Does Your Strategy Need a Strategy Part 2

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we also deal with leadership in the book what why would we begin with leadership
  2. in a book on strategy it's because we're interested in the in winning outcomes the the whole point of strategy and that
  3. requires the execution and the orchestration of these approaches in the ambidextrous organization now the
  4. problem is that the classical model of leadership cascading instructions based on experience and judgment down a
  5. hierarchical organization and then managing execution against those instructions
  6. what's perfectly fine in a classical environment but it won't work in say an adaptive environment that is much more
  7. unpredictable and it's simply not possible for the leader to be having a stable instruction set and so that the
  8. question becomes how does a leader animate the collage of approaches multiple approaches across an
  9. organization and in the book we deal with eight facets of leadership that need to be taken into consideration in
  10. the new environment let me just touch on a few of them so firstly somebody needs
  11. to diagnose and segment these different approaches to strategy which approach to
  12. strategy in which part of the organization and somebody needs to disrupt in other words somebody needs to
  13. say yes that as approach to strategy is not the approach that we need right now somebody needs to coach and deploy pick
  14. the right people and develop the right people to be deployed against the right approach to strategy because each
  15. requires a different cognitive skill set and we talked about the need for Inquisition for questioning namely where
  16. we can't have a stable instruction set sometimes the best we can do is to ask really great questions so leaders need
  17. to be really good at getting to the bottom of things by by asking the right questions so if you like we define the
  18. skill set of the ambidextrous leader the title of the book is your strategy needs a strategy mentions the word
  19. strategy twice but in fact the book is not about strategy it's about effective strategy in other
  20. words it's about obtaining the winning outcomes which are the very reason why we use the word strategy in the first
  21. place and therefore necessarily we need to think also about implementation now just as we've said that strategy is
  22. not one thing we think that implementation is not one thing the actions were required to implement
  23. strategies vary according to the situation and not only that but the relationship between implementing and
  24. strategizing also varies according to the environment so let me give you two examples in the classical environment
  25. the strategizing may consist largely of analyzing opportunities and deriving a plan and the implementing may consist of
  26. remote execution against that stable plan and performance monitoring of that execution against the plan let's think
  27. about that software company this implementing adaptive strategy really the equation is turned upside down and
  28. inside out because it starts with experiments from empowered employees at the coal face of the company trying new
  29. things and some of those new things work and are picked up and communicated and amplified and what a strategy strategy
  30. is the continuous stream of improved ideas the results from those actions so in this particular case strategizing
  31. cannot be separated from action and actually the action the experiment comes before the strategy the strategy is a
  32. result of the implementation if you like and if we went through each of the styles of strategy you'd find that this
  33. relationship between strategy and implementation and the nature of implementation varies in each case so
  34. what we really need is not just different approaches to strategizing in different environments but different
  35. approaches to strategizing implement a implementing innovation culture leadership of all aspects of business in
  36. each environment so in the process of writing the book we had a little strategic problem of our
  37. own in fact two problems one of them is that our research showed us that CEOs would probably be interested in what we
  38. had to say but they may not read the whole book we needed a more concise form of communication the second inconvenient
  39. truth was that we found that in our survey 150 multinationals we found that the right beliefs about the environment
  40. and about the choice of approach to strategy did not correlate perfectly with the right behaviors so if you like
  41. understanding was insufficient necessary but insufficient to be doing the right things so the solution to this was
  42. really two things the first one was to write a very compact first chapters of the book that could be read in its own
  43. right and the the second one was to build a game a game for the iPad where we led with experience so the game is
  44. quite a fun game we take the five boroughs of New York New York where I happen to live why New York because it
  45. has five there's the number of approaches to strategy and the idea is to win against a fictional opponent
  46. called Bruce who is named after a founder Bruce Henderson a great strategist in in selling lemonade from a
  47. lemonade stand in each of these environments and the tricky part is that Bruce is a raised fierce component and
  48. each environment requires you to not only think but more importantly to act out a very different approach to
  49. strategy so through experiencing these different environments you develop a muscle memory for what an adaptive
  50. strategy feels like for what a visionary strategy feels like and then you can go
  51. backwards into the content you can ask what happened in that game you can read a little bit about the particular
  52. approach to strategy that was required in that particular environment and you can even click through and and and by
  53. the book if you're interested so that's the idea of the game many of the approaches that we detail in
  54. the book may be challenging but not so challenging if you're doing them afresh if you're doing them as as a startup
  55. if you're a ecommerce company and you're putting place a digital marketplace it may be hard in its own right but you you
  56. don't have to negate the past to do so large corporations have a challenge on top of that which is they have to move
  57. away from over previously successful recipe and adopt a newer unknown one and they have to pick the right timing and
  58. the rate of progression in doing so and that's that's that's a really hard problem on many dimensions so you might
  59. call it rejuvenating the corporation I think the first success factor is to is to really understand that need so the
  60. the analysis in the book shows quite clearly that the durability and the value of leadership positions is
  61. increasingly tenuous so there really is a need for large corporations to to look
  62. ahead at new ways of doing strategy and the second one is to is to revile the problem down because you can't change
  63. everything everywhere and we've said that it boils down to three essential capabilities one of them is the
  64. capability of adaptiveness or experimentation the second one is the capability of shaping which is not just
  65. participating in environments but actually shaping ecosystems and the third one is ambidexterity which is
  66. comfort with diversity comfort with a mosaic of approaches rather than a single monolithic approach we we
  67. recently saw the announcement that Google was dividing itself into pieces under a new holding called
  68. alphabet and this is a great example actually of structural ambidexterity and all of this has to be managed not only
  69. as a change in the organization but change in people's minds - it requires familiarity with new ways of thinking
  70. that hopefully we we detail in the book you

Brief Summary

Leadership strategies must adapt to unpredictable environments, emphasizing the relationship between strategy and implementation.

Key points

  • The Role of Leadership in Strategy. Leadership is crucial for winning outcomes in strategy implementation.
  • Adaptive vs Classical Environments. Classical leadership models fail in unpredictable environments; adaptability is key.
  • The Challenge of Implementation. Implementation varies by environment; it’s not a one-size-fits-all approach.
  • Innovative Learning through Gaming. A game simulates strategic environments to develop adaptive strategy skills.
  • The Need for New Strategies. Large corporations must rejuvenate their strategies to remain competitive.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes