household saving rate to go down, and that concerns me, because we are living longer and some of our -- some of the things
  44. the boomers did well or were lucky to have happen, namely, big increases in housing prices, pretty low inflation for most of
  45. our lifetimes, that may not characterize the next generation. - One of the things you've said to me numerous times, and it's
  46. great to repeat, is the fact that if you're an employee, you want to always make sure that you are maximizing not only what
  47. you can save, but maximizing what the company is willing to provide you as well.
  48. - Absolutely. So some companies, like my university, provides a basic amount for everybody, even if the employee doesn't
  49. contribute, but then they also match contributions up to a max. And if at all possible, you should definitely save that
  50. much. Otherwise, you're just leaving money on the table, and that's not a sensible thing to do. - What
  51. do you think then this data potentially says for us longer term, moving forward? I mean, you mentioned we're kind of -- it's
  52. good news, but are we truly on the right path, and maybe the mindset of younger generations has changed a little bit on
  53. this? - Well, the big unknown is the huge and growing government debt that we all face, and even if households are doing a better job to save
  54. for retirement and other factors, the government is not doing that. And so part of what might be driving people to save
  55. more on their own is that they're concerned about the possibility of higher tax rates and other factors. Studies
  56. suggest that private saving offsets government borrowing by about 30 to 40 percent. So you know, this is -- this means that as
  57. public debt grows, people may increase their saving in anticipation of fewer taxes -- higher taxes in the future. So
  58. this is a time of a great amount of uncertainty, a lot of volatility, and I'm happy to see people saving more in their
  59. retirement accounts, but I am also a bit of a budget deficit hawk. I wish we could do better to try to not grow that as well.
  60. - Olivia, always great to get your insight. Thanks again. - Thank you. - Olivia Mitchell, Professor and Director of the Pension
  61. Research Council here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Olivia Mitchell discusses rising retirement savings rates and generational differences in saving habits amid concerns over government debt.

Key points

  • Record High Savings Rate. Fidelity reports a record high average savings rate of 14.3 percent for retirement plans.
  • Generational Saving Trends. A generational change in savings rates shows varying levels of commitment to retirement.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes