What Is Art? Surprisingly, the Crowdfunders and Experts Agree

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Crowds are smarter than one might think. A Wharton research paper discovered that the artistic tastes of the masses are remarkably aligned with those of experts. More: http://knlg.net/1c03M6j

Read the full paper: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2443114 📂 Finance & Accounting 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. this paper wisdom and Madness is actually about trying to resolve an interesting puzzle that's happened
  2. recently which is as of about 2012 According to some measures more money goes to the Arts through Kickstarter the
  3. crowdfunding site than the National Endowment of the Arts the major government organization that gives money
  4. to the Arts so this sort of raised the big question what does that mean right does that mean we get more good art more
  5. bad art uh does more or get funded what happens when you switch from a pure expert based system to also having
  6. crowds involved this paper with Ramen Ananda who's a business school professor at
  7. Harvard Business School and he and I work to get a group of professional judges people who judged things like the
  8. National Endowment of the Arts or who acted as expert critics or helped judge prestigious theater Awards and we asked
  9. them to evaluate Kickstarter projects to see whether or not their agreement would
  10. agree with the ones that were funded by the crowd and what we found were a few interesting things first of all that the
  11. crowd and experts generally agreed so we thought at first there might be a big gap between what the experts liked and
  12. what the crowd liked it turns out there wasn't they were very similar and where they disagreed with each other the vast
  13. majority of the times it was because the crowd was willing to fund projects that
  14. the experts were not a willing to so the crowd actually funded more art and had a
  15. lower threshold and when we actually followed up what happened to these projects afterwards it appeared that
  16. projects funded by the crowd were slightly more likely to fail but we also appeared to be more likely to actually
  17. achieve giant success so winning prestigious theater Awards running off Broadway so the crowd actually seemed to
  18. do a pretty good job of selecting High variance projects those had succeeded by a large amount or else
  19. failed when I think about what we were trying to kind of measure here it was really answering a question that was
  20. posed by two books that were published 100 years apart so in the 1800s there was a book called uh The Madness of
  21. crowds delusions of The Madness of crowds and that tried to look at things like tulip Mania in Holland or Ponzi
  22. schemes and trying to understand why crowds were so often crazy in 2004 James swii published a book called uh the
  23. wisdom of crowds all about how crowd markets are smarter than individuals and how we should do kind of group-based
  24. decision- making and this is two really interesting ideas contrasting with each other on one hand you have crowds are
  25. inherently crazy right and they they suffer from Madness they run after interesting ideas and in theater you
  26. might think of that and some of our experts did think this would Happ happen would would be that the crowd would tend
  27. to fund musicals about happy internet dancing cats right uh or about bacon kinds of things the internet likes right
  28. on the other hand you have this idea that crowds are actually wise that collectively they're actually smarter
  29. than individuals and they make great decisions and often better decisions than experts so what I think was
  30. interesting to us was that we found a lot more support for the wise crowd than the Mad crowd even in this area which is
  31. so subjective like theater more and more decisions that used to be in the hands of experts are also being
  32. put in the hands of Internet online communities so you could think about crowdfunding and how it's replacing
  33. expert judgment in theater or how it's replacing venture capital in some cases there's the idea of crowd science um the
  34. crowd sourcing so there's a whole bunch of things that we used to do as experts and now we throw to communities to help
  35. us solve and we don't know a lot about when communities are better than experts and when they're the same and I think
  36. one of the interesting findings here is even in this very subjective field of theater where you'd really expect a huge
  37. High culture low culture difference right so the things that a theater snob would like would be very different than
  38. what the mass Market would like even in this case it seems like the crowd has value in adding to decisions it helps
  39. actually lower barriers and democratize access so I think that's a really important point that would probably
  40. apply even more in other specialized Fields so what's actually interesting is despite the sort of famous book on the
  41. wisdom of crowds most of the work on why Crowds Are smart or not has tended to kind of revolve around um expert markets
  42. where you have experts making decisions and there's been some really interesting
  43. work by Shane Greenstein and others looking at things like Wikipedia and finding that Wikipedia is smart but it's
  44. a remarkably under kind of researched field and so uh crowdfunding is relatively new there's relatively little
  45. work on that and this whole idea of testing wisdom Madness is relatively novel so I think it's a a first step to
  46. trying to understand this increasingly important phenomenon so I'm really interested in crowds in
  47. general and how internet communities operate how we can make them work better what uh expert and standard
  48. organizations can they substitute for and I think we have a huge amount of questions right the internet is a
  49. relatively new phenomenon in academic terms uh we're still kind of grappling with what does it do what does it enable
  50. that we couldn't do before how could companies use it how can governments use it how can individuals participate in
  51. these environments in a way to make a difference how do we stop negative behavior there's a huge amount of
  52. interesting questions and I'm really excited to try and dig into [Music]

Brief Summary

Crowdfunding in the arts shows crowds often make wise funding choices, challenging traditional expert evaluations.

Key points

  • The Rise of Crowdfunding in the Arts. More money goes to the arts through Kickstarter than the National Endowment of the Arts.
  • Crowd vs. Expert Judgment. Experts and crowds generally agree on art projects, but crowds are more willing to fund.

Related episodes