How Workplace Networks Evolve During Mergers and Acquisitions

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Wharton professor Tiantian Yang discusses how workplace networks shift during mergers and acquisitions — and why men and women respond differently to organizational disruption. She explains that men tend to expand their networks by forming new connections with other men, while women strengthen existing relationships with other women, increasing trust and reciprocity during uncertain times. Her research reveals that in turbulent periods, women’s denser networks can actually provide greater short-term performance advantages, including increased referrals and resource sharing. The conversation challenges the assumption that women’s networks are inherently limiting and offers new insight into how organizations should think about integration, trust, and long-term career strategy during restructuring.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

#OrganizationalBehavior #WorkplaceStrategy #CorporateRestructuring #ProfessionalNetworking #WomenInBusiness #ManagementScience ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. We found that during re organizational restructury events for instance merger and acquisition men and women tend to
  2. react differently and we found that gender homophy is intensified. Men are making more friends new [music]
  3. friends with men. They they focus on network formation. They try to expand their networks by making more new
  4. connections [music] with with other men. And women tend to focus on their existing networks with other women. So
  5. their networks are more dense but stronger. >> Welcome to the Ripple Effect, the
  6. podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host Dan Looney and in each
  7. episode we'll be diving deep into the [music] inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton
  8. professors have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the world [music] today.
  9. The impact of one business combining with another can play a significant [music] role in how social networks in
  10. the workplace develop and at times [music] can potentially come apart. Research from our guest today and her
  11. colleagues look at that fact specifically. [music] Tienanyang is an assistant professor of
  12. management and of sociology here at the [music] Wharton School. Tian, great to talk to you again. How are you?
  13. >> Hi Dan. Great to see you here. very exciting talk about my work. >> Yes, absolutely. Uh I guess let's start
  14. with the concept of networks and what was it that drove you to want to look at how networks in the workplace get
  15. impacted especially when there's some sort of you know strong event like a merger or an acquisition that occurs.
  16. >> Yeah. You know the idea of networks how important it is like everyone can even
  17. feel that in their daily lives we all have all kinds of social relationships when people look for jobs they ask their
  18. friends their family members and in organizations these kind of networks are really important because networks
  19. actually serve as a conduit for information and resources and such networks are not only shaped by the
  20. formal structures. For example, the kind of jobs people have. Usually, if they are working in higher level, more
  21. powerful positions, they tend to be the center of larger networks. However, there are also like interpersonal
  22. relationships that shape these networks. So, it's a it's a very complex dynamic and different people tend to engage
  23. networks differently, which actually have consequences for a lot of important things. And so for this research
  24. specifically, you were looking in and around the medical community as to how some of these impacts occur.
  25. >> Yes. And you know, I kind of stumbled on the healthcare industry, but after I
  26. studied the industry, I realized networks are uh so important. For example, um people when people ask when
  27. people look for doctors and doctors sometimes need to refer refer them to other doctors. For instance, um
  28. generalist need to refer their doctor to specialist. And these kind of referral networks are not only shaped by
  29. insurance networks but also shaped by doctor's networks. And these networks are very important because they really
  30. affect how many patients doctors will have and also the kind of effective um effective care
  31. that will be delivered to patients. So they have consequences for both physicians and the patients.
  32. >> But you note that there is a difference between men's networks [clears throat]
  33. and women's networks especially when there is this kind of disruption. >> Yes. So the disruption you are referring
  34. to uh is uh merger and acquisition that we studied but I think there are other kinds of restructuring events in
  35. organization. So going back to the question about gender difference in networks and it's very interesting that
  36. when people think about gender and networks they they tend to think about network formation right for example you
  37. know some people have better networks larger expensive more useful networks because they're good at the networking
  38. meaning that they reach out to people more they build a larger networks they're good at making friends but
  39. network formation is only one kind of network dynamics. The other kind is network maintenance. So people do after
  40. they establish networks, make friends, build a new networks, they have to have ways to maintain networks. And if they
  41. are not good at maintaining networks, they may experience network decay, which is that networks will become weaker and
  42. eventually disappear. So when when people talk about gender differences in networks and also the gender gap in
  43. resources acquired from networks, they tend to attribute this to men's better ability to build a networks with other
  44. men. So it's gender homophy because men's networks tend to be uh larger, stronger and also because men tend to
  45. occupy higher positions in organizations, more powerful positions. So gender homophy allow men to build a
  46. better network. So that's the kind of combination of notion people have about gender homophy and social networks. So
  47. what we're saying is you know look at network for look at network maintenance like men and women may do differently
  48. too. So there we found something really interesting. We found that during re organizational restructury events for
  49. instance merger and acquisition men and women tend to react differently and we found that gender homophy is
  50. intensified. Men are making more friends new friends with men. They they focus on network
  51. formation. They try to expand their networks by making more new connections with with other men. And women tend to
  52. focus on their existing networks with other women. So their networks are more dense but stronger. And this has
  53. consequences for net resources they acquire from these networks during merger and acquisition because during
  54. these turbulent times each woman actually provided more resources referred more patients to each other. So
  55. women's networks actually provided a greater advantage to them during turbulent times. So that's the big
  56. finding we have from this research. >> Part of the story is obviously the importance of women's networks sticking
  57. together. >> Yes. >> Do do women's networks tend to be stronger than men's networks in general?
  58. >> So we don't find a general pattern that women tend to be better at maintaining
  59. networks. However, there are particular circumstances under which women are become better at maintaining networks.
  60. For instance, during COVID, there has research showing that women tend to maintain networks better without
  61. face-toface interaction. For some reason, men's network for them to maintain relationships, they have to do
  62. certain activities together. They have to see each other. So women are better at kind of recording information,
  63. maintaining networks without inperson uh face-to-face interaction. But what we found in this context, I think it's kind
  64. of also explained by the kind of social psychological mechanisms because women feel like they need to support each
  65. other during difficult times. That's why they are lean toward each other rather than looking for new connections. And so
  66. that brings up the component of trust when you're talking about when you're talking about continuing and
  67. strengthening these networks as well. Correct. >> Right. >> Yes. So there is some indogenity because
  68. when they if you think about existing networks and new networks, existing networks presumably are stronger, right?
  69. So these networks maybe during difficult times or turbulent times and there is a
  70. lot of uncertainty in who will be helping me. So people women tend to lean on the relationships they already had
  71. and there is also like a greater level of trust in those relationships and and if you think about people helping each
  72. other when there is reciprocity people support each other when it's mutual and it also reinforces the trust level of
  73. trust in the relationships. I found it interesting in in looking at the research that it seems like the belief
  74. is that women's networks tend to be more inward focused whereas men's networks tend to be more outward focused and in
  75. many cases the outward focus even goes beyond the walls of the company to other other networks and other firms as well.
  76. Correct. >> Yeah. So I think that that might be an outcome or general pattern people
  77. observe but I wouldn't attribute that like what social media and the conventional wisdom say to individual's
  78. personality. So it's not just because women are more introverted, men are more out extroverted. They are shaped by
  79. social structures and cultural norms, right? Like there are differential like gendered expectations for how men and
  80. women should uh should act in terms of building and for maintaining relationships. Think about that. Women
  81. are prescribed to be more communal. That means they need to take care of their friends, support each other. Whereas men
  82. are more agentic and more assertive. So they're going out to making new connections with other people. And there
  83. also impacts of structural the positions impact of their current jobs, right? If
  84. they're at a higher level positions, more powerful positions that will help them to make more new connections. So I
  85. think the general pattern you described is right but the kind of reasons the structural cultural reasons that shape
  86. those um patterns I think are beyond the individual personality. Let me finish up
  87. with kind of a two-parted question. A and first in doing this research, what do you think you have learned and maybe
  88. is going to be passed on to others about just the value of women's networks in the workplace and how they can have such
  89. a significant impact on the company that they're working for in general? Yeah, I I think that's a question that
  90. my co-author Marissa Kane from Warden and IFA who is um a postto at INSIA all of us have thought a lot about right we
  91. want to really think hard about the implication of our research for women men and women for individuals and for
  92. organizations so our research focus on the short-term changes following structure restructuring events so we
  93. don't know the long-term impact yet. I think when mer acquisition happen in organizations actually I think
  94. if you think of this beyond not not just hospital organizations in general so organizations want people to build a new
  95. connections right because then >> the the units the the different the existing organization new organizations
  96. can like can be integrated better. I think in that process what we observe is that because it creates some kind of
  97. uncertainty in relationships women are actually leaning back right so it's not necessarily helpful for the organization
  98. in long term however in short term like women are able to kind of sustain their relationships maintain the resources
  99. they acquired from networks so that would be one thing I would say it's a double-edged this word so it's not
  100. universally good Um the other thing is you know when when people think about gender differences in networks where
  101. impact of homophy tend to claim generally that networks are networks leading to disadvantages for women right
  102. so that's a general notion or convention of wisdom people have but I think I want
  103. people to think differently based on our research which is there are circumstances
  104. women can benefit from networks and even the networks they have with with other women. It's not like a women shouldn't
  105. be making friends with each other. They shouldn't like spend time maintaining building relationships. Actually, the
  106. networks can become an advantage for them during turbulent times. So the question is more about how do you build
  107. a more balanced relationship which can provide a lot of resources in stable environment and also the kind of network
  108. relationships that can like help you um weather through difficult or uncertain conditions. Well, and and I guess to a
  109. degree, part of that also is not only having that network expand and grow, and it might even be outside of the borders
  110. of the of the of the company that you work for >> to help that firm, but also to
  111. potentially help that person's longer term goals of where they want to take their career.
  112. >> Exactly. And here we have only looked at patients referral. So, it's a kind of
  113. career relevant outcome. But in real life there are so many other outcomes that can be shaped the networks like our
  114. well-being the activities we do in our private private life and our work outcomes the other like even more
  115. general career outcomes career mobility moving to other firms moving up in organizations. So I think there are um
  116. there are actions that individuals can take to that that to help themselves. Tanten, great to talk to you again.
  117. Great research. Thank you very much for sharing it. >> Yeah, [music] it's a pleasure to talk
  118. with you, Dad. Thank you so much. >> Thank you. All the best. Tanti Yang, who is an assistant professor [music] of
  119. management and of sociology here at the Wharton School. Thank you for listening [music] to the ripple effect. We hope
  120. you found this episode informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can
  121. continue to bring you [music] the best insight from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Gender differences in workplace networks impact support during mergers and acquisitions, with women benefiting from existing connections.

Key points

  • Gender Differences in Networking. Research shows men and women react differently during organizational changes, impacting their networks.
  • The Ripple Effect Podcast Introduction. Join Dan Looney as he explores groundbreaking research from Wharton faculty.
  • Impact of Women's Networks. Women's networks provide significant advantages during turbulent times, especially in healthcare.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes