How CommonBond Disrupts the Student Loan Market
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
A new start-up, CommonBond, is revolutionizing America's student loan market by offering competitive loans via alumni investors, and it just received a huge vote of confidence from the former chief executive of Citigroup, Vikram Pandit. Pandit, along with a group of financial backers, recently invested more than $100 million in CommonBond to help the company expand across the States and compete head-to-head with leading lenders. The company is also making waves because it employs the one-for-one business model, offering educational opportunities to needy students whenever a new loan is financed. Knowledge@Wharton spoke with CommonBond's CEO and co-founder, David Klein, to understand how he is working to upend the dysfunctional student debt market. π Leadership
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- So we're joined today by David Klein, CEO and co-founder of Common Bond. Thanks for joining us, David.
- Thanks, Encore. Thanks, Mullell. Um, so Common Bond, as I understand it, is an alumni lending or crowdfunding
- platform for student loans. Um, I know you recently about a little bit less than six months ago, uh, started lending
- for the first time. Can you tell us a bit about Common Bond, um, and how how you came to this?
- Sure. So, Common Bond, you hit it on the head. Common Bond is a student loan crowdfunding platform. Uh we source
- capital from alumni and individual investors and pass it on to students to lower the cost of students education. Um
- students can save about 20 to $25,000 over the life of repayment and alumni investors and individual investors
- receive a financial return in exchange. But there's much more than just financial return. There's also social
- return. uh there's social return in the core competency of what we do as well as
- social return in the social promise that we wrap around our model. So I can tell you a little bit about
- what that means. Um so financial return we all get right the students save a good amount of money and the investors
- can make a competitive financial return relative to other investments in the market right now of similar risk. Right?
- The social return component from an alumni alumni investors perspective is that they have an opportunity to be part
- of a solution to a large national problem and that is student debt. Um they also have an opportunity to be part
- of a solution at a very localized level and that is with a student at their alma
- mater. So we think that's um that's very uh strong motivator for uh alumni investors. Beyond that though, there's
- something that we call our social promise. And our social promise is both global and local. Our global social
- promise is that for every degree fully funded on our platform, we will fund the education of a student in need abroad.
- And our local social promise is that for every new city we bring our loan program
- to, uh, we will fund financial literacy programming uh, in a local charter school in an underserved community. And
- how did this idea to get involved in the student lending market come about or where did the interest come from?
- Yep. The interest came from a very personal pain point. Um I got into school. I got into Wharton Business
- School and um you know I knew just like anywhere else you get into school tuition as we all read about is pretty
- high, right? I didn't realize though that the cost of financing my education was going to be high as well. Um and so
- I very much felt that personal pain. I looked around to see what my options were. I wanted to go into a fixed rate
- product. I didn't want to deal with the risk of variable rates. And I noticed that my options were twofold. One, the
- federal government, two, private banks. Um, and I was pretty much looking at something akin to 8% fixed in the in the
- traditional space. Um, and I decided there had to be a better way, right? There there had to be an option that was
- pricing risk better, and there wasn't. Um, and so I decided to to do something about it. I actually came back to
- business school on the other side of average age, as I like to say, with the express purpose of wanting to start a
- business and and run it before or upon graduation. And so, between my personal pain point uh in student lending and my
- very strong desire and commitment to start a company while in school, um it ended up being a great a great marriage
- and I ended up meeting my my two co-founders, Michael Tramina and Jessup Sheen, here at Wharton as well. and the
- social social promise element. Um, tell us more about the inspiration or the motivation behind including that as part
- of common bond as well. Sure. Um, so it comes from I might have said this before but it comes from a
- very deeply rooted personal philosophy in what I think and we as co-founders think business should be um and has a
- responsibility to be. you know, um, businesses and corporations wield an incredible amount of influence. Um, and
- a lot of that has to do with the fact that they yield an incredible amount of capital and profits in their business.
- Um, and when I think about the future of business, I think there is huge opportunity for business to play a much
- larger role in the communities, the local communities that they're a part of and also broader society that they're a
- part of. And what I'm very hopeful about or rather encouraged by is that there are a number of companies who've come
- before us who have really put the social mission front and center. Um Warby Parker of course is a great example come
- coming right out of here at Wharton. Um to us a major inspiration. Um they were part of the same startup incubator
- Wharton venture initiation program that we were a part of just two years later. Um, you know, when we had our first
- company offsite, Neil Blumenthal, co-founder and co-CEO, welcomed us to their headquarters in in New York City
- to have an all day off-site event. Um, he came and he spoke and it was incredibly inspirational, right? And so
- we were we have been inspired by the likes of Warie Parker, Tom Shues, and we decided, you know, we can bring the one
- forone model, we can be the first to bring the one forone model to education and to finance. Um, and so that's what
- that's what we decided to do. And so going back to the financial return, so how are you or how is uh
- Common Bond able to provide investors and students sort of better returns than they're currently able to get in in the
- uh public market? Sure. Um it's a really interesting time that we're in in terms of macrolevel
- interest rates, what's happening in the credit market. Um things are a bit out of whack and it's very much a cause of
- the financial crisis. We're still seeing the effects of that. Um, and if we believe what the Fed tells us with
- interest rates, we'll continue to see that for a few years, right? And so there's, and by the way, that's part of
- what makes for a broken student loan market. Uh, federal government had to take over the student loan market.
- They're charging one price to everybody. It's a very inefficient pricing of risk.
- Private banks are a different story. they're more still skittish after the financial crisis, charging a risk
- premium on top of student loans, particularly given the fact that it's unsecured debt and they don't want to
- take on that much of a risk. So, what we've done is we've come in and we've said, uh, you know, we don't have the
- structural problems of the federal government. Uh, we don't have the baggage of the private banks and we're a
- much leaner operation than any of our competitors, direct or indirect. U, we can come in and we can price risk what
- we consider to be much more appropriately, which is a 6.2 24% fixed rate for students and they can lower
- that all the way down to 5.99% fixed when they sign up for automatic debit. Um, and so that that's what we've done.
- We we've essentially come to the market and said we can we think we can price risk better than what traditional
- alternatives are pricing. Um, and so taking a step from a student perspective, if you're looking to
- partner with Common Bond for your loans, how does that process work? Sure. Um so you know a student might
- hear about us from either press or from onschool uh in school activities on campus activities might hear about us
- from uh you know financial aid office where they post all alternative private lenders um and then a student engages
- with us. um we would hope and what we've seen is that students are particularly compelled um because of the community
- that we bring to the table. Not just the lower cost, right? Not just the 20 $25,000 savings, but also the community
- of students across schools that they're getting plugged into and the community of students and alumni within schools
- that they're getting plugged into. Um we're also we're also noticing that our social promise is resonating a lot with
- our students. Um you know the social promise for us was again a very personal thing. Um I have a very personal
- philosophy that business can and should be a p a force for for positive change. I think that business and corporations
- in general have a responsibility to give back to the local and broader community
- that they're a part of. And I'm hopeful that what we see going forward is that business and corporations more and more
- um kind of meet their uh social responsibility right in a big and real way. And so that that speaks to a little
- bit as to why we have a social promise. Um and that and that's something and that's something by the way um that you
- know the millennial generation which are the the students in school right now seem to to gravitate towards and that
- makes sense. We're millennials ourselves and we gravitate towards this. We're all
- about valuesdriven business. So th those are the things that I think attract students to to Common Bond.
- So when you deal with students for Common Bond, uh are students mainly looking for original financing or uh
- might some of them also want to refinance uh existing debt, student debt, which is more highriced.
- It's both. Um so we're originating new loans for students who are coming into school and students even at school for
- the the following semester. We're also very much participating in the consolidation market, the refinance
- market. So, we have a refinance loan product as well. And and where's the greater demand
- coming from? The demand is across the board. Um, and so what we've what we've noticed is that
- whether it's newly originated or refinanced, the demand is is equally large. If we look at how big the markets
- are right now, the refinance market um is much larger than the the new originations, which makes sense if you
- think about it. There's a backlog of years there in the refinance market than there are in the newly originated market
- which is really an annual an annual market. And and how risky are these loans and
- how do you deal with that risk? Yep. So the risk on these loans from an investor's perspective is incredibly
- low. Um and that's part of what allows the model to work especially now in the beginning as we're proving out the
- model. You know this this this industry is still relatively nent. Um it's about a year old. um plus or minus. And so one
- of the things that we have found to be incredibly important is that we derisk the model as much as we possibly can to
- give it a chance to succeed in the beginning and then we kind of use that as a platform to build off of. Um and so
- what we're when we're focusing right now on MBA programs, what we notice is that
- default rate is incredibly low. Payback payback is incredibly high. And it makes
- sense when you think about it just because employment rate is high and earnings potential is pretty high for
- students at uh at top MBA programs. And from an alumni perspective, so you've mentioned uh about the returns.
- Can you tell us more about the value proposition uh for any alum that you're looking to source to invest in common
- bond? Sure. The value proposition to alumni or individual investors or any any source
- or any cadra of investors that we use to kind of complement alumni capital. Um, I
- think it's three things. Uh, one is the financial return, and we've talked about
- that a bit. It's a pretty competitive financial return relative to other investment products of similar risk. Two
- is the social return. Uh, the fact that they have an opportunity to help lower the cost of education of a student at
- their alma mater, but they also are able to power the social mission of our company. Literally for every new alumni
- investor that comes to the table, for every new student borrower who comes to the table, they're actually helping us
- pay for uh another child at school at the African School for Excellence or fund that much more the financial
- literacy programming that we're funding in local communities here in the US and every new city we bring our program to.
- Um and so their participation powers our social mission, right? And that's very that's very powerful. The third thing
- I'd say is that the alumni and other individual investors who participate are able to plug in to a network, a
- community of top tier, top talent. Um, and we think that matters. Um, and so in thinking about this
- community, what's what sort of events or activities do you actually offer to alumni and to recipients of the loans?
- Yep. So, good question. You know, when we think about community, what does that mean? Um, a lot of people pay lip
- service to community. In fact, what I would argue is that any player that comes into this space or really any
- space as it pertains to finance or pretty much any other industry today, you have to build community, right? That
- to us is table stakes. That's not what's meaningful. What's meaningful is who can
- build a community that people want to belong to. And that's what we think we're building. uh you know when I think
- about the types of community events that we're putting on and by the way when I say community events and community I'm
- not just talking about building an online platform right we have a lot of online platforms and what you see over
- time with online platforms is as they grow as they become a bit more ubiquitous the value actually decreases
- right and so what we say is real connection meaningful community is done in the real world humanto human in
- person and so what we've done is we've spent a lot of time creating environment ments for students, investors,
- forward-inking professionals to come together under one roof, meet and connect. And what we found so far, you
- know, we have a number of examples of students who are within what we call our common bond family who because they are
- part of the family, because they are interacting with members of the community, they've been able to propel
- their professional success. Um, you know, we have one student who met uh the head of corporate acquisitions at
- American Express at one of our events, and American Express is her dream company. Um, and he was able to set up a
- number of interviews for her, and it looks like she might be getting a full-time job there uh when she
- graduates. Um, you know, I think about another MBA student who uh has a startup and she met a reporter at Business Week
- at one of our events in business week covered her company about two months after meeting and she wrote excitingly
- to us over email, you know, thank you so much. This was all because of of Common
- Bond. So, we think of ourselves much more than just a student lending company. We consider ourselves a company
- that reflects um that reflects kind of the future of finance. You've got to be more than just what you can argue is a
- commoditized lending product, right? You've got to do more than just lower the personal expense line of the
- student, which we do, but you've also got to help students maximize their topline, and that's what we feel like
- we're doing with our with our community. Great. And so, as you approach alumni, I
- have to imagine alumni affairs offices at different institutions uh may or may not be worried. How do you partner with
- or approach or or work with alumni affairs um departments through the universities that you're working with?
- Yeah. What what we say is it's best to um talk with everybody, right? And so while we're talking directly to
- students, um we don't want to lose sight of the fact that there are a number of different constituents out there. Uh
- admissions offices, financial aid offices, alumni affairs offices, not to be officially affiliated in any way, um
- but to build positive relationships with them. We think that matters. Um as it pertains to the alumni offices, frankly
- the reaction to this model is a bit mixed, right? Um there are kind of two camps that you can fall into. Um one is
- kind of a camp territorial camp where there's a zero sum game. There's a finite size to the pie and there's
- another camp that you can fall into, right? And that's kind of the camp of abundance. Um where there's a growing
- pie. We happen to fit or consider ourselves to be in the the uh the camp of abundance, right? We actually believe
- that our model can engage an entire swath of alumni who currently are not participating or otherwise engaged in
- university affairs. Um and and in a sense our model can bring those folks into the fold because there's a
- financial return component to it. And from there um I actually think our model can complement the efforts of alumni
- offices pretty well. Um some alumni offices see that others don't. Um, and that's fine by us. We think that over
- time what we'll be able to show, you know, as we get more and more data, we'll be able to prove that we actually
- live in a world of abundance as it pertains to alumni investor participants. So, is the concern of some those alumni
- offices that you might cannibalize some of the alumni giving that might otherwise go to fund scholarships for
- those students? That's that's the concern. And what what we how have you addressed that uh with uh
- uh you know the more territorial alumni offices, right? So what we say is two things. Um
- one the scholarship uh is a different kind of investment or or giving from alumni right or put another way we fall
- into the conservative slice of any investor's portfolio right um alumni giving alumni scholarships falls into
- another slice of somebody's personal portfolio that falls into the philanthropic slice as opposed to the
- conservative investment slice. And so we see them actually as quite different kinds of investments. And so even among
- the alumni who currently participate uh you can see a world in which they can participate in both because they're
- still able to diversify their portfolio. The second thing we tell them and we talked about it a little bit before and
- that is hey we actually think this is going to engage a large group of alumni who are currently not engaged with the
- university. you you say that u the industry um is about a year old. Uh who's your
- competition and how have you positioned Common Bond uniquely uh in this space? Yeah, our competition really falls into
- three different categories. Um you have traditional players, the federal government and the private banks. The
- federal government represents about 93% of u of student loans and private banks represents about 7%.
- The the second is this um it's the social lending space that's a bit more mature, right? Um and so you have
- players like a lending club or a prosper.com who have been in peer-to-peer lending since 2006 and 2007
- respectively, right? Um they're not in student loans right now. Could they be? They could. Um and then the third piece
- is what I would call social lending as it relates specifically to student loans. That's the market that's about a
- year old. Um and and that's and that's where the problem is particularly acute and particularly large. And so we feel
- pretty excited to come in and solve that. Um you know there are a couple of different things that make us different
- than any of our competitors across the board regardless of what segment they fall into. Um we talked about we've
- touched on a few of them. Um the first what we're noticing and getting feedback from students again the millennial
- generation is that our social promise makes us pretty distinct. Um that's something that doesn't exist across the
- board. Again we feel proud of the fact that we're the first in education or finance to bring the one for one model
- to to both education and and finance. Um and I can speak as to why that's important if you'd like me to. Um the
- second is the community piece that we've been talking about. Um, some folks are building community. Um, some are doing
- it better than others. For us, again, we think that's table stakes. We think that's an absolute requirement. But what
- makes what's going to make a player in this industry different is creating a community that students and alumni
- investors want to belong to and that's what we think we're doing in a very real way. Um, you know, the third piece is
- risk management. Um I think our approach to risk management is different than any
- other player in the space. Uh when I think about you know who we're going after at first to ensure that this model
- works and when I think about what those default rates look like not after 6 months of origination but after 3 years
- of origination what do those default rates look like? We think that the approach that we're taking is is a bit
- thoughtful and appropriately methodical to allow for our model to succeed early and therefore for the long term. The
- other thing I would say on risk management is that and this is one of the benefits of coming from a place like
- Wharton. Um you know we have been working with a professor in the statistics department who's helping us
- build a proprietary model that helps us better predict future repayment. So a lot of proprietary underwriting today
- and we have proprietary underwriting scorecard but it's what I would call traditional the power is when we go
- forward being able to find those attributes that better predict future repayment as opposed to any
- backward-looking tool like a FICO based tool. Could I wonder if I could just ask you
- one last question? Sure. Uh five years from now where would you like common bond to be?
- Good question. I don't get that a lot. We think about it a lot. We see it in our model, but I don't get the question.
- We would like to be a premier lender, period. Uh we're starting with student loans. It makes sense to for two
- reasons. One, the problem is large. Uh and it uh is derived from a personal paypoint uh of myself and my co-founder,
- Mike Terramina, uh who I met at Wharton Business School. Um and so that's why it
- makes sense to start with student loans for us in particular. But if you think about going forward and you think about
- finance and the future of finance more broadly um and you think about what the financial crisis did in destroying trust
- between banks and people and people and banks what you realize is that that trust
- needs to find itself somewhere and it does exist. It exists in trusted networks. exists uh among affinity
- groups and schools happen to be a natural fit for affinity and trusted networks, right? Which is why this model
- works so well. Another reason why we're we're starting with schools. But if you broaden out what trusted networks mean
- and you broaden out the definition of affinity groups, you can envision a world in which not only are student
- loans being better priced, better administered, and better serviced with this model, but all different kinds of
- lending products as well. Thanks so much for joining us today. Thank you. Thanks for having me.
- [Music]
Brief Summary
David Klein discusses Common Bond's innovative approach to student loans and its social impact on education financing.
Key points
- The Social Promise. For every degree funded, Common Bond supports a student in need abroad.
- Common Bond's Unique Model. Common Bond connects alumni investors with students, offering financial and social returns.
- Community Building. Common Bond fosters a community that connects students and alumni for professional success.
- Future Aspirations. Common Bond aims to be a premier lender, starting with student loans due to personal connections.
- Building a Trusted Network. The speaker emphasizes the importance of trust in financial relationships, especially within affinity groups.
Episode highlights
- The Social PromiseFor every degree funded, Common Bond supports a student in need abroad.βOur global social promise is that for every degree fully funded, we will fund education abroad.β1:56Sep 25, 2013
- Common Bond's Unique ModelCommon Bond connects alumni investors with students, offering financial and social returns.βWe can price risk better than traditional alternatives.β6:51Sep 25, 2013
- Community BuildingCommon Bond fosters a community that connects students and alumni for professional success.βReal connection meaningful community is done human-to-human in person.β12:59Sep 25, 2013
- Future AspirationsCommon Bond aims to be a premier lender, starting with student loans due to personal connections.βWe would like to be a premier lender, period.β21:16Sep 25, 2013
- Building a Trusted NetworkThe speaker emphasizes the importance of trust in financial relationships, especially within affinity groups.βTrust exists in trusted networks.β21:57Sep 25, 2013





