Bain & Company's Rob Markey on 'The Ultimate Question 2.0': Would Your Customers Recommend You?
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
KNOWLEDGE@WHARTON ARCHIVES: Fred Reichheld and Rob Markey's The Ultimate Question 2.0 is a follow-up to the bestselling book that first helped businesses understand their Net Promoter Score. One question -- would you recommend us to a friend? -- offered businesses a vital metric that has since been adopted widely by organizations, including GE. Wharton marketing professor Peter Fader spoke with Markey about what NPS is, how companies can increase the number of people who promote them and why it is now a system and not just a score. More on this interview: https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/the-ultimate-question-would-your-customers-recommend-you/
#customerservice #customerrelationshipmanagement #businessgrowth 📂 Marketing
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- [Music] this is Pete fader from the marketing department at the Wharton School of the
- University of Pennsylvania and I'm here today with Rob Mary from Bane Consulting
- to talk about his new book The Ultimate question 2.0 Rob it's great to have you with us thanks Pete it's great to be
- here before we jump in and talk about the book first can you tell us what all this NPS stuff is all about those three
- letters are on everyone's mind these days a lot of businesses are being run by them so before we talk about the
- implications of it tell us what NPS stands for well NPS uh originally when we started it stood for the net promoter
- score and it was designed as a way to help you know marketers operations folks call center
- operators um Business Leaders figure out the extent to which they were really meeting their objective of earning the
- Loyalty of their customers and the way that you get your net promoter score is that you ask this
- one simple question How likely would you be to recommend my company my product my
- service to your friends your colleagues your family members and based on the answer to that
- question we can then sort customers into promoters the people who are enthusiastically loyal to your brand
- your company your product and are out there telling all their friends and personally buying more staying longer
- you know helping build your business the passives people who are you know passively positive they think your stuff
- is okay and then the the worst group the detractors people who just really dislike doing business with you they
- would leave if they had a choice um they tell their friends how terrible it is to
- work with you and you get your net promoter score by taking those promoters and you and subtracting out the
- detractors to get that Net score and so the research that you've been involved with and Fred reld has done uh both in
- the current book and the previous book has has shown that this NPS score has just some amazing associations with
- other more bottom line oriented business metrics tell us about those well the essence of it boils down to the fact
- that individual customers behave consistently with the designation promoter passive detractor so if you
- were a promoter you'd be buying more staying longer telling your friends building the business and the detractor
- doing just the opposite that's that's the foundation on top of that what we discovered is that
- if you aggregate all the promoters and detractors and create that Net score and then compare one company's score to
- another company score in the same industry in the same Market you'll find that the the one that has a higher score
- score tends to outgrow the one with the lower score and in fact the net promoter
- score leader in an industry in a market tends to outgrow its competitors by a factor of more than two and a half to
- one so that that right there actually was the thing that started to really um make this catch on because people
- understood suddenly if I can grow my net promoter score then I can get more customers to stay longer buy more tell
- their friends I can outgrow my competitors and I can even in some cases achieve a cost Advantage MH now before
- we move on from net promoter score to net promoter system I have to admit my initial bias my skepticism uh as a
- marketing professor as someone who focuses on measurement when it first came out my reaction was it's it's too
- simple and knowing that there are so many uh uh colleagues in the field and other companies who have been working on
- very similar kinds of measurement issues but capturing for instance the multi-dimensional aspect to satisfaction
- or loyalty my reaction was you can't boil it all down to one thing and have it work for you so your reaction to that
- well you can't actually the the truth is that the net promoter score is designed
- to be radically simple not because it's statistically better but instead because
- it's statistically fine and that Simplicity appeals to Frontline employees and even CEOs can understand
- it m so this designation promoter passive of detractor based on one question it's a simplifying construct
- that helps motivate inspire people to want to create more promoters and fewer detractors if you really wanted a
- statistically robust thing that was far you know that all it was was about the statistically um accurate correlations
- you'd always go for more questions MH but what we found is that there's about a 10 or 15% Improvement by adding more
- questions in terms of statistical accuracy but it tremendously degrades your ability to
- motivate the organization to take action because then you get into these debates
- well what are the questions that are part of the index and how are they weighted and I don't know maybe that
- question isn't relevant for my business and then you you end up debating the score and not actually focusing on what
- matters which is getting your customers to stay longer buy more and tell their friends and indeed what you just
- described as very consistent with the academic research which shows that a a richer multi-dimensional scale can be
- say 10 to 15% better um but that this this this one question this ultimate question really is good enough so in the
- academic Community it's kind of a half full half empty I'm I'm a half full kind of guy saying give me a measure that's
- good enough one that that managers can actually appreciate understand Implement uh spread throughout the organization uh
- and it it raises the whole idea of of measurement and understanding customer differences to a level that we've never
- seen before in any organization well we're proud of what we've been able to accomplish from a practical perspective
- with net promoter score um I think what motivated us to start thinking about NPS
- those three letters as standing for the net promoter system was that um the appeal of this radically simple approach
- actually got you know just like just like happened with um Six Sigma or happen with other management tools some
- companies were using it really well and other companies honestly all they were doing is calculating a score and then it
- wasn't impacting their business and they were saying well we're not getting any impact here why you know we're measuring
- what's going on and the um that frustration that they felt and that we felt watching them led us down this path
- of trying to discover what are the differences between the companies that are getting real impact and the
- companies that are failing m and that led to this Insight that there are these three things that the
- successes are doing that the failures aren't and that was the the foundation of the net promoter system so let's hear
- about them okay well the the first one is that the the companies that were doing really well had a really robust
- and thorough way of collecting the data to create a a reliable score a reliable outcome metric you know the foundation
- of the application of this was built out in some ways at GE where they were trying to apply Six Sigma to service
- operations and sales and they you can't apply Six Sigma unless you have a reliable way of identifying a defect and
- a success and net promoter became that that outcome metric for them well if the fundamental outcome metric is unreliable
- because you fail to sample appropriately or because you're asking the question in
- a way that frames it with prior question or because you're inconsistent about the
- uh set of set of uh product Services you know you have no basis for making decisions about where the defects
- lie and where the opportunities are to create promoters so foundationally number one
- robust robust score number two and this is maybe most important the successes were using the the feedback that came
- out of net promoter as the basis for fast cycle closed loop learning action and and um uh service recovery so
- instead of just treating this as a score to calculate and something to measure they were actually turning it into an
- operational functional uh part of their business they take the feedback directly
- from a customer give it within 24 hours to the employee who had been most responsible for creating the outcome
- and then Coach them on how to improve so that timing is important because I if I
- if I'm your the person serving you I can remember the interaction we had that created your feedback as opposed to what
- we traditionally do where we we aggregate months of data give a an employee like an average score and say
- okay improve so this this closed loop became the the second thing we discovered and
- then the third in a way it's um it it's it sounds so trite and obvious but the companies
- that were successful they believe deeply from the senior leadership on down that earning
- the Loyalty of their customers was really critically important to their business
- strategy that that was how they were going to grow profitably and the score was a way of the and the system were a
- way of of helping achieve that objective the failures almost invariably they set
- a goal on a on a number hey we want to we want our net promoter score to be higher than it is today or we want to
- earn the JD power award and then they delegated it to like the head of service or somebody deep in
- the organization and said okay go do that and tell me how it goes so for those firms that really embrace it as
- you just said there's going to be more broader more fundamental organizational changes tell us how companies have
- realigned themselves around that promoter system oh it's a big deal it actually what sounds so simple this
- sorting your customers into promoters passive detractors turns out in practice to have profound impacts for your
- culture the way you organize the processes that by which you run the business so as an example um you've got
- in most of the companies that are doing this really well this infrastructure data infrastructure um Financial
- infrastructure to help figure out which customers are promoters and passives and
- detractors take action against that and figure out what the value would be of improving you know of of turning a a
- detractor into a promoter or to Turning hundreds or thousands of customers from detractors into promoters um you end up
- having the the guys in product development suddenly changing the way that they think about success instead of
- just getting the product launch out and having lots of initial sales to the channel they now not only have to have
- lots of initial sales but they have to have night High net promoter score in fact at at Logitech at Logitech um each
- SU excessive uh product release has to be has to have a higher net promoter score than the one before it or it into
- it they do the same thing and it it actually changes their perspective in in the development of new products so going
- one step further so not only is it going to realign a company to do what it does
- better I'm interested in in the Step Beyond that so as you know I have a recent book on customer centricity
- saying that companies need to be following a a a fundamentally different strategy uh let's sort out different
- kinds of customers the good from the bad and realign everything we do for from product development uh on on down around
- the better kinds of customers are we seeing fundamental shifts in strategy as people have something like NPS to guide
- them we are although I would say that the companies that are successful actually start with with the principles
- that you're talking about Pete um net promoter system works best when it's embedded in a culture in a company that
- fundamentally believes that earning more loyalty from the profitable customers is
- the Strategic outcome that they're trying to create and the net promoter system helps provide guidance about
- where to focus what actions to take to get there and how to help individual employees tens hundreds thousands of
- individual employees align their actions around that objective but that doesn't substitute
- for business strategy and what you're talking about and I I love your your new book what what you're talking about
- there is the the more fundamental question well which customers loyalty should I be striving to to earn because
- they are the ones that offer the greatest potential in the marketplace and because my company has skills
- capabilities um Market position that allow us to be more successful with that that group of customers great so
- thinking about the future we've gone from net promoter score a particular measurement device to net promoter
- system a broader system to help companies better appreciate and leverage uh what they got out of that score uh I
- know that the book is new you're you're out there uh trying to get more companies to fully understand what this
- new NPS is all about but thinking ahead two three years what's next what's the next level to add to it I think you're
- going to see two two big areas of focus from us and from our clients the members
- of The NPS loyalty Forum one um over the last few years we haven't written a lot
- about it but we we we mentioned it in the book significantly more focus on this linkage between employee advocacy and
- customer advocacy the recognizing that it is very hard to sustain high levels of customer focus of customer centricity
- of customer advocacy unless you have also earned the same thing from your own employees and that there are specific
- things that you can do on the employee advocacy side that lend themselves more to custom Custer advocacy so that's one
- and then the second one is around Innovation and design for Delight as some people call it or um the process of
- Designing products Services value propositions that will differentially create promoters I think in the early
- days because partly because its foundation was like a GE with Six Sigma defect elimination a lot of the emphasis
- was on rooting out those defects the things that create detractors and now we are spending a lot more of our energy
- around the things that you can do to create promoters and even to what we call activate promoters give your
- promoters a voice give them a story to tell a reason to get excited about talking to their friends about your
- company well I'm excited to talk to you rob uh want to encourage everyone to take a look at ultimate question 2.0
- it's been a pleasure having Rob Mary here with us today thank you very much thanks Pete
- [Music]
Brief Summary
Rob Mary discusses Net Promoter Score and its impact on customer loyalty in his book <i>The Ultimate Question 2.0</i>.
Key points
- Understanding NPS. NPS stands for Net Promoter Score, a metric for customer loyalty.
- The Impact of NPS. Companies with higher NPS scores tend to outgrow their competitors significantly.
- Transition to Net Promoter System. The shift from NPS to a broader Net Promoter System emphasizes actionable insights.
Episode highlights
- Understanding NPSNPS stands for Net Promoter Score, a metric for customer loyalty.“How likely would you recommend my company?”1:14Nov 21, 2011
- The Impact of NPSCompanies with higher NPS scores tend to outgrow their competitors significantly.“Outgrow competitors by a factor of more than two and a half to one.”3:10Nov 21, 2011
- Transition to Net Promoter SystemThe shift from NPS to a broader Net Promoter System emphasizes actionable insights.“The appeal of this radically simple approach.”6:17Nov 21, 2011





