City Shapes and Economics

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Public Policy 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I work on urbanization in developing countries and in my recent research I have looked at the spatial patterns of
  2. urbanization in India trying to understand the economic implications of different city structures and more
  3. specifically I've looked at one particular property of urban footprints which is their geometry if you look at
  4. urban areas from a plane for example you can see that cities become in different
  5. shapes some have outlines that are roughly circular others appear more fragmented and yet others are
  6. constrained by their geographies for instance cities on islands or peninsulas end up having even more irregular shapes
  7. so my question was what influence if any does a cities shape have on the location
  8. choices of consumers and firms do consumers and firms benefit in terms of welfare or productivity from locating in
  9. cities with particular shapes now why would we expect City shape to matter at all from an economic standpoint
  10. primarily because as urban planners have long recognized City shape is one of the
  11. determinants of urban commuting efficiency along with more widely studied factors such as infrastructure
  12. or travel demand and the reason is that more compact more circular city geometries are conducive to shorter
  13. within city trips to give you a sense of how this works this is just coming from
  14. the properties of geometric shapes think of a circle and now imagine that holding
  15. area constant you start tweaking the circle turning it into some irregular shape as the shape of this polygon
  16. departs from that of a circle becoming less and less compact the average distance between points within this
  17. polygon will tend to increase and the same thing happens to cities as they expand in space
  18. a good real-world example of these types of interactions is the comparison between kolkata and bangalore of the top
  19. cities in india kolkata is the least compact one it kind of looks like an upside down giraffe head with a long
  20. north-south tentacle so to say bangalore on the other hand is more like a pentagon it's the most compact one i
  21. calculate that all else being equal if kolkata had the same compact shape that bangalore has the average within city
  22. trip proxied by the average distance between points within the city would be shorter by six point two kilometers and
  23. this is not trivial if you think that the average commuting speed in the top cities in india is around 15 kilometers
  24. per hour so what i did was to look at the outlines of over 450 cities in india based on how they appear in nighttime
  25. satellite imagery if you look at a picture of the earth at night taken from a satellite urban areas are clearly
  26. visible as patches of light essentially so for each city for each of these patches of light i computed a number of
  27. indicators for geometric shape that are basically telling us the extent to which
  28. a city's shape departs from that of a circle and I did this for multiple years to have a sense of the dynamic evolution
  29. of City shapes over time and finally I linked City shape to economic outcomes measured at the city level such as
  30. population aggregate look sorry average local wages and average housing rents so I find that households locating in
  31. more compact cities are better off first more compact cities attract larger populations second households that are
  32. located in more compact cities are implicitly paying a premium in terms of higher housing rents net of local wages
  33. in order to live in cities with better geometries so this tells us that essentially consumers are valuing City
  34. compactness as an urban amenity that they are willing to implicitly pay for in this implied premium that they are
  35. paying is actually quite large i estimate that households are trading off implicitly five percent of their income
  36. in order to live in cities that are more compact by one standard deviation now for the average City a one standard
  37. deviation improvement in compactness implies that your average round-trip commute decreases by 720 meters these
  38. are potential commutes estimated based on the distribution of points within the city these are not observed commutes
  39. which unfortunately I can't see in my data on the other hand firms are not affected in their productivity by City
  40. shape compact compact cities are just as productive and compactness appears to be
  41. a pure consumption amenity now you may worry that compact cities are systematically different from others in
  42. some dimension other than geometry what if these more compact cities are also more successful more developed cities
  43. that consumers like for reasons that are just correlated with geometry but have nothing to do with it to address the
  44. fact that these confounding factors might be biasing my results in my analysis I'm not simply making a crude
  45. comparison between compact and non compact cities what I do is look at what happens when a given City becomes less
  46. compact as a result of hitting some topographic obstacle like a mountain or a lake as it expands in space and what I
  47. find is that when a city ends up with the worst geometry because of hitting some geographic constraints its
  48. population growth slows down and housing rents net of local wages tend to decrease
  49. well India's predicted to urbanize very rapidly in the next decades and local policymakers need options to accommodate
  50. this urban growth in space and my findings suggest that accommodating this urban expansion in a more or less
  51. compact way can have potentially relevant implications for household welfare and for urbanization patterns
  52. now clearly not all cities can be circular due to topography and in fact at a descriptive level one of the
  53. patterns that I find is that cities tend to become less and less compact over time as they expand but there is room
  54. for land use regulations to promote more or less compact development and as an example of this in my work I consider a
  55. regulatory tool that is considered quite controversial in India right now vertical limits restrictions on building
  56. heights that in India are considered very strict relative to international standards and a lot of commentators and
  57. local policymakers are concerned that these stringent vertical limits are inducing sprawl and making cities more
  58. and more spread out what I find is that cities that have more restrictive building height regulations end up
  59. having footprints that are not only larger but also less compact relative to what their topography and predicted
  60. growth would suggest so relaxing these constraints would be a way at least to slow down the deterioration in City
  61. shape that city growth entails and a second policy implication could be related to investments in urban
  62. infrastructure one of my findings is that the negative consequences of bad city geometry are more pronounced in
  63. cities that have a poor road network so providing road infrastructure might be a
  64. way to compensate consumers for the poor shape of the city that they live in well so far in my research I have looked
  65. at City level aggregate outcomes and I have compared the outlines of cities looking at cross city comparisons what
  66. I'd like to do next is take this to a more disaggregated level and look at what happens within cities look at the
  67. internal structure of cities as a follow-up to this project it would be important to understand who bears the
  68. costs of longer commutes in cities that are not compact what categories of consumers are affected the most perhaps
  69. low-income households that don't have access to individual means of transportation what consequences if any
  70. does City shape have on residential patterns and in particular residential segregation by socioeconomic status are
  71. some kinds of City shapes more conducive to segregation and others more conducive
  72. to integration you

Brief Summary

Urban shapes in India affect commuting efficiency and household welfare, with compact cities like Bangalore offering significant advantages over less compact ones like Kolkata.

Key points

  • The Geometry of Cities. Exploring how city shapes influence economic outcomes and commuting efficiency.
  • Kolkata vs. Bangalore. A comparison of city shapes reveals significant differences in commuting distances.
  • Policy Implications for Urban Growth. Findings suggest that compact urban development can enhance household welfare.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes