Challenges for Women in the Workplace | Wharton Professor Martine Haas — Ripple Effect Podcast

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Wharton’s Martine Haas talks about the trade-offs women make with remote and hybrid work, and working internationally. This episode is part of a series on “Women & Leadership.”

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#womeninbusiness #womenshistorymonth #hybridwork ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so I think there are some gender differences and we've seen that um in some of the data right there I think the
  2. data that I saw most recently about 10% higher demand from women um for remote work or hybrid work which makes sense in
  3. lots of ways in this when women are doing a lot of the home care and and child care and need that kind of
  4. flexibility welcome to the ripple effect the podcast that takes you on a journey
  5. through the minds of work and faculty I'm your host Dan Looney and in each episode we'll be diving deep into the
  6. inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that Wharton professors have conducted and exploring how their
  7. findings resonate with the world today well the workplace continues to evolve in the wake of the Corona virus pandemic
  8. and there is obviously a focus on a variety of elements uh one being is making the hybrid workplace fair for all
  9. involved there's also a focus on how much a job internationally could mean to someone's career pleasure to be joined
  10. here in Studio by Martine hos who's professor of management here at the Warton school she is also director of
  11. the Lauder Institute for management and International Studies great to see you great to have you in the studio here
  12. today good to see you how you doing I'm doing very well let's start with hybrid because I think that's one that's on a
  13. lot of people's thought process because of how things played out with the pandemic and and where we are right now
  14. we know it's probably going to be around here long term how much though do you think around hybrid work is still to be
  15. determined from where we are right now yeah it's feeling pretty kind of settled in some ways for a lot of companies in
  16. the sense of we're kind of relieved it's kind of working we seem to be in decent shape
  17. right um which you know is good but it also means we need to be careful about becoming complacent I think because
  18. there's definitely you know aspects of it that can use continuous kind of focus and maybe some tweaking and maybe some
  19. improvements right so we shouldn't get too kind of you know too too settled in this but there's no question it's going
  20. to be around for a while in lots of ways there lots of things about it that are good right um and there's it's kind of
  21. in many ways a good compromise between lots of things that employees want and have wanted for a long time right more
  22. flexibility less commuting more autonomy right and things that companies want to
  23. need in terms of having people in the office at least some of the time right so it seems to be a pretty good balance
  24. but there's there's a lot of issues that arise that still that need to be continually kind of worked through and
  25. it seems like the the and it's not every company but the mindset of of certain seite Executives is very much anti-
  26. hybrid work or remote work and others seems to be okay I I I understand it's a component that we're going to need and I
  27. don't know if it's a generational component or what we're seeing play out here but it is unique that you talk you
  28. hear commentary from some Executives and they are very much anti-hybrid work yeah
  29. no it's definitely true they have serious concerns about it and that you know so it adds up to if you're going to
  30. need to have it because your talent tent wants it and your talent has a lot of power in the labor market then as
  31. managers you got to figure out how to make sure that that is going to still meet the organization's needs right um
  32. and so how to put in place kinds of systems and processes that are going to help it to work smoothly for everybody
  33. right um and there's there's a whole there there's a whole set of challenges associated with that that I think we
  34. still really kind of you know there's been a lot of just let's carry over what we were doing before and hopefully it
  35. applies pretty well for hybrid work but it may be that we need to really kind of
  36. think much more carefully about how we design our onboarding processes our mentoring processes our talent
  37. development and it's got of skills training kind of processes to make sure that people can really um are really
  38. equipped and really have the skills that they need and I guess it's going to be interesting to see play out in the
  39. months and years ahead as to who the people are within the workforce that are majority going to be the people that are
  40. are ending up working hybrid obviously as you said before there's a component of Lifestyle
  41. and things outside of work that are allowing hybrid work to be a good combination but whether or not it is men
  42. or women that see this opportunity as being more applicable to what they want to
  43. have in their careers yeah so I think they're awesome gender differences and we've seen that um in some of the data
  44. right there I think the data that I saw most recently about 10% higher demand from women um for remote work or hybrid
  45. work which makes sense in lots of ways in this when women are doing a lot of the home care and and child care and
  46. need that kind of flexibility um but it's also very much a kind of um time time of your life kind of thing and that
  47. really you know is a really big deal that I think we've we've come to realize a bit more recently so for younger
  48. people more Junior in their careers and not don't necessarily have families and that kind of need that kind of
  49. flexibility at that point in their careers it makes a lot of sense and I think people have you know those young
  50. people who kind of were like oh it's going to be great to be on a beach somewhere no they've kind of realized
  51. right actually there's a lot of value that they get from being in in the work in the workplace and if they're not
  52. there they're going to miss out some stuff they really need like those mentoring kind of and networking kind of
  53. connections um but then you know midlife when people have families a lot of other
  54. demands it can you know people want more flexibility and later in life I think I
  55. suspect it probably diverges a little bit some people really like being in the office some people not so much and
  56. there's maybe just more individual differences I guess we also have to look at it from the perspective of a person's
  57. career and and where that path is going to go and if you are somebody that is working hybri
  58. what potential impact that might have if you are not in the office 5 days a week
  59. but you're you know working remotely two or three days a week yeah so for sure and you know I think as people's careers
  60. evolve it's there's so many good reasons why people want that that flexibility they want to be hybrid or they want to
  61. be remote um that we should respect they're really important right in terms of the rest of your life right and your
  62. ability to manage manage the rest of your life but I think it's really important to recognize that it does come
  63. with some disadvantages and just be conscious of those doesn't mean you shouldn't do it right but it does mean
  64. that you are less visible to possibly your manager who's in the office more than you are and maybe to everybody else
  65. on your team right they just don't quite know if you're there all the time or working as hard as you should be you
  66. don't necessarily have the access to resources that people have when they're in the office more of the time and over
  67. time you know it's probably fine in the short term right but over time that might mean maybe you're not really quite
  68. in the loops that you need to be in with in terms of information maybe you're not
  69. doing your job quite as well or maybe you are and people just see it right and maybe you don't get that promotion as
  70. fast as you might otherwise or whatever you don't get the opportunities that you
  71. might otherwise so again you can make that decision for yourself just make it consciously right that you're making
  72. that tradeoff um and and you know and I think managers have to really be conscious of that too and try to make
  73. sure that they're not they're being fair and they're not disadvantaging people who are taking advantage of work
  74. policies that they've put in place and have agreed they're okay to have in place well and I guess it becomes even
  75. more of a focus for women because there're still elements of the workforce that uh disadvantage women compared to
  76. men so they as you said have to have that kind of conscious understanding of the impacts that that could come along
  77. in the terms of where they want to take their careers yeah and so I think for a women you know I call this a double
  78. disadvantage right there is we know there can be a remote work penalty for anybody who's kind of not in the office
  79. so much especially when other people are in the office more right if you are a a
  80. woman in a malale dominated industry or workplace um you know you automatically probably have a bit of a disadvantage
  81. from that and there's a lot of research showing that in different ways you put together the two disadvantages and you
  82. have a bit of a you know potential at least for a double disadvantage right you're both remote and you're maybe a
  83. bit more marginalized in the first place maybe a little bit less likely to be listen to when you speak maybe a little
  84. bit less likely to be given the best opportunities or hooked up with the most senior male mentors or whatever it might
  85. be um and so again over time that couple double disadvantage could U be a disadvantage could be a substantial
  86. disadvantage for your career right and and again women may choose to make that decision deliberately and consciously
  87. and understand that and still have really good reasons for doing it um but but it's important to be aware of it and
  88. it's also I think worth noting it's not just women I mean I think it's anybody who might be or feel marginalized in the
  89. workplace in the first place could be people of color could be people who are non-dominant language speakers right not
  90. English speakers in an English speaking company just you can get that double disadvantage in other ways right it's
  91. just if you're already a little bit marginal and then you're not in the office as much those things can compound
  92. and from a career point of view you should be aware of that well and off of that because there's there's also been
  93. the conversation as hybrid work has kind of developed of kind of segmenting your
  94. day like you may not be anymore traditionally 9 to5 or 8 to4 but those hours may be spread out over a 12-h hour
  95. window and it makes you wonder whether or not the people who may end up being in that double disadvantage feel like
  96. they have to work a longer day in order to make up for that presence of not being there yeah and we we know that
  97. that has happened it happened to a lot of us during the pandemic and you know hopefully it's eased up for a lot of us
  98. but that sort of sense of being on call the whole time um is you know is an unfortunate byproduct I think of kind of
  99. relying so heavily on technology and not being in the office with clearer um work
  100. hours all the time so yeah it's something to look at but it's also important for people who are working
  101. from home I think to recognize that managers don't see them all the time during the workday so it's kind of don't
  102. know that they're doing their work during all the work day so sort of trying to align their hours with the
  103. manager's hours in some ways is desirable and the manager should not take too much advantage of that and be
  104. trying to you know get people to work you know 12 15 hour days do does technology hopefully fill in maybe some
  105. of those gaps then in those circumstances I mean being able to have a zoom call with your co-workers or does
  106. it does it not do enough do you think I mean technology you know is a is a double-edged sword right it's it's great
  107. for a lot of these things it wouldn't be possible to be doing hybrid work if we didn't have the technologies that we got
  108. used to during the pandemic it would just not have happened in the same way certainly not as fast in terms of being
  109. able to do Zoom calls and being online all the time just you know and easily accessible technology has its
  110. disadvantages too right you don't get the the real kind of cues that you get from being with somebody face to face
  111. you don't get those side conversations that you have when you're in the workplace so it's too easy to think as a
  112. it's a perfect substitute we all know it isn't we also all know that there's too
  113. many Zoom meetings that's right exactly right we rely on that technology too much a little too much you have also
  114. done research looking at the career but the potential of the benefits or or impacts of going International uh of
  115. getting a job offer some other place in the world or working for your company in
  116. another office take us into a deeper dive on how that is impacting the dynamic of career right now yeah so um
  117. I'm I've done a a recent study um with uh my co-authors Matthew Bidwell who's a a colleague of mine here at Wharton um
  118. and Isabella Isabelle Fernandez Mato who's at London Business School and gvan Capone who's in the Netherlands and you
  119. know we we took this big data set of alums MBA alums from one of the leading European Business Schools who tend to be
  120. super International and we looked at their careers over time and how their International moves affect their
  121. compensation right which turns out you there's a lot of research on how International moves might affect your
  122. opportunities but actually they don't usually look at compensation and so we were really interested to understand
  123. um what the effects are on pay and we found some really interesting things which are kind of you know um there
  124. there's research that says you know the stuff is likely to be negative you move internationally and you you know you
  125. kind of lose opportunities you lose your local networks um it's hard to come back
  126. it's hard to resettle and all that stuff maybe it's bad there's other research that says maybe it's good right because
  127. you're gaining all these international skills and maybe somebody's going to pay you more for them right we didn't really
  128. know what we found in the study um and it's a pretty compr prehensive and kind of carefully done study is that when
  129. people people who have moved once or twice and this is post MBA um careers so they their knowledge workers they're in
  130. business careers right um if they've moved once or twice it's actually negatively associated with their pay in
  131. the sense of their pay doesn't grow as fast um as people who haven't moved internationally and we were a little
  132. surprised there's a negative effect right um what then we find on top of that which is kind of even maybe even
  133. more surprising is there are a set of people for whom these International moves are really beneficial
  134. but they people that we call Super globals they're people who have moved internationally many many times and our
  135. study it's four or more times since they're MBA and those people get a substantial pay premium so you know from
  136. a career point of view I think you know International moves can have positive implications in all sorts of ways from a
  137. pure pay point of view um first couple of moves don't seem to have you know not the not you're not doing them
  138. necessarily because they're going to pay you the most sure you may be doing them
  139. for other really good reasons right there are these people who move a ton super globals who you know are the very
  140. elite kind of end of the of the international employment spectrum and they're making a lot of money from it
  141. are those people that end up having all of those experiences and maybe they are more relied upon within the corporate
  142. kind of environment of a company they've seen more they've seen more components of the company and therefore they can
  143. bring more to the table Yeah I think that's right so I mean our sense is that and we did a lot of interviews trying to
  144. understand exactly who who the super globals are what they careers look like why they're so valuable it is the case
  145. that you know some companies really need people who have substantial International experience right because
  146. of the kind of work they do these folks have bu built a really unique set of skills and perspectives and sort of
  147. adaptability and they can COPE in many different environments they can cope with a lot of different unexpected
  148. events right they've often demonstrated that through the way they worked internationally um and then on top of
  149. that these people are rare right so there's not that many people you can find who are going to be able to run
  150. that you know super internationalis out there so once you as a as an employe you
  151. know as somebody you know to in a career where you've moved multiple times you not only have the set of skills but
  152. you're also really rare in the workplace and so you're not you know going to get
  153. employed for some job that doesn't value that but for the jobs that do really value that you can command a premium and
  154. that's what we see in this data and again it it probably falls back into that category of being the personal
  155. decision the understanding of what the components are of that career that really have to be thought about in order
  156. to kind of take that leap yeah that's right in some ways maybe that connects back to our kind of hybrid work
  157. conversation is it's just about being conscious of the choices that you're making right and what we do find
  158. especially for people which will be more people than the super globals right the
  159. people who are thinking about moving once or twice um internationally in their in their careers it's about being
  160. conscious of the trade-offs you're making right and those can be really good trade-offs or really you know valid
  161. trade-offs to make right are you moving because you personally value there's personal enrichment right you love
  162. spending time not just traveling but spending serious time in different countries right and having different
  163. experiences and having adventures and you really want to learn from that are you moving because there are fabulous
  164. professional opportunities for growth that are going to kind of expose you to you know maybe you get to run your own
  165. division or do something that you wouldn't have been able to do domestically and do you really want to
  166. maximize your pay and the chance that those things all go together in at least in the first you know move or two when
  167. you're relatively Junior in your career are not super likely probably going to make trade-offs again just recognize
  168. that that's the trade-off that you're making and it's totally valid right um but don't assume that these things are
  169. necessarily all going to align and and work in your favor so as you say that is does there seemingly come a point in
  170. that process where people kind of make that decision that okay I'm G to kind of be that super Global or maybe I'm not
  171. going to be and that's kind of the you know whether there's a moment in time where that kind of Transitions and and
  172. you go one way or the other yeah I think that probably is for a lot of people I mean it's somebody who's
  173. moved internationally I said my co-authors in the study a lot um you know I think usually at some point you
  174. get to a point where you've most people get to a point where they've kind of moved enough and kind of want to settle
  175. at least for a substantial period of time there are a small number of people who just love it and Thrive and do
  176. extremely well and keep having these kind of international opportunities um that lead them to move but it does it is
  177. interesting I think in the sense of kind of as you're thinking about the skills that you want to develop um and what
  178. you're trying to get out of these different opportunities you know once you're somewhere you kind of think is
  179. maybe the longer term place you want to stay you're going to be trying to develop you know really local networks
  180. and understanding and language and really settle right um and but if you think you're going to keep moving that
  181. kind of local knowledge is important it's probably going to be important for your longer term jobs too but you're
  182. going to need a different set of skills on top of that right adaptability and flexibility and kind of open-mindedness
  183. and Global mindset so you're going to kind of be adding a different layer because you're going to you think you're
  184. going to keep moving Martin great to talk to you great to talk to you too D thank you Martin hos management
  185. Professor here at the won school and director of the Lauder Institute thank you for listening to the ripple effect
  186. we hope you found this episode informative and engaging don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that
  187. we can continue to bring you the best Insight from the warten school

Brief Summary

Martine Hos discusses gender differences in remote work and the impact of international job moves on career growth.

Key points

  • The Ripple Effect Podcast. Exploring the evolving workplace dynamics post-pandemic and the rise of hybrid work.
  • Gender Differences in Hybrid Work. Research shows women have a higher demand for remote work due to caregiving responsibilities.
  • The Double Disadvantage. Women face unique challenges in hybrid work environments, impacting their career advancement.
  • The Challenge of Transitioning. Many people reach a point where they want to settle after moving internationally.
  • Skills for Global Mobility. Adaptability and open-mindedness are crucial for those who keep moving internationally.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes