Preventing Student Loan Delinquencies: A Behavioral Science Study

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

A study from The Wharton School Professor Katy Milkman on 13 million borrowers found that behaviorally informed email reminders significantly reduced student loan delinquencies. Repeated reminders were more effective than single notifications, and framing savings in percentage terms improved borrower engagement. The findings suggest simple, cost-free messaging strategies can prevent thousands of missed payments.

#behavioralscience #nudge #studentloans #studentdebt ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Dan Loney: Well, there's been concern for several years now about the impact that student loans are having on people's lives once
  2. they're done with their time in college. New research looks at what can be done to provide a quote, unquote "nudge" and help
  3. people on that repayment path so that they have limited negative impacts. Pleasure to be joined by Katy Milkman, Professor of
  4. Operations, Information and Decisions here at the Wharton School, and obviously one of the important people involved in this
  5. research. Katy, always great to talk with you and talk about your research. Thanks for a couple of moments.
  6. Katy Milkman: Always a pleasure to be here. Thanks for having me. All right. So, tell us about this research.
  7. And I— I think the interesting thing at the top, 13 million people involved in this research?
  8. Yeah. Well, I should say, you know, it was led by an amazing PhD student named Rob Kuan, and it was made possible by a
  9. partnership with the Department of Education, an incredible group working there in fall of 2023. And they were planning a
  10. communication campaign after the pause that you might remember happened during COVID on requirements that students repay
  11. their loans, the pause on interest. And so we were thinking about, how could we be helpful? They already had a plan
  12. to start communicating with people who missed their first payment once that payment pause ended, and they wanted to pull
  13. in behavioral scientists to help. So we got this amazing opportunity to do science at this incredible scale, with 13
  14. million borrowers who missed a payment and needed a little nudge to get them back on track. And we had the opportunity to be
  15. part of thinking, you know, what might be most effective, and testing to make sure that then the Department of Education could
  16. use the very best insights from our work to move forward and try to help borrowers who were at risk of delinquency.
  17. So when you say nudge, you mean what? So we helped develop an email campaign. So if a borrower had a missed payment,
  18. they'd get a notification from the Department of Education that was an alert, essentially to say, you know, this has
  19. happened, and here's some advice on next steps. And we varied what those messages said. And so by nudge, I mean there's no
  20. change in the incentive structure they face. You know, they're not getting different interest rates or different
  21. rules applied to them or different periods of forbearance. Instead, it's just a different way of communicating
  22. the same information to see what's most effective, using insights from behavioral science to try to make it maximally
  23. helpful to borrowers. Yes. Yeah, the idea of behaviorally informed is just that a group of scientists who were trying to take the best
  24. insights they could from the behavioral science literature about how humans make decisions, developed a set of messages that
  25. simplified things as much as possible, made it as clear as possible what the action steps should be. And then we— we tested
  26. first of all, was that better than just sort of sending people a notification that they should go check in with their servicer?
  27. Could we do better than that by using sort of every trick up our sleeves as behavioral scientists? That's the first
  28. thing we tested in this project. And then we also did some other testing of things we weren't sure about, where we weren't
  29. positive which way it would go. For instance, we said, you know, does it really help if we bug them again? Should we send a
  30. reminder, not just one message, but two? And does that create value? We also looked at whether or not, when we talked to them
  31. about actions they could take that would reduce the— like, you know, that would be helpful, actions like signing up for
  32. what's called an income-driven repayment plan, where, if you have lower income, you can actually make smaller payments.
  33. So this is really helpful for a lot of people struggling to make payments, to switch and sign up for that kind of a plan. If we
  34. described that and talked about the savings they could achieve potentially in percentage terms, would that be more effective, or
  35. would it be more effective to talk about the savings they might receive in terms of what they'd owe each month in dollar terms?
  36. We weren't sure, so we tested that. And we also tested whether or not it's better when we had multiple pieces of advice for
  37. people, should we give them one piece of advice at a time? So each email focused on one piece of advice, or should we give
  38. them two pieces of advice repeatedly? So assume you only can send, say two communications to someone a month, because
  39. there's some limit on either nagging or how many times you can bother them before they click unsubscribe— so you have
  40. that limit. Are you better off separating your points or putting them all together? So those were the things we tested.
  41. Do the behaviorally-informed emails work? Do reminders make them better? Should we talk about savings in percentage or
  42. dollar terms, and should we give you one action step at a time, or two action steps at once repeatedly.
  43. So two questions for me off of the scenario you just laid out. One being, it sounds like giving them the information, that the
  44. element of having an option or having a variety of kind of components that— that they can refer to, certainly help the
  45. people have a better understanding of ways that they can kind of deal with some of these issues. - Absolutely.
  46. So we we think there's value add, and we empirically demonstrate that the sort of package of not just telling you
  47. you need to check in and figure out what's going on, but giving you this guidance about, it might be a good idea to sign up for
  48. auto debit pay, or automatic payments, so that you don't have to think every month to go and make your payment. It might be a
  49. good idea to sign up for these income-driven repayment plans. We do believe that that information is going to be
  50. valuable and that we can frame it in a valuable way, and we find that we can. So that, I think, is the least interesting
  51. part of the paper in some respect, although it's always nice to prove an assumption holds. So we find that that is
  52. beneficial and reduces 60-day delinquencies after borrowers receive those kinds of communications. But I think
  53. what's more important and more interesting is also some of the things we learned on top of that that were maybe not quite as
  54. intuitive. In fact, more important than that was actually just sending a reminder. The reminder was more impactful than
  55. the behaviorally-informed initial email itself. So nagging really works. That's a theme of a lot of research I've done. We
  56. just want to remind you multiple times if you haven't taken action on something important, and that really boosts the
  57. efficacy even of these behaviorally informed, sort of well designed reminders. We also learned that when we talk about
  58. what you could save in percentage terms, that was more effective than talking to you about the dollar amount you
  59. could save, which I think is really interesting and potentially generalizable to a lot of contexts. And then the
  60. final big takeaway was that we were better off giving you the same two pieces of advice twice across two emails, than sending
  61. one message with one piece of advice followed by a second message with just one piece of advice. So rather than breaking
  62. up two things you want to tell people so that they only have to think about one step at a time, you're better off hammering that
  63. home twice. And that was, I think, a real question. Like, simplification is important, but so is repetition. And we were
  64. able to isolate, at least in this case, that repetition beat simplification. So let me go back to the component of the savings in percentage
  65. terms, and why you think potentially that was more beneficial to people than actually seeing what the cold,
  66. hard dollar number was in terms of what they would be saving. It's a really great question, and we truly didn't know what the
  67. answer would be. Past research, there's reasons to think it could go either way. Dollars might be simpler and easier to
  68. interpret, if people aren't super comfortable thinking in percentage terms. What we— our best explanation, and it's still
  69. a guess, and future research is needed to really look under the hood, because all we have at this point is just, we sent
  70. emails. This one worked better. So we don't have, you know, we don't have interviews with people. We— we don't have—
  71. we don't have the kind of data I'd love to have to explain the why. But our best guess is that the percentage numbers were quite
  72. large. So we're talking about something like thinking about a 46% reduction, or a 40% reduction in your payment, and
  73. dollar terms were, maybe, you know, similar in scale. So, like, that's about a $40 reduction in your monthly
  74. payment, is also roughly 40%. So these are the kinds of numbers we're throwing around at people. They're pretty big percentages,
  75. and maybe the dollar isn't as huge. We know from some recent research by other scholars that when you look at a percentage,
  76. you think of it on a scale from zero to 100. Of course that's not true, right? I could give you 300% increase in your bill
  77. or— -Right. - Right? But— but we think of them as being on that scale. So when numbers get sort of in the two-digit range
  78. and get up close anywhere near 100%, people think that's a huge savings, because 100 is the max. And these numbers were pretty
  79. big on the percentage scale. So one possibility is that in percentage terms, this felt bigger in magnitude because of
  80. that sense that anything that's getting close to 100 is, wow, massive. Which is not fully accurate, but— but it's a
  81. perception people have. So that might be why percentages beat dollars, but we don't know for sure. And one of the fun things
  82. about an experiment like this is we can point to what works, and we can also point to exciting new directions that researchers
  83. who like to, you know, dig into the why, and you know— you could put somebody in an MRI scanner and try to explore, you know,
  84. how do they react differently when they see numbers versus percentages or dollars versus percentages? Both are numbers,
  85. of course. But— but, you know, does the— does the brain process that differently? Or if you ask people to talk about what they
  86. imagine being able to spend on now, after showing them a number in percentage terms that they might be able to save, or in
  87. dollar terms, would they think of different things? So there's a whole host of research you could do to follow up on this,
  88. and we think that's really exciting, but it's not the focus of this project here. We just show it works better. We
  89. speculate a little bit about why, and we are excited to see what future researchers find.
  90. Can you estimate, then, off of this research— and I guess off of this group— potentially, how many delinquencies could have
  91. been prevented if this path had been followed? Yeah. Well, what's really exciting about even small gains at scale
  92. is how massive they can be. So if— once you sort of imagine, what if we scaled the best performer to all 13 million
  93. borrowers who had been in this experiment, which is, of course, straightforward for an organization like the Department
  94. of Education to do, they could use now the best performer. What we see is, just over this time period studied, it would have
  95. averted about 80,000 sixty-day delinquencies. Just these small changes to improving messages. And I think what's exciting
  96. about that is it shows the power of behavioral science and testing at scale to make an impact on lives. These are
  97. essentially free adjustments to a messaging campaign that have the potential for large impact. And again, each individual
  98. effect is pretty small, but when you scale it to 13 million people, that's when you start to see there could be real, real
  99. benefits. And in fact, we know this campaign did prevent delinquencies, because people got these— these behaviorally-
  100. informed messages, and it had this impact. So you mentioned about, you know, hopefully doing more research in
  101. this area. But that being said, off of the research that you've done here, what do you think is your biggest takeaway that
  102. people should really kind of understand about this process? I mean, this is one of those projects where it's hard to boil
  103. it down to one takeaway, because there's so many. But probably the one takeaway is, reminders really work. Reminders really work. And
  104. I guess the second takeaway would be, you know, when you use behavioral science and you do AB testing, you can get— you can
  105. squeeze more juice out of your— you know, the lemon or the orange or whatever metaphor you want to use. We were able to
  106. make those reminders not only work by using behavioral science, but we were able to use AB testing to optimize further
  107. in ways that are pretty potent. And so I'm a big fan of AB testing. I'm a big fan of applying scientific insights to
  108. improve communications. And this just shows that both of those things matter and can have huge positive impact on our wallets.
  109. Katy, great work. Thanks very much for joining us and giving us all this insight. - Thank you so much for having me.
  110. You got it. Katy Milkman, Professor of Operations, Information and Decisions here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Katy Milkman discusses research on effective student loan repayment messaging strategies and the impact of behavioral nudges on borrower behavior.

Key points

  • Behavioral Science at Scale. Research shows small adjustments in messaging can prevent thousands of delinquencies.
  • The Power of Reminders. Katy Milkman reveals that reminders significantly boost repayment rates for student loans.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes