The Job of Change

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Studies put the failure rate of organizational change at 70% or higher. Yet, managers face increasing pressure to implement change to meet short- and long-term goals. Gregory P. Shea and Cassie A. Solomon share their approach to dealing with this challenge in Leading Successful Change: 8 Keys to Making Change Work. Jeff Klein, director of the Wharton Graduate Leadership Program, recently spoke with the authors about why we are not as good at change as we need to be, and how we can get better at it. πŸ“‚ Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. [Music] [Music] Uh we're here today with Greg Sheay and Cassie Solomon to discuss their new book
  2. uh leading successful change. Greg, Cassie, thanks for being with us today. My pleasure. Thanks, Jeeoff. So, you
  3. start off the book and you begin with a bit of a paradox. You say we live in a world of permanent change. our main jobs
  4. are change yet most organizational efforts to succeed with change fail. Uh can you talk about that a little bit? So
  5. I think part of the challenge of being where we are uh just in the history of the planet let alone the history of of
  6. of business or modern organizations is that we're in a place that much of the change that is occurring is simply
  7. picking up speed for any number of reasons from advances in technology the autoc catalytic nature of that of that
  8. change changes in the financial market uh changes in globalization that it just has become a more and more turbulent uh
  9. turbulent environment. that we're in. So that precipitates more and more change,
  10. which exposes us to what we don't do particularly well, which is to do that not just uh in a one-off fashion, but to
  11. do that repeatedly. So uh the pressure to get good at it shows us what we don't do particularly well, which is we're not
  12. as good as we need to be at it. uh and I think that uh that that pressure is actually a skill that people in
  13. organizations including leaders but not limited to leaders have to pay conscious
  14. attention to. This is a key skill. In fact, one can argue uh that it's the key skill for people is uh we assume that
  15. you can do the parts of your job that used to constitute your job namely keeping the place running. Uh but today
  16. people assume that and the rest of it is what are you doing about and whether it's installation of a of a of a new
  17. information system have you made have you dealt with changing markets have you been able to open or close parts of of
  18. of your organization new parts of the organization reach to new parts of new markets? Have you been able to adjust to
  19. changes in the workforce? All of those things end up being how we often think about a person's job. We assume the
  20. other stuff. So all the the change piece has become more prominent. One can argue
  21. it's your real job. Uh but we're not uh what we're exposing is that we're not particularly good at it particularly
  22. when we're talking about being able to do it agile. Uh do it in a way that's sustainable. Uh do it over time, do it
  23. repeatedly. So I think it's an outside pressure is is uh providing the occasion for us to see our limits in terms of of
  24. doing this doing J. Interesting. Interesting. And in the book you talk about the lead dog myth uh and the role
  25. of a a leader or or maybe the myth of a leader within change efforts. Um what is
  26. the lead dog myth and and how can leaders uh avoid falling into that kind of trap? Well, let me take a shot at
  27. this and then I'm sure Cassie you have something to something to add. uh there's there's a way in which uh we
  28. tend to over overcribe in general uh what may be a indication of a system to the characteristics of an individual. So
  29. this is a particular example of something that's I think is a broader phenomena. So we look at well if it
  30. didn't work it must be either because you as the follower weren't motivated or it must be because you as a leader were
  31. not inspirational. uh what we know is that yes that can be part of it and there's a wide literature
  32. about how to how to go about leading change in the sense of inspiration, communication, etc. And I'm not trying
  33. to say that's not important. However, in the end, human beings are much better at
  34. adapting to a changed environment than they are to try and be pushed into into change. And we underattend to that. So
  35. when we say it's all about the lead dog, that myth is that well if you don't see
  36. good change either you've got a problem with the lead or you got a problem with the follower suggests that really in the
  37. spirit of uh and then in the tradition of systems thinking which key parts of it came out of Wharton, Eric Trist, Fred
  38. Emory uh that that if you think about it from a system standpoint, the place to start is not at the at the at the leader
  39. or follower. It's to say, what's the environment that you want to set around people that would make a certain set of
  40. behaviors make sense to them? Because human beings do well much better at adapting to environments than they do
  41. being told to change in a way that may or may not make sense with what the world around them, their workspace,
  42. their strategic business unit, their service line indicates that they should act. So, you tell them one thing, uh the
  43. world around them tells them another thing. People are pretty intelligent. They'll go, "Well, you'll come and go,
  44. but the world that's immediately around me, my reward system, measurement system, uh, they're telling me to do
  45. something else." Uh, so they'll do the something they'll they'll do the something else. And so I think we we
  46. underattend to that. And that's part of the reason, back to your first question,
  47. that our record for change is not so good. So we we put too much on the individual. Whereas I' I'd suggest and
  48. Cassie uh and I in our book suggest that it's far more useful to think about the
  49. work of leadership as a critical part of that is including how you're going to design the work systems or the
  50. environment around people to make the kinds of behavior that you want to see make sense to them. That's a key part of
  51. leadership. If you don't do that, what you do as a leader is you're pushing against what might make sense to people
  52. dayto day. And that's not only not going to work very well, hence the numbers that you quoted at the beginning, but
  53. it's also going to create a strain and even break your relationship with your followers.
  54. So, I just want to I want to sort of add to that from a different perspective. I
  55. think this is a very accessible uh set of ideas. So, think about I'm going to change my behavior. I'm going to go off
  56. to a productivity training or a time management seminar. And you can feel very inspired and and motivated and you
  57. know make all kinds of resolutions. This is right in line with the New Year's resolutions research and coming out of
  58. the box you feel like I have changed something inside of me because I've learned and I'm motivated and we know
  59. because of research that it doesn't it doesn't last. And the most dramatic example of this I think and it's in the
  60. book is people who are recovering from bypass surgery. Now you think someone has just sawed your chest open, right?
  61. And you're motivated to change your lifestyle. But the statistics are extraordinary. It's like 94% of people
  62. don't make those changes. So it we believe it's really not about getting better at motivating. It's not the
  63. charismatic leader who can convey a sense of urgency. You don't explain the threat to your workforce. This is where
  64. burning platform stuff can come in because you can you can have those dramatic experiences and still step
  65. back. You know, there's been a kickoff. You've launched an initiative. You've poured yourself into explaining
  66. charismatically why everything needs to be different and it's, you know, the middle of February and you've forgotten
  67. it was the New Year's resolution that was just left by the wayside. So, becoming more of a designer of the
  68. environment. So using the same examples, how do I design the environment around myself to change my behaviors for time
  69. management? How do I design the bypass patients environment so that it's easy for them to make the lifestyle changes?
  70. That that's a different approach. It's a very different way of looking at change.
  71. And people get really excited when they when they learn it. They're like, "Yeah,
  72. I get it." Because we've all experienced this even in our own in our own lives. Sure. and it can connect back to our
  73. personal our personal experiences. A as I think about the work systems model that you've laid out then
  74. is part of the implication that bold change um might have better success if you had a choice between setting up
  75. more dramatic change and doing it in a way that you can line up enough of the environment around people that it makes
  76. sense to take the the bold move. that's more likely to be successful, we'd argue, than a change that was a much
  77. more limited change, but you only change one aspect of of the environment. Uh, and so people say, well, it that seems
  78. irrelevant to me actually. Why would I pay attention to that piece that you want to do? So, uh it's it certainly is
  79. conceivable uh that bold change could be easier if you can do the work that you need to work to do to get the the
  80. environment around it around the individuals to change enough so it makes sense for them to engage in what you're
  81. looking for them to to do. And can I just add because this is a point you made earlier with me which I love which
  82. is it's got to be bold and aligned. So I think we we often find ourselves called
  83. in. I'm thinking of these as like change management turnaround situations. And you've got this silo saying, "Oh, we're
  84. going to have this bold change and this new technology. This is a bold change." If these things are, it's cancelelling
  85. each other out like a signal and noise problem. Just being bold is not the answer. It's thinking about a coherent
  86. and aligned system that drives change. We actually fall into a trap. I think u uh regularly in that in order to try to
  87. make the change quote more manageable we do make it smaller when in fact we miss
  88. the point about what the actual change is. So uh a typical or a common example I should say of that is there's some new
  89. software perhaps business enterprise software that people want to install and the change gets defined as simply about
  90. the software. Well, that's seems like it's big enough, but actually that's not big enough because the change really is
  91. you want a set of people making a different set of decisions using a different kind of information with a
  92. different set of objectives with a different kind of collaboration using different skills that happen to be
  93. connected with the installation of this new information system. And that's actually feels like a bigger change. But
  94. for for the tens or hundreds of millions of dollars you're putting into the the software, you actually should be
  95. thinking about the change bigger. Because if you think about smaller, what you're going to get is 10% of the
  96. functionality is going to get used about the software system. People aren't going
  97. to see why they should change their behavior. They're simply going to be compliant to the where what to really
  98. we're trying to do is change patterns of behavior inside the organization. So bigger in that case could very likely be
  99. more likely to be successful than smaller in that case. Right. And the work systems model that you present in
  100. the book gives readers an opportunity uh to look across those set of factors. Right. Right. Right. And we use it we
  101. use it to design with with groups and sit down and say all right you know tell us what it is you want to see and then
  102. use this almost as a checklist. You know design with all of these elements. so that it's coherent. Um, and it's people
  103. understand it once they've learned it and they they sit back and come out with pretty radical things actually. And and
  104. so I think that the way one way to think about the book is it's both a framework
  105. which we've been talking about as well as a technique which we try to be specific enough in the book so that both
  106. are accessible. So how you think about it as well as how you would do it, right? And and part of that technique
  107. and maybe I can ask you to describe this uh briefly now. part of that technique is about really envisioning what the
  108. future looks like and importantly the set of behaviors that are occurring in the future. Um, what advice would you
  109. have uh for a reader who's trying to put him or herself that that far into the future? Well, again, let me take a cut
  110. at this and I'm sure Cassie is going to have something to to to add to the the points. Uh, a couple pieces that that we
  111. know of. There are various kinds of techniques for trying to do envision envisioning or visioning of the future.
  112. Uh in common of those one aspect is you want to get far enough out into the future so you can free people up from
  113. from the present. So if you want to get change to happen by and large you don't want to work from well how do we improve
  114. the present because you've already got a whole bunch of constraints built in there and you're not going to get people
  115. to be as creative as you can be if you can get far enough out. So whether one is talking about bad backcasting or
  116. idealized design, you want to get far enough out temporally that people get freed up to then think about what might
  117. we actually create. So that'd be one piece of of counsel. The second piece would be and this is what sets I think
  118. this technique apart from others is to to work hard to envision as if you were a playwright. Uh uh what is the scene
  119. that if I saw it, I'd know we've gotten to the kind of place we want to get to. uh and and that's actually I think in
  120. the whole part of of what we talk about in the book that's the hardest p piece for people to stay with is to push to
  121. the specificity of what you actually want to see. How would you know it? Who's in the room? How are they talking?
  122. What tools are they using? What measurement system are they responding to? That that kind of specificity is not
  123. there to then end up being deeply prescriptive. So somehow you out you're going to tell people this is the script
  124. you got to follow. but rather it helps to set up the second part of the model which is to help be diagnostic in a in a
  125. in an acute in a in a a precise way uh diagnostic about well that's what we want and that's clearly not what we're
  126. seeing in terms of how the field and headquarters or how R&D and sales whoever it is that you might put in that
  127. scene how they deal with each other if that's not what we're seeing let's assume that it's not because of those
  128. people we can get back there if we have to but Let's assume it's because of how we designed the system. So what would we
  129. have to do to make it make sense to those people to behave in the way we just described? We'd like to have but
  130. it's not the way that it's happening. If we've done the work around the scene and
  131. done the work of trying to be precise about that now we have what we need to do um a pointed analysis of the systems
  132. around people that we need to change. If we don't do that work in the scene, then
  133. we're left with platitudes or vague and it makes it hard to do the more detailed
  134. planning about what am I actually what do I have to actually do to create the environment that makes the behavior that
  135. I want make sense to people. Got it. Got it. Well, and I I'm so glad you went there because I was sitting here and
  136. thinking I want to give everybody like a vague button that they can learn how to
  137. hit when they hear it, you know? So, what is it you're trying to actually do here? Oh, I want people to
  138. collaborate. What does that look like? And you know, you get all these agreements at this 50,000 foot level.
  139. Conceptually, everyone is going to say, "Oh, yes, we definitely we just had a merger and acquisition. We definitely
  140. want everybody on both sides to collaborate." And we we nod our heads and walk away. And then we say, "Gosh,
  141. what happened?" You know, what does that really mean to people? What does that look like? What's the behavior we're
  142. looking for? If you bring the conversation down to that level, you might discover you don't have quite as
  143. good agreement and you have to keep thinking and working. And one of the ways that uh you
  144. highlight this in the book is with the examples uh that you've raised, right? And and two of them really stood out to
  145. me and Cassie, if I can, I'd like to ask you about them. Um the first was fostering innovation at Whirlpool and
  146. the second was about how to sustain the customer service success that Disney has
  147. seen for so many years. What I was really struck with was how these were change efforts that were born out of
  148. success as opposed to crisis or failure. Um how should leaders of successful organizations uh think about change?
  149. What I what I love about the Whirlpool case is the CEO had tried to change Whirlpool's culture. it's really a
  150. culture case. Um, two or three times and it was really towards the end of his tenure he said, "I'm going to take one
  151. more run at this thing." You know, we've been an engineering company. We're geared that way. I need to be customer
  152. focused and we need to be innovative. And it took it took years partly because I think they started more um modestly
  153. and then just kept adding layer after layer of system change um and building all of the ingredients that actually
  154. create culture such that three years into it they had really seen tremendous impacts to the bottom line. And what
  155. what's great about that, if you're a successful leader, you see the changes coming, the kind that Greg was
  156. describing, before the crisis hits, before the burning platform arrives, you want to begin to move. And the model
  157. gives you a way of designing into that future without having to wait for panic to set in all the way down through the
  158. ranks. That's too late to start a change like this. It's going to, especially a big culture change. Disney is kind of
  159. the opposite partly because our friend Walt had that vision from the beginning and he he just was a holistic thinker.
  160. He wanted environment to convey a certain quality of guest experience. They designed feedback mechanisms for
  161. people to understand the guest experience. If you read the history of how they built the customer satisfaction
  162. experience there and now they tell other people how to do it. Um, it really includes all of the ingredients that we
  163. discuss in the book. And, uh, one of the things that was really helpful to me as
  164. I was reading it was all of a sudden I was thinking about sustaining success as a change process as well. Oh, can I can
  165. I take that one? Because we push changes into our organizations because I'm thinking about handwashing in hospitals,
  166. which is just a horrifically difficult change to incorporate. And as long as you're bearing down and sending the
  167. message, you're getting the behavior you want. But if you turn your attention away, you know, 6 months later, it's
  168. it's slid back to to the baseline. And that really requires this kind of re-engineering of the environment, I
  169. think, to hardwire the change. One thing I' I'd add to to what Cassiey's talking
  170. about is one of the choices we make uh is what are you going to use as the emotional energy for change, right? So
  171. we come out of a a period which I actually think this part of the issue of having done this for as long as I've
  172. done it uh you you can you can remember when it might have been different. So I think one of the products of the 80s uh
  173. is that we associate developing either sense of urgency or what I would term felt need as based on fear. People have
  174. to I mean just the very image of a burning platform right let's take a human being put them on a platform and
  175. light it on fire and that's how we're going to get change to happen. Uh and that language came out of the 80s which
  176. was a particularly difficult painful time uh radical restructuring lots of layoffs all that was going on in the US
  177. economy. That's one way to go about fueling change. And and yet when you do that we know that when people are very
  178. anxious when they're scared you can get them focused but at the same time that's
  179. not the way that you get the most innovative creative because anxiety up intelligence down. Uh another way to do
  180. it is what more to what we were doing before that which is that we were thinking more in terms of what are you
  181. trying to create? What's the hope? What's the dream? Uh put two men on the moon or put a man on the moon and bring
  182. him back. Say that type and and if you're trying to change an organization that's successful, it's hard to use the
  183. lessons from burning platform uh because where you going to create that and even
  184. if you do, you're going to buy a set of problems. That's fine if that you actually have a burning platform. But
  185. what's the other way to do it? And the other way tends to be uh much more in terms of what would you like, as good as
  186. we are, what would we like to see? What are the things that we're not seeing here that we'd love to see if we could
  187. see? Or we've come this far, what's the next thing? And so you can use this technique that we're talking about
  188. either when you're working off of more of a fearbased driven by the world outside or maybe it's in the in the
  189. framework of success. you're trying to construct what's the next place where's the hope or optimism that we can
  190. generate given our success about what might be even better that we could create in the world uh what it would be
  191. like to work with each other what the type of connection or how do we get the next 10% or how do we go from the
  192. playoffs to the championship whatever image one wants to use and so I think when we think about this this process
  193. and winning organizations that's something that isn't isn't talked about in part because we haven't gone back and
  194. changed the constructs drugs that we formed in a very very traumatic and painful period of time and I don't think
  195. we've quite adjusted or balanced or calibrated right and hopefully the model uh I think provides a way to do that. So
  196. thank you. uh as we think about as we think about organizational change efforts and I speaking personally um as
  197. an organizational leader uh I appreciate what you've said about expanding our view beyond leaders and followers uh to
  198. really en encompass the whole environment. Um I know the question that I often face though is how much is
  199. enough? How much of the environment um needs to be shaped? How do I know uh what or what are the cues to let me know
  200. that we're making progress towards our goal? So the uh the only slightly flippant answer to that would be uh
  201. you've changed enough when people experience that they're in a different place than they were before. So the the
  202. kind of clinical judgment is do people say whoa this is different? I'm in a I'm in a different I'm in a different domain
  203. than I was before. to get to that place our council is that you at least start by thinking of changing four of the
  204. eight dimensions that we talk about levers uh you change at least four of those and uh then you're into a into a
  205. judgment about is it well if I could change six kind of is it as good as three dramatically and and the point is
  206. not that there's something magic about the four but in the end we come back to the my first point here which would be
  207. people whose behavior you're trying to change should experience that they're in a different environment than they were
  208. before. And our council would be that's probably going to involve a heavy pull on at least half of the dimensions of of
  209. the of the work environment which would be four of the eight. The more the better. Can I work with fewer? Yes, but
  210. it gets harder and you got to pull harder and and so we're in a area where hopefully uh people who do research on
  211. the model will end up clarifying exactly what the answer to your question should
  212. have been Jeff. Right. But that's that's the best cut currently. Okay. Um well this book functions really well in
  213. describing a relevant accessible uh conceptually sound approach to leading change in organizations. Um for your
  214. readers how would you suggest they use the book? Often in fact the entire family multiple copies for everyone
  215. would be the way they should use the book. Well, actually, speaking of family, I I I we couldn't put this in
  216. the book as they would never speak to me. But once you learn to see the world this way, you can see the whole world
  217. this way. And I when I'm teaching it, I talk about waking up and going, "Yeah, I
  218. got this scene going on with my pre-teenage daughters, and this is not the scene I want." You know, how wait a
  219. minute, like I teach this stuff. How how should I rethink this? And how do you know you've gone far enough? Is because
  220. I went about halfway and went not there yet. you know and redesign the environment. So I think that once you
  221. understand the theory you go through this tempting period where you look around and say oh my organization oh you
  222. know my my my sleeping habits oh my family you know uh and you can you can see it everywhere you look which is
  223. cool. Uh another another pass at this uh would be there I think there are two major
  224. ways which go back goes back to something we were talking about earlier. Um, one is simply as a framework. So if
  225. if if you if you think of the world just in the way that that Cassie was illustrating, if I'm thinking about it
  226. in terms of systems that comprise the environment around me, just doing that is a different way of of approaching
  227. this. It's consistent with the best out of of of the tradition of Deming and Jirean where they said don't don't blame
  228. an individual when you keep putting the individual in and new individuals keep having the same problem. Think about the
  229. system. Uh so just having that orientation uh in and of itself is a use. Uh the the the other way to use or
  230. another way to use it is to very consciously work your way through the through the technique and to to follow
  231. it in a in a far more uh far more um linear fashion of working through the different steps. Although it's never
  232. done, there's always cycling back through. Uh and and to that point um you know one of the we mentioned in the
  233. acknowledgements about our gratitude to the different organizations we've worked
  234. with and support and uh there's nothing like working with somebody particularly people who are pressed for time which
  235. most of us are in organizations today and they'll say say more about that that's useful right and the
  236. encouragement you get from that well related to that is when you walk around an organization and you see at different
  237. levels in the organization they got a copy of the model that we have um stuck over their desk, right? And and it's and
  238. it's being used in those two ways. It's just a reminder to think about the world
  239. in that fashion. And there may be particular projects that they're involved in, whether it's a business
  240. enterprise system or whether it's whether it's a merger where they are using this in a far more detailed
  241. project management guidance kind of kind of fashion. And I'm reminded of one of our clients coming up to me and saying,
  242. "Hey, hey, I figured it out. This worked because we changed all eight." You know,
  243. and kind of showing me like this piece of paper where he kind of mapped the the framework onto what we had actually
  244. done. And that's right. So, how just so happens that that group designed a really different system and it worked
  245. and then he was able to map it back to the to the model. I think one other use that I throw in, we we have a chapter we
  246. talk about different uses of the of the model as you know uh is I think particularly back to where we started
  247. the conversation when you're in a world that's got this much pressure to change going through the use of this model can
  248. lead you to the point where you say you know we can't change enough of the work systems to make this thing work and it's
  249. a that can be a valuable contribution. So you either say well let's go back and figure this out again or you say not now
  250. here we we got other things we can be doing. So it's a basic sorting device even if it leads to a point where you
  251. say I don't think so we can't really do this given the number of change initiatives threats opportunities that
  252. are present in the world uh around almost any around almost any business that I think is a worthwhile use just in
  253. and of itself and from what I hear you'd likely have a chance the next day or the
  254. day after that to use the framework again for the thing you just decided you well we can't do this let's do that
  255. let's try it on that yes right exactly Well, Cassie Greg, thank you so much for being with us today. Thank you. Thank
  256. you. [Music]

Brief Summary

Greg Sheay and Cassie Solomon discuss their book on effective organizational change, emphasizing environment design over individual motivation.

Key points

  • The Lead Dog Myth. Exploring the misconception that change relies solely on leaders or followers.
  • Designing for Change. Discussing how leaders can create environments that facilitate change.
  • Sustaining Success. How successful organizations can proactively manage change before crises arise.
  • The Burning Platform. Change driven by fear can lead to anxiety, which stifles creativity. Instead, focus on hope.
  • Shaping the Environment. Organizational change requires shaping the environment to ensure people feel different.
  • Seeing the World Differently. Understanding the framework allows you to apply it to various aspects of life.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes