Do Sin Taxes Actually Work?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW The Wharton School Professor Ben Lockwood joins host Dan Loney to discuss "sin taxes" and their efficacy in curbing "sin" behaviors, like soda consumption. Lockwood remarks that in cases where taxes successfully curb behavior, they concurrently fail to generate revenue for a city.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Ben Lockwood: My read of the current evidence is that that tax reduced total soda purchases in the city of Philly by close to 50%, and then
  2. around half of that reduction reappeared outside the city as sort of cross-border purchases. So you go into Jersey, or you go
  3. outside, you go up to the Main Line or wherever those taxes aren't in effect, and you buy your soda there instead. So some
  4. of it gets offset by that kind of cross-border shopping. But still, that's something like a 25%
  5. reduction in total purchases. - Welcome to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>, the podcast that takes you on a
  6. journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host, Dan Loney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the
  7. inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted and exploring how
  8. their findings resonate with the world today. Dan Loney: Have you ever heard of a sin tax? It's a type of tax put forward by a city or a state
  9. primarily to add a cost to something that may not be the healthiest or the best for us. There have been sin taxes on
  10. things like soda, tobacco products, alcohol and others, and they may even be growing in use to raise needed revenues.
  11. But do these sin taxes actually impact the public's thought process enough to change their behavior in using them? This is
  12. research conducted by Wharton's Ben Lockwood, who's an Assistant Professor of Business, Economics and Public Policy, and he joins
  13. me here in the studio. Great to see you, Ben. Thanks for your time. Sure thing. Thanks for having me on, Dan.
  14. So the research looks in kind of the mindset of the people as these sin taxes are implemented, and whether or not they actually
  15. have an impact on their purchasing habits? Yeah, that's the idea. So I've done a couple of research papers
  16. in this area, sort of ranging from the general theory and an understanding of how sin taxes work and how effective they
  17. might be, when you might want to use them. Obviously, they're pretty— they're used on a bunch of different products, from
  18. alcohol to cigarettes to— to other forms of tobacco, to now sometimes gambling or soda. And then more specifically, I've
  19. kind of zeroed in on a couple of particular types of sin taxes— one big set of projects on soda taxes, specifically, another set
  20. of projects on gambling in the form of state-run lotteries— to kind of understand what the trade offs were and what the
  21. behavioral effects were in those specific areas. And so with the sin tax— and we've talked about it in the past,
  22. with here in Philadelphia, with the sin tax that was put into place, what kind of research do we know or impact do we know
  23. from having that on soda, and whether or not it had an impact on sales here in Philadelphia? - Sure.
  24. So now— it's been several years ago now, maybe close to a decade ago, Philadelphia implemented a 1.5 cents per ounce tax on
  25. sweetened beverages. So soda, but also diet soda, and also some other kinds of, you know, non-carbonated sweetened drinks.
  26. And 1.5 cents per ounce might not sound like a very large amount, but actually, the average cost of soda in the US
  27. is something like 4 to 5 cents per ounce, so something like a 30% tax. It's actually pretty substantial. Now there's
  28. enough of a track record, enough evidence over these last several years, to kind of see what sort of effects that's had. My read
  29. of the current evidence is that that tax reduced total soda purchases in the city of Philly by close to 50%. And then around
  30. half of that reduction reappeared outside the city as sort of cross-border purchases. So you go into Jersey, or you go
  31. outside, you go up to the Main Line or wherever those taxes aren't in effect, and you buy your soda there instead. So some
  32. of it gets offset by that kind of cross-border shopping. But still, that's something like a 25% reduction in total
  33. purchases. So it's not trivial, regardless. - But that's the interesting thing, is that people would even consider
  34. the fact of not buying their soda within the city limits, but they actually would go outside the borders. And I guess it's
  35. probably people who are probably close to the borders in general, go a mile, go two miles, whatever, to buy their soda and
  36. then bring it back into their— into their residence in the city limits. Yeah, I think that's right. So it's people who sort of live
  37. close to the edges. I think there's some evidence for— for sort of being geographically close to the edges, and also
  38. being people who kind of chain their trips together and do a large set of purchases, you know, at the Costco nearby or
  39. something, and then that's when you get all your— all your soda. In the research that we do, one implication of them is, if you
  40. do want to do this sort of sin taxation, it can be beneficial to try to implement those taxes at sort of a larger geographic
  41. area, because the smaller the area is that these taxes are confined in, the more you just lose any of their revenue-
  42. raising ability, and also any of their sort of desired behavioral effects, to people who are just cross-border shopping.
  43. So it's interesting you said that the amount of soda went down as much as it did. And again, that component of how much the tax is
  44. in comparison to how much a person might spend on a soda is very unique. And you wonder whether or not there's actual
  45. recognition by the public of the difference in cost because of that sin tax component itself. - Yeah,
  46. so you might wonder about this. And you know, often— this is not specific to sin taxes. Often in economics generally, people are
  47. sort of surprised to find out that small price changes can nevertheless generate kind of a change in total behavior. So you
  48. know, the price of a $30,000 car goes— or these days it's probably a $60,000 car, goes up by $1,000 and it's like, does
  49. anyone pay attention to that? But you can see in the data, you know, demand curves slope down, just like they— just like we
  50. teach in our MBA classes. And you can see in the data that there were some people who were a little bit on the margin
  51. between this and something else, or between buying now or— or waiting till next year, whatever. And you do see some—
  52. some effect in response to that. So this is sort of echoing those— those general results, that even small price changes do
  53. create changes in how much people purchase. Can you determine, then, maybe even larger-scale impact on health
  54. and maybe other components because of a lowering in the consumption, or at least the purchase, of soda
  55. within the city of Philadelphia? So, you might be able to see this sort of thing eventually. Now,
  56. from the— from the way that we think that, you know, health consequences of sugar consumption operate,
  57. you might not actually expect these things to materialize for, you know, 10 years down the road or something, with reductions in
  58. diabetes contraction. And even then, you know, many people who lived in Philadelphia at the time might now live in Florida
  59. or somewhere else. So I would be surprised if we're able to pick up very much direct effect for sort of the— this quasi-
  60. experiment of the soda tax being implemented here. But there is evidence, more generally, of, you know, the effects of sugar
  61. consumption on health down the road and other types of consumption. Certainly in the case of cigarettes, for example.
  62. There's a lot of evidence about the linkage between smoking and cancer. - But because
  63. of the connection that seemingly cities and states will have to these taxes, I guess it's probably not a surprise that— you
  64. kind of alluded to before— the types of products that they may put a sin tax on is growing in the last few years as well.
  65. Yeah, I think that's true, partly because there is this sort of growing realization that some products might have these
  66. health consequences or— or what have you. From an economics perspective, the way I think about this is not necessarily
  67. that you need to tax things just because they have harmful health consequences. I mean, there are lots of things that might be
  68. harmful for one's health, but people are aware of those harms, and they're interested in doing the thing. You know, we don't
  69. necessarily tax mountain biking or rock climbing just because they can be dangerous. The way I think about this is, if there is
  70. some aspect of a cost, a health cost, or whatever else, that people aren't thinking about or aren't taking into account,
  71. either because of behavioral biases or because they aren't aware of the information or whatever, then what you want to
  72. try to understand is, you know, if they were fully informed and if they really understood the context and the consequences and
  73. everything of all their actions, would they be consuming less than they currently are? And if so, that's a situation where you
  74. might want to impose a tax to try to get— sort of bring their actual consumption into line with what they might kind of
  75. rationally do if they took all those costs into account, in pretty much the same way that, you know, we have this rationale
  76. for imposing a gas tax so that people take into account the negative externalities, the pollution consequences or the
  77. congestion consequences of— of buying gas, and bring it into line with— But from a public policy perspective, this— these have
  78. become important revenue drivers for cities and states to be able to have them in the mix of their— of their need to try and bring
  79. revenues to provide services in other areas as well. It's true. And in a way, this is sort of one of the ironies of
  80. sin taxation generally, as I think they're sometimes looked to as a potential source of revenues. But of course, if part
  81. of the goal of the tax is to reduce people's consumption of something that might be harmful for them, then if the tax works
  82. well and people reduce their consumption a lot, then it necessarily doesn't bring in as much in in revenue, right? So
  83. the way I think about the revenue question is that, you know, whether you're talking about Philadelphia or the state
  84. of Pennsylvania, or whatever jurisdiction, fundamentally, the taxes that you bring in, that you need to bring in, are
  85. determined by the jurisdictions' spending decisions and their— their priorities. And then you're going to have to raise those—
  86. you're going to have to cover that spending one way or another. If you don't raise it via a soda tax, you're going to have to raise
  87. the sales tax or the personal income tax or something else. And really, it's a question of which different things are we
  88. going to tax, rather than, you know, should we tax soda at all? What do you think, then, the
  89. larger discussion is— and maybe it's— it's a little bit of the health, a little bit of the taxation
  90. side— of the impact that— that sin taxes are having in communities around— around the country?
  91. So I think there are a couple pieces to this. One is the kind of behavioral consequence piece. Are people changing their
  92. behavior? Is that making them healthier or not? To what extent is it— is it having an effect there? Another piece of it is,
  93. you know, are there distributional consequences to this, which is sort of the fancy way that economists talk
  94. about, you know, being— being really regressive or progressive with your tax choices. Are you going to tax poorer people much
  95. more heavily, or richer people more heavily? One thing that we know about lots of these goods— soda, cigarettes, to some
  96. extent, alcohol— is that they're more heavily consumed by people who are sort of lower in the income distribution. And so a
  97. thing you want to be aware of, a thing you want to be want to be careful of, is, are you increasing taxes that are going
  98. to sort of fall most heavily on people who are poorer? Now, there are ways of offsetting that with like, you know, making the
  99. income tax a little more progressive at the same time that you impose some sin taxes that may, in a way— that sort of
  100. offsets that distributional impact. But it is something that you want to have in mind when
  101. you're deciding on these kinds of tax policies. So you're not really doubling up on the— on the component of
  102. the tax. There's not a doubling of the impact on the people's wallets because of the tax being included as well. - That's right.
  103. - Yeah. What's your expectation, then, for looking at this research and taking it forward?
  104. It's a good question. So there are a number of kind of increasing future areas of potential sin taxation that I think are
  105. becoming relevant. So some of these are— you know, there's been an explosion in various forms of online gaming, sports
  106. betting, this kind of stuff. There's also increasing marijuana legalization, and that's viewed as a potential
  107. sin tax base. And so with those sorts of areas too, my question would be, to what extent are people buying those things or
  108. doing those activities more than they would if they were sort of fully rational or fully aware of the costs or— or fully cognizant
  109. of this stuff? A flip side of that is that I think that, you know, sort of for political reasons, there's sometimes a
  110. drive to tax these new markets, just because they don't have an entrenched body of stakeholders already that are existing and
  111. that can oppose a tax. Now, from an economist point of view, that's not really a good reason to tax them, just that nobody is
  112. currently— currently consuming them a whole lot. Really, you want to think about whether there are these, you know,
  113. behavioral biases, and what the revenue trade offs are and that— that that sort of thing. - But are
  114. we at a point right now where you do see sin taxes in a majority of states, or a lot of communities or cities within
  115. states right now? - Yeah. I mean, most states have, if you if you look at the set of
  116. different sin taxes that are available from— lots of states have alcohol excise taxes, cigarette taxes. Many states
  117. have state-run lotteries, which I do think of as sort of a taxed good, in the sense that the— you know, portion of the revenues
  118. are withheld before the prizes are paid back out, and that goes into the state's coffers. So between those things, you're at
  119. a point where most states and an increasing number of localities, of cities and smaller areas,
  120. are imposing these kinds of taxes too. Ben, great to have you here. Thanks very much for your time.
  121. Thanks for having me on. - Thank you. Ben Lockwood, Assistant Professor of Business, Economics and Public Policy,
  122. here at the Wharton School. Thank you for listening to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>.
  123. We hope you found this episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue
  124. to bring you the best insight from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Ben Lockwood discusses the impact of Philadelphia's soda tax on purchasing behavior and public health outcomes.

Key points

  • The Ripple Effect Podcast. Explore the minds of Wharton faculty and their groundbreaking research.
  • Impact of Sin Taxes. Ben Lockwood discusses how sin taxes influence consumer behavior and public health.
  • Behavioral Economics Insights. Small price changes can significantly alter purchasing habits, according to Ben Lockwood.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes