How CommonBond Disrupts the Student Loan Market

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

A new start-up, CommonBond, is revolutionizing America's student loan market by offering competitive loans via alumni investors, and it just received a huge vote of confidence from the former chief executive of Citigroup, Vikram Pandit. Pandit, along with a group of financial backers, recently invested more than $100 million in CommonBond to help the company expand across the States and compete head-to-head with leading lenders. The company is also making waves because it employs the one-for-one business model, offering educational opportunities to needy students whenever a new loan is financed. Knowledge@Wharton spoke with CommonBond's CEO and co-founder, David Klein, to understand how he is working to upend the dysfunctional student debt market. πŸ“‚ Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. So we're joined today by David Klein, CEO and co-founder of Common Bond. Thanks for joining us, David.
  2. Thanks, Encore. Thanks, Mullell. Um, so Common Bond, as I understand it, is an alumni lending or crowdfunding
  3. platform for student loans. Um, I know you recently about a little bit less than six months ago, uh, started lending
  4. for the first time. Can you tell us a bit about Common Bond, um, and how how you came to this?
  5. Sure. So, Common Bond, you hit it on the head. Common Bond is a student loan crowdfunding platform. Uh we source
  6. capital from alumni and individual investors and pass it on to students to lower the cost of students education. Um
  7. students can save about 20 to $25,000 over the life of repayment and alumni investors and individual investors
  8. receive a financial return in exchange. But there's much more than just financial return. There's also social
  9. return. uh there's social return in the core competency of what we do as well as
  10. social return in the social promise that we wrap around our model. So I can tell you a little bit about
  11. what that means. Um so financial return we all get right the students save a good amount of money and the investors
  12. can make a competitive financial return relative to other investments in the market right now of similar risk. Right?
  13. The social return component from an alumni alumni investors perspective is that they have an opportunity to be part
  14. of a solution to a large national problem and that is student debt. Um they also have an opportunity to be part
  15. of a solution at a very localized level and that is with a student at their alma
  16. mater. So we think that's um that's very uh strong motivator for uh alumni investors. Beyond that though, there's
  17. something that we call our social promise. And our social promise is both global and local. Our global social
  18. promise is that for every degree fully funded on our platform, we will fund the education of a student in need abroad.
  19. And our local social promise is that for every new city we bring our loan program
  20. to, uh, we will fund financial literacy programming uh, in a local charter school in an underserved community. And
  21. how did this idea to get involved in the student lending market come about or where did the interest come from?
  22. Yep. The interest came from a very personal pain point. Um I got into school. I got into Wharton Business
  23. School and um you know I knew just like anywhere else you get into school tuition as we all read about is pretty
  24. high, right? I didn't realize though that the cost of financing my education was going to be high as well. Um and so
  25. I very much felt that personal pain. I looked around to see what my options were. I wanted to go into a fixed rate
  26. product. I didn't want to deal with the risk of variable rates. And I noticed that my options were twofold. One, the
  27. federal government, two, private banks. Um, and I was pretty much looking at something akin to 8% fixed in the in the
  28. traditional space. Um, and I decided there had to be a better way, right? There there had to be an option that was
  29. pricing risk better, and there wasn't. Um, and so I decided to to do something about it. I actually came back to
  30. business school on the other side of average age, as I like to say, with the express purpose of wanting to start a
  31. business and and run it before or upon graduation. And so, between my personal pain point uh in student lending and my
  32. very strong desire and commitment to start a company while in school, um it ended up being a great a great marriage
  33. and I ended up meeting my my two co-founders, Michael Tramina and Jessup Sheen, here at Wharton as well. and the
  34. social social promise element. Um, tell us more about the inspiration or the motivation behind including that as part
  35. of common bond as well. Sure. Um, so it comes from I might have said this before but it comes from a
  36. very deeply rooted personal philosophy in what I think and we as co-founders think business should be um and has a
  37. responsibility to be. you know, um, businesses and corporations wield an incredible amount of influence. Um, and
  38. a lot of that has to do with the fact that they yield an incredible amount of capital and profits in their business.
  39. Um, and when I think about the future of business, I think there is huge opportunity for business to play a much
  40. larger role in the communities, the local communities that they're a part of and also broader society that they're a
  41. part of. And what I'm very hopeful about or rather encouraged by is that there are a number of companies who've come
  42. before us who have really put the social mission front and center. Um Warby Parker of course is a great example come
  43. coming right out of here at Wharton. Um to us a major inspiration. Um they were part of the same startup incubator
  44. Wharton venture initiation program that we were a part of just two years later. Um, you know, when we had our first
  45. company offsite, Neil Blumenthal, co-founder and co-CEO, welcomed us to their headquarters in in New York City
  46. to have an all day off-site event. Um, he came and he spoke and it was incredibly inspirational, right? And so
  47. we were we have been inspired by the likes of Warie Parker, Tom Shues, and we decided, you know, we can bring the one
  48. forone model, we can be the first to bring the one forone model to education and to finance. Um, and so that's what
  49. that's what we decided to do. And so going back to the financial return, so how are you or how is uh
  50. Common Bond able to provide investors and students sort of better returns than they're currently able to get in in the
  51. uh public market? Sure. Um it's a really interesting time that we're in in terms of macrolevel
  52. interest rates, what's happening in the credit market. Um things are a bit out of whack and it's very much a cause of
  53. the financial crisis. We're still seeing the effects of that. Um, and if we believe what the Fed tells us with
  54. interest rates, we'll continue to see that for a few years, right? And so there's, and by the way, that's part of
  55. what makes for a broken student loan market. Uh, federal government had to take over the student loan market.
  56. They're charging one price to everybody. It's a very inefficient pricing of risk.
  57. Private banks are a different story. they're more still skittish after the financial crisis, charging a risk
  58. premium on top of student loans, particularly given the fact that it's unsecured debt and they don't want to
  59. take on that much of a risk. So, what we've done is we've come in and we've said, uh, you know, we don't have the
  60. structural problems of the federal government. Uh, we don't have the baggage of the private banks and we're a
  61. much leaner operation than any of our competitors, direct or indirect. U, we can come in and we can price risk what
  62. we consider to be much more appropriately, which is a 6.2 24% fixed rate for students and they can lower
  63. that all the way down to 5.99% fixed when they sign up for automatic debit. Um, and so that that's what we've done.
  64. We we've essentially come to the market and said we can we think we can price risk better than what traditional
  65. alternatives are pricing. Um, and so taking a step from a student perspective, if you're looking to
  66. partner with Common Bond for your loans, how does that process work? Sure. Um so you know a student might
  67. hear about us from either press or from onschool uh in school activities on campus activities might hear about us
  68. from uh you know financial aid office where they post all alternative private lenders um and then a student engages
  69. with us. um we would hope and what we've seen is that students are particularly compelled um because of the community
  70. that we bring to the table. Not just the lower cost, right? Not just the 20 $25,000 savings, but also the community
  71. of students across schools that they're getting plugged into and the community of students and alumni within schools
  72. that they're getting plugged into. Um we're also we're also noticing that our social promise is resonating a lot with
  73. our students. Um you know the social promise for us was again a very personal thing. Um I have a very personal
  74. philosophy that business can and should be a p a force for for positive change. I think that business and corporations
  75. in general have a responsibility to give back to the local and broader community
  76. that they're a part of. And I'm hopeful that what we see going forward is that business and corporations more and more
  77. um kind of meet their uh social responsibility right in a big and real way. And so that that speaks to a little
  78. bit as to why we have a social promise. Um and that and that's something and that's something by the way um that you
  79. know the millennial generation which are the the students in school right now seem to to gravitate towards and that
  80. makes sense. We're millennials ourselves and we gravitate towards this. We're all
  81. about valuesdriven business. So th those are the things that I think attract students to to Common Bond.
  82. So when you deal with students for Common Bond, uh are students mainly looking for original financing or uh
  83. might some of them also want to refinance uh existing debt, student debt, which is more highriced.
  84. It's both. Um so we're originating new loans for students who are coming into school and students even at school for
  85. the the following semester. We're also very much participating in the consolidation market, the refinance
  86. market. So, we have a refinance loan product as well. And and where's the greater demand
  87. coming from? The demand is across the board. Um, and so what we've what we've noticed is that
  88. whether it's newly originated or refinanced, the demand is is equally large. If we look at how big the markets
  89. are right now, the refinance market um is much larger than the the new originations, which makes sense if you
  90. think about it. There's a backlog of years there in the refinance market than there are in the newly originated market
  91. which is really an annual an annual market. And and how risky are these loans and
  92. how do you deal with that risk? Yep. So the risk on these loans from an investor's perspective is incredibly
  93. low. Um and that's part of what allows the model to work especially now in the beginning as we're proving out the
  94. model. You know this this this industry is still relatively nent. Um it's about a year old. um plus or minus. And so one
  95. of the things that we have found to be incredibly important is that we derisk the model as much as we possibly can to
  96. give it a chance to succeed in the beginning and then we kind of use that as a platform to build off of. Um and so
  97. what we're when we're focusing right now on MBA programs, what we notice is that
  98. default rate is incredibly low. Payback payback is incredibly high. And it makes
  99. sense when you think about it just because employment rate is high and earnings potential is pretty high for
  100. students at uh at top MBA programs. And from an alumni perspective, so you've mentioned uh about the returns.
  101. Can you tell us more about the value proposition uh for any alum that you're looking to source to invest in common
  102. bond? Sure. The value proposition to alumni or individual investors or any any source
  103. or any cadra of investors that we use to kind of complement alumni capital. Um, I
  104. think it's three things. Uh, one is the financial return, and we've talked about
  105. that a bit. It's a pretty competitive financial return relative to other investment products of similar risk. Two
  106. is the social return. Uh, the fact that they have an opportunity to help lower the cost of education of a student at
  107. their alma mater, but they also are able to power the social mission of our company. Literally for every new alumni
  108. investor that comes to the table, for every new student borrower who comes to the table, they're actually helping us
  109. pay for uh another child at school at the African School for Excellence or fund that much more the financial
  110. literacy programming that we're funding in local communities here in the US and every new city we bring our program to.
  111. Um and so their participation powers our social mission, right? And that's very that's very powerful. The third thing
  112. I'd say is that the alumni and other individual investors who participate are able to plug in to a network, a
  113. community of top tier, top talent. Um, and we think that matters. Um, and so in thinking about this
  114. community, what's what sort of events or activities do you actually offer to alumni and to recipients of the loans?
  115. Yep. So, good question. You know, when we think about community, what does that mean? Um, a lot of people pay lip
  116. service to community. In fact, what I would argue is that any player that comes into this space or really any
  117. space as it pertains to finance or pretty much any other industry today, you have to build community, right? That
  118. to us is table stakes. That's not what's meaningful. What's meaningful is who can
  119. build a community that people want to belong to. And that's what we think we're building. uh you know when I think
  120. about the types of community events that we're putting on and by the way when I say community events and community I'm
  121. not just talking about building an online platform right we have a lot of online platforms and what you see over
  122. time with online platforms is as they grow as they become a bit more ubiquitous the value actually decreases
  123. right and so what we say is real connection meaningful community is done in the real world humanto human in
  124. person and so what we've done is we've spent a lot of time creating environment ments for students, investors,
  125. forward-inking professionals to come together under one roof, meet and connect. And what we found so far, you
  126. know, we have a number of examples of students who are within what we call our common bond family who because they are
  127. part of the family, because they are interacting with members of the community, they've been able to propel
  128. their professional success. Um, you know, we have one student who met uh the head of corporate acquisitions at
  129. American Express at one of our events, and American Express is her dream company. Um, and he was able to set up a
  130. number of interviews for her, and it looks like she might be getting a full-time job there uh when she
  131. graduates. Um, you know, I think about another MBA student who uh has a startup and she met a reporter at Business Week
  132. at one of our events in business week covered her company about two months after meeting and she wrote excitingly
  133. to us over email, you know, thank you so much. This was all because of of Common
  134. Bond. So, we think of ourselves much more than just a student lending company. We consider ourselves a company
  135. that reflects um that reflects kind of the future of finance. You've got to be more than just what you can argue is a
  136. commoditized lending product, right? You've got to do more than just lower the personal expense line of the
  137. student, which we do, but you've also got to help students maximize their topline, and that's what we feel like
  138. we're doing with our with our community. Great. And so, as you approach alumni, I
  139. have to imagine alumni affairs offices at different institutions uh may or may not be worried. How do you partner with
  140. or approach or or work with alumni affairs um departments through the universities that you're working with?
  141. Yeah. What what we say is it's best to um talk with everybody, right? And so while we're talking directly to
  142. students, um we don't want to lose sight of the fact that there are a number of different constituents out there. Uh
  143. admissions offices, financial aid offices, alumni affairs offices, not to be officially affiliated in any way, um
  144. but to build positive relationships with them. We think that matters. Um as it pertains to the alumni offices, frankly
  145. the reaction to this model is a bit mixed, right? Um there are kind of two camps that you can fall into. Um one is
  146. kind of a camp territorial camp where there's a zero sum game. There's a finite size to the pie and there's
  147. another camp that you can fall into, right? And that's kind of the camp of abundance. Um where there's a growing
  148. pie. We happen to fit or consider ourselves to be in the the uh the camp of abundance, right? We actually believe
  149. that our model can engage an entire swath of alumni who currently are not participating or otherwise engaged in
  150. university affairs. Um and and in a sense our model can bring those folks into the fold because there's a
  151. financial return component to it. And from there um I actually think our model can complement the efforts of alumni
  152. offices pretty well. Um some alumni offices see that others don't. Um, and that's fine by us. We think that over
  153. time what we'll be able to show, you know, as we get more and more data, we'll be able to prove that we actually
  154. live in a world of abundance as it pertains to alumni investor participants. So, is the concern of some those alumni
  155. offices that you might cannibalize some of the alumni giving that might otherwise go to fund scholarships for
  156. those students? That's that's the concern. And what what we how have you addressed that uh with uh
  157. uh you know the more territorial alumni offices, right? So what we say is two things. Um
  158. one the scholarship uh is a different kind of investment or or giving from alumni right or put another way we fall
  159. into the conservative slice of any investor's portfolio right um alumni giving alumni scholarships falls into
  160. another slice of somebody's personal portfolio that falls into the philanthropic slice as opposed to the
  161. conservative investment slice. And so we see them actually as quite different kinds of investments. And so even among
  162. the alumni who currently participate uh you can see a world in which they can participate in both because they're
  163. still able to diversify their portfolio. The second thing we tell them and we talked about it a little bit before and
  164. that is hey we actually think this is going to engage a large group of alumni who are currently not engaged with the
  165. university. you you say that u the industry um is about a year old. Uh who's your
  166. competition and how have you positioned Common Bond uniquely uh in this space? Yeah, our competition really falls into
  167. three different categories. Um you have traditional players, the federal government and the private banks. The
  168. federal government represents about 93% of u of student loans and private banks represents about 7%.
  169. The the second is this um it's the social lending space that's a bit more mature, right? Um and so you have
  170. players like a lending club or a prosper.com who have been in peer-to-peer lending since 2006 and 2007
  171. respectively, right? Um they're not in student loans right now. Could they be? They could. Um and then the third piece
  172. is what I would call social lending as it relates specifically to student loans. That's the market that's about a
  173. year old. Um and and that's and that's where the problem is particularly acute and particularly large. And so we feel
  174. pretty excited to come in and solve that. Um you know there are a couple of different things that make us different
  175. than any of our competitors across the board regardless of what segment they fall into. Um we talked about we've
  176. touched on a few of them. Um the first what we're noticing and getting feedback from students again the millennial
  177. generation is that our social promise makes us pretty distinct. Um that's something that doesn't exist across the
  178. board. Again we feel proud of the fact that we're the first in education or finance to bring the one for one model
  179. to to both education and and finance. Um and I can speak as to why that's important if you'd like me to. Um the
  180. second is the community piece that we've been talking about. Um, some folks are building community. Um, some are doing
  181. it better than others. For us, again, we think that's table stakes. We think that's an absolute requirement. But what
  182. makes what's going to make a player in this industry different is creating a community that students and alumni
  183. investors want to belong to and that's what we think we're doing in a very real way. Um, you know, the third piece is
  184. risk management. Um I think our approach to risk management is different than any
  185. other player in the space. Uh when I think about you know who we're going after at first to ensure that this model
  186. works and when I think about what those default rates look like not after 6 months of origination but after 3 years
  187. of origination what do those default rates look like? We think that the approach that we're taking is is a bit
  188. thoughtful and appropriately methodical to allow for our model to succeed early and therefore for the long term. The
  189. other thing I would say on risk management is that and this is one of the benefits of coming from a place like
  190. Wharton. Um you know we have been working with a professor in the statistics department who's helping us
  191. build a proprietary model that helps us better predict future repayment. So a lot of proprietary underwriting today
  192. and we have proprietary underwriting scorecard but it's what I would call traditional the power is when we go
  193. forward being able to find those attributes that better predict future repayment as opposed to any
  194. backward-looking tool like a FICO based tool. Could I wonder if I could just ask you
  195. one last question? Sure. Uh five years from now where would you like common bond to be?
  196. Good question. I don't get that a lot. We think about it a lot. We see it in our model, but I don't get the question.
  197. We would like to be a premier lender, period. Uh we're starting with student loans. It makes sense to for two
  198. reasons. One, the problem is large. Uh and it uh is derived from a personal paypoint uh of myself and my co-founder,
  199. Mike Terramina, uh who I met at Wharton Business School. Um and so that's why it
  200. makes sense to start with student loans for us in particular. But if you think about going forward and you think about
  201. finance and the future of finance more broadly um and you think about what the financial crisis did in destroying trust
  202. between banks and people and people and banks what you realize is that that trust
  203. needs to find itself somewhere and it does exist. It exists in trusted networks. exists uh among affinity
  204. groups and schools happen to be a natural fit for affinity and trusted networks, right? Which is why this model
  205. works so well. Another reason why we're we're starting with schools. But if you broaden out what trusted networks mean
  206. and you broaden out the definition of affinity groups, you can envision a world in which not only are student
  207. loans being better priced, better administered, and better serviced with this model, but all different kinds of
  208. lending products as well. Thanks so much for joining us today. Thank you. Thanks for having me.
  209. [Music]

Brief Summary

David Klein discusses Common Bond's innovative approach to student loans and its social impact on education financing.

Key points

  • The Social Promise. For every degree funded, Common Bond supports a student in need abroad.
  • Common Bond's Unique Model. Common Bond connects alumni investors with students, offering financial and social returns.
  • Community Building. Common Bond fosters a community that connects students and alumni for professional success.
  • Future Aspirations. Common Bond aims to be a premier lender, starting with student loans due to personal connections.
  • Building a Trusted Network. The speaker emphasizes the importance of trust in financial relationships, especially within affinity groups.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes