"Gut Feel" and Early-stage Investors

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I want to welcome Laura Wong and she is a management professor here at Wharton and she's going to tell us about her new
  2. research which has to do with investors using a gut feel to make decisions important investment decisions and I
  3. think it's based mostly on angel investors and it's a little bit counterintuitive it's not quite what you
  4. would think investors are relying on so we're anxious to hear about that so thank you for coming in hi thanks for
  5. having me I think that the best way to get into it this is to ask you to do a short summary of the of the arc of the
  6. paper sure so what we found in this research was well actually I'll step back a little bit the the origins of
  7. this paper was we're really interested in how investors make decisions and this one thing kept coming up right so they
  8. would talk about the size of the market they would talk about the product but investors kept coming back to well then
  9. I rely on my gut feel or then I invest based on my gut feel um you know I've even heard stories of investors kind of
  10. just saying you know I invest because I rub my tummy and that's how I make my investment well we would have expected a
  11. right and so I thought that was really interesting um and I thought it was really kind of critical to understand
  12. what is this got field that they're they're referring to and so the paper really sought out first we what we
  13. wanted to do is to do this investigation of what do investors actually mean when
  14. they say that they invest based on their gut feel and what we found actually was
  15. really fascinating was that not only do they use their gut feel to make their investments but that there's actually a
  16. practical reason a reason for why they use their gut feel and it makes sense in terms of looking at their outcomes and
  17. how effective they are so one of the big findings of this paper in particular and
  18. we're continuing on some follow-on work from here but is that decisions are not all the same right we tend to think of
  19. decisions as being right or wrong but in the entrepreneurial context investors are very willing to be wrong in fact
  20. they know that they will be wrong on a lot of there investments and so in terms of their gut
  21. feel it doesn't actually make a difference in terms of being right or wrong on any one given investment
  22. decision that they're making but it allows them to identify the home runs when they rely on their gut feel they
  23. may be wrong on a lot of different investments but they're actually going to be able to be more likely to pinpoint
  24. that home run so if we think about it in terms of baseball averages right so investors perhaps might have if your if
  25. your goal is to have a very high batting average your gut feel might not be as effective but if you're willing to have
  26. a really low batting average but hit more home runs then perhaps you want to rely on your gut feel so this is partly
  27. a strategy that works because of the level of investment meaning it's like very very early stage when a lot of
  28. things aren't proven and you can't Marshall all the evidence you would like because because this is just a new thing
  29. let's examine but it probably is input it but you're going to take a risk on it right so we were looking at the very
  30. earliest stages of ventures right so we're looking at angel investors who typically are the first outside external
  31. form of financing for for these entrepreneurs and you're you're at this stage where perhaps you you may have a
  32. prototype or maybe you just have a glimmer of an idea you're not exactly sure what the market is gonna look like
  33. there may not even be a market out there and so there's lots of hard data there's
  34. numbers and facts and figures that you're able to put down but a lot of those numbers are based on estimates and
  35. hopes and dreams and guesses and so that hard data is actually not as reliable to
  36. these investors as their own experience the things that they're getting from their own mental schemas and prototypes
  37. and mental models that they that they have really developed through lots and lots of investments and that's kind of
  38. where their gut feel is coming from and that becomes a more reliable factor to them in kind of gauging where this is
  39. going to be you know in three years five years ten years down the line that's an
  40. interesting point they're not just throwing darts at the dartboard they're basing their decisions on a lot of
  41. experience and so it's a sort of more of an educated guess that's right right so
  42. you know so we hear the term intuition and gut feel and a lot of times we think about you know oh this is
  43. something where it's going to be something that's that's very biased or it's going to be something that is just
  44. based on on some arbitrary kind of thing but their gut feel is actually based on
  45. years of experience investments that they've made that have gone well that have gone poorly so so it's really
  46. something that is a criteria that they rely upon and that in fact has a basis for for this reliance so they're pretty
  47. good at this or they wouldn't get to keep doing it you know it's funny some of them we've looked at the the
  48. investors that we looked at in one of our samples had all approximately around the same amount of experience but we've
  49. also done studies where we looked at different levels of experience right some that have maybe only been investors
  50. for five years some that have been doing it for 35 years and you do get lots of variants for example we had one investor
  51. who you know he bought his house that he lives in now in Malibu off of one investment that he made and he said you
  52. know sometimes I can tell within five to ten seconds of meeting somebody whether
  53. or not I'm gonna invest in them right so there is a different and there's others
  54. who do lots of due diligence right due diligence probably for three months six months however long they do and then
  55. they kind of say well you know throughout the course of that it was this this this judgment that I had at
  56. the very end of it that I used my gut feeling to to make this investment so there's there's all sorts of ranges of
  57. this what are the key takeaways from your research would you say I mean I think one of the key takeaways is that
  58. this is a highly uncertain environment right there is extreme and certainty in this environment and so the way that we
  59. think about the ways in which we think about decisions are not going to be the same based on the different contexts
  60. right so in the entrepreneurial investment context here you're looking at this portfolio strategy where we're
  61. not looking at was the decision a good one or not a good one we're really looking at it in terms of I'm willing to
  62. have nine really bad investments that I make and forsake that for one huge one huge investment that turns into
  63. extremely profitable investment for myself right so there's this portfolio strategy and so decision making is going
  64. to be different based on that the other thing that I think was really an important takeaway from this is that
  65. there's different types of data out there and the investors got feel is actually trumping the data behind
  66. business viability right so the hard data so things around financials or market size or um you know product that
  67. their gut feel was a more important consideration to them than some of these other things right and so that kind of
  68. matters it's not to say that those things don't matter but it's that there's lots of different considerations
  69. to consider and we tend to have this very economic driven model of how investors should make decisions when in
  70. fact perhaps we should consider these behavioral and micro level influences at least at that early stage yeah and also
  71. when you talk about that they are maybe doing 10 investments and maybe one pays off but in general they're doing small
  72. stakes right they're not they're not betting the farm on each one of these is that correct right relative to their
  73. their net worth or to their wealth these are these are small stakes right so um you know it could be 20,000 50,000 that
  74. they're investing but we also are continuing to look at this in terms of follow-on investments do they continue
  75. to invest going forward if you look at some of the venture capitalists right the Sequoias of the world's right
  76. they're gonna have a very different sort of criteria a different way of investing
  77. so if you hit on one Instagram that that's a even if it was only a twenty-thousand-dollar investment you're
  78. not doing too bad yeah I mean these extraordinarily profitable investments are returning things in spades so were
  79. their conclusions here that surprised you I mean we were a little bit surprised that gut feel had this kind of
  80. bifurcated result where it doesn't actually necessarily help you identify what's going to bring you a return or
  81. not a return but that it it does have this effect in terms of identifying those extraordinarily profitable
  82. investments you know that was kind of surprising because it suggests that the way that we think about you know we hear
  83. lots of this type 1 type 2 types of decision-making right do you rely on your intuition or do you rely on data
  84. and it seems to suggest that there's room for both and then it's not quite that clear-cut where where intuition is
  85. necessarily this bad thing it does it does also depend your experience it does append on lots
  86. of other things so what are some practical implications so if you're an investor go with your gut don't ignore
  87. your gut entirely how would you how would you come away with some practical implications for you know one way that I
  88. always that I've always thought was interesting to think about this is you know I heard this quote at one point
  89. that was you know some people go with their their brain and some people go with their heart and before you decide
  90. whether to go with your brain or your heart you should decide whether you have a better heart or give you a better
  91. brain right and so it's a little bit of that right you want to think about you want to think about the criteria that
  92. you're using you want to think about how you're making decisions but if you're perhaps a very very early investor in
  93. terms of you maybe this is your first investment you want to actually perhaps think about this and and triangulate and
  94. look at all the different you don't help your great exactly exactly so I think that that goes into it uh maybe this is
  95. an easy one but what misperceptions with the public have about how this all works
  96. are they out there thinking this is entirely a rational process where we're just looking at the numbers and and
  97. weighing things and then making the decision well I think one of the one of the things you already touched upon is
  98. that sometimes people will see this and they say okay this the conclusion here is go with your gut right and that's not
  99. necessarily the main sort of take away that we would like God feeling and the investor gut feel is it's this very
  100. complicated sort of emotional cognitive sort of thing that's that's happening and so so that's one thing to kind of
  101. consider the other thing is that it tends to suggest that there's this um that that entrepreneurs can somehow game
  102. the system right that if you're able to present yourself in a certain way or caterer in a certain way that perhaps
  103. investors will then be somehow tricked into investing in you and so that's something that weird i'm doing a lot of
  104. follow-on research with some co-authors to look at you know the the influence of
  105. you know the the the impact of authenticity versus catering to what you think the investors want and lots of
  106. implications for could there could this introduce bias right if investors are investing based on what their gut feel
  107. is could this maybe be a a shroud for them than investing based on their own biases or their own sort of
  108. reasons that they can it's this cover for for how they're actually investing and so these are all things that that
  109. I'd like to continue looking at because I think they're important to uncover and
  110. how does your research differ from other research in this area you know I think a
  111. lot of the research that has looked at entrepreneurial finance and the way that investment investors make decisions has
  112. been very macro has been much more economically driven looking at these hard factors right and so this is really
  113. looking at those non codify factors these subtle signals and cues that are actually driving decision making and so
  114. a lot of times we look at these criteria and we're actually able to map them out
  115. and very quantifiably look at them and so what we're trying to do is really take gut feel and and this this perhaps
  116. nebulous concepts and quantify that and look at how are these how are these these subtle factors actually driving a
  117. very distinct process and you've alluded to a couple of areas that you're going to look at and actually we're to sum up
  118. what you're going to do next with this with this line of thinking yeah I think um you know I I'm really interested in
  119. all of these factors that are not necessarily these distinct factors that we typically think about so like I said
  120. these these subtle signals and cues and biases that might be driving important decisions and how that impacts both the
  121. decision-making as well as the ultimate outcomes thanks for coming in and drink so much thanks
  122. you

Brief Summary

Laura Wong discusses how angel investors rely on gut feel for investment decisions, balancing intuition with data in uncertain environments.

Key points

  • Investors Rely on Gut Feel. Laura Wong reveals that investors often trust their gut feelings over hard data.
  • The Surprising Role of Intuition. Wong discusses how gut feel can help identify profitable investments despite uncertainty.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes