Going Local Before Going Global

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Can penetrating domestic rural markets help local firms in China capture revenues from foreign competitors and also enter markets abroad?

Read the fully story: http://knlg.net/1j9WNIr 📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. the type the title is motivated by the directionality the idea that by going into otherwise inaccessible regions of
  2. country you can capture revenues from abroad that's the unusual idea for companies
  3. the paper poses both opportunities and challenges the opportunity in china is this you too
  4. can rent the higher channel and it might be a very efficient thing to do rather than to try to establish
  5. independent distribution networks their costs and their risks but it's an option
  6. for those seeking to emulate higher in china it's a real challenge because first
  7. mover advantages are dramatic and hires market share in the countryside is very high
  8. for companies seeking to emulate higher outside of china that's where the ball game becomes very
  9. interesting who will be the first for example to do the same let's go back into you
  10. who will be the first to do the same in other regions will this also be a chinese export
  11. or will domestic companies given the home team advantage figure out the path to the countryside
  12. and rent it out to others as higher as done in china only time will tell the idea
  13. came from meeting the team that designed the rural distribution system for the higher group
  14. i think i met them in qingdao in july 2010 had i known this question were coming i
  15. might have brought a picture of the team but for their leader they were all youngsters in their 20s
  16. and they described to me how very powerful team incentives part of the higher management system
  17. motivated them to rethink entirely rural distribution in china and they asked what in retrospect are the obvious
  18. questions what are we doing why are we doing it which almost no one had asked because the
  19. traditional 5000 year old system had hardly changed what are the alternatives to it
  20. and what they discovered through very careful analysis was that at a certain scale
  21. it became much more efficient to substitute a circular for a radial distribution
  22. system and once they had that idea the rest was easy implementation of course was not easy
  23. but conceptually the redesign was easy so i was totally taken with this and i put it in my
  24. back pocket then the idea came to fruition however um when i went back re-read and re-thought
  25. the 2008 paper with max wazeau that's uh mentioned here um and i did so um sadly
  26. in the context of uh writing a chapter for a book in memory of max max passed away a few years ago
  27. and his friends colleagues decided to put together a volume to honor his enormous contribution in
  28. many fields and that forced me to rethink the earlier paper and the rethink is there out loud
  29. in the manuscript you've got in front of you so it's a combination of two things
  30. one is meeting the team very very important understanding their process and then second
  31. being asked to rethink a paper published in 2008 really written in 2006 and that rethinking then brought the
  32. conclusions you see well they're they're kind of two methods method number one is boots on the ground
  33. quite apart from interviewing the team i went out into the countryside of china and
  34. watched the distribution system watch these teams at work and i've done so as recently as march
  35. whenever i get to china whenever there's the opportunity i don't have to go very far inland but
  36. i'll go out into the rural counties of qingdao into the rural counties in southern jiangsu province
  37. even the rural counties around beijing which can be very very poor by the way and
  38. observe how the goods are distributed how they're sold it's the combination of these
  39. direct observations and repeated observations i typically go back to the same sites
  40. uh to judge change over time uh the combination of repeated field observation with uh meeting the teams
  41. then with introspection with thinking about it that produces this result now i'm going to use your question as a
  42. lever for telling you some of the developments that have happened and i want to tell you about
  43. one merchant in rural qingdao about an hour away from the metropolitan area whom i visited now three or four times
  44. because it's convenient his name is huang there are lots of people nippong in china
  45. um he's from the villages of china a village near qingdao um and he's a very plain man
  46. even today in the summertime at least he still wears sandals not shoes he started
  47. a small business with an investment maybe sixty thousand rmb less than ten thousand dollars at the
  48. time it was a town level store um where he made large appliances even small electronics
  49. available to local residents and he's gained enormously from this distribution system because he
  50. doesn't have to keep much inventory doesn't have to tie up money and inventory and doesn't have to tie up
  51. time as mentioned in the paper in going to the county level city to make the purchases but here's the
  52. part that i found so interesting first of all doesn't compete on price i've watched customers come and go
  53. and i've watched him refuse to drop prices all maybe some small you know gift he would add in but
  54. no major drop in prices he does compete on service usually the deal is tell you what
  55. if you're able to make this purchase today it's a refrigerator sometimes it could be two one for mother-in-law
  56. i'll put them on the back of my truck right now we'll take them to your house and you'll
  57. get a free ride home and that often clinches the deal but beyond this he's developed a network of
  58. representatives of coordinators in the small villages and so the villagers only 10 minutes
  59. away or so but they'll collectively make a trip to town to visit his store and that business has grown to the point
  60. where now he has opened outlets in the villages and last time i got to see the first of them
  61. about the size of this room not much larger oh maybe twice the size of the roof not huge very plain very plain
  62. merchandise but there you have it he's created a second business will create a third
  63. business and his business has grown dramatically as the result of the distribution
  64. information systems described in the paper a complicated question there are a couple of answers
  65. one is just arithmetic if you have a first mover advantage as higher has in china's rural markets
  66. then you can rent the highway the higher highway out to other firms including your direct
  67. competitors and you can extract not only highway tolls but you can gain further revenues
  68. through providing service that again the foreign competitors aren't able uh to uh provide
  69. so uh what you're doing is you're capturing uh at least one end of what is it called
  70. the smile curve from stanchia you're capturing distribution and service revenues and profits which can
  71. actually be much greater than manufacturing profits and in this sense you're taking money
  72. uh away from your foreign competitors it's not acquiring revenue abroad but it's
  73. acquiring revenue domestically that might otherwise go to foreign competitors now the larger question and it's a
  74. trickier question is whether the capability the rural distribution capability at home is transferable abroad
  75. and quite frankly i don't yet know the answer to that question and why is that it's because
  76. china is unusual any country that size china india going to be unusual have unique
  77. characteristics but in china's case and i think a little bit in contrast to india
  78. the physical infrastructure is fairly well developed and so it's easy to roll the trucks
  79. in a way that is or it seems easy i should say to roll the trucks in a way that is
  80. efficient um in fact in china as it noted the paper in the paper very few chinese firms have
  81. taken advantage of these potential efficiencies um it's simply the result of tradition
  82. it's the result of having small and fragmented markets and it's you know it it just takes a while before
  83. there's break breakthrough thinking uh about distribution in china but once the breakthrough thinking occurs
  84. then it's possible to actually implement this thinking given that the asphalt's all in place
  85. and large efficient trucks can be moved around with a day's worth of distribution for many many outlets
  86. you know china could be different i mean india i'm sorry could be different uh and that's because it's my sense that
  87. the the highway system is not as well developed and so implementation of a similar platform
  88. in india may prove difficult that said the success in china i think might motivate haier or hires
  89. competitors in india to try to do the same somehow it's it's incredibly relevant for
  90. alibaba um you've probably read that alibaba new technology has just made a 360 million dollar investment
  91. in a joint venture with higher hull technology the new requires the old to move the goods
  92. and so the intent of the joint venture is to open distribution for all large goods including furniture
  93. sold over taobao timal by alibaba uh into the countryside of china the joint ventures in its early
  94. stages who can guess what the success will be but uh it's yes it's it's it's very very
  95. relevant it will be really interesting to see i'm not expert really on other countries
  96. so it's hard for me to sit here and say what the rural distribution issues in india
  97. in latin america in sub-saharan africa alike my guess is that the economies especially sub-saharan africa
  98. look not only a lot like china but maybe an exaggerated version of china where you have prosperity in the port cities
  99. and much less development in the hinterlands and the question is the role of physical
  100. infrastructure in opening distribution there circumvent the problems of physical
  101. infrastructure or correct those problems and then yes the higher model has enormous
  102. applicability outside of the chinese context and so that turns then to the question of hires
  103. strategy is there strategy to make more refrigerators at a time when manufacturing is becoming
  104. something of a commodity and becomes very portable or is the strategy again to hit the two ends of the smile kerf
  105. one side design the other side distribution and service where the money is and if so
  106. will they decide to roll up their sleeves and try to do in other countries what they've done in china
  107. i don't know the answer to that i've raised the question with them and quite frankly
  108. the senior managers when they hear the question at first almost almost don't grasp it
  109. and because they have so focused of course on china as the base of their operations
  110. my bet however um is that they'll try my bet is that they'll do so in a small country i
  111. can't name a country and they'll do so following their general model of internationalization remember the
  112. history they were they were offered they almost had the right of first refusal on maytag
  113. in the united states they wouldn't do it for many reasons in part it was at the time in the
  114. history when they were less confident than they are now they were smaller they were less confident but there are other
  115. reasons as well one of their key western acquisitions has been fisher and pakel new
  116. zealand-based high-end appliance company great brand okay but they're acquiring it in part for the
  117. technology they have advanced technology they're inquiring it in part because new zealand's a small country
  118. it's a great country but it's a small country and it may be a very good place for hire to learn a lot more about
  119. western markets at lower cost than a larger country like the us so my guess would be
  120. if they try to port their system their distribution system outside of china likely sub-saharan africa like likely a
  121. smaller country and likely a learning experience for them how it will come out who can guess at this time
  122. the most surprising piece here um um for a person brought up in this culture is the speed with which
  123. organizational innovation takes place it's almost as if the org chart changes every saturday
  124. morning when the senior management meets i attempt to learn something i try to grasp it i try to get the details
  125. the ink is dry on paper almost and there's version two version three version four
  126. that's the nature of the management process in china and it makes research as we know it
  127. as western scholars know it a little bit challenging because we want to get data
  128. we want to get quote hard data nail down the facts in china those facts are always shifting on you
  129. because everything's experimental it's a highly decentralized system and if you're lucky you'll get a first
  130. approximation so this paper for example i can't guarantee it's accuracy at the time it's printed
  131. it may have all changed by then maybe that should be an asterisk at the very beginning i don't know
  132. but that that's that's the biggest surprise over the last five or six years there are a couple things possible
  133. i think the immediate piece of research will be more microscopic to go into the teams
  134. to observe the teams even more closely and to ask a question that's a little different than the question
  135. posed in this paper in the paper you got mucho the proposition is that a firm may effectively internationalize
  136. by developing otherwise impenetrable domestic markets opening access to those markets to foreign
  137. companies we can certainly observe the progress of the system the sustainability of this system
  138. and the based on the analyst reports it looks like it's doing pretty well certainly heyers performance
  139. has jumped dramatically uh from 2012 to 2013 and a time when its main domestic competitors haven't done
  140. quite so well but there's another issue i think needs to be explored the paper described brief describes
  141. briefly the team structure of higher the so-called zzjyts that operate as if they're standalone
  142. businesses even though they're very very small 12 13 people perhaps the question is whether
  143. these teams become even more independent of the center of higher some instances already
  144. they the teams do internal m a one team will literally acquire another through an
  145. internal bidding process sometimes they do joint ventures with their distributors with their
  146. retailers they have partial hr function at this point i mentioned hiring village
  147. coordinators to you some have begun to spin out of higher and become totally independent legal entities still within
  148. the family but legally separate and so the big question i want to research is whether
  149. this is the future of capitalism of china are we going to see the devolution of the firm
  150. our standard theories going back many many years alfred chandler the historian oliver
  151. williamson the theorist of transaction cost economics talk about the integration of the firm
  152. from market to hierarchy but my question is whether in china they're going to ultimately solve the
  153. problem of enterprise reform which has proved intractable quite frankly by reversing this process
  154. by going from hierarchy to market by spinning out of large organizations whether or not
  155. state-owned higher is not state-owned by spinning out of large organizations little pieces
  156. and by having these pieces become the central economic actors uh in the marketplace of china i don't know the
  157. answer to that but i think it's a fundamental question and it has to be pursued given china's highly fragmented market
  158. structure which i don't think will change fundamentally despite a rail system despite a highway
  159. system it's entirely possible that rather from market to hierarchy you'll see china go from hierarchy to
  160. market as a solution to many many problems you

Brief Summary

Haier's rural distribution model in China offers insights for international markets and raises questions about the future of capitalism in China.

Key points

  • The Unusual Idea. The paper poses both opportunities and challenges for companies in China.
  • Rethinking Distribution. The speaker reflects on the evolution of rural distribution in China.
  • Huang's Success Story. Huang, a merchant in rural Qingdao, thrives by focusing on service over price.
  • The Future of Distribution. Questions arise about the transferability of China's rural distribution model abroad.
  • The Speed of Innovation. Organizational innovation in China happens at a remarkable pace.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes