How to Save More for Retirement Using Behavioral Science

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Katy Milkman, a professor at Wharton, studies psychological factors influencing retirement savings, particularly the "fresh start effect," which motivates people to adopt new financial behaviors during symbolic new beginnings. She found that framing retirement-saving opportunities around fresh-start dates, such as birthdays or New Year's Day, significantly increased savings rates among employees who previously saved little or nothing. However, Milkman also discovered that peer comparisons, particularly highlighting high savings among coworkers, unexpectedly reduced retirement savings participation among lower-income, unionized workers due to feelings of inadequacy or demotivation.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#retirementsavings #BehavioralEconomics #BehavioralScience #FinancialPlanning #BehaviorChange ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Katy Milkman: A lot of the psychology in this space really relates to sort of how I relate to my past self and my future self.
  2. Thinking about that carefully led us to want to use the fresh start effect, or this motivation, to try to propel
  3. people to save more for retirement, to think more about future me, to pursue those goals. And so we thought fresh
  4. start moments would be an ideal time, because people have that extra motivation to pursue goals and to think about the future
  5. and to feel disconnected from past failings. Welcome to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>, the podcast that takes you on a
  6. journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host, Dan Loney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the
  7. inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted and exploring how
  8. their findings resonate with the world today. - The decision to head into retirement
  9. not always an easy one. People consider this option to have to bring in a variety of factors, including,
  10. will they have enough savings? Especially since people are living longer right now. This is an area of research focused on
  11. by our guest here today, Katy Milkman, who's a Professor of Operations, Information and Decisions here at the Wharton
  12. School. Katy, great to talk to you again, as always. Thanks very much for your time.
  13. Thanks for having me. I think I'll start out with like— when you— when people think about
  14. the decision to make retirement, obviously, all these factors come in, but from the research you've done and people you've
  15. talked with, is it a harder process to make some of these decisions now than maybe it was a few decades ago?
  16. Yeah, things have changed a lot. So we now live in a society, in the US, where it's common to work for an employer who offers you
  17. what's called a defined contribution plan instead of a defined benefit plan. So it used to be, basically, that you would
  18. be guaranteed some amount of income for the rest of your life if you worked for an employer. That's a defined benefit, even
  19. after retirement. And there's been a major shift over the last 30 or 40 years towards giving people the opportunity to
  20. contribute a defined amount and maybe have an employer match to a retirement fund, but then the income they'll have in
  21. retirement is a function of how much they choose to save, whether they potentially dip into those funds prior to
  22. retiring. And there's no guarantee, because it depends, really, on the performance of those assets. So it's a really
  23. different world, and it has led to not great results, honestly, in terms of the retirement income people have to live on
  24. who've worked their whole careers. A lot of people are ending up working longer or living less comfortably than
  25. they would have liked because of this new era. That's my— my takeaway. Though, I should say I'm not an expert on either
  26. defined contribution or defined benefit plans, but that's my rough understanding of the change. And then the work I do
  27. with my collaborators really focuses on, okay, in this current era where defined contribution plans have become so common,
  28. it's a big challenge to convince people to save. We have to make sure people are saving an adequate amount, and we face a
  29. lot of biases when we're trying to make that pitch. And one of them is present bias, the fact that we tend to be more attuned
  30. to the instant gratification we get from, say, spending a paycheck now, than saving it for later. We focus more on the here
  31. and now. That's what present bias means, and undervalue future everything. Future me. Whatever money I'll have in the
  32. future, it's worth less to me. I think, you know, that's forever away, and I don't value it as much. And so that's a major
  33. bias. It's something I teach my MBA students about. And given that we're fighting that uphill battle when we're trying to
  34. convince people to save for future— essentially future me, we try to use a lot of psychological insights to— to
  35. propel people to save what they'll need. Well, part of this discussion, as you just mentioned, is around
  36. savings being one of the big factors. And you research this through this idea of a fresh start.
  37. Give us an idea of what it is. Yeah. So this is a topic I've studied with my former Wharton PhD
  38. student, Hengchen Dai of UCLA. And Hengchen and I look at this idea that not only at the beginning of a new year, but
  39. there are lots of moments in our lives that we feel motivated by the sense that we have a clean slate or a fresh start. So we're
  40. most familiar with New Year's resolutions as part of the fresh start effect. At the start of every new year, we think, "Oh,
  41. it's a clean, it's a new year. It's a new me. I can achieve more." And we set these resolutions. But we have
  42. actually documented that this phenomenon of feeling like we have a fresh start and and are more motivated to make change
  43. arises at lots of other moments too. At every birthday, on Mondays, at the start of a new month, following the celebrations
  44. of any kind of sort of major event that feels like the start of a new cycle. So all sorts of new beginnings give us that
  45. fresh start feeling, which increases our motivation to pursue our goals and makes us feel more disconnected from past
  46. failures. Because we can say, "That was the old me, and this is the new me." So a lot of— a lot of the psychology in this space
  47. really relates to sort of how I relate to my past self and my future self. Thinking about that carefully led us to want to use
  48. the fresh start effect, or this motivation, to try to propel people to save more for retirement, to think more about
  49. future me, to pursue those goals. And so we thought fresh start moments would be an ideal time, because people have that
  50. extra motivation to pursue goals and to think about the future and to feel disconnected from past failings.
  51. So when you say fresh start moments, you mean what exactly? Yeah. So a fresh start moment is a moment that's the beginning of a new
  52. cycle in our life or on our calendar, and they can be personal, right? I might feel that I have a fresh start on my
  53. birthday, or maybe right after a promotion at work, or after the birth of a child. Those are all major turning points in a
  54. person's life. We— we tend to think about our lives like we're characters in a book, and we're living through these chapters.
  55. And the chapter breaks are not linear, necessarily, right? When you move to a new community, you take a new job, those are
  56. chapter breaks too. But these chapter breaks at the start of a new year or a new season or a new month or a Monday or a
  57. birthday, those are also small fresh starts, or sometimes big fresh starts, that make us more motivated to pursue our goals.
  58. And so employees were receptive to— to this, and looking at this kind of moment in their life as a fresh start and a great way to kind of
  59. maybe head down a different, different path in their lives? So what we did to explore that is we ran an experiment with
  60. thousands of employees who were not yet saving for retirement, or who were saving but at a very low rate, a rate that was well
  61. below what they would need to save to have a comfortable retirement. We partnered with four different organizations and
  62. sent mailings to employees who were in these categories. Non- savers, or a small number of very low savers. And we tried to
  63. use this insight about fresh starts to increase the likelihood that people would save. What we did is we sent
  64. mailings that invited people, certainly if they were up for it, to start saving right away. But we know that people like to
  65. procrastinate on anything that sounds difficult, like starting towards a savings goal. So we also invited them an opportunity
  66. to delay. We said, "You could also, if you don't want to save now, start saving on this future date." And what we randomized in
  67. our experiment is, some people the future date was a fresh start date, and for some people it wasn't. So for instance, if
  68. you had a birthday, Dan, coming up in two months, we might flip a coin and decide, are you going to be invited to start saving
  69. now or after an upcoming birthday, or after your next birthday? That would be what your mailing might say in one
  70. condition. Or— and this is what's kind of really tightly controlled about it— we would say, "Would you like to start
  71. saving now or in two months?" So actually, in both cases, it's exactly the same offer. But in one case, we've tied it to your
  72. birthday, which makes it more clear that this is an opportunity we think you might want to align with that fresh
  73. start moment. And we tried this with several fresh start dates. We tried aligning New Year's, so inviting you to start saving
  74. after a new year. We invited you to start saving after the start of spring, and we invited you to start saving after a birthday.
  75. So you'd just get one of these offers. It was random assignment in this trial, but we tested all of those different Fresh Start
  76. opportunities. And we tested it against just inviting people to save at an equivalent time delay. Or we also tried some
  77. dates that don't feel so much like fresh starts, just as sort of— we think of them as placebos. So Valentine's Day. It's a— it's
  78. also a day that is sort of notable on the calendar that we can label. But nobody typically thinks of Valentine's Day as a
  79. fresh start moment, unless— you know, if you met the love of your life, then maybe for you, it's meaningful. - Right. - But for most
  80. people, that's not a day that feels like the beginning of a new cycle in life. So we ran this experiment, and what we
  81. found is that when we invited people to begin saving after a fresh start date, and we compare what happened to people's
  82. savings rates who were invited to save now at an equivalent time, but without that fresh start date call out, we see
  83. more savings, significantly more savings, over the next eight to nine months. We look at savings rates, and we see, depending
  84. on how you model it, a 20 to 30% increase in the next eight months savings among the population that is invited to
  85. start saving after a fresh start date. So this does seem to motivate more people. It doesn't lead them to decline saving now,
  86. and it increases the total number of people who are saving, leading to this higher savings rate over the subsequent months.
  87. And I think it's also interesting, because you mentioned in the paper that we tend to make decisions, in many cases, that
  88. don't help us in the long term. So I guess by doing this, and maybe there's a little bit more immediacy to it, that maybe to a
  89. degree, we're also changing behaviors as well. That's right, we are— we're— we are changing behavior by getting
  90. people to recognize this opportunity is one that's aligned with their goals and sort of— and seeing, yeah,
  91. actually, I do want to start saving following my birthday. That— that sounds exactly like the right moment to do this. Or
  92. yeah, at the start of spring really does feel like a moment when I should be upping my savings contributions. But if
  93. I'd asked you, "Do you want to start saving next month?" which happens to be the start of spring, but I haven't called
  94. your attention to it, you don't have that same resonance, and you don't make the same decision. So it's changing
  95. behaviors. It's changing long- term outcomes for people by increasing their savings rates. And we think that's a really
  96. important insight. And the more we can leverage these kinds of moments that people see as fresh starts to increase savings or
  97. any other goal-directed behavior, the better. You've also done research that looks at the component of peer
  98. information in retirement savings decisions. Tell us about that. Yeah. So this was another randomized, controlled trial, also inviting
  99. people who were either non- savers or low savers to save. So there's a pattern here. These are projects— and there's a— I
  100. should also say there's a common co-author on both of these. John Beshears of Harvard Business School is a fantastic
  101. researcher, does a lot of work on retirement savings, and was involved in both of these projects. And so that's— that's
  102. the other common variable. We, in this case, partnered with one big company that had a lot of employees who had been part of a
  103. union, and as a result of their union bargaining, they had not been automatically enrolled in the— the savings program, the— the
  104. contribution program that they had on offer. So it's a 401(k) plan, where you put a portion of every paycheck into this plan,
  105. and you get a tax benefit when you do so. That money is not taxed, it's put in before taxes. So lots of people were not
  106. saving, because if you're not automatically enrolled, they had to take steps to start saving, and a lot of people don't bother
  107. to do that. So we tested this both with those union employees whose union had not negotiated for them to be automatically
  108. enrolled, as well as a non-union population. But the non-union, non-savers, were different because they had— they had
  109. intentionally opted out of savings. So they're— there's sort of selection bias, if you will. That's our nerd term for
  110. saying they're slightly different populations. So that effect that you saw play out, was it similar for pretty
  111. much everyone across the company? So, it wasn't. It actually turned out to matter what— which
  112. population they were in. And what we were testing was whether or not telling them about how many of their peers were already
  113. saving, or were already saving at a higher rate, whether or not that might increase their savings likelihood. So we tried
  114. actually two things. One, we varied whether or not they got a mailing that told them about the high number of their peers who
  115. are already enrolled and encouraged them to follow suit. And then the other thing we did is that we varied what number
  116. they saw. So we were never deceptive, but we randomly assigned people to either find out about the savings rate of
  117. peers in their five-year age cohort— so you know, if you're in, you know, age 40 to 45, you might find out about others age
  118. 40 to 45, or in their 10-year age cohort. So if they were age 44 they could also see the 40 to 50- year age bucket instead of the
  119. 40 to 45 age bucket. What that did is it meant we had some variation in the number people saw, so we could test not only
  120. what's the impact of finding out how many of your peers are saving, but also, what is the impact on finding out a slightly
  121. different number when you hear— when you learn that your peers are saving, right? So when you're in the 40 to 45 age
  122. bucket, you might find out 75% of other 40 to 45-year-olds are saving. But if you saw the 40 to 50 age bucket, you might find
  123. out that, you know, 80% of folks in that group are saving. So you see a different number. So we have these two ways we can look
  124. at what's the impact of peer influence. One, finding out that lots of peers are saving and two, what's the actual number
  125. you see? And how does that matter? And what was really, I will say, surprising, given what we know about how influenced we
  126. are by our peers, is that in this study, what we found is a backfire effect. Meaning, for— and specifically among union
  127. employees. So this was the group we expected to be most malleable because they hadn't previously made an active decision about
  128. retirement. They just passively not signed up. This group, when they saw a peer comparison and learned, hey, you know, 75% of
  129. your peers are saving. That reduced the likelihood that they chose to save. In addition, when we look at the specific number
  130. they saw, we see the higher the number they observe, randomly assigned, the less likely they are to save. And again, this is
  131. two things that go against what we normally expect to see in terms of peer effects. Because one, when I find out everybody
  132. else is doing something and the majority of other people are doing it, I normally decide to do it too, at a higher rate.
  133. - Right. Right. - And two, the higher the number of my peers doing something, the more likely I am to want to join. But we see the
  134. opposite in both cases. So this was really puzzling. We don't see this among people who weren't members of the union, so
  135. they hadn't actively opted out. There, we don't see any effect. But we wanted to dig into this backfire effect. And I want to say,
  136. first of all, I still feel that we don't know for sure what happened. But our best explanation at this point, based
  137. on additional analyzes we ran, is that it seems to be sort of an upward social comparison reaction, where people are
  138. feeling like they could never possibly catch up, because it's driven by lower-income members of the population. So when we do
  139. a median split on earnings and look at people who are below median earners in all the different states around the
  140. country where this company has employees who received our mailings, we see that the effect is really driven by the lower-
  141. income folks. And that leads us to conclude, potentially, this is driven by that sense that I can never catch up. So you know,
  142. the idea of social norms is, I want to keep up with the Joneses, so I'm going to try to do what the Joneses are doing.
  143. But if you feel you can't possibly keep up with the Joneses because their income is so much higher and they're
  144. already way ahead of you on so many dimensions, it may just be demotivating to hear, yeah, they bought another luxury car, and
  145. they saved more for retirement, and so on. And it may make you feel that it's hopeless. And so that's our guess as to what
  146. happened in this particular study. And it was very disappointing, but also useful to know.
  147. So is there kind of a next logical step that you would like to take, having learned all this and done this research about,
  148. you know, deeper understanding about retirement decisions? Well, the answer to everything right now, Dan, is AI. You know,
  149. that's the answer to everything we want to do next. So a lot of the work that my collaborators and I are talking about in the
  150. space of behavior change is related to, how can we use these large language models to incorporate some of the best
  151. behavioral insights we know into dialogs to help people make better decisions? So that's the next natural step. And certainly
  152. the LLMs that we train to try to help support people's retirement savings ambitions will be armed with the knowledge from this
  153. research that, you know, it may not be as effective as we thought to use social norming, particularly on low-income
  154. consumers, when we're trying to encourage them to save more for retirement, and that it can be effective to leverage fresh
  155. start dates as moments when people feel it's appropriate and optimal to begin saving.
  156. Katy, always great to talk to you and discuss your research. Thanks very much. - Always great to be here.
  157. Thank you so much for the great questions and the opportunity. Thank you. Katy Milkman, who's a Professor of Operations,
  158. Information and Decisions here at the Wharton School. Thank you for listening to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>. We hope you found this
  159. episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring
  160. you the best insight from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Katy Milkman discusses retirement savings, the fresh start effect, and surprising peer influence on saving behaviors.

Key points

  • The Fresh Start Effect. Katy Milkman explains how fresh start moments can motivate people to save more for retirement.
  • Changing Retirement Savings Behavior. Research shows that aligning savings with fresh start dates increases savings rates significantly.
  • The Backfire Effect of Peer Influence. Katy Milkman reveals surprising results about peer influence on savings decisions among union employees.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes