What Makes Emerging Technologies Click?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Google+ Email Print Comment Quote

Anyone who has watched the evolution of technology knows that sometimes, clever new technologies emerge and quickly supplant the incumbents, while others may take years or decades to take off โ€” if they gain widespread traction at all. So for investors, consumers and businesses, the key question is: What is the differentiating factor between the fast winners and the slow losers? More: http://knlg.net/1St9p0q ๐Ÿ“‚ Technology ๐Ÿท๏ธ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so the researchers really looking at a puzzle that we observed um in terms of new technologies being introduced into
  2. the market but significant differences in terms of how fast they're able to reach mainstream adoption and disrupt
  3. existing markets existing players so we we observe that in the printer space injet printers came about quickly took
  4. over the dot matrix we look at stdv it took decades for it to be mainstream adoption and then we look at things like
  5. the segue or the Palm uh types of Technologies which either created some value or never really reached mainstream
  6. adoption so so the question was really what explains that why some technologies are introduced and immediately supplant
  7. existing Technologies whereas others take decades or sometimes don't really reach mainstream adoption and so what we
  8. did was we we we tried to find a context where um we could observe enough variation in terms of how quick or slow
  9. these technology adoption patterns were but helped us to control for a lot of confounding effects as well and so the
  10. idea was to find a natural experiment so to speak and uh that helps us to ensure
  11. that the source of variation is not driven by some systematic effects which may make inferences more problematic so
  12. what we did was we we came across you know I had some experience in the semiconductor industry we came across
  13. the semiconductor lithography technology as as a setting that we could study this
  14. question um what is interesting about this setting is this is kind of the engine behind more slow or any progress
  15. in semiconductors over the last 40 years has been fueled by lithography technology so it's it's important we
  16. know it's fast-paced and and we thought that this is where we may want to study this question and so the research design
  17. looked at the semicon lithography and 10 different new technologies that were introduced in that industry over a
  18. 40-year period um you know we interviewed about 30 industry experts to try to get a sense for what's driving
  19. these patterns we collected data on Technologies markets uh Industries um in terms of really trying
  20. to understand the factors that may be explaining this difference and uh what we found was was interesting you know a
  21. lot of the research and practice focuses on on on new technologies and how it interacts with the markets and look at
  22. is the technology better than what's available now or it's not and that explains whether it's going to reach
  23. mainstream adoption what we found was that's sort of part of the explanation and actually in our case a very small
  24. part of the explanation we found that the bigger explanation was not focusing on the new technology and the market but
  25. looking at the technology ecosystem which is to means that how is the technology created what are the
  26. different elements that make up the technology so think about batteries making electric cars but also how is the
  27. technology used by the users in terms of other elements or complimentary Technologies and services think about
  28. electric car and charging stations and garages who can fix that electric cars and and not only that uh that you need
  29. to look at the technology ecosystem for both the new technology and the old technology
  30. so what we set out is you know we want to explain this variance what we see from our our our
  31. fieldwork and our interviews that by looking at the technology itself the resolution in terms of fast versus slow
  32. is not going to be very good let's look at the ecosystem and so as as part of the research we collected data that
  33. systematically identifies each technology in terms of its ecosystem and and compared in terms of the existing
  34. technology and what we found was because when we think about the new technology there's sometimes what we call an
  35. ecosystem emergence challenge which means the technology is ready but the ecosystem still needs some Investments
  36. like the charging infrastructure for electric car for it to reach mainstream adoption and we call that ecosystem
  37. emergence challenge but we also see in the old technology sometimes you can extend that technology by improvements
  38. in components or these complimentary elements so think about the gasoline cars you know nobody thought 10 15 years
  39. ago that they will be going at 30 m per gallon or even 40 m per gallon but improvements in engines improvements in
  40. fuels allowed the cars to get to that point you think about the hybrid versus electric car uh sort of discussion where
  41. the hybrid cars introduced were able to grow market share much faster than electric cars and the main difference is
  42. the hybrid cars could plug and play there wasn't an emergence challenge in the ecosystem electric cars had these
  43. emergence challenges by creating the infrastructure by having these charging stations in place so at the end of the
  44. day after doing this research we were able to document fairly clearly that if one were to understand the likelihood
  45. that the new technology is going to come and immediately disrupt the marketplace
  46. versus it may take much longer or may not happen you have to look at the new technology ecosystem in terms of its
  47. emergence Challenge and the old technology ecosystem in terms of the extension opportunity and it's really
  48. The Joint consideration of these two factors that explain whether you will see a fast technology
  49. takeoff or a technology that will never reach mainstream adoption you know the research presents
  50. some very interesting takeaways for managers for uh policy makers for investors into technology companies and
  51. also for users of Technologies whether you're consumers or businesses so if you are a manager of a firm whether it's a
  52. new startup or it's an established firm you always have to think about sort of resources that you have to allocate
  53. towards new technologies and how you transition between an existing to a new technology so think about Kodak shifted
  54. from the chemical based to the digital photography or you think about Netflix moving from a DVD rental business to the
  55. online streaming business and so what we find is you know managers can use this framework to set realistic expectation
  56. in terms of both whether and when to invest in new technologies and it may sometimes actually make sense and they
  57. will generate more shareholder value or destroy less shareholder value uh by focusing on the existing Technologies
  58. than kind of going all out and pushing for the new technology from an Investor's perspective again it sets
  59. realistic expectations uh when you are investing in technology companies in the ability to create value over time you
  60. know sometimes the expectations could be 2 years but as we know anecdotally it often takes much longer than that for
  61. new technologies to create value users you know same same sort of decisions whether you're a business or a consumer
  62. you're always up against the decision should we go for the latest and greatest or should we wait until until the new
  63. technology is developed to a point where it creates value and so having the sensibility in terms of existing
  64. ecosystem and new ecosystem can help them make more optimal decisions policy makers I mean this is a big question in
  65. terms of the role of policy in shaping technological progress and we know that a lot of economic
  66. progress that we see is driven by improvements in technology so if you run into a scenario where the new
  67. technologies are not emerging at the rate where you expect them to to to to sort of emerge you know that has a
  68. downside in terms of jobs in terms of economic output in terms of GDP growth so thinking more in terms of ecosystem
  69. both for the new technology and the existing technology helps all of these actors get better Returns on the
  70. investment get less surprises in terms of expectations you know that was the original intention in terms of our
  71. ability to forecast uh how Technologies are going to evolve over time and the title of the
  72. paper has S curves as a way people have thought about it and there two different
  73. ways people thought about forecasting Technologies one is thinking about the performance improvements of the
  74. Technologies and we know that those performance trajectories tend to be in s shaped early stage you invest a lot but
  75. you're not getting improvements then there's a takeoff where you expect most of the market takeoff and then there's
  76. maturity similarly like that there's an adoption esurf which is the early stage of the technology the users who are
  77. going to be going after it are not the ones who really care about the total value but they just like the new
  78. technology that's a very small part of the market the mainstream users are looking to see what's the main value
  79. proposition not just technology being new and that depicts an s-shaped distribution as well so what we what we
  80. were up against is these existing Frameworks and tools which has this nonlinear s-shaped Dynamics and what we
  81. are able to show through this ecosystem based sensibility is that the pattern of
  82. these Evolutions both in terms of Technology Improvement and market adoption may not fit well with a smooth
  83. s shaped trajectories and they often could be very nonlinear patterns could be very discontinuous patterns and
  84. having the sensibility can help you predict right whether the S shapes are going to be smooth and quick or these
  85. may not be s shaped and they may actually get resolved in a much longer time frame and and you know where I'm
  86. going with this project is exactly along those lines is to have um a a model and
  87. an approach that helps us to improve technology forecasting in fact one of the things I
  88. was surprised um when we were doing this research is um the amount of resources that both companies and governments were
  89. expending into these new technologies often running into hundreds and billions of dollars as you know semiconductor
  90. industry is very Capital intensive and despite these resources and expectations they have well documented industry road
  91. maps that say these new technologies are going to be hitting mainstream 3 to 5 years more often than not they would
  92. take double the amount of time or in many cases never take off at all um and that's something that I was not some not
  93. expecting as much I was expecting some of it but not at the scale that I observe the other issue that I thought
  94. was particularly surprising is you know we kind of write off existing Technologies and old Technologies you
  95. know the the cell phones nobody's going to use it everybody's going to shift to let's say tablets on and a newer newer
  96. ways to do things um but seemingly geriatric Technologies uh continue to create a lot
  97. of value for a very long time and that was counterintuitive for what we expected to see in this result
  98. especially in an industry which is being driven by Moors law so I think from a firm perspective
  99. as we said you know the big implication is thinking about resource allocation and whether it makes sense for firms to
  100. go all out on these new technologies at the rate that they expect to invest um the other implication from a firm
  101. perspective is timing um you know in a related study I was able to document that you know first mover Advantage as
  102. we often claim in many technology settings turns out not to be the case and in fact we were able to show
  103. significant first mover disadvantage in Technologies where the ecosystem emergence challenge was so high that
  104. first movers couldn't create any value so issues of timing was important another issue that I think uh you know
  105. managers and uh investors need to think about is a technology is seldom a single
  106. artifact or a single technology element it is the ecosystem and that makes it very difficult for firms to control all
  107. the elements that go into creating value from the technology so one sensibility that you know I'd like to share with uh
  108. the managers and and investors is as we think about evaluating technological opportunities it's not enough to look at
  109. just the focal technology whether it's the phone or it's a computer or it's the car is to think about the ecosystem what
  110. are the elements that go into it and could you orchestrate the ecosystem system in a way that mitigates these
  111. potential downsides of the users not deriving value when the technology is ready um you know what was uh
  112. particularly interesting from our study was every time the new technology was introduced that technology was actually
  113. Superior in terms of performance but despite that it never reached mainstream adoption and the explanation was really
  114. rooted in the ecosystem of the new technology and the ecosystem of the old technology we had a we had a case where
  115. new techn ology came in three times four times Superior performance but a critical element that the users need to
  116. use so think about you have a camera as this technology but you need the film but the film that is you available with
  117. this new technology is not as good for you to get the full potential of this new camera so users don't really see an
  118. incentive so you're coming up with the best camera but with a below par film and the total value proposition is not
  119. there in other cases the Technologies are fairly increment m al but they're able to Plug and Play like a hybrid car
  120. for example and that doesn't feel that doesn't see these sort of resistances and fictions in the marketplace uh from
  121. a venture capital perspective again as we think about these entrepreneurial ecosystems as a way for Venture capitals
  122. to to sort of get in and create value um again you know you cannot just localize
  123. on a single firm as a basis of investment as a basis of value creation if you think about ebooks as a case in
  124. point U you know a lot lot of venture capital Investments companies like e Inc back in the day were funded through a
  125. lot of VC money both uh private Venture Capital but also corporate Venture Capital um but it wasn't about the ink
  126. itself it was about content it was about the reader it was about Amazon's business model that had to bring the
  127. solution together so as we think about the opportunities for venture capital for any given technology it's not enough
  128. to just focus on that technology but thinking about the broader ecosystem and how one could control and dve
  129. progress through the ecosystem important uh misperception that you see quite often is you know
  130. fairly optimistic aggressive expectations about new technologies and some people call it Hypes and some
  131. people you know refer to it as hype Cycles um and I think we're able to kind of identify
  132. reasons of those Hypes and just calling them as a hype is not enough in in my view is to understanding the factors
  133. that drive the hype and then you know using that as a basis of making good decisions um so you know there was
  134. clearly very high expectations in in our research context that these Technologies
  135. would reach mainstream adoption we going to be investing Millions if not billions
  136. of dollars into into these Technologies but it turned out those Investments were
  137. in vain because either the ecosystem didn't emerge at the right time or at the cost that made it attractive for the
  138. users the second sort of uh misperception is again this um you know very dramatic
  139. views about the decline of the old Technologies and this you know framing of the world as a world of disruption
  140. and all the values going to be created through creative destruction coming from new technologies I you know we do feel
  141. that that's that part of the world is a bit oversold and in fact uh a lot of the
  142. value uh in semiconductors in many of the other industries that I've studied is is been created through continued
  143. Innovations and finding Market opportunities through existing Technologies and we found that in our
  144. context as well a very interesting company called ultratech has been in this industry for 40 years that we have
  145. studied this industry it has never been at The Cutting Edge of the technology like some of its peers who entered and
  146. exited in a fairly short span and this company has existed for a very long time and still creating a lot of shareholder
  147. value so I think I think those perceptions in terms of you know a very optimistic view of of the new
  148. technologies and a very pessimistic view of the value proposition in the old technology is something that we think
  149. needs to be more balanced as opposed to these extreme views so we are certainly not the first
  150. ones to study new technologies and the ability to create value in the marketplace um but I do think that we
  151. are one of the first if if not the first to bring to attention the important role
  152. of the ecosystem in the way the technology gets developed and commercialized and to really understand
  153. how these Technologies transition and Technology Dynamics we think it's not enough to just take the ecosystem
  154. perspective but look at both the new technology ecosystem and the old technology ecosystem it's really
  155. bringing these two ecosystems together as an analytical framework can generate a lot more valuable insights in our view
  156. and we showed that in our research by just looking at the new technology on its own you know the other sort of
  157. aspect of the research which I think you know I'm particularly proud of is the approach that we took to study this
  158. question it was you it required almost two years of field work we interviewed more than 30 industry practitioners
  159. managers Consultants from a variety of roles in the ecosystem and that took a lot of time but we felt that you know we
  160. were able to generate a set of robust findings that made that effort worthwhile something that we don't often
  161. see in a lot of management research so this was in my view you know probably a first step for me to try to
  162. think about how one could make better decisions in terms of new technologies and provide a framework that could guide
  163. that uh decision- making I think we're still not quite at the point I would like us to be in terms of our ability to
  164. forecast Technologies both existing and new and and to kind of take a more probabilistic view that can guide
  165. managerial decision- making Venture Capital Investments and even how policy makers think about so what I'm I I'm
  166. sort of moving on is to take the issue of Technology forecasting more seriously and anecdotal evidence suggests that
  167. we're actually very poor technology forecasters I mean there's not a lot of uh documentation in terms of accuracy of
  168. forecasting but if you look at some of the the big technology forecast that come out nobody tracks them which is a
  169. problem of course but anecdotally you can tell that you know a vast majority of them turn out to be wrong either in
  170. terms of missing the timing completely or missing the new technologies that nobody predicted 3 to 5 years ago um so
  171. my goal is to think about the theoretical logic but also think about an estimation modeling approach that
  172. helps us to predict new technologies in a way that we have not able to do so far
  173. and I'm starting with the auto sector which which is going through some fairly interesting uh shifts at the moment as
  174. you've shifted from the electrification now we're talking about autonomous cars we have the technology companies coming
  175. into it in addition to the auto sector um and so I think it's it's an environment that presents a lot of
  176. uncertainty but also a lot of variability in terms of technological choices being pursued so I'm working on
  177. a project where uh we will try to create good forecasting models and hopefully we
  178. can show the accuracy of these forecasting models in explaining many of the Technologies being pursued in the
  179. auto sector and the hope is to kind of take that as a template and apply it in other technology settings you know think
  180. about internet of things think about variable Technologies think about financial Technologies and we could
  181. scale this model to make better technology forecast [Music]

Brief Summary

The episode examines technology adoption patterns, emphasizing the importance of ecosystems in determining success or failure.

Key points

  • Understanding Technology Adoption. Exploring why some technologies quickly reach mainstream adoption while others take decades.
  • Ecosystem Emergence Challenge. The readiness of technology versus the need for ecosystem investments is crucial for adoption.
  • Balancing New and Old Technologies. The research highlights the importance of both new technology ecosystems and existing technologies.
  • Technology Forecasting Project. Aiming to create accurate forecasting models for various technologies, starting with the auto sector.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes