Building a Better Earned Income Tax Credit

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Recent Wharton research suggests that redefining who is eligible for the Earned Income Tax Credit in the U.S. may make it more effective. More: http://knlg.net/2idDllD πŸ“‚ Finance & Accounting 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here today with Wharton business economics and public policy professor Benjamin Lockwood to discuss some of his
  2. recent research Ben thanks for being here thanks for having me so first of all could you give us a brief summary of
  3. your research what you were looking at sure gladly so um so I my research focuses fundamentally on tax policy
  4. issues of redistribution and rising inequality and and so the most recent paper that I've been working on this
  5. involves issues of work subsidies so this is a particular kind of anti-poverty program where the
  6. government pays especially low income people to work more and these kinds of policies are quite widespread they exist
  7. from the UK to Scandinavia to the to New Zealand they exist in the u.s. in the form of the Earned Income Tax Credit
  8. which is an incredibly popular policy on both sides of the of the political aisle
  9. but there's a sort of puzzle in optimal tax research because this kind of policy
  10. is is suboptimal according to standard economic models instead you should just give people kind of a lump sum and let
  11. them do choose the amount of work that they would like to like to provide so so to resolve that puzzle I've essentially
  12. looked to more recent developments in behavioral economics research which studies temptation and self-control
  13. these kinds of issues and one of the lessons of that research is that people often underestimate benefits when they
  14. come with a delay and overestimate upfront costs so this can explain everything from under saving for
  15. retirement to exercising less than one intends to and when you think about it labour effort the decision to work often
  16. often involves those kinds of trade-offs you need to put in time at a menial task
  17. or you need to do do lots of unpleasant work work searching for for a new job upfront in exchange for the possibility
  18. of a delayed benefit in the form of a pay raise or a promotion so once you take that that kind of behavioral bias
  19. into account these sorts of work subsidies can actually make a lot of sense so what were some of the key
  20. takeaways of the paper so I think that there are a couple one is that this helps us understand why policies like
  21. the Earned Income Tax Credit might be so widespread and so politically popular it
  22. also helps us understand the kind of puzzle related to the EITC expansion in the
  23. 1990s so the way that expansion worked was to expand work subsidies for for primarily for single mothers while at
  24. the same time reducing unconditional welfare welfare grants and and so that had the effect of encouraging single
  25. mothers to enter the workforce which they did quite substantially and conventional economic theory suggests
  26. that because it was it was accompanied by reductions in other welfare programs this should have actually unbalanced
  27. made single mothers worse off on the other hand when you look at subjective happiness reports from single mothers
  28. over this same period you actually see that they report being happier over that time frame which is consistent with this
  29. kind of behavioral economic model as they gained the benefits of these delayed delayed returns to being in the
  30. labor force and so if I am either a policymaker or even just the average person what are some of the practical
  31. implications of these research of this research so I think there are a couple practical ramifications one is it helps
  32. us better understand why we have these kinds of policies and why they're so widespread why people on both sides of
  33. the political aisle might favor them on the other hand it also points to reforms
  34. that we could potentially make to programs like the EITC to actually improve them so one type of reform would
  35. be to expand the program from its current more narrow focus on families as primarily single mothers with children
  36. to also expand it to families with it without children single men and the like because even though because those types
  37. of workers also faced these delayed benefits in exchange for upfront costs of work on the other hand it also
  38. suggests how the structure of the timing of EITC benefits could be improved so the the EITC has currently paid out as
  39. one lump sum at the end of the tax year and that results there and that results in many people taking out loans against
  40. those anticipated refunds often at very high interest rates in excess of one hundred and fifty percent at an
  41. annualized level so by paying out EW I see benefits more frequently throughout the year we could avoid those kinds of
  42. high interest loans by providing people the liquidity they need more frequently now with that also though would you have
  43. to consider that that is less delayed gratification you know because they'd be getting it over the
  44. course the year as opposed to waiting till the end yes exactly so in fact that's part of the benefit of that sort
  45. of alternative timing structure if we can pay those benefits more frequently and closer to the time that the work is
  46. actually performed then we can help mitigate this temptation to to sort of sit back and not think as much about
  47. those delayed benefits because people can connect it more directly to yes exactly
  48. and so what is what's next for this research what are you going to look at value gonna follow this up sure so I
  49. think there are many different contexts where it's helpful to build considerations of behavioural temptation
  50. and self-control into models of optimal redistribution so the next project that I'm working on along these lines is
  51. actually looking at sin taxes like this more recent soda tax that the city of Philadelphia has introduced so there are
  52. one of the kind of rationales for those kinds of policies is that they help discourage unhealthy behavior in this
  53. case consuming sugary beverages hopefully then reducing the incidence of obesity and diabetes but at the same
  54. time one caught one perceived cost of those policies is that they can tend to be really regressive falling heavily on
  55. poor on lower-income consumers so so this more recent research that I'm looking at sort of ways those those
  56. benefits and costs against each other to try to find the optimal point and also looks at other possible policies like
  57. making the income tax more progressive at the same time as we increase sin taxes like like a tax on soda to kind of
  58. offset those regressivity costs thank you so much for being here my pleasure [Music]

Brief Summary

Professor Benjamin Lockwood discusses work subsidies, the EITC, and behavioral economics in tax policy reform.

Key points

  • Behavioral Economics and Tax Policy. Benjamin Lockwood discusses how behavioral economics informs tax policy and work subsidies.
  • Implications of EITC Research. Research reveals why the Earned Income Tax Credit is popular and suggests reforms.
  • Reforming the EITC. Lockwood suggests reforms to improve the timing and structure of EITC benefits.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes