Retention Plans: Why Offering Rewards to Stay Can Drive Customers Away

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

On the surface, customer retention plans seem to make perfect sense. But according to new Wharton research, it’s a lot more complicated -- and sometimes, the result is exactly the opposite of what firms intend. More: http://knlg.net/1Ee3el3 📂 Marketing 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. um so this particular research involved looking at the efficacy of retention campaigns so many companies do retention
  2. campaigns this is basically campaigns which are targeted towards consumers they want to keep those consumers so
  3. they might give incentives for example you might kind of say for your next purchase you might get ten dollars off
  4. so these campaigns are very common and many companies think that these campaigns work do they really work so we
  5. had an opportunity to work with a cell phone company which was trying to do these retention campaigns what was great
  6. for us is that they actually did a field experiment for one group of customers who were randomly selected they did a
  7. retention campaign this was a pricing plan campaign for another group customers they did nothing what did we
  8. find the group of customers who are actually in the retention campaign actually left a lot more in fact
  9. staggeringly a lot more this was pretty bad for the company so what's the big picture do retention campaigns work
  10. actually on mass they might not work what we found was a more nuanced finding they work but only if you're that
  11. targeted so do retention campaigns but do it in a targeted way so the key takeaways again focus on
  12. retention campaigns i think primarily as many companies start thinking about these campaigns the typical thing that
  13. most companies do is do a mass-marketed campaign send a retention package to every one of their customers why because
  14. it's easy to do they don't have to think too much they'll send it to everyone what did we find sometimes actually
  15. sending campaigns to people might actually make them start questioning their own behavior for instance in this
  16. particular case for the cell phone company when they sent a retention campaign which was basically about
  17. looking at people's behavior their usage patterns and saying look there might be
  18. other plans that might be better for you it made many customers question whether a they were getting a good deal
  19. and if they're getting a good deal here why not look elsewhere so what that suggests is retention campaigns must
  20. often be targeted campaigns so think carefully about who in your customer base might be likely to leave
  21. don't do it mass do it on a targeted basis so on the surface when you think about
  22. it again going back to this idea of retention campaigns most people think the retention campaigns work so let me
  23. give you some hard numbers what we found so in the study that we did when we did
  24. the retention campaign and this was for a bunch of customers from a telecom service we monitored
  25. their behavior three months before the campaign and three months after the campaign
  26. what we found was when when these customers who were in the retention campaign we looked at what happens three
  27. months afterwards 10 of these customers left the service as opposed to a control
  28. group where no campaigns were done six percent left the service so you would imagine on the surface four percent is a
  29. staggeringly high rate of churn now should companies not do these campaigns that's not what we found what
  30. we found was on average yes it's very hard to kind of find evidence whether retention campaigns work but it
  31. was very easy to find evidence for who it worked for there were many sets of customers which had certain
  32. characteristics which are very easy for firms to observe for whom these campaigns work so surprising fact was on
  33. average they didn't work and for many companies i think this is an eye opener because what they should
  34. be thinking carefully about is how should we customize even our retention campaigns
  35. so i think this is very interesting in terms of customization what is uh what is very good nowadays is especially many
  36. companies who are data driven they have a lot of information about their customers so for instance in the mobile
  37. phone context companies routinely gather information about past consumption in our case we had information for example
  38. in the past three months that we had been collecting you know what was the level of overage which is the amount
  39. that people are going consuming over the number of plant minutes we had information about how much variability
  40. do they have you know in one month are they using 100 minutes in the other month are they suddenly using 200
  41. minutes or two you know 500 minutes so these are very observable types of patterns that you can find in your own
  42. customer base so many times what we found was cutting up the data on customers using these observable
  43. patterns might be a great way to customize so let me give you a specific example
  44. in our case what we found was that people who were consuming a lot way above the number of minutes that they
  45. had consumers who had a huge amount of variation consumers who had negative trend over
  46. the time that they were consuming less and less those were the people who are likely to
  47. leave and it cannot be surprising for many of these customers doing the retention
  48. campaign actually made them more likely to leave so sometimes it's best to let sleeping
  49. dogs lie now i think one of the interesting thing that's going on nowadays especially if
  50. you think about big data analytics and all of that is companies are rapidly experimenting
  51. so many many companies out there do routinely do a b testing now what did we find here what we found here was it's
  52. not enough to just do a b testing it's important to analyze the data correctly so let me give you a specific example in
  53. our a b test one group was the people who received recommendations the other group was people who received no
  54. recommendations on the surface people who received recommendations in that group and who
  55. accepted them actually churned less as compared to the control group now you would imagine well then one
  56. might think that the retention campaign worked but what's important to remember is that customers
  57. decided to accept the campaign so there is self-selection there so even for people who are exposed to the campaign
  58. and decided not to accept it they actually churned a lot more so the very fact that they were exposed to the
  59. campaign changed their behavior so it's important when companies are doing a b testing they think carefully about
  60. what's randomized and what's self-selected by consumers glossing over the fact can actually lead them to think
  61. that some campaigns are successful when they are not and a b testing is something that we
  62. believe is going to be rapidly taking off in this date of in the day of data analytics
  63. but again doing a b testing is easy analyzing it and interpreting the results correctly is way more important
  64. so a lot of people including some of my own work has looked at pricing plans and
  65. how customers choose among pricing plans what's a big problem there many of these
  66. things are self-selected by consumers so from a company's perspective if they want to look at the causal impact of
  67. what happens when they give pricing plans it's difficult to do so a prior right because there's an aspect of
  68. consumer self-selection involved so how do we get around this convincing a company that they should do a field
  69. experiment that is the gold standard of causal interpretation what we ended up doing was doing a field experiment where
  70. again people were given some pricing plans and some people were not given any recommendations so that helped us give a
  71. causal interpretation which was very very hard to do so just using secondary data which many researchers have done
  72. so i think what i'd like to continue on is work more on this area of pricing plans and recommendations i'm actually
  73. working with a company down in austin which is starting to look at energy consumption and the whole idea of smart
  74. meters how do we make people understand that when they are they are consuming electricity they are on different
  75. tariffs and different tiers what we're trying to do actually is to do a field experiment again making things salient
  76. to consumers and seeing how they might change their energy consumption over time or over days depending upon how
  77. much they're consuming now so that's the next plan you

Brief Summary

Retention campaigns can backfire if not targeted; a case study reveals higher churn rates with mass marketing.

Key points

  • Retention Campaigns: Do They Work?. A study reveals that mass retention campaigns may not be effective, highlighting the need for targeted approaches.
  • The Power of Data Analytics. Companies must analyze customer behavior data to customize retention campaigns effectively.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes