Crowdfunding Commercial Real Estate β€” the New Disruptor?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Crowdfunding is proving capable of taking on commercial real estate deals under $10 million. Is it just a matter of time before it moves up the ladder and disrupts the whole industry? More: http://knlg.net/1IBWwbP πŸ“‚ Finance & Accounting;Real Estate

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're joined today by dan miller and he is the co-founder and president of a company called
  2. fundrise which is a crowdsourcing company in the real estate sector and this is a fairly new idea
  3. and why don't you tell us about it how it works and how you got involved sure so my brother
  4. and i launched fundraise in 2010 we're the first crowdfunding platform in the u.s
  5. initially we built the platform to fund our own real estate transactions so we were
  6. buying and developing properties in washington dc created the platform to let anybody invest with us in the single
  7. deal for as little as 100 bucks this is the first crowdfunded transaction and now we fund other real
  8. estate companies so scaled from doing our own projects to now projects all over the country
  9. so when people hear that number 100 they're probably thinking a very small scale but it's not necessarily a small
  10. scale so why don't you tell us what what size the projects are and is it residential
  11. is it commercial sure it's mostly commercial projects in urban areas about under 30 million so a little below
  12. institutional scale we're normally providing about two to five million bucks per deal
  13. three years ago that was three hundred thousand last year it was a couple hundred you know six seven hundred
  14. thousand so it's growing very quickly and really what crowdfunding allows people to do is
  15. distribute investments online take a lot of very small investors pool those together into a larger check so
  16. just because they're small minimums doesn't mean the sum doesn't add up to a large amount so you have
  17. people you you put a project on your website and you say we want to buy and develop this building
  18. would you like to invest and you can invest any amount you want i i guess the minimum sounds like it might be 100
  19. but you get investors up to a million i understand yeah is there an average or a
  20. mean that makes sense for people to understand about 10 000 10 000 is a good number people think of of
  21. of what the kind of average investment is and so we source deals we underwrite deals you have offices around the
  22. country so that process is like traditional real estate sourcing underwriting you
  23. have people work the markets they meet real estate developers they discuss our platform and then we put the
  24. deals together the innovative part is putting it on the site and allowing anybody to be part of
  25. the investment and the investor what is it that they get out of it what kind of return
  26. why would they want to do that than maybe some other kind of deal what's the advantage to them well that that the
  27. real value is in that you have technology cutting out middlemen that were direct between investor and real
  28. estate companies as opposed to having private equity funds or other groups in the middle
  29. and so that way you're able to have double digit returns for investors which is still the cheaper cost of
  30. capital for real estate companies so generally we're doing preferred equity investments so
  31. junior to bank debt in the deal but senior to equity in the deal so it's a kind of high term or high
  32. fixed deal relatively short term during the transition or development of the real estate asset
  33. so if someone didn't know your company how would they know that their money was secured that this was a good idea
  34. or it may be a good idea or or maybe not a good idea they really watch and see so that's what
  35. we've seen on consumer behavior people sign up for the site they rarely invest in the first 120 days
  36. they sign on regularly they look at deals they check them out they see that they're raising the funds that they're
  37. closed and then they invest 5 000 and then they start getting distributions on that deal
  38. and then they might invest 10 and 25. so we've really seen that type of consumer behavior happen which i think
  39. is similar what e-commerce was you know the first time you bought something online
  40. you weren't sure if it was safe to put your credit card in you didn't know when the box was going to arrive
  41. and now it's instantaneous you know same-day delivery i think similar consumer behavior patterns
  42. because you're serving them a product they've really never invested in before through a mechanism online that they
  43. haven't done for that many different types of investments so interestingly you're you have a niche
  44. here when it comes to the size of projects you're not you're not um investing in or
  45. developing 200 million dollar office towers you're investing in in a certain size
  46. project which um those with with large amounts to invest tend to not be interested in so much could you
  47. explain how that that's really where we begin so with institutional investors they'll rarely
  48. write a check of less than 10 million of equity and that's not because the deal doesn't
  49. make sense if it's smaller it's because they have a multi-billion dollar fund they can put it out in so many
  50. increments if they have a lot of one million dollar investments they won't be able to manage it
  51. and so it creates this artificial barrier where the small medium enterprise the mid-size real estate operator who's
  52. established who has a real track record if they bring a deal that's 15 to 20 million dollars of value
  53. it's very hard for them to get that finance so we plug what technology tends to be efficient at
  54. is the kind of mid-market space for the the real estate operators and provide them capital to deals that
  55. are often ignored by institutional investors what kinds of projects have you completed so far we've done
  56. projects in 15 different markets the highest profile was we raised five million dollars for three world trade
  57. center we sold five million dollars of the senior bond the senior construction loan
  58. on that deal we've done about half of our business between dc and new york and just
  59. launched offices in la and san francisco most of our deals like i said between five to 25 million dollars in deal size
  60. again we're funding another real estate company they come to us we're funding a portion of that deal
  61. and most of them are urban areas in transition so buying a apartment building upgrading the units
  62. then selling and refinancing lots of different types of projects but always in some development or transition
  63. so in addition to finding investors through the use of technology which wasn't so easy to do before
  64. the technology allowed for it and finding people who wouldn't have been able to invest this way before you're also you
  65. mentioned earlier cutting out the middleman so that means you're saying that you're cutting costs
  66. quite a bit could you explain how that whole cost cutting exercise works how much of
  67. the cost do you cut out i assume that's a big part of the business model and uh what what
  68. how how what percentage of the cost you cut out and how does that translate into how these deals work right and and
  69. that's really the real value that we're able to deliver cheaper capital the real
  70. estate operator and and better investments to the real estate investors ultimately if
  71. that's not the value proposition then there is no business here and our comparisons off into a private
  72. equity fund we charge half a percent per year to the investor to asset management and service
  73. the investments private equity fund normally charges two percent a year management fee and 20 percent of the
  74. upside over a preferred return so we kind of use a mock sample deal three year investment
  75. 12 year 12-year i mean 12 percent annual return we charge one and a half percent over
  76. those three years a typical private equity fund will charge 8.4 over those three years so it's
  77. really a huge spread that then gets split between the real estate company and the
  78. investor so we hear a lot about disruptive technologies and you're just talking about disrupting private equity
  79. in the real estate space do you think that that's um that's a scalable model that's at least
  80. in the uh at the level of project that you're talking about which is under 30 million
  81. roughly although i guess that could change it's going to change i mean i think what
  82. you've seen in other businesses when you look at digital media blogs twitter facebook they started out relatively
  83. small and then it became large and institutional so i think where where is the most efficient
  84. place to start is is the ignored portion of the market that institutions have difficulty
  85. serving because of their scale but i think it really will shift it's about creating efficiency for private
  86. commercial real estate transactions it's very inefficient market it's a huge market
  87. but you have a deal you make some phone calls you try to raise some funding there's not an efficient way to put the
  88. deal to have it distributed for people to look at it to make investments to have a platform like ours standardize
  89. it so i think it's going to bring efficiency to all parts of the market it's just going to take
  90. time to go to different sectors so it's a little bit like an airbnb or an uber where
  91. you're you're the the i guess the conduit that's connecting the the uh the person with the need uh
  92. with the person who can fulfill that need and that's uh creating less overhead and that sort of thing is that
  93. the idea right it the business model is called marketplace lending at this point lending club's the best known ones
  94. so you have borrowers you have investors you connect the two you also use your own capital to
  95. guarantee the funding so that you match you make the two stick together and by by creating that standardization
  96. you have efficiency on both sides so what we've seen is with the decentralized model it can operate much
  97. more efficiently at much cheaper costs it doesn't have all the centralized infrastructure that
  98. bank branches have with big offices and corporate overhead and so i think as you see crowdfunding
  99. get larger and the sums of capital be bigger i think you're really going to see a
  100. challenging challenge existing banking infrastructure that is very centralized with a lot of overhead and additional
  101. costs but it's not just bank infrastructure it's not just bank buildings and right and that sort of
  102. thing but it's also the cost of actually going out and finding investors which is
  103. i i guess labor intensive and it involves a lot of meetings and lunches and hand-holding and
  104. you're basically saying that's not necessary anymore at least in projects of this size at least for now
  105. yes we think of ourselves like an outsourced capital markets division for a lot of these firms
  106. mid-sized real estate operators they don't have a full-time person on a capital markets desk
  107. and we're arranging financing we're giving them a sense of what the quotes for different capital is going to be
  108. we're giving them connection to the investors but we're handling the investor relations the distributions
  109. the tax documents so it's very much centralizing that role letting the real estate developer focus
  110. on their jobs sourcing deals developing deals and us managing the entire capital
  111. raising infrastructure so compared to how it used to be done and what it used to cost to do that
  112. how does your cost structure compare in other words how much are you cutting out
  113. right right when you say you're cutting out the middle man what percentage of fees and costs are you cutting
  114. so generally somebody who syndicates equity will charge three to five percent uh minimum potentially higher for them
  115. to corral and raise the capital private equity funds will charge two to twenty so you have on the investor side
  116. at least a five to ten percent fee that the investor indirectly pays or directly
  117. private reits are another market that's similar for private real estate transactions that's a 15
  118. up front fee when you enter the investment so you're talking about pretty huge fees that that we think technology
  119. is going under versus your fee would be what half a percent per year and then we
  120. charge the borrower one and a half percent at closing um so it's it's for the borrower it's cheaper capital
  121. for the investors it's more access to investments and also opens up a new part of the market traditionally
  122. with uh you know with a real estate syndication you're limiting it to people investing 100
  123. 000 or more and so you're talking about a huge unmet part of the market that hasn't been able
  124. to invest in single real estate transactions there's something else about this also
  125. about the the kinds of projects that you do where the people that invest oftentimes will have some connection to
  126. it maybe it's in their neighborhood or maybe they know somebody that's involved in in
  127. that building somehow and so they it feels more real to them somehow that's that's where we began i
  128. mean we were developing urban info projects with leasing to chefs and restaurateurs that
  129. people knew locally converting old historic buildings that people were very excited about
  130. and we always had people come and talk to us about you know what are you doing why what are these projects looking like
  131. and how are they coming out we thought why don't we go out to those investors let them invest in it they might own a
  132. home in the neighborhood they have already understood the real estate they have a lot of other data around it
  133. that makes them excited to invest that might not be purely financial but doesn't mean it's wrong and so we just
  134. did our first project in detroit we're going to raise capital for the old tiger stadium redevelopment
  135. and in the same way it's old baseball stadium everyone in detroit's been to it they want to be part of revitalizing
  136. that area and bringing it back and so i think you're seeing what we're able to do is because you're selling
  137. these investments to retail investors they're buying you know they're buying a product that has more texture
  138. as opposed to just a 16 ir there's other components that they're able to evaluate
  139. so how big of a project is that and what percentage of that amount do you think you'll be able to help that project's
  140. about 30 million um and it's gonna be at 20 equity will raise between a half a million to a
  141. million um and we now fund with our own balance sheets so we guarantee the funds at
  142. closing with our own cash and then put it up on the site so it really for the real estate company
  143. they're not taking the risk of raising the money online that's been one of the big things that shifted that
  144. we centralize the asset management we centralize the investor reporting and we make sure that the funds are
  145. there at the appropriate time so this is the part of commercial real estate development
  146. that's going to be changing big time in your estimation what parts will remain the same there's
  147. obviously a people element to some of this and so yeah deal sourcing we've seen most of our
  148. deals come offline for with our kind of regional offices people being in market knowing the neighborhoods meeting
  149. the developers in person done very few deals where we haven't met the developer or where they originated
  150. online so we're finding that putting the deals together is a very offline process
  151. we're finding underwriting due diligence there's certain information needs to be
  152. collected it has to be ordered from these third-party groups appraisals environmental surveys
  153. and somebody has to centrally underwrite it two functions that we're looking at there to
  154. to you know use the people more efficiently is kind of crowdsourcing that aspect where
  155. if a broker somebody brings us a deal they can upload it and share fees with us or maybe you start to have experts in
  156. certain markets who underwrite the deal and into the crowd kind of become a credible
  157. third party group but right now it's us handling all those aspects so i would say the sourcing underwriting
  158. and closing is very old school it's the distributing the investment the marketing of it online the investor
  159. reporting that's where we've done it had a fundamental shift thanks very much for joining us thank
  160. you so much you

Brief Summary

Dan Miller discusses Fundrise's crowdfunding model for real estate investments and its impact on the market.

Key points

  • Fundrise: A Crowdfunding Pioneer. Dan Miller shares how Fundrise became the first crowdfunding platform in the U.S. for real estate.
  • Investing Made Accessible. Dan explains how crowdfunding allows small investors to pool resources for larger projects.
  • Transforming Real Estate Investment. Dan discusses the shift in commercial real estate development and investor engagement.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes