Was Jesus an Effective Leader?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Reza Aslan's new book, 'Zealot: The Life and Times of Jesus of Nazareth,' paints Jesus as a revolutionary as well as a spiritual leader. Wharton professor G. Richard Shell talked with Aslan about Jesus's leadership qualities. πŸ“‚ Leadership;Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hi my name is Richard shell I'm here with Reza aen the author of zealot The Life and Times of Jesus of Nazareth uh
  2. and I'm proud to say that we're happy at Wharton to uh host a best-selling author
  3. uh and someone who knows more than probably most people living about the facts of the this life of Jesus so
  4. welcome Rea thank you thanks for having me uh Rea um I'm U curious about how this book came to uh be next on the
  5. plate you've written about Islam you've written about fundamentalism both of which are sort of Islamic oriented
  6. Middle East subjects but how did how did the idea of writing a life of Jesus come
  7. to your mind well it turns out Jesus is Middle Eastern too true um no I've actually been in
  8. wanting to write this book for a very long time it actually has its source in my uh undergraduate thesis work at Santa
  9. Clara University which was on something called the Messianic Secret in mark this
  10. very difficult to understand uh thing that happens with in the First Gospel where Jesus is constantly denying his
  11. Messianic identity constantly rejecting it when other people throw it at him and
  12. Scholars have been trying to figure out for 200 years why that is and I wrote a little little thesis on it that then
  13. became kind of the impetus for wanting to dig deeper and deeper into the historical Jesus um it's just that I
  14. didn't get a chance to actually write the book itself until until now okay great um well um for our listeners
  15. um I think it would be helpful to start this if you could just give us sort of your thesis in a nutshell so uh you can
  16. sort of set the plate right well this is a book this it's a biography of the historical Jesus the man who lived 2,000
  17. years ago this itinerant Jewish preacher who despite his illiteracy his lack of Education started a movement uh that uh
  18. that was seen as so revolutionary at the time so threatening to the political religious powers of the of the day that
  19. he was ultimately arrested tortured and executed for it it's an attempt to kind of dig through all of the layers of
  20. Mythology and interpretation the Legends and theology that have Arisen about this
  21. man over the last 2,000 years and to see as much as possible how we can get to the person himself it's a admittedly
  22. quite a difficult task it's one that has been uh a part of a quest for the historical Jesus for two centuries now
  23. and really what I'm trying to do is distill these 200 years of academic scholarship and Research into something
  24. that's appealing that's popular uh and meant for a general audience people who are interested in trying to figure out
  25. who this man was over and Beyond what the sort of Christian Traditions about him have created and who he is is a
  26. Jewish nationalist revolutionary who like the dozen or so other Messiah as of his time had at as his chief goal the
  27. removal of the Roman occupation from the holy land so people who are familiar with the Bible I think have an image of
  28. Jesus as sort of sitting in a meadow with a group of children uh uh and birds on his shoulders looking at mustard
  29. seeds and flowers uh and your image of Jesus is much closer to the one of the uh powerful physical person who could
  30. overturn the tables of money changers well look if you know nothing else about Jesus except that he was crucified you
  31. know enough to at the very least begin to question that image that you're referring to of this pacifistic preacher
  32. of good works with no interest in the cares of this world crucifixion was a punishment that Rome reserved almost
  33. exclusively for crimes against the state crimes like sedition or Insurrection treason Rebellion that's all that you
  34. could be crucified for so again if that's all you know about Jesus then you know enough to think that perhaps this
  35. guy was a little bit more of a troublemaker a little more revolutionary than we we perhaps think the image of
  36. Jesus as this celestial spirit with no concern over uh anything about this world that Jesus frankly would have gone
  37. totally unnoticed by Rome interesting so um um I think you know a lot of people when they just encounter the Bible have
  38. this puzzle you know what did this guy do that deserve this punishment so you're saying well what let's look at
  39. the punishment and go back to see what he must have done precisely that's exactly where you start at the end of
  40. the story not the beginning of the story this man was at the very least seen as a
  41. rebel as as seditious and let's be honest I mean if he did declare himself to be the Messiah that is a treasonable
  42. offense in the first century the Messiah means the anointed one the job of the Messiah as the descendant of King David
  43. is to reestablish David's Kingdom on Earth to usher in the rule of God well if you're claiming to usher in the rule
  44. of God you're claiming to Usher out the rule of Caesar and that is something that the Romans would not have ignored
  45. right yeah I remember the first time I read the Bible uh just on my own I I remember being struck at about Midway
  46. through the second gospel Jesus was a Jew who let who did who kept the secret for me it's funny that you say that
  47. because that really is the key to understanding the historical Jesus and it seems
  48. obvious I mean everybody thinks everybody knows Jesus is a Jew but there are consequences to that fact which is
  49. that everything that Jesus said or did he said or did as a Jew that every word that came out of his mouth has to be
  50. understood in the Jewish context that his audience were Jews so when Jesus said I am the Messiah he meant the Jew
  51. Jewish Messiah and every Jew who heard that understood what that meant when he uh overturned the tables of the money
  52. changers when he talked about the kingdom of God as a very real thing on earth those were the statements by a Jew
  53. about Judaism for Jews and that should immediately change the way that you read the gospels the gospels were written by
  54. Christians but they're written about a Jew that uh I remember I read the Bible all the way through in a relatively
  55. short amount of time and when I hit the New Testament I suddenly started hearing
  56. uh verses I'd heard before and they were all from the prophets and and various things so I started circling passages
  57. that that I could find in another book in the Old Testament and it really became obvious that he was referencing a
  58. tradition so referencing a tradition and what's really fascinating too about what
  59. you just said is that we have to understand the the direction where that prophecy
  60. goes so obviously a person of Faith a person a Believer thinks that Jesus fulfilled these prophecies that were
  61. written by the Hebrew prophets in reality the gospel writers wrote Jesus's story in a way to fulfill those
  62. prophecies so for instance one of the prophecy says that the Messiah has to be born in Bethlehem but Jesus was not born
  63. in Bethlehem Jesus was a nazaran that's how he was known throughout his entire life so the Gospel of Luke has to figure
  64. out a way to make Jesus fit the prophecy and so he creates this entire story about a census that forces Jesus's
  65. family to uproot themselves from Nazareth and go to Bethlehem where where he is born that's how the prophecies
  66. were fulfilled you take the story of Jesus and you shift it so that it fits the prophecy not the other way around in
  67. uh in U law we call that reverse engineering right right precis so U so let me ask you a couple of things that
  68. might be of interest to our audience who are business uh leaders uh people interested in business uh just because
  69. you know so much about the historical life of Jesus and sort of put it in context for us so uh uh in your view
  70. having studied uh all the records do you think that Jesus was an effective leader let's let's talk about the basic
  71. facts of this man's life he is illiterate as 98% of his fellow Jews were totally uneducated if he was a
  72. tekon like the gospel say uh he was at the second lowest rung of the social ladder just above the slave the Indigent
  73. and the beggar the tekon is a tecton is a woodworker you know we always think of
  74. him as as a carpenter but the image that we have of him is some guy with a small
  75. business you know that he's like making tables and chairs and people coming and buying that's not what a tecton was a
  76. tecton was a day laborer a tect on was the kind of guy who hangs out uh in front of Home Depot waiting for a truck
  77. to come by to get a job he would go from City to City looking for work so you're
  78. talking about the poorest of the poor illiterate uneducated and yet despite all that was
  79. able to start this movement on behalf of the poor the weak the marginalize the dispossessed that ultimately led to this
  80. confrontation with Rome so I guess what I'm saying is that the the leadership principles there are so fascinating to
  81. me because the gospels over and over again say that the people that Jesus spoke to were amazed not So Much by his
  82. teachings but by the authority with which he spoke it was his personal Charisma that brought people to him he
  83. wasn't a scribe he wasn't a Pharisee he wasn't a priest he was not learned he did not talk uh about the scriptures
  84. from a position of an E from an expert he was not an expert in the scriptures instead what he did was talk about the
  85. needs of the individuals that he was speaking to and he would address those needs through his Charisma a and that's
  86. where his power came from so in a in an American political context he might have
  87. been a populist uh politician someone who came from the working class and who spoke to the working class and uh was
  88. you know very charismatic and able to to develop a big precisely indeed if you were to distill Jesus's social teachings
  89. it was about the reversal of the social order the first shall be last and the last shall be first the rich shall be
  90. made poor the poor shall be made Rich this was about as populist as it gets I mean nowadays we would call him a
  91. socialist and you know we would we would denigrate him to the margins of society
  92. well it turns out that that's how they thought about him back then too okay uh what about his skill another leadership
  93. skill as a communicator uh What uh what evidence do you have to suggest that he either was uh on the A+ wrong or the C
  94. Rong of Communicator well as most people know Jesus's primary form of communication was through Parables some
  95. of these Parables of course for us are somewhat incomprehensible you know that the kingdom of God is like a mustard
  96. seed uh the kingdom of God is like a Wedding Banquet the kingdom of God of course being the primary uh message that
  97. he had in mind that when he talks about the kingdom of God he's talking precisely about this reversal of the
  98. social order that I was referring to now obviously this is a message that is profoundly appealing if you're at the
  99. lowest rungs of the social ladder and it's profoundly threatening if you're at the highest rungs of the social ladder
  100. so Jesus by speaking in these Parables has figured out a way to communicate the truth of this Kingdom to his audience
  101. who would understand precisely what he is is talking about but at the same time to keep it as much as secret as possible
  102. from the those that would feel threatened by it indeed he says about his Parables that the secrets of the
  103. kingdom of God are spoken of in Parables so that those who have ears to hear can
  104. hear them those who can understand them can understand them and to everyone else
  105. it's maintained a secret and I think that's a very interesting and unique way of communicating your thoughts in a way
  106. that only your intended audience can understand well one of one we in in our teaching uh here about persuasion and so
  107. on uh probably the most profound skill is coming up with the right metaphor uh and the metaphor always has to connect
  108. to the specific audience so I think what you're saying was he knew his audience and he had metaphors they could relate
  109. to exactly and it's interesting because if you took let's say you know some herodian Elite uh and some uh farmer and
  110. said to both of them the kingdom of God is like a mustard seed the farmer understands what that means this tiny
  111. insignificant seed that then becomes the biggest of bushes the herodian elite would have no idea what you're referring
  112. to what's a mustard seed some small thing on a dining room table Yeah so that oh so then you mean it's irrelevant
  113. is what you mean interesting uh there was your a lot of your book is taken up with the succession problem that follow
  114. Jesus's death and uh that's a huge issue in business when a Founder uh gives the
  115. Reigns or dies or moves on uh there's usually rivalries in who's going to run the company or how how how what
  116. direction it'll take I was wondering if you could uh tell us a little bit about whether uh Jesus's succession planning
  117. worked out the way he planned well so what we do know is that the the person who ended up leading the community that
  118. Jesus left behind after his death was his brother James James was a very significant man in in the first century
  119. um he was called the bishop of Bishops and he he led what was known as the Jerusalem assembly or church they didn't
  120. have the word church back then but the the the Jerusalem Church which was then in charge of all the other churches that
  121. pop up everywhere James had a very uh limited conception of what this movement was about Jesus was a Jew James was a
  122. Jew this was a Jewish movement it was for Jews uh certainly non-jews could join this movement if they'd like but
  123. first they had to become Jews they had to follow all the Jewish dietary restrictions the Jewish laws after a few
  124. years James decided to forego the circumcision uh requirement which was marketing wise probably a good idea but
  125. nevertheless as far as he was concerned this was a Jewish movement for Jews and that you had to become a Jew to join it
  126. the sort of rival to James was Paul Paul this former Pharisee who never knew J Jesus while he was alive but who has
  127. this ecstatic experience uh of the Risen Jesus and decides that he's going to actually transform this movement for
  128. non-jews he's going to preach it to Gentiles and if he's going to do that particularly if he's going to preach it
  129. to Rome he has to get rid of these Jewish requirements so as far as J uh Paul is concerned forget about the law
  130. of Moses forget about circumcision forget about the dietary requirements forget about the even notion of having
  131. to become a Jew first that Jesus's movement transcends Judaism now here's the interesting thing during the
  132. lifetime of both men uh Paul dies around 66 ad James dies at 62 ad during the lifetime of these two men James is
  133. descendant after all you don't argue with the brother the Flesh and Blood brother of Jesus he wins any argument
  134. that you have James is going to win but after the death of both men and certainly after 70 the destruction of
  135. Jerusalem it's Paul's idea of Christianity that suddenly becomes ascendant as Christianity becomes less
  136. and less a Jewish religion and more a a Roman religion this notion of a universalism that a a Christianity
  137. that's divorced from its parent religion becomes enormously popular and successful and James's version of
  138. Christianity a Jewish religion for Jews continues to exist but just begins to slowly die away so it's an interesting
  139. notion that the successor of Jesus James who thinks that he is following Jesus's
  140. Vision uh becomes the failed version of Christianity and the version of Christianity that divorces itself from
  141. Jesus's teachings and creates something new appealing open to everyone becomes the largest religion in the world so um
  142. I find it ironic if Jesus was a sort of failed revolutionary that his kingdom actually ended up overtaking Rome right
  143. uh and one wonders depending on what you how you characterize Jesus whether he might not have had uh a bit of an
  144. insight into how this would all work out I think that that's certainly what Christians would say is that the failure
  145. of the Cross was actually a victory and but again you're going to have to thank Paul for that and not so much Jesus well
  146. Jesus appeared to Paul you're right right the Risen Jesus appeared to Paul and Paul says that he's getting all this
  147. information from the Risen Jesus so that that's a good point I mean that's where
  148. I guess A Book Like Yours uh goes straight to the border of faith and then it becomes you know pretty hard to you
  149. know have a discussion around facts here's the dividing line and I and I'm glad that you brought this up is it
  150. possible that Jesus had this conception of himself utterly unique than what any other Jew understood when it came to the
  151. the role of the Messiah is it possible that he thought to himself that this Celestial Kingdom will overcome the
  152. Roman Empire and that no action on Earth would do that yes it's possible is it likely no it's not likely and that's the
  153. dividing line between the historian and the person of Faith the person of faith is interested in what is possible the
  154. historian is interested in what is likely I guess the uh the the fact that this Faith uh worked out so well uh in
  155. terms of an institution uh suggests that that wasn't likely either so I think that's a good point so two two quick
  156. points to to wrap it up for us um first of all you've been on this book tour you've written a controversial book uh
  157. that sort of looks at at something that's very hard to see the historical Jesus uh what are some of the surprises
  158. that you've met on the road as you've exposed this message to different audiences well it's interesting I I you
  159. know I get I've gotten an overwhelmingly positive response particularly from Christians I think a lot of Christians
  160. uh who email me I get dozens of these emails a a week uh telling me that although they actually believe that this
  161. person that I'm describing is also God they so rarely get an opportunity to if you will suspend that this that belief
  162. and instead look at Jesus as just a man it's very hard to do that you know if you think that Jesus is fully God and
  163. fully man no matter how hard you try the man part gets subsumed by the god part um and this is an opportunity for them
  164. to have that experience at the same time I get just as many emails from atheists
  165. who say that finally this is the Jesus that they've been looking for that the other Jesus
  166. The Godly Jesus they know is just a bunch of bunk but in reality this is the Jesus that they want so for me as a
  167. writer and as a thinker it's been incredibly satisfying to see Christians and atheists come to this book and both
  168. enjoy it for their own sort of preconceived reasons right you've had this issue that arose as well having to
  169. do with um your own uh background and your own family uh tell us a little bit about how that uh has worked out well so
  170. you know I've I've as I've me mentioned before I'm a Muslim that I I uh that my faith background is Islam uh that my
  171. scholarship of course is something entirely different and you know it might be difficult for a lot of people to
  172. understand that religion is an academic discipline that we are all you know coming at it from as much as an academic
  173. and objective and scarly Route as we possibly can despite the fact that many of us have our own background so you
  174. know Jews write about Buddhism and and Christians write about Islam and sometimes Muslims write about uh
  175. Christianity uh in my world that's totally normal but in the popular world and particularly amongst certain media
  176. Outlets that shall remain unnamed uh that's crazy that you can't possibly not have some secret agenda if you're
  177. writing about uh a religion not you know from that religious uh religion's perspective but you know to be honest
  178. that's as much our fault as it is the media's Fault the truth of the matter is and I can say this for Scholars of
  179. almost every discipline including business uh we don't do a very good job sometimes of communicating to a popular
  180. audience we spend so much time locked in these Ivory Towers talking to each other
  181. in our own specialized language that nobody else can understand we talk about these complex theories and ideas as
  182. though they don't they don't have a real world uh uh uh you know uh impact and we
  183. don't spend enough time I think communicating to the popular media to the popular world and by the way when we
  184. do we're often criticized by our own colleagues for doing so so it's a two-way street I mean it's on the one
  185. hand there's a misperception of what Scholars do in the media but we bear some of that burden ourselves yeah well
  186. Jesus encountered his culture and was misunderstood and you've encountered yours uh I'll take that so last last
  187. question uh and this is just a a quirky one but I know a lot of our listeners have read Dan Brown's The Da Vinci Code
  188. right and the premise of that novel and some sequels is that Jesus had a family a wife uh children that there's this
  189. bloodline of Jesus that's uh persisted through the Middle Ages to the present well you've investigated the life of
  190. Jesus more than anyone I know so what do you think well this is actually a very complex question it's sort of one of the
  191. biggest paradoxes about Jesus studies on the one hand it would have been inconceivable for a 30-year-old Jewish
  192. male in the first century not to have a wife and children he may as well be from
  193. Mars I mean it would have been absolutely inconceivable that's not to say that there weren't celibates in
  194. Jesus's time there were but they were monastic orders they separated themselves from society not just from
  195. wives and children and Jesus obviously did not do that um so that's that's the that's the first fact it would have been
  196. downright inconceivable here's the other fact in every piece of writing ever written
  197. about Jesus by his friends and his enemies by his detractors and his worshippers everything written by
  198. Christians by Jews by pagans by apologists everything ever written about about Jesus there is never a mention of
  199. wife and kids and that is difficult to overcome uh now is it possible that we'll come up with something one day
  200. that a piece of Papyrus will suddenly show up as as perhaps my colleague Karen King may have found which we're still
  201. waiting to find out whether that's authentic or not and there's some question about whether it is or not will
  202. some gospel all of a sudden show up uh one day that that shows that Jesus was married maybe but those are the
  203. irreconcilable facts it would have been impossible to think of him as not married and yet no evidence no evidence
  204. all right great uh Raza aen author of zealot The Life and Times of Jesus of Nazareth thank you very much thank you
  205. for having me all

Brief Summary

Reza Aslan discusses his book on the historical Jesus, examining his revolutionary role and leadership qualities in the context of early Christianity.

Key points

  • The Revolutionary Jesus. Exploring the historical Jesus as a Jewish nationalist revolutionary, challenging traditional images.
  • Leadership Lessons from Jesus. Analyzing Jesus's leadership style and its implications for modern business leaders.
  • The Irony of Jesus's Legacy. Discussing how the movement Jesus started transformed into a major world religion posthumously.
  • The Da Vinci Code and Jesus. Exploring the claims of Jesus having a family in popular literature.
  • The Paradox of Jesus' Life. A complex discussion on the societal expectations of Jesus' marital status.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes