Why Better Urban Planning Won't Reduce Traffic -- but Taxes Will

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Many cities have adopted land use policies encouraging greater density as a way to reduce traffic and related pollution. But new research by Wharton's Gilles Duranton finds that such initiatives don't have as dramatic an impact as officials would like to believe. More: http://knlg.net/1SFKmaH 📂 Public Policy 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. yes I'm interested in understanding how what we call urban former effects travel
  2. behavior so by urban form I mean all sorts of characteristics of the built environment you live in so density is
  3. the amount of jobs were achieved to residency is a quantity of roads and all of those characteristics and we're
  4. interested in how this is going to affect the way you travel and how many miles you actually do and how many miles
  5. you do especially by car why are we concerned by that because there are some social cost associated with using
  6. personal transportation so we know for each mile that we drive society anchors a caste or three or four cents maybe
  7. well maybe were slightly more associated with two different forms of pollution one is greenhouse gas emissions I a
  8. carbon that fosters climate change global warming and all of that and the second one is much more localized small
  9. particulates which typically give asthma to babies and all people and from time to time they die
  10. so what we found is that urban density measured by summing the quantity of jobs and residence in whatever five miles
  11. around where you live was remind someone where you live reduces higher urban when density
  12. reduces your travel so the elasticity is typically 10% higher well density leads
  13. to reduction in traveling of about one percent so the conclusions that surprised us
  14. most is the fact that actually we were expecting the situation and the results to be fairly complicated and fairly
  15. subtle what we discovered it actually reality was for once very simple in the sense that there's actually one major
  16. characteristic of cities that matters the moment where we live that matters that's the was that's the density were
  17. around you everything else is really well secondary and matters far less and what we also found is that those results
  18. were extremely robust we were also expecting like different groups of residents to react differently depending
  19. on where they lived because we were also expecting people who like driving to live in places where it's easier to
  20. drive and these to be really important in the results actually not at all everybody seems to be reacting more or
  21. less in the same way or at least we could not find very much of a difference across different groups across different
  22. types of environments so basically again if you were if you bring up what density
  23. by about well 10% you reduce driving by about 1% even though we do find some effects but
  24. this 10% higher than CG leading to one percent less driving is actually a very small effect so if you want to see what
  25. it means or what to understand what it means in reality if you were to take the 30 million Americans that live at the
  26. lowest weight density in rural areas and bring them to nearly the highest rent density in the country that's a scale of
  27. displace that's a displacement where the scale of Syria at the moment so it's massive it's not something that's going
  28. to happen at all but that would lead to a reduction in driving by whatever four or five percent some even something that
  29. is still extremely drastic but slightly less so so taking again 30 million more Americans from northern city areas which
  30. instead of shootings end up will completely bring them to high density areas but leaving some people into low
  31. density areas the effect on electric driving would be minimal because who's that who that are broked to high-density
  32. areas will drive less but those that actually are left in the low density areas will drive lots more
  33. and this it's nearly what a perfect world offset so as a result you won't be able to achieve will very much in terms
  34. of global warming using urban policies of that sort what you need to use or to go after well pollution you need after
  35. well local pollution what you need to tax for congestion ie the concentration will the concentration but of course in
  36. some areas where the cities so you need to make them pay for that and you need to tax well carbon well emissions like
  37. for instance the province of British Columbia does in Canada it's a resounding with success so I know it's
  38. politically a really hard proposition in this country but that's the one thing that works everything else will not do
  39. very much so we have this perception that because indeed the federal government in this
  40. country is not very effective at doing very many things that's a lot of the solutions have to be local and you are
  41. whatever Meyers for America and all the solutions have to be coming from City Hall's and from Wheeling Meijer to some
  42. extent but global problems they require global solutions they require federal interventions we are not going to solve
  43. all global warming by having cities practicing smart growth that will only achieve very very little and some of it
  44. like imposing green bells if anything might be just counterproductive so what sets us about what I eat
  45. scenario where there's been a lot of research so what he's setting us about is first we use extensive data for
  46. travel instead of looking at the tiny area and the number of cars we actually rely on a big survey done by the
  47. department of transportation with nearly a million trips so that's a very large gauge survey then we use extensive
  48. measures of the local environments where people reside so what we've done was actually used satellite imagery and grid
  49. every seeing on a one kilometer by one kilometer basis both the description of the physical environment but also using
  50. a vast array of data are coming from the census coming from employments and so on
  51. and so forth and greeting all that to know exactly what there is around where people leave in terms of number of jobs
  52. of number of residents how richest residents are how educated they are and this and that so we use vastly more data
  53. also to describe the environment and the last thing we did it's not because you observe a negative correlation between
  54. how dance and REI is and how little people drive that is that this relationship is causal this relationship
  55. may may just be completely spurious because again people that like to drive may want to live in low-density
  56. environment so what we've done was to design a new methodology to address that question looking at the fact that people
  57. when you in some cases they move what will somewhere where car went mm they moved to neighborhoods that were very
  58. highly well comparable in terms of all characteristics but some of those neighborhoods between 2000 and 2010 got
  59. a lot more population and not everybody moved out or move Dean so we look at people how they responded to well
  60. differences in the amount of population went at the guards for zoos that have stayed for a long time so that allows us
  61. to go sorry to be with technical here but but dr. Rosen's good to go with ruvie selection problem and actually
  62. make some causal statements where we can actually claim that the local environment has an effect on the amount
  63. of driving one that you do but this effect again is more so what's next is I want to think more
  64. about what congestion because we think of congestion as a big problem it's true that to where traffic jams are for
  65. everyone to see is everywhere particularly in developing countries where people keep well buying cars with
  66. economic growth and the situation gets worse at the same time we have no serious idea about the economic cost of
  67. that congestion and for that I want to be able to use new data that's now made available through through web mapping
  68. with services like Google Maps where you can actually get some travel times from
  69. anywhere to anywhere else in real time knowing about the number one of travelers you can actually estimate the
  70. true cost of congestion the other thing I want to look at well more is urban land use because we tend to think about
  71. land use as a use so it's something that could be one use one day maybe another use another day so really key is when we
  72. build stuff it's for a very very long time and very often that stuff is very pal it's very well tacky weather to the
  73. needs of a particular user or set of users so when we think about land use we can see land use moving from agriculture
  74. to residential and VC's for everyone to see but what's happening to all manufacturing it's usually not places we
  75. go to so some of it gets reconverted whenever it's really really central very valuable land but there's a lot of
  76. suburban land in declining cities it looks like nothing is happening so we'd like to be able to know actually how
  77. much changes well there is in land use well over time among the more residential slash manufacturing slash
  78. with different types of development and we will also like to know if things revert back with to nature well from
  79. time to time our perception is not but again this is something that we don't know

Brief Summary

Urban density reduces driving; federal action needed for pollution control.

Key points

  • Impact of Urban Density on Travel. Higher urban density leads to reduced travel, with a surprising simplicity in results.
  • Need for Global Solutions. Local policies alone won't solve global warming; federal action is essential.

Related episodes