Banking with a Public Benefit -- Kat Taylor

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Kat Taylor, co-CEO, Beneficial State Bank, discusses how the triple bottom line company enhances economic sustainability in low-income communities. πŸ“‚ ESG;Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hi i'm catherine klein i'm vice dean for social impact at Wharton and I'm delighted to speak today with Kat Taylor
  2. who is the co-founder and CEO of beneficial State Bank beneficial State Bank is a triple bottom-line business
  3. focused on enhancing the prosperity economic sustainability and environmental sustainability of
  4. low-income communities so Kat thanks so much for being with us thank you this is
  5. a tremendous opportunity for us thank you I'm delighted to speak with you so let's start with a bank so why a bank so
  6. others with your level of professional achievement your level of financial achievements with success would and your
  7. passion for social justice for environmental change I think would say alright let's start a charitable
  8. foundation you said let's start a bank yeah I think yeah so often people don't even want to talk about banking because
  9. it's boring and complex and has some negative affiliations but banks nonetheless are extremely important in
  10. the way not only the economy works but in in what we drive in terms of societal outcomes the way we think about banking
  11. is that it is in a way the original and most powerful form of crowdfunding not that a specific deposit funds a specific
  12. loan but all deposits fund a lending practice and they do it with enormous prerogatives granted by us the public
  13. starting with FDIC insurance that allows banks to gather deposits at very low cost because they're insured risk free
  14. up to one hundred two hundred fifty thousand dollars also we're a leveraged business model banks enjoy leverage of
  15. at least ten to one so we have sort of exponential impact we recycle the capital it goes out and loans and comes
  16. back to us in large part so we can loan it again so the impact is accumulates over time and it's an extremely
  17. disciplined business model we have 13 exams a year and three separate regulators so we're constantly
  18. monitoring and understanding what that capital is doing banking is super important and we've underestimated how
  19. much it drives in society and in our view under expected of it we should ask more of our banks they drive
  20. so much important outcomes of importance to us so we did look at other models before starting the Bank venture
  21. philanthropy of traditional private foundation etc but we kept coming back to the Bank model because of its
  22. influence and its centrality to most people in their lives it's probably likely where a lot of people got their
  23. mortgage where they transact their business used to be a pillar of the community in communities it's less that
  24. now but it can be a really important part of the whole ecosystem in which the families and individuals and communities
  25. we care most about live and and for those who are not familiar with beneficial State Bank give us a picture
  26. of this Bank what's different it's not it's not Bank of America yeah you know what what is it what should we how do we
  27. visualize this how do we understand its scope and size sure so we started in 2007 some might have considered that an
  28. inauspicious time to become a bank but actually by the luck of the timing of our birth we made it through the great
  29. recession that landed in 2008 because we hadn't lent much money out yet so we didn't have sick assets because we
  30. honestly didn't have many assets at all other than cash and we got enormous insights looking at that Maelstrom what
  31. caused it what the repercussions were how it amplified over time at this point we've grown to be 800 million in assets
  32. that sounds like a big number to me but it's actually quite tiny in the banking landscape the biggest banks in the world
  33. are now well over 2 trillion in assets that's many many zeros away but actually our size is now getting to be an asset
  34. for us in terms of coverage we have 18 offices 225 employees in the three West Coast state so we're starting to get the
  35. geographic info we desire we're not attempting to be a National Bank in in large part because our model depends on
  36. accountability and that requires responsiveness but we're getting to a scale where we can have influence
  37. on the banking system and we also are getting a product set that more fully answers what people could and should
  38. expect from a bank so we're now a consumer lender as well as a commercial lender offering auto loans and credit
  39. cards but also scaled finance for social enterprise nonprofits etc so the difference in the bank our design
  40. features that we intentionally laid in to make sure that our bank model would be in alignment with the public interest
  41. and the values of our stakeholders first off we define our stakeholders much more
  42. broadly much more like a B corporation like we are they include not only our customers borrowers and trans actors of
  43. course not only our equity shareholders but also our communities the environment
  44. and the public at large so in order to have true alignment with those stakeholders the first thing we change
  45. was the ownership structure of the bank so 100% of the economic rights of beneficial State Bank are held and owned
  46. by beneficial State Foundation which is a public charity public charities are governed permanently in the public
  47. interest they can never be controlled by a private individual and the bylaws of that foundation require it when it
  48. receives profit from the bank through the dividend process to reinvest those profits back into the communities that
  49. we serve which are primarily low income and the environment upon which we all depend the second design feature has to
  50. do with that lending practice if we are crowdfunding on behalf of our stakeholders then we should crack that
  51. we should lend with respect to their values so preponderantly we put our loan capital meaning we count the loan
  52. dollars and at least 75% should be in the hands of change makers who are either providing something we
  53. desperately need like affordable housing renewable energy sustainable food or their unique ownership structures like
  54. ours as well B corporations worker cooperatives or they're simply communities and actors who've been
  55. deprived of capital in the past and have a very valid point of view to bring into
  56. the main econo so that would be small business at large women and minority-owned businesses
  57. low-income communities nonprofits etc that's design feature number two design feature number three is radical
  58. transparency so we not only report out on what our loans are doing who's holding them and that warrant that they
  59. aren't undermining our triple bottom line that you described but we're also taking affirmative commitments about how
  60. we act as a corporation we are B Corporation v is in the satellite the community we are also a community
  61. development financial institution which is a Treasury designation that's hard to
  62. get hard to keep we have a living wage policy we pay a hundred and fifty percent of living wage and all markets
  63. fully benefited we don't finance fossil fuels we measure our greenhouse gas and water landfill footprint drive it down
  64. every year put on an FTE basis we design the small business bill of rights etc etc you can see right what we're trying
  65. to do is hold ourselves accountable to third party auditable standards so that we act and fly right yeah and the
  66. purpose of that is double because our mission is to change the banking system for good and we're not going to do that
  67. as one bank we're going to do that and a theory of change it involves migrating over time deposit equity and human
  68. capital into these kinds of warranties into banks that act like us they will always be bigger than us but they can
  69. act like us and they might choose to as their growth strategy where the big banks can't change very readily the
  70. mid-size banks need always new strategies for growth and we think we're giving them sort of a playbook on that
  71. fascinating so a couple of questions and points to underscore one is are your are
  72. your branches based only in low-income communities how do you think about you know where they're located and where
  73. you'd want to expand sure well the whole branch model is somewhat up to inquiry at the moment because of the arrival of
  74. technology to banking like every other industry we feel like we still need to have a physical presence and we're
  75. possible we choose for that to be in in communities so preponderance of our branches are in low-income markets some
  76. exceptions just by inaccurate anachronistic choices of the past we've bought for banks and so sometimes we
  77. inherited their branch decision but for instance the two banks that we just merged with in June gave us seven new
  78. branches five in the Central Valley of California very important area for us for us to serve one in East LA one in
  79. North Hollywood and they are very much aligned with low-income community service the whole question of branch
  80. banking is one of not only what are the what's the user experience that people are looking for it's also a chance for
  81. us to improve the ecological footprint of banking I sometimes think it would be nice if we converted all those corner
  82. bank branches of old that are not so necessary anymore into low-income housing the re-insert needed
  83. affordability into the urban core but that might be a pipe dream at this point at this point at this point I wouldn't
  84. put it past you so you've been in business nearly 10 years what do you think the is even reflect back on those
  85. 10 years what important lessons learned I mean when you launched this Bank with these bold ambitions and now you've
  86. you're here and alive and well 10 years later key lessons key points of a transition so I think in the beginning
  87. we had to begin and we had to experience what it was like to be a bank what the opportunities and challenges are in the
  88. banking landscape and understand them deeply and and I think we've probably thought we were going to change the
  89. banking system in an incremental fashion by just becoming kind of a bank that better serves the public interest I
  90. think now we've grown to realize that we need to redefine the category writ large
  91. that we should expect more from our banks we should understand the enormous public prerogatives publicly derived
  92. prerogatives that they have and how impactful they are on societal comes and make the banking system work
  93. for us there's 12 trillion dollars of deposits in the American economy alone those belong to us so if we make choices
  94. and align with our own values we might get better outcomes out of the banking system and at this point we really need
  95. to because it overwhelms a lot of other industries ability to address those large societal problems and it we dacent
  96. have it driving them the problems that is so if you look at philanthropic capital for instance I was told recently
  97. that all the philanthropic capital in the United States put together would fund about 15 months of the public
  98. school budget Wow yeah so if we can get business models fundamentally right in the first place especially banking so
  99. that they don't cause a lot of negative externalities or problems for us then we
  100. don't have to spend so much time and resource cleaning things up that's the main insight I think I mean there are
  101. many we've made our share of missteps along the way acquisition and integration is tricky culture is
  102. massively important a lot of young companies ignore culture until they have an accidental one these are things the
  103. blocking and tackling of every single day that we have to keep working on and we still need to grow half of
  104. Californians lives south of Ventura Boulevard and we're not really present there so we have more wood to chop yeah
  105. yeah and so you have this larger mission of not only serving your customers and communities but transforming the banking
  106. system this huge vision how do you get there yeah so we were just revisiting some proof points that were derived from
  107. a rebranding process we went through to become beneficial State Bank you can imagine on the way buying for banks and
  108. growing the initial one and moving into three state markets we had to change our
  109. name a fair bit along the way but beneficial State is a name that's meant to suggest the beneficial State we
  110. should all be in as a result of our banking system being an alignment with our values so the proof points that we
  111. call out and use to identify if we're getting closer to changing the banking system for good
  112. our number one making sure that we're deploying capital for its highest purpose which means actually helping our
  113. borrowers attain their highest purpose make sure that for instance B corporations who have a very explicit
  114. high purpose instilled in their very DNA we need to help them be successful and grow that community so first basically
  115. power to the highest purpose second is to make sure that the banking system is generating healthy transactional
  116. services for people banking services that actually make them better off the day after them they were the day before
  117. not payday loan debt that is a debt trap not the overextension of products that no one wants or needs but banking
  118. services that literally allow someone to be healthy in their life the third is and it's based on our
  119. profit taking model is it reinforces this but we need the banking system to actually reinforce the communities that
  120. they serve and the earth upon which we all depend so the fact that we are putting profit back into those
  121. communities and the planet is an important proof point for us I will say we have not issued a dividend because
  122. young banks especially who are still acquiring are encouraged by the regulator's to retain all earnings for
  123. growth but the bank the strongest lever we have to achieve healthy communities and a healthy planet is the bank it's
  124. really the lending practice that does it so we would always preference lending over grant making nevertheless we did
  125. capitalize the beneficial State Foundation so that it can grant into our communities about five to ten percent of
  126. the equivalent of our profit every year which is much higher than other banks the last is that we need to be true
  127. advocates we need to be a voice for change it isn't enough to quietly labor on our own we have to join trade
  128. associations like the Global Alliance for banking on values and the community Developers Association to advocate with
  129. our regulators and stakeholders and the public for a better banking system and the best way we can do that is first and
  130. foremost to show that Bank aligned with those values that's resilient ly profitable is a viable
  131. alternative to some of the other models in the system but we also speak with as louder voices we possibly can
  132. yeah all right so so part of it is being a role model doing your business well being a role model and sharing the story
  133. and getting out an alternative model of banking I want to go to the your B certification as a as a certified B
  134. Corporation so as you know well know companies that are be certified go through this elaborate vetting process
  135. and assessment around a set of practices the B lab assessment measures your environmental practices your practices
  136. for your workers your customers your community and your governance and and as you said I think what you said you're
  137. the fifth highest scoring but so a quite an accomplishment I'd love to to hear more about your
  138. practices specifically with regard to workers so some years ago as you know I studied a lot of attention pointing out
  139. that nearly a third of all bank tellers in the United States qualified for and receive some form of public assistance
  140. so people working in the banks on food stamps on on Medicaid and so on how do you pay your your workers how do you try
  141. to not be those banks right so we call that part of the train of misery actually that one-third of bank tellers
  142. and it shocks people because the banks are among the most profitable corporations in the world so why they
  143. would not pay their workers enough to avoid needing public assistance is a quandary in our case we proactively make
  144. a an affirmative commitment to them that we will pay a hundred and fifty percent
  145. of living wage in all markets fully benefited so we don't tolerate piecemeal part-time work that disqualifies people
  146. from benefits we use the MIT living wage calculator to make sure that we have a credible source of what that living wage
  147. should be in our markets we 150 percent is what is suggested for an one adult and one
  148. dependent so we're trying to make sure that the wage contributes to the household income adequately we'd love to
  149. increase that amount and we will strive to overtime but it represents to us the minimum that we would ever pay anyone
  150. and it's always above $15 an hour we also adjust for other salaried and wage earners to make sure there's
  151. rationale across the whole group of people um we're big advocates for fight for fifteen national standard minimum
  152. wage no exemptions but we do also worry a lot about other non salary non-wage conditions and benefits for our
  153. employees so we try to make sure that starting with our culture that we're creating a
  154. culture that's healthy and respectful for our fellow colleagues we have a run a lot of employee driven committees on
  155. wellness on the green team etc we recruit them to design their own sort of work life if you will we work with a
  156. benefits provider that's fashion forward and thinking about new things we can do
  157. we also are just labeled so that's a food style label that it tends to pick as 22 areas of social justice practice
  158. in a corporate setting is looking at procurement policies labor practices ethnic and gender diversity we choose
  159. diversity if you don't choose diverse you don't get it so if you wait for it to happen you will be subject to legacy
  160. dynamics in our view so we affirmative ly go out and choose diversity everywhere we can try to keep very high
  161. proportions of diversity throughout the organization and work with other vendor partners like labor X is a platform we
  162. go to often to seek non-traditional workers so that we have a better pipeline and I'm curious how others respond to
  163. your practices others in other banking institutions and the you know you're paying 150 percent of a living wage do
  164. they look at that and say well that's all very nice your small bank you have a social mission you know good for you we
  165. couldn't possibly yeah and what's the response if that's happening what's your response so being a small bank should
  166. actually make it harder for us to pay that because we don't have the same scale economies that the big banks do we
  167. don't have the bargaining power we don't have that concentration of power so it's
  168. a somewhat of a shamira to say we're too big to pay our employees fairly likely it's more capital market pressure we we
  169. also need to be profitable that is part of our business model and it is certainly a regulatory requirement we
  170. target a six to ten percent return on equity in a very stable way we feel that's enough to fuel our growth and be
  171. resilient but not so much that we're overcharging or underpaying somewhere because in our experience high returns
  172. from overcharging and under paying are not only not part of our mission but they're not sustainable over time and
  173. they set off other second-order effects and you see them yes I mean if people aren't making enough in their basic wage
  174. then you're gonna have a very strong sales culture if that's the only other place they can pick up some income right
  175. interesting so um you lead a triple bottom-line business as we've been discussing in what ways is leaving a
  176. triple bottom-line business more difficult and then leading a business that has a more singular focus and there
  177. are there ways in which is less difficult than building a business with a singular focus on profit yeah I am
  178. sort of a half glass fold gal but they so I think it's actually easier it is more complex because it's an
  179. optimization model not a maximization model but I don't have a categorical mind I really it's very hard for me to
  180. focus because everything is related to me so I an optimization model and I think it's
  181. more reflective of reality that in a sense if you put a maximization model into the world you're solving for one
  182. outcome that that isn't actually truly sustainable in the world that we know the I think it's it's interesting
  183. diversity and optimization are both perceived to be harder to manage more complex but they lead to better decision
  184. aim I think the studies are starting to show this that and can you give an example of what that might mean in
  185. practice optimization and diversity and how it might influence your decision-making mmm-hmm so diversity and
  186. decision making I think means that you are inviting if not recruiting more points of view into the decisioning
  187. process you will in a sense have less common ground at the outset but you will have a richer consideration of all the
  188. real factors that are influencing the best decision to make optimization I think is harder it's a harder process to
  189. manage because you can't sort of take a linear approach I'm not explaining as well but I think there's just more
  190. things going on at once that you have to keep track of and think of what the interdependencies are so you're really
  191. trying to balance multiple goals or pursue multiple goals and find the way that those are synergistic yes and
  192. mutually interdependent but I think what we've done for a couple hundred years now is insist on a maximization model
  193. that isn't eliminating those second-order and Inter dependency effects it's just ignoring them so we're
  194. opening the aperture of the camera lens and looking at everything that's going on I keep a list called these things
  195. also happened because just because you aren't noticing them doesn't mean they aren't happening yeah yeah so a final
  196. question then about you as a as a leader so in this space and what your bank is trying to do given that it's a triple
  197. bottom-line business you are managing lots of different goals as we've described connecting with lots of
  198. different constituencies what do you think makes you particularly successful in doing that so that if somebody else
  199. is aspiring to this and thinking I don't know and do that are there you know is there
  200. is there something that allows you to achieve this so it begins with it's not me it's us and it is a so we believe
  201. that we do better together than apart that's sort of a basic philosophy of the bank and that means we also would we
  202. manage better when we listen to all the voices and when people have agency and accountability and authority so we're
  203. trying to delegate out decisioning not in a disorganized way but we're trying to get more heads into the process I
  204. often say let's put more in different people in charge let's get those new points of view let's
  205. get the diversity let's get that optimization minds in there and let's get as many as we can if if I think
  206. about the world when we you know we sort of been mown seven billion people because it seems like such a challenge
  207. but that's seven billion hidden geniuses and if we could find a way in an organized way to harness all that mental
  208. energy and imagination and vision I think we'd actually make better choices and come up with better institutions and
  209. so that's what we're trying to do on a mini scale and that means a lot of emphasis on succession not that
  210. succession like if someone gets hit by a bus who's gonna take over them but we're
  211. really trying to focus on how do we help people develop their skills and opportunity set the the highest that
  212. they could possibly be so they can take a large leading role in the organization
  213. great fabulous thank you so much for being with us thank you very much for having us here and delving into banking
  214. thank you you

Brief Summary

Kat Taylor discusses Beneficial State Bank's mission to transform banking for low-income communities through social justice and environmental sustainability.

Key points

  • The Power of Banking. Kat Taylor discusses how banks serve as crowdfunding mechanisms for societal change.
  • Redefining Banking. Kat Taylor shares insights on the need to redefine the banking system for good.
  • Expect More from Banks. Kat Taylor emphasizes the need for higher expectations from banking institutions.
  • Commitment to Fair Wages. Kat Taylor explains the bank's commitment to paying employees a living wage.
  • The Power of Collaboration. A philosophy of teamwork leads to better decision-making and outcomes.
  • Harnessing Hidden Genius. The potential of seven billion people can lead to better choices and institutions.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes