What I've Learned: Wharton Professor Mike Useem Discusses Leadership with Dean Erika James

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

In a special interview with Dean Erika James, Professor Mike Useem dives into the history of Wharton’s innovative leadership curriculum and his part in shaping it.

When Professor Emeritus of Management Michael Useem was told to build a leadership course from the ground up at Wharton, he had to become an expert on the subject first. Through decades of in-depth research and developing innovative learning opportunities, Useem has done just that. Today, he is an award-winning teacher, a consultant for companies across the globe on leadership development and governance, and is the author of multiple books, including The Leader’s Checklist. In this insightful conversation with Wharton Dean Erika James, Useem discusses his unique journey through academia and why leadership skills are critical for all ages.

The talk is part of the series, “What I’ve Learned,” which puts the spotlight on Wharton faculty who have made a lasting impact on their fields. Watch the video for the full conversation.

Topics and questions covered: 00:00 - Introductions 1:06 - Professor Useem’s background in leadership 6:20 - The McNulty Leadership Program at Wharton 9:18 - Strategies for hiring leadership 12:20 - Leadership in crisis management 16:38 - Students who inspired Professor Useem 21:45 - Professor Useem’s legacy at Wharton

#wharton #leadership #management ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU 📂 Leadership;Management 🏷️ Research;What I've Learned

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Hi. Thanks so much for joining us, Mike. Erika Thank you. It's a privilege to be here.
  2. So I thought I'd start with this age old adage or debate whether or not leadership can be taught.
  3. It's probably something to do with our family, our maybe friends and school culture, too, along the way.
  4. But I don't think anybody is born with the leadership gene or the teamwork gene or the creed, the culture gene.
  5. And if not and I actually think not, then it's up to us to find ways to help people.
  6. Grade school on influence, parents help people develop. And it takes a long time.
  7. It's a it's a hard road to begin to master fairly early on. The key elements, the key capabilities
  8. of helping other people to get to a more promised land. It's learned. Tell us your professional origin story of how leadership
  9. became so ingrained in something that you wanted to do professionally. Here's the origin story.
  10. And like many origin stories, I'm the accidental guy. So I'm on the faculty here at the Wharton School.
  11. I was asked to join a committee that was then going to bring a new curriculum at the time into the MBA program for executives.
  12. Long story made sure we had no faculty member to teach a newly required course on leadership and teamwork and the head of the committee.
  13. I compliment the head of the committee of being excellent at strategy and negotiation.
  14. I had pointed out that we don't have anybody to teach the horn course, and he looked at me and said, Well, Mike, I guess you're going to have to do it.
  15. I said, I can't do it. I don't know a thing about the topic. And he said, Perfect.
  16. You won’t have any prior prejudice or bias. So he was good. Next thing I knew, I was walking into a leadership classroom.
  17. But like every topic that any of us teach here at the Wharton School, we weren't born with that.
  18. We had to learn it. And I had to. I had to sit down and think about it. Learn about it. I read about it.
  19. I spent time with people like yourself. Gradually, I learned a little bit about leadership,
  20. enough to teach and teach really well over the years. If you can remember that first year, the first couple of years
  21. when you were teaching leadership and you're learning it along with your students in many respects.
  22. Walk us through what that class was like. What were some of the topics that you covered?
  23. How did you bring these issues to life and get the students to enact leadership, not just read about it theoretically.
  24. You know, Erika, it began with a head start in the sense that the students in the executive MBA program, the MBA program for executives
  25. average age 34, 35, as you know well, they, without putting it quite in these words, had an enormous hunger for learning,
  26. mastering, developing, strengthening their own leadership, often because they had taken over a team, maybe a division, maybe a clinic,
  27. because so many were in medicine, some had become heads of law firms. And they said, I can't believe the mistakes I made.
  28. Can you help us out? And so in a sense, I had a head start in that the classroom did not need a proof of concept.
  29. The people in the class, and that's true for our students now when they arrive, they've seen great leadership.
  30. They've seen deplorable leadership. So the first point I would make is that went into a classroom.
  31. And even then and unequivocally these days, you you'd know that because you go into classrooms to teach leadership
  32. the interest and hunger for the that the principals, the concepts, the the capabilities of leadership
  33. cannot be overstated. With that said, the classroom itself was good, but not great for the mastery of leadership,
  34. the classroom as a venue, returning the concepts and the action can be subpar. With that, said Ryan, as I do on cases
  35. examples, I bring leadership speakers into the classroom. It I also concluded it's really important
  36. to take students mid-career or even undergraduates. iSchool students for that matter,
  37. into settings where they can feel and see the leadership moment. They can feel the moment where their own leadership
  38. is being tested or it's needed. And for that, we began to experiment very gingerly
  39. with taking our students out to the great Civil War battlefield, Gettysburg. This, of course, is July one,
  40. two and three, 1863, a kind of turning point in the Civil War. And as you stand, we're at some of the history making
  41. locations were to appreciate, for example, how critical it is to be prepared ahead of time,
  42. to be resilient when the time has come to make a decision to be ready to act. You come to appreciate all that much more
  43. how vital it is to be prepared to have thought through strategically what you're going to do to have
  44. people animated, motivated to follow you when you go into battle. So the Gettysburg battlefield proved a kind of an experiment.
  45. I didn't know it was going to work. A worked in my own experience very well in helping people become more
  46. committed to engaging with the ideas and above all, more committed to then applying the ideas that they the concepts,
  47. the principles to the workplace, or if they're still a student and in the student organizations they may be maybe part of.
  48. Since then, working now with what we call the McNulty Leadership program, we have rolled out a series or a comparable experiences.
  49. So, Erika, as you know well, we take students for a day with the New York Fire Department
  50. at its great training center on Randall's Island, East River of Manhattan. And our students go through
  51. a day of direct engagement and survey. Now equipment and all around them and a helmet on their head,
  52. serving in small teams, going in to fire combat. You have to be safe. Risk is considerable.
  53. We don't put our students in a risky circumstance there. So we have developed a program that emphasizes, for example, teamwork
  54. and risk abatement and working with the New York Fire Department. We have a program going back, I think, about 20 years now with the U.S.
  55. Marine Corps officer, candidate School, Quantico, the base in Virginia, about 45 minutes south of Washington.
  56. And there are students that I've been through the program under the extremely effective instruction
  57. of Marine Corps officers and drill sergeants. Our students I've been on a team down there.
  58. I put myself through. I learned the vital importance of here and a small team of everybody contributing to the team of the team leader run
  59. the best out of all four or five people on the team. If you're ultimately going to meet your objective and I think
  60. all of that is just so representative of what makes Wharton's approach to leadership really distinctive
  61. and helps us then put out into the world really strong leaders, regardless of their professional background and over the last 30 years,
  62. this school, your school now as Dean has in my view, pioneered the provision of leadership, learning opportunities in class work,
  63. extracurricular settings to high school students, to undergraduates, MBA students, executive MBA
  64. students and mid-career people for a good reason. And that is the world that we live in, I think has learned
  65. that the difference between a prospering company, a company that is going to grow but not grow as fast
  66. as it should, or a company that can adopt new technologies. And one that does not depends critically on the quality
  67. of the leadership at the top and actually through out the links. So our engagement now with all of our constituencies
  68. in providing leadership development opportunities I think is just a direct product to how the world is calling for it.
  69. And we are trying to deliver it. I was hired to be Dean of Wharton as an external hire.
  70. How how should companies think about succession planning for leadership when it comes to internal or external hiring?
  71. It was a great question because it always comes up when almost anybody is hiring.
  72. There is always a let's look over our shoulder and there's some outsiders that are good.
  73. But when you know the data, 90% of let's make it the S&P 500 companies, when you have a succession
  74. event in 90% of the cases they hire internally and that's a good sign that usually points
  75. to, in fact, a very good indication that the company has been concerned about leadership development.
  76. 30 years ago, a very few companies, except GE, had a whole lot of leadership development going on today.
  77. Everybody does and does one product of a great internal leadership development, a specific educational program, or helping people move around the company
  78. to learn all the different functions before they are ready to become a totally general manager.
  79. These kinds of endeavors have become not only widespread, but they're commonplace snow and ice.
  80. In saying that, I do point to the fact that I think companies have become, with the prodding of their boards, much better
  81. at internal leadership development, which partly explains the 90%. There are great people
  82. appreciate the person that you just brought up at your company. It's great. Looks like a very promising future.
  83. That said, there is also great academic research on the fact that if a company is in trouble,
  84. kind of strategically misdirected or maybe just poorly managed, showing up in the stock price or whatever metrics you use,
  85. it's good to take a look over your shoulder and ask yourself whether great people out there
  86. that can make up for the cultural shortcomings or the strategic shortcomings that have become endemic within our company.
  87. So quick summary is companies much better leadership development. So I expect that 90% to stay pretty high.
  88. We're looking at on the inside. But it is, you know, this the duty of director is to make certain
  89. you're getting the best out there and of a company has been in trouble. It's languishing, it's underperforming.
  90. It's an especially good time to take a look around. So I have been fortunate to have been invited by you
  91. on several occasions to teach in some of your programs at the Wharton School. And as you know, my own area of expertise is in crisis leadership.
  92. As you see what's happening in the world, there are all sorts of dynamics that make it increasingly difficult for companies to be successful.
  93. How do you think about leadership in a time of crisis versus in sort of more strategic growth
  94. context? Well, to take a step back on that, to establish a baseline, good to ask yourself
  95. as a leader of an academic institution, has the leader of a private sector company,
  96. under what conditions does your leadership have? It has to impact. Good way to sum that up.
  97. Not talking. Now we're really talking when this comes out again, University research
  98. has when the university, the company, the the hospital, the community group is facing
  99. a difficult period when uncertainty is high, it's unclear which way to go. Leadership has greatest consequence
  100. in a period of uncertainty and change. And not only that, if we look very carefully, it's hard research to do, but has been done.
  101. If we look very carefully at how much difference one person could make who is elevated from the inside or maybe brought in from the outside.
  102. The statistic that for me says it all is that if we hire the right person as opposed to the wrong person,
  103. the right person can make as much as 20 to 30% difference within 1 to 3 years. Same finding for collegiate sports,
  104. same finding for professional football. So as they bring in a new general manager or a new coach,
  105. everything else, the same same players, same fan, same venue, right Coach versus the wrong coach, the right general manager versus
  106. the wrong one can make as much as 20 to 30% difference. So we've really got to get it right.
  107. And I think that's increasingly so because of this uncertainty. Markets in a way, a capital follows these days in the U.S.
  108. and abroad. So to put this a little bit more normatively or prescriptive play, really important to get the formula right for the kind of leader
  109. that's going to make a difference. Every institution is different. That is true because the impact is a,
  110. it's subscale. It certainly is. And I think also about what's happening just in our country
  111. and what many people would describe as a void of leadership at every level. And how do we move as a society from what we're seeing.
  112. You know, the House had trouble finding a new speaker for a period of months that was leaderless.
  113. There are so many examples of ineffective or troubled leadership. How do we, with credibility, teach our students at Wharton
  114. that leadership actually matters when all around them they're seeing such a vacuum of leadership in some respects,
  115. and with the proviso which I should have referenced earlier, that the impact of the
  116. the coach at a professional NFL team, the impact of a dean or a president of university is especially consequential in a period of uncertainty.
  117. Change, and in particular during a crisis. So that itself tells me, as I've looked at the research literature that supports that,
  118. it is vital to reiterate that point. The conceptual framing that we can offer and then provide opportunity is
  119. where people will come to our shores or undergraduates or MBA students. Last time I checked, I think we have about 2000 MBA students
  120. and several thousand undergraduates, 15,000 mid-career people, a couple million people who were coming into our programs online.
  121. Really important, really important for us to get the content of those programs right
  122. and to make them available to everybody who was looking to strengthen their ability to make a difference and get us all
  123. to a born promised land. So I want to switch the conversation back to you for a minute.
  124. As you think about your career at Wharton and and beyond. Was there any particular student that stood out for you
  125. as someone who helped you think about your own work and life and responsibilities around leadership differently?
  126. Who, Who has impacted Mike Useem? I'm going to name two students, and I'm actually going to name them.
  127. They're their public figures. So I think this is appropriate. One is Tricia Griffith,
  128. who is the chief executive of Progressive Insurance. By the way, a couple years ago, she was the star on the front of Fortune
  129. magazine as the Fortune 500 CEO of the Year. I've met her. I understand why she received that designation.
  130. And she is a terrific performer and she's just a wonderful person. She's an alumnus who came out of our what we call
  131. our advanced management program that you teach in. And just to make an observation on her that has
  132. forever affected how I think about what you do, what our President does, what the President of the United States does is.
  133. I had asked to follow her around for a day at her headquarters outside of a little bit to the east, to Cleveland, Ohio.
  134. He said, yeah, come on out. We walked into a room that was already filled up with 300
  135. new hires, a progressive insurance there, huge 40,000 employees. They're always hiring.
  136. So income in comes Tricia Griffith, CEO. She stopped on the way to the front of the room.
  137. Stuck out a hand and had a conversation with maybe a dozen people on the way to the front.
  138. She said as she then took the microphone, she says, I'm Tricia Griffith. I started here at Progressive as an adjuster many years ago.
  139. I realized sometimes you had to lift cars up to see underneath. So I became a certified lift operator,
  140. forklift operator, where you can pick large objects up, including cars. And I'm thinking, Whoa.
  141. So she is Lucy's CEO. She's the CEO as they come now, But she has a blue collar past.
  142. And I could sense in the room when I talked to a few of the participants that at the end of that, Tricia Griffith had just given me a lesson
  143. on the vital importance of being in touch to the extent that you can. She's got 40,000 people
  144. with always their last way to illustrate the same point. There is a lunch room at the headquarters where it must be hundreds of people will come to take
  145. a table. And Tricia Griffith happened the habit of walking into the lunch room, looking to a table that haven't had five people seated, not six.
  146. And she would come over and say, Do you mind if I step down, sit down with you for lunch?
  147. Everybody is looking at their neighbors, texting their partner. I can't believe I'm sitting next to the CEO.
  148. But with that repeated effort to personalize her relationship, her ability to lead the company
  149. put her under front of Fortune magazine as the best CEO of the year. So here is a second example.
  150. Just a very quickly get back to your question. Here a person I knew, you know well named Alex Gorsky had been chief executive
  151. at Johnson Johnson for the better part of a decade. He now serves, as you well know, also on the board
  152. of Apple of IBM and JPMorgan Chase. So he's moved from running companies to now helping helping the governance countries.
  153. I personally have known Alex. He was an executive MBA student quite some time ago.
  154. We've kept in touch. He has come in many times. He's a great supporter of the Wharton School, as you know.
  155. I've had him come in many times as a guest instructor, and the who's impact on students is just extraordinary
  156. as he and his case places an almost emphasis on what Johnson & Johnson has always called the credo,
  157. the 302 words that provide a almost a blueprint on serving patients, first families, communities and, of course, shareholders are there.
  158. And as Alex Gorsky comes into the classroom, you know better than anybody I've ever seen.
  159. He helps us understand the power of company culture to get the job done. And I'm proud that I have had an opportunity to interact with both of them.
  160. So great examples. So we're almost out of time, and I want to just have this end
  161. on how you think about your own legacy. And you spent years at the Wharton School.
  162. We all know your impact. How would you most like to be thought about when people reflect on your role with Wharton?
  163. We all have a purpose. We all have a calling, and let's get clear minded about what it should be was focused on that.
  164. Let's get really determined to make the best possible impact we can. And for me personally, it's been a gift to be a faculty member here,
  165. a privilege and a gift to be here as a faculty member. But being drawn as an external professor into a course on leadership,
  166. I came to appreciate that wherever my legacy may be, I'm going to try as hard as I can
  167. to help high school students, undergraduates, MBA students and mid-career people
  168. and strengthen their ability to make the world a better place. Well, you have done that with
  169. aplomb, and we are fortunate to have had you part of the Wharton School. Thank you.
  170. Mike Useem thank you so much.

Brief Summary

Mike Useem discusses leadership education, experiential learning, and succession planning, emphasizing the importance of effective leaders in crisis situations.

Key points

  • The Accidental Leader. Mike shares how he became a leadership instructor by chance, emphasizing the importance of learning leadership skills.
  • Lessons from the Battlefield. Experiential learning at Gettysburg teaches students about leadership under pressure.
  • The Importance of Internal Leadership Development. Mike discusses the significance of internal leadership development in companies, citing a 90% internal hiring rate.
  • Crisis Leadership. Mike reflects on the challenges of leading during crises and the impact of the right leadership.
  • Legacy at Wharton. Mike expresses his desire to strengthen students' abilities to make a positive impact.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes