Investing for the New Normal

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

๐Ÿ“‚ Finance & Accounting

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. today knowledge at Wharton welcomes Richard Marston A Wharton Finance Professor who's going to talk to us
  2. about his new book investing for a lifetime managing wealth for The New Normal thanks for joining us oh thank
  3. you um the book has made a bit of a splash it's got a really good review uh in the New York Times uh which as you
  4. mentioned has an appropriate headline it's worse than you think um the book is about retirement for the most part uh so
  5. it's a a subset of personal investing and one would have thought there wasn't that much new Under the Sun and personal
  6. investing but you come along and uh and and show that's not the case so um let's
  7. just start with the title where you talk about the new normal and in what way do
  8. you mean that new normal well actually um it's bad enough if we're in the old normal of normal returns that we've seen
  9. over the last 60 or 90 years but Bill gross of Pimco came up with this idea of the new normal and in a sense it's
  10. pretty SC because he's saying that uh because the industrial countries have slowed in growth uh we're not going to
  11. earn the same Returns on Equity that we have in the past and uh that means it's going to be harder to save enough for
  12. retirement and then once we're in retirement we not might not be able to spend as much as we have in the past so
  13. it's a little scary now there's um some folks out everyone's aware that that returns are down whether it's your money
  14. market whatever it is people complain all the time about how low interest rates are if you put your money in the
  15. bank and and and so forth but um there's uh there's a thought that says well you
  16. know inflation's also low so isn't it just sort of relatively speaking uh the same Arrangement that that used to be
  17. the case but you're saying that's not the case well Bill gross actually talked about equities not uh stocks rather than
  18. bonds but in my book I actually talk about the possibility of a new normal for bonds as well and the reason for
  19. that is uh I think pretty obvious to most observers that we've been through a wonderful bow market for bonds where
  20. interest rates have come down for the last 30 years and now we're at the end um we don't know whether the the
  21. absolute end is going to be now or 6 months from now or 15 months from now but we do know that uh we are near the
  22. bottom of the interest rate cycle and inevitably the interest rates are so low they have to go up they have to go up um
  23. the 10year yield is at 2 and 1 12% the inflation rate has recently been at uh 2% or close to 2% so that means we're
  24. earning virtually nothing on our bonds and and that's not going to go on uh there has to be some increase in
  25. interest rates over the next 5 years and that's going to hurt our returns because
  26. as interest rates rise bond prices fall and uh we don't get the returns that we had in the
  27. past so I think maybe the key Point um in the book is that not only aren't people saving enough there's been talk
  28. of that before but that they don't even realize how far away they are from saving enough that's right the savings
  29. goal what I talk about the savings goal in the book and um the discussion of savings is really aimed at people in
  30. their 20s and 30s and 40s rather than people who are near retirement because you have to think about the goal that
  31. you need uh for retirement and the way to think about retirement is uh when I retire I want to have the same standard
  32. of living that I have had during my working years and how do you achieve it well a few years ago one of the mutual
  33. fund companies said well there's a rule of thumb you need to save 8 times your income when I read the report I was a
  34. little surprised because it seemed too low that means that if you're used to earning $100,000 a year that means you
  35. have to save $800,000 to retire that seemed too low to me so what I did is I formulated a section of the book on
  36. savings goals how much do you have to save and the long and short of it is um it's a lot more than eight times income
  37. if you have normal income and if you have high income because Social Security becomes less important as your income
  38. goes from 100,000 to 200,000 to 300,000 um you have to save even more and uh for
  39. somebody who's has worked all his or her life and is single and retires and is used to earning around $100,000 a year
  40. you actually have to save close to 15 times your income so that's a big difference between eight times what
  41. you're saying one one of the one of the investment companies had been recommending now um does that number
  42. take into account that some folks will have other income streams Social Security of course comes to mind for
  43. most and and there may be other things that could lower that a little bit perhaps it does not take into account
  44. other income if you're lucky enough to have one of these old style pensions then you won't have to save as much but
  45. um the majority of Americans in the private sector now only have 401ks and other um pensions that where they save
  46. the money themselves and uh for those people um that calculation takes into account Social Security but I'm assuming
  47. that the family doesn't have other pensions available and that's the reality for an awful lot of people in
  48. the private sector so earning 100,000 you need to save roughly 15 times that income have that in savings when you
  49. retire if you want to maintain that level of income that's right even though you might have 25,000 or
  50. something like that coming in through Social Security or that's right between say 20 to 22,000 it turns out that if
  51. somebody's earned about $100,000 a year and retires in 2013 they actually start off with about
  52. a $26,000 Social Security payment now I should mention that if you're married and um there's a significant spousal
  53. benefit the uh Social Security payment could go up in your savings goal could go down but even for a married couple
  54. getting the maximum Social Security payment who's earned $100,000 in their Peak years you actually have to save
  55. over 11 and a half times your income in order to retire and have the same kind of standard of living you had during
  56. your working years that's the best case scenario right there that's the best case scenario but if you're used to a
  57. higher level of income um you have to save more so it makes it even more difficult um you talk about savings
  58. goals and and and what's the best way to set these goals how do people do this they've got education for children to
  59. save for they've got lots of other expenses um how how do you how do you accomplish that what percentage of your
  60. income should you be saving to reach those multiples generally speaking if you're in the $100,000 range in income
  61. you have to save something like 15% of your income and that's before any taxes um how do you possibly do that I think
  62. the easiest way you can get a lot of the way to that goal is to uh fully participate in your 401k program at at
  63. work the defined contribution plans in America that have developed over the last 30 40 years are a tremendous Boon
  64. to savings um what employees should be doing is joining as soon as possible um and contributing as much as possible at
  65. the very least you have to contribute enough to get your full company match because in many cases the company will
  66. match at least partially your your contributions then if possible um save up to the the maximum in some cases it's
  67. 15% it's even uh higher number for people over um in their 50s and so on um take advantage of that program it makes
  68. such a difference in terms of because that's automatic otherwise a lot of Americans treat the savings as a
  69. residual what they do is they do their mandatory spending uh for example mortgages and then they do the
  70. discretionary spending and then whatever's left over is savings um it's much more difficult to do that savings
  71. it's much easier to do it automatically within a 401k plan so have it taken out have it withdrawn from your check each
  72. each paycheck uh as an automatic thing that's exactly right so does that mean for example um of course attitudes about
  73. housing have changed a lot too it used to be buy as much house as you can because it's an investment now after
  74. houses house prices have fallen people are no longer so sang green about the housing market but does that mean you're
  75. really better off buying something less of a house than you might be able to afford and putting that other money into
  76. savings rather than thinking of the house as a as a savings vehicle um actually you're right but um I can even
  77. show that and I have a chapter on this even if you sold your house at the peak of the market for the average American
  78. in fact I do the case of a American lucky enough to live in California with their gloriously Rising housing prices
  79. um it's true even in California that if you sold your house in 2006 having held it since the late 1970s you would have
  80. been better off buying half the house and putting in in a portfolio you would have earned a higher return housing is a
  81. terrible investment in the long run for Americans and you should not buy more house than you really need for your for
  82. your comfort and your enjoyment that's a really great point and I I I'm sure a lot of people don't realize that um so
  83. uh what about the you you mentioned another concept about the rate of savings could you tell us about that
  84. well I figured that 15% for someone of of uh ordinary income 15% if you start saving early enough will be sufficient
  85. to generate enough savings by the time you retire now it's important to mention that it makes a tremendous difference
  86. whether you start saving in your 20s 30s in fact I compare the situation for somebody starting at 26 as opposed to 36
  87. of course to be honest there are many Americans who can't start saving in their 20s for retirement because they
  88. have uh University loans um they have um the need to build up sufficient funds to be able to afford
  89. a mortgage to buy into housing and so on so there are a lot of goals for savings
  90. particularly people who are younger but nonetheless it's so important to try to start saving earlier on you said at the
  91. outset that this book is about retirement but it's really onethird of it is about the savings that have to be
  92. done by younger people the middle third is about investing wisely and it's nothing complicated I try to make
  93. investing as simple as possible and then the last third is about retirement but what I say in the book is investing is
  94. easy what's difficult is the is the savings and knowing when to retire and knowing how to actually spend in
  95. retirement those are the tough things why is investing easy why why investing is easy because as far as I'm concerned
  96. all you need to do is to choose an appropriate portfolio and there lots of financial advisers who can help you with
  97. that and then you have to have the good sense to leave it alone that means that you're choosing a portfolio in your 30s
  98. that is relatively aggressive to try to pick up the uh gains from Equity uh the gain from Real Estate and so on and then
  99. as you get older and closer to retirement what you do is you reduce your risk this is relatively
  100. straightforward it's um in fact some mutual fund companies actually give you what are called Target date retirement
  101. funds where what you do is you decide when you think you'll be retiring let's say you're 35 and you think you'll
  102. retire in 30 years you buy a fund that's appropriate for that and then you just leave it alone and before you know it
  103. you're ready for retirement and you've you've done sensible investing that is the easy part but there's one caveat if
  104. you start to play games with that portfolio you can run into serious problems and I particularly mention this
  105. because we just went through a financial crisis where Americans um were frightened I mean stocks went down by
  106. more than 50% and what some Americans did is they panicked and they pulled out of the market uh planning to get back
  107. into the market as soon as things look better well now we're 5 years into a rally and an awful lot of Americans
  108. never got back into the market don't play games with it and in the in the book what I do is a calculation is I ask
  109. the question suppose that you are unlucky enough to have retired in October 2007 at the peak of the market
  110. so the Market's peaking and let's say you've saved a million dollars and ask the question what would have happened if
  111. um you just stuck with your portfolio well through the worst financial crisis since the 1930s the portfolio fell very
  112. sharply during the crisis but if you left it alone by the end of 2013 you would have been intact with almost
  113. exactly the same amount you started with on the other hand if you had panicked and in my book I consider the
  114. possibility of panicking in the spring of 2009 now let me remind you what to happen in September 2008 Leman Brothers
  115. failed we fell into a deep crisis by March 2009 we know the market reached the bottom and started to rise suppose
  116. in the spring of 2009 you pulled out well that million today would be scarcely more than
  117. $600,000 because you shifted out of your portfolio and tried to beat the market for the rest of your life if you in that
  118. situation your retirement will be diminished by that amount by over 40% because you try to be smart enough
  119. in the market just leave the portfolio alone choose a good one seek advice from financial advisers to help you with that
  120. then just leave it alone so I it's easy I think there's a saying I've heard which is um in a crisis like that you
  121. you haven't really suffered any losses until you sell exactly so stick with it U and you talked about age of retirement
  122. and that that idea of of of timing it correctly uh tell us what's a good way to approach that how think about it we
  123. know the general rule is that if you're able to stay uh working until your full retirement age it's currently 66 for
  124. people who are about to retire if you do that rather than retire at 62 your Social Security benefits are actually
  125. 25% lower if you retire at 62 so that's the first decision you have to make and you know you have to be careful about
  126. this because not all Americans can work past 62 not all Americans have their um jobs past 62 so it depends upon what
  127. industry you're in and what circumstances you have but to the extent that you can possibly wait another four
  128. years it makes tremendous difference in two ways first of all the Social Security payment is much higher but also
  129. you have four more years of savings and those are years when you can save a lot of money because for most families
  130. College educations are already paid for um you have a lot of discretionary income at that point relative to the
  131. past and you can save a lot but in in addition the money that you already had by the time you're 62 can accumulate
  132. further before you retire so there's a double bonus Social Security is higher and your savings are definitely going to
  133. be significantly higher if you wait an extra four years uh another question that people sometimes have especially
  134. people getting close to retirement now is if I don't retire at 66 then each year I believe that there Social
  135. Security payment will increase by a certain amount it might be even 8% that's a heck of a return if you keep
  136. working um you're go your Social Security payment assuming you're not already at the top limit will will
  137. increase 8% and then if you you know in the second year after 66 it would go up I believe another 8% um so that's a
  138. decision for people depending on their health there's many factors obviously that go into that but um what what can
  139. you tell us about there's a tremendous bonus if you were able to work until 70 as you say you get a a bump up by about
  140. 8% per year I don't think you have to wait till 70 to get each of those increments that's right that's right
  141. every year it's an extra 8% and think of of what the Social Security is it's a an
  142. annuity payment which is guaranteed by the government and it's index to inflation so it's almost too good to be
  143. true uh if you're able to wait those extra years um you can have an enhanced payment for the rest of your life that
  144. keeps Pace with inflation it's a wonderful program it's a wonderful program a lot of um of Americans uh um
  145. think that it's it's not that important to retirement when you do the numbers for somebody earning as much as a
  146. $100,000 or even $200,000 Social Security is a significant contribution to retirement and it's index to
  147. inflation one last question something I've always wondered about especially younger viewers might be interested in
  148. this so you advise people to start saving as young as you can in your 20s your first job out of college open that
  149. for a 1K start putting something in um when I've looked at the charts something really interesting happens when you do
  150. that when you when you start really young so through the miracle of compound interest you watch your your money
  151. multiply of course you're adding but but nevertheless you're you're gaining uh interest or dividends or whatever it may
  152. be but then somewhere along the line I don't know if it's year 30 or something all of a sudden this line that's going
  153. late suddenly goes like this what what that's the magic of compounding it's right right but it's
  154. but it's a it's not it's linear not linear but it's a sort of a slope like this and then suddenly it just shoots
  155. into the stratosphere it's it it's amazing and I I do that experiment in the book I ask what if you started 26 or
  156. 31 or 36 it makes a tremendous difference and you know even if you don't contribute the maximum in your 20s
  157. you're making progress towards that goal and remember that that money is going to
  158. be compounding for 40 years rather than 30 years so it makes a tremendous difference so uh for um listeners in
  159. their 20s if you can start doing the contributions that will make a difference later on and uh boy we we
  160. have a long time to save um but later on there are other obligations there's children there's education there's
  161. paying the mortgage and so on uh try to start early as early as possible makes a
  162. difference and there's always worrying about whether you'll outlive your money that's right so well thanks very much
  163. for joining us been thank you very enlightening yeah [Music]

Brief Summary

Richard Marston discusses retirement savings strategies and the challenges of achieving financial security in the new normal of lower investment returns.

Key points

  • The New Normal in Investing. Richard Marston discusses the challenges of saving for retirement in today's economy.
  • Savings Goals for Retirement. Marston reveals the shocking truth about how much you need to save for retirement.
  • The Truth About Housing Investments. Marston explains why buying a house may not be the best investment strategy.
  • The Power of Early Savings. Starting to save early can significantly impact your financial future.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes