Wind or Rain: Which is Worse?
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
The greatest challenge of disaster preparation is changing the biases that shape the way people prepare -- or cause them not to prepare -- for a particular hazard, Wharton research shows.
Read the full story: http://knlg.net/1mdJ0Ub 📂 Management 🏷️ Research
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- a lot of the work that I do and a lot of the work that we do at the the risk Center is involving help people make
- decisions to prepare for hazards whether it's an earthquake or a hurricane or or
- or also possibly um for example a possible terrorist attack and so forth and a lot of the work that I've been
- interested in in trying to do is try to figure out why people often make mistakes when doing these preparations
- uh a lot of times when we have disasters people come in after the fact and they say well if they had only done this and
- why did people leave their cars in a flood zone when they were given All These Warnings that floods were going to
- come in and so forth and basically what we found you know over a number of years
- and using a combination of field surveys and working with people in Laboratories
- and so forth uh is that effectively people kind of are suffered are subject to three major biases okay what one of
- which is and simply put there's a tendency to underappreciate the future or or too quick to remember the or too slow
- to remember the events that have negative happens in the past and the third one is if in doubt what often it
- happens is that people will follow the advice of other people who are no less prone to those sorts of mistakes than
- they are so a lot of which we're really interested in studying is why is it that
- people have Mak these mistakes why is it that they don't consider the future enough and why is it that they too
- quickly forget the past and why is it they just turn to other people that we if in doubt uh well the main thing that
- we find is that often for a lot of Hazards uh people have really bad mental models what we call them of how things
- are going to unfold so for example uh if A hurricane's coming in order for you to
- make a decision about how to prepare for it how many packs of batteries to get or
- or even whether or not I should evacuate uh what you have to do is sort of mentally reconstruct how is this event
- going to unfold before me okay is it how high is the water going to get when the
- wind comes how strong will the wind be and what is it going to do to my house and so forth and then what people have
- to do is sort of mentally simulate how this thing is going to unfold and then based on that make a decision about
- what's the right preparation to get like how many days am I going to need be possibly without power what we find out
- is that people often have very bad mental models they do that process very poorly so often what happens is that the
- that what they think is going to happen is often very different from what actually does happen um so for example
- in one of the things we found out in in a lot of studies we did uh of surveys we
- did of of Hurricane Sandy when it was approaching the coast uh was that people grossly underestimated a couple things
- uh one of which is how long the after effects of the storm are going to be uh often in the media coverage you would
- say well A hurricane's coming A hurricane's coming a hurricane is coming tonight and people kind of draw from
- that the inference that the the the thing that they have to worry about is getting through the night okay and and
- they have these images of them sitting in their home and winds swirling all around the roof blowing off and so forth
- the reality is in Sandy that was never really in the cards for most people okay what was in the cards particularly for
- people Inland was basically being without power for two weeks okay and uh and in that particular case so people
- were were all set to survive the night they had enough beer and they had enough pizza and they had enough snacks to get
- them through the storm event but they weren't really prepared for the two weeks afterwards um for example we found
- out beforehand we asked people do you have plans of where you would go if you have to evacuate um and often and we
- found out that only 23% of people that were located right along the immediate Coast in most in harmes way and Sandy
- made plans for what they would do if they had to evacuate one of the conclusions that
- that we got from a lot of the Sandy work for example was it just underscoring sort of how bad people's mental models
- were uh was people that lived right along the coast um really underestimated uh the degree to which
- the thing that they had to worry about was floods not W not uh not or water damage not necessarily wind damage um
- and in a lot of the the advisories and the warnings coming in they basically said well hurricane Sand's coming in if
- you live on the coast you should be worried about flooding and so forth because in some sense flooding is the
- thing that kills people in hurricanes generally not wind it's flood is the one that that's worth that's that's worse
- and and and yet when we talked to people that lived as close who as one half block from the water and we asked them
- what are you most worried about left but they stayed the basic problem is how do you
- get people to have a better mental model or be able to better mentally simulate what's going to happen to them so they
- can basically line up what's going to happen with them with how they're going to prepare for it uh and right now the
- real problem is um that people aren't getting very specific information about what's going to happen to them at their
- house um one of the things we found for example is that when hurricanes approach
- what people tend to do is they even people that normally sit around the internet and get all their information
- and and uh off of Twitter feeds and and Facebook and so forth what people tend to have a tendency to do is sit down and
- watch television uh watch uh The Weather Channel watch CNN and what they're getting is a very monolithic view of
- what's going to happen to the storm uh then in particular they if you're living in coastal New Jersey you see a
- broadcaster sitting in Central Park New York or the battery in New York and so you're not getting a real clear sense as
- to what's happening to you personally um so one of the challenges is that and I know that the National Hurricane Center
- and Noah in generally is sort of trying to do this is trying to find ways of communicating to people at specific
- locations what are the actual experiences that you're going you're going to get um another one which is
- also a really tough one to overcome uh is how do you get people to to uh appreciate the threat that water places
- uh like for example one thing we find is that uh people tend not to buy flood insurance okay people don't live in a
- flood area don't buy it okay and and that's uh FEMA has a real tough time trying to convince people to buy flood
- insurance because it's something that they have a difficult time imagining uh if you've been living in a place for a
- long time you've never seen water uh the the idea that that you might all of us your house might be underwater someday
- is a thing which is very very difficult to imagine um so and this is particularly the case in hurricanes
- where where usually when we talk about hurricanes you naturally think of a windstorm uh and in fact the naal
- Hurricane Center grades the severity of storms based on their category and the category is tied to wind speed so you're
- it's a cat 2 or a cat 3 um and so in the case of uh so what happens is is when people think of hurricane they naturally
- think hurricanes mean wind categories mean wind and they don't really think so much about water effects um and so one
- of the real challenges is how do you get that across to people and how do you try
- to correct for that um so for example a lot of the forecast will say something like um well for when this storm comes
- in there could be a 10-ft storm surge okay so but then you have to ask people how many people know how high up off sea
- level their house is no one knows that okay so it's hard to make the connection between that and uh and and what the
- personal impacts are going to be uh so that's that's a real challenge um uh and so I think that that one of the things
- to do would be to for the for Noah and was thinking about doing this is try to put ways of in their poast actually
- deemphasizing the attention which is given to the damage which is caused by wind and really focus a whole lot more
- on the personal damage that can happen through flooding and which is a tends thing that tends to be underestimated um
- another thing that often happens is is that when people are unsure what to do in a situation and they don't know which
- of several actions to take often what people do is they fall back to what psychologists called default biases uh
- and that is if you don't know what to do just do the thing that is easiest or the
- thing that you've been used to doing so if you think about it in the context of preparations uh what's the default bu
- well it's to do nothing you know it's just to stay at home it's not to go out and buy extra supplies and things like
- that so as and and often people kind of worry about well what if I take precautions and and nothing happens like
- if I go out and and they say I should fill up my whole house with water okay and I should get five cases of water to
- last me for two weeks and people are thinking through well you know how long is am I going to be without water well
- they tell me two weeks but it could be two days and I remember a time in the past when or last year when they came in
- and nothing happened and those and and after a while you just can't really make up a decision and so what ends up
- happening is people do nothing okay and so one of the possibilities is to think about ways of making prep preparation or
- making taking precautions to be the default action rather than uh uh rather than being the effortful action so for
- example um when of my colleagues at the whis center is sort of advocating one way to get people to make sure they
- renew their flood insurance is when you buy a home and if it's in a flood prone area uh that to make it like part of the
- mortgage so that every year you kind of naturally have to you have to renew it and it's not a decision you have to
- consciously make or uh or one idea that I've had is um uh that part of your your
- property taxes in a given year you automatically pay for a hurricane protection kit in flood in Hurricane
- prone areas where the community comes by and drops off a protection kit for you and then if you want they'll give you
- your money back if you don't want it and so therefore you have to consciously think rather than default being whether
- to take action the default is whether to not take action and I think that people
- would more more inclined to you be led to safety under that circumstance to me what's really
- interesting about um work and although a lot of the work just by convenience happens to be focused on Hurricane
- preparation because it's something we can study quite frequently a lot of the biases that we observe in the context of
- why people make mistakes preparing for hurricanes are really observed in a wide variety of other context um for example
- consider uh protection against terrorism um there's a great image that I think that going back to the uh the 9/11
- tragedies there's this famous picture of Muhammad ATA walking breezing by uh security at the Portland airport and
- there is you see this image of Muhammad ATA uh screaming by and there's a an attendant who's basically kind of like
- this at the uh at the counter basically letting this person go through and one and one of the difficulties there it
- sort of epitomizes one of the real problems that UR occur in trying to make protections to prepare against events
- that have occur with very very low frequency but occur but when they do happen have incredibly dramaic dramatic
- consequences is that most of the time we're reinforced for not doing anything okay that that the number of times that
- we're we're taking a lot of effortful action to protect against something the number of times that that that you ever
- actually going to encounter the disaster it was very very rare so you can think for example for someone who's an airport
- screener uh how often do they actually see a terrorist coming through it almost never happens and most of the time
- there's a natural tendency we we learn by trial and error and most of the time every time you put out this little
- effort that says let me work harder let me try to think harder let me put up more protection let me uh uh uh let me
- prepare for the storm or let me put about more effort to be more Vigilant against a possible terrorist attack
- every time you put all that effort most of the time it's not going to be rewarded most of the time it's going to
- be effort for nothing and that's often why uh why people princial cancel flood insurance because most of the time when
- they buy their flood insurance they write out a big check for it no flood next year they write out another big
- check no flood and all of a sudden they're thinking wow I could have used that money to buy a good TV you know it
- could have been for really good purposes and I'm I'm wasting it on flood insurance um uh that for example um
- after uh uh Hurricane Katrina to go back another another hurricane example um which was very Vivid in the press in
- terms of all the flooding that happened in New Orleans there was a significant increase in number of people
- they they see they understand that it's going that what the dangers are but somehow or another there's an instinct
- that says yeah that's going to happen but it's not going to happen to me I'm going to be the careful one it's going
- to happen to someone else and all of a sudden what ends up happening is then you have sort of the you know the
- accident and hopefully it's not a not a tragic consequence um and you know we see this sort of robustly across a BRI
- variety of different areas uh for things like terrorist attacks and um wildfly fires earthquakes hurricanes you name
- the disaster I think it's also reinforced from the fact that that how is it that people
- learn the consequences of these things well they don't learn them from things that have personally bad happened to
- them but they learn about them from seeing images of these things happening other places so for example when a When
- A hurricane's coming in or if I'm worried about an earthquake I've never seen an earthquake at my house but I've
- seen a lot of earthquakes over in Chile I've seen a lot of earthquakes in China and that's where earthquakes occur okay
- and so therefore you know I'm worried about earthquakes but when does happen I know where it's going to happen it's not
- going to be at my house it's going to be in uh you know far up in the North Bay Area it's going to happen in Chile it's
- going to happen in uh you know in Japan or in China I think we're actually a lot
- closer to that then because certainly right now the combination of high resolution satellite elevation data and
- block byblock uh uh information that certainly the data are out there that basically emergency planners do know
- that if if if a tide was to come up to a certain level they exactly know what will happen at a particular house they
- really have that information um and we know have an awful lot of data like that one of the problems is is how do you get
- that information and get it down to at least an individual who personally so that they kind of see the personal
- relevance and I think with um uh with apps with smartphone technology I think that that we're not that far away uh I
- think that often people may not respond to a generic message that says everyone in West Philadelphia should do this okay
- because because when you're thinking about what's going to happen you're going to think well it's not me in West
- Philadelphia it's this other person in West Philadelphia their house is the one that's going to be in danger but on the
- other hand if I get a a message that basically says me Robert Meyer this is a dedicated message for you uh that this
- is what's going to happen at your house at your particular address suddenly that
- takes on I can identify with that information a whole lot more and I understand it's not a generic message
- but it's speaking to me directly so I would like to think that we're actually much closer to that than than you might
- think the real challenge in trying to figure out how do you get uh better communication messages and and how do
- you study help people make preparation for for disasters and so forth is uh that there are not a lot of
- opportunities to study that in the real world you know fortunately uh we're not into a situation where Noah is going to
- run a controlled experiment where let's not warn some people and let's warn some
- other people and see what happens we obviously we can't do that uh so one of the things that that that I've been
- involved in a group that I'm a research group that I'm involved in is developing
- very realistic uh simulations in which you basically a person is put into a virtual living room and you have the
- opportunity to go turn on the television uh you can go to the web you can go out
- leave the house and talk to neighbors and so forth uh and the goal is is that in the that in the concept these
- simulations they can experience what for example would be a virtual hurricane coming in over a period of time and they
- get to watch the news the feeds as they change all hypothetically um and the the
- great thing about that is we can use that as a natural laboratory for testing well how would people's decisions in
- this realist simulated environment be CH be altered if we gave them different kinds of messages or if the tone of the
- TV broadcast was a little bit different or what happens if the people that they talk to were experts versus novices with
- respect to hurricanes these are sorts of things we can't run these controlled experiments in the uh in in the field
- the one thing that we've discovered though is one of the the natural reservations that you might have as well
- there's a real difference between sitting in a computer lab and responding to a hypothetical hurricane threat um uh
- versus actually experiencing hurricane or experiencing a real earthquake but what we find surprisingly is that the
- way in which people behave in these two environments is remarkably similar uh that that if you design these
- simulations realistically enough all their Natural Instincts for what they do when these things come in Kick in so for
- example when we had the simulation uh where you put in this virtual living room our our worry was that people would
- just try all different sorts of things in the living room that they wouldn't naturally do just because it's a
- simulation but we found for example was that in these hurricane simulations that
- what people tended to do was just turn on the TV okay and that's exactly what they do in real life and actually
- surprisingly they didn't do some of these things so when we kind of correlate uh the use utilization of
- media in the simulation with the utilization uh in the field which we observe in our hurricane studies there's
- a remarkable remarkable parallel and we see a lot of the same bias he coming up in one or the other so that gives us a
- lot of optimism that in fact we can start doing uh testing of of communication vehicles and so forth in
- in the lab which when hopefully we can take in the real world like for example you gave the example of uh you know can
- we do better individual targeting of of of impacts well one of the things we can
- do in our our simulations is they have a table that they can look at and there's
- a cell phone on sitting on the table and they can pick up the cell phone and one
- of the things we can do is manipulate the type of of message that's in that cell
- phone we're basically going to continue on a lot of what we're doing uh one of the things that we're actually
- interested in lately which is sort of um uh which is a a front burner item for a
- lot of people not only for people in Hazard preparation but also for people in businesses uh is how people are going
- to respond to climate change and uh one of a lot of the with the scientists are really uncertain as to uh uh how this
- will affect for example hurricane impacts frequency of tornadoes droughts and so forth but I think there is there
- is a general feeling that uh that things will be different in the future than they are now and a lot of um a lot of
- this U mitigation against climate change is something which requires both individuals and communities to make very
- large long-term Investments and uh and in protection like for example New York City after Sandy is thinking about what
- can we do to protect against sea level rise uh and the problem with sea level rise is the type of thing where in order
- to protect against it you're talking about not just putting up some sandbags but you're talking about major
- multi-billion Dollar in investments in infrastructure which are things which people don't really like communities
- don't like to do and unfortunately it's a type of thing when you look at the budget in a given year you say well you
- know we want to do it okay we want to be safe but in some sense we don't really have the money to do it this year we'll
- put it off to next year and then next year becomes the year after and the next year becomes after that and then
- eventually suddenly there's another Sandy comes in and there's another flood and so forth um and so one of the things
- we're interested in studying is how is it that that people in communities will adapt to um to to climate change in
- particular uh sea level rise and so forth and what are types of messages and types of things that you can do to get
- people to see the benefits of re of of Investments today against something that's really long term that in fact you
- may never even see the benefits of in your lifetime and that as hard as it is to get people to uh to take actions to
- prepare against immediate threats like hurricanes as you might imagine getting people to see the the benefits in inv in
- taking protections against sea level rise or or or global warming is much much harder but that's sort of the the
- big thing that's on our plate [Music] now
Brief Summary
Robert Meyer discusses biases in disaster preparedness and the importance of effective communication for better decision-making during hazards.
Key points
- Understanding Disaster Preparedness. Exploring why people make mistakes in disaster preparations and how biases affect their decisions.
- The Challenge of Mental Models. Discussing the difficulties in getting people to accurately simulate disaster scenarios in their minds.
- The Impact of Hurricane Sandy. Analyzing how people's perceptions of hurricane threats can lead to inadequate preparations.
- The Challenge of Sea Level Rise. Addressing sea level rise requires long-term planning and community commitment.
- Investing in Climate Change Mitigation. Communities must make significant investments to protect against climate change impacts.
Episode highlights
- Understanding Disaster PreparednessExploring why people make mistakes in disaster preparations and how biases affect their decisions.“People often underestimate the future and forget the past.”0:49Jul 7, 2014
- The Challenge of Mental ModelsDiscussing the difficulties in getting people to accurately simulate disaster scenarios in their minds.“How do you get people to have a better mental model?”5:37Jul 7, 2014
- The Impact of Hurricane SandyAnalyzing how people's perceptions of hurricane threats can lead to inadequate preparations.“Most of the time, effortful action to protect is not rewarded.”11:44Jul 7, 2014
- The Challenge of Sea Level RiseAddressing sea level rise requires long-term planning and community commitment.“People don’t really like to invest in long-term protections.”20:24Jul 7, 2014
- Investing in Climate Change MitigationCommunities must make significant investments to protect against climate change impacts.“Major multi-billion dollar investments are necessary for protection.”20:31Jul 7, 2014
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





