In Praise of the Office: Why Hybrid Work Has Its Limits

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Wharton professor Peter Cappelli, co-author of the recently published book, In Praise of the Office: The Limits to Hybrid and Remote Work, joins the Ripple Effect to unpack how hybrid and remote work have evolved — and what’s been lost along the way. He explains why productivity, collaboration, and culture suffer when teams rarely meet in person, and how younger employees, in particular, miss out on the unspoken lessons of workplace dynamics. Cappelli also discusses why companies are tightening “work from anywhere” policies, the long-term impact on management practices, and what organizations must do to make hybrid work purposeful and effective.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

#HybridWork #RemoteWork #FutureOfWork #WorkplaceCulture #EmployeeEngagement #Management ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Peter Cappelli: Because, particularly when you're beginning your career, you know, you don't know much that more experienced people
  2. take for granted. Like, how do you get along with people? How do you know when you're not irritating somebody when you're
  3. trying to get help from them? How do you read the boss's emotions, then get a sense informally about what's going
  4. on, what the priorities are? You know, the gossip that helps you understand why somebody got fired that you're never going to
  5. see in a memo, right? You only learn that stuff if you're there face to face, right? And it's important to remind ourselves,
  6. everybody who is saying how wonderful it is to be hybrid are people who began their careers not hybrid, right? They began
  7. their careers in offices where they learned all this stuff. You know, I'm not in an office now, right?
  8. Dan Loney: Welcome to the Ripple Effect, the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host,
  9. Dan Loney. And in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that
  10. Wharton professors have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today. Loney: Well, certainly the
  11. pandemic changed the way that many of us think about work. We were able to be successful in our jobs working from home, but
  12. as we move farther away from the days of the pandemic, more jobs seem to have a hybrid component in them. Three to four days a
  13. week in the office and maybe one to two days a week working from home. But there are issues that pop up when you look at hybrid
  14. or remote work. Peter Cappelli is a Professor of Management here at the Wharton School, as well as director the Center for
  15. Human Resources. He's also co- author of a new book titled, <i>In</i> <i>Praise of the Office: The Limits of Hybrid and Remote Work</i>, and
  16. he joins us right now to discuss the new book. Peter, great to talk to you. How are you, sir? - I'm good, Dan, thank you. - Take
  17. us through, I guess, let's start out with the importance of doing a book like this, especially right now.
  18. - Yeah, I think there are -- there's a practical reason, and there's a bigger reason. The practical reason, I think, is lots of
  19. employers, and by the way, employers, in case we haven't noticed, have all the marbles here. They control everything
  20. about how we're going to work. And I think employers have -- many of them did not want to stay remote or hybrid. They wanted to
  21. come back, and they expected to. But the problem is, they never quite told anybody that. And surprisingly, in 2022, surveys of
  22. employees said they understood why they would have to come back to the office, 88 percent, it was a huge proportion. But if you wait five
  23. years, you know, then people start to get a little irritated if you ask them to come back. So part of it is employers now, I
  24. think, are rethinking whether they wanted to keep this arrangement, which they never often really stamped and
  25. approved, partly because they're seeing productivity issues, and partly, because in hybrid places, I think what's really irritating,
  26. so they can't see, you know, performance so clearly, is attendance. They're just finding nobody's coming in. So I think
  27. that's the practical reason. There's a conceptual issue that concerns me more generally, and we've talked about this at least
  28. once before, and that is, I think there's been this drift over time toward management of employees being worse and worse
  29. and worse and worse, and just cutting, cutting, cutting. We're seeing this on lots of things now. But there's a kind of
  30. belief that is growing in influence that you really don't have to manage people. They don't have to be together, they
  31. don't have to be in an office. You don't do anything for them, really. Just tell them what you want them to do, and if they
  32. don't do it, fire them. You know, and there's 100 years of research showing that's not true, but lots of people want to
  33. believe it, and so that's another reason for doing this book. - What has been lost then by not having employees in the office
  34. five days a week? That inner office connection obviously, is probably part of this. - Yeah, well, I think the -- it's not clear you'd lose
  35. anything with four and a half days in the office, but human contact and connection matters, and we've known this for 100
  36. years of research. You know, some of it is we're engaged and we're committed to the people we work with, not the logo on the
  37. building, especially now, because those just flip all the time. So it matters for those reasons. We also learn a lot
  38. from each other. We, if we have a good workplace, help each other in various ways. We solve problems a lot faster. When we
  39. have conflicts, they don't escalate the way they can if you're doing it by email. So there's lots about the way work
  40. gets done in offices that maybe wasn't so clear to us before, because we never separated office work from an office
  41. structure. But now we're trying to do office work without an office structure, and you can start to see how some of these
  42. problems are popping up. - What about something like career advancement? I mean, if
  43. somebody is out of the office a couple of days a week and maybe doesn't have as much of a connection to the office on a
  44. daily basis, might there be an issue there as well? - Yeah, so you know, there were about 25 years of serious
  45. research about remote work before the pandemic, and it was all about the circumstances you're describing, and that is
  46. you've got some people in the office and a few who are not in or not in very often, and the way hybrid is playing out, this
  47. is maybe more likely than we would think. Even though we have anchor days, people aren't showing up for them. So if you're in the
  48. office, the prior evidence was overwhelming that you got ahead, and if you were not, you didn't. Everything was worse, work wise,
  49. for you. You didn't get promoted as often. Your wages were lower. Your engagement was lower. Your commitment was lower. Your
  50. turnover was higher. So you know, if you have to choose and you are going to be the outlier at home when your colleagues are
  51. in the office, just expect it might be worth it for you, but your career is likely to take a hit.
  52. - What about for new employees? It seems like one of the stories we've heard a lot in the last few years is, you know, kids
  53. coming out of college, going into the workforce, have developed this expectation that hybrid work is how they are
  54. going to work their career. - Yeah, they might think that. I always ask their parents, and when you get a group of people in a room for
  55. executive education and other things, and many of them are big fans of hybrid, you know? But I asked him, "If your kid had a
  56. choice of going into the office or working remotely, what would you tell him?" And virtually everybody says you should go to
  57. the office, right? Because, particularly when you're beginning your career, you know, you don't know much that more
  58. experienced people take for granted. Like, how do you get along with people? How do you know when you're not irritating
  59. somebody when you're trying to get help from them? How do you read the boss's emotions, then get a sense informally about
  60. what's going on, what the priorities are? You know, the gossip that helps you understand why somebody got fired that
  61. you're never going to see in a memo, right? You only learn that stuff if you're there face to face, right? And it's important
  62. to remind ourselves, everybody who is saying how wonderful it is to be hybrid are people who began their careers not hybrid,
  63. right? They began their careers in offices where they learned all this stuff. You know, I'm not in an office now, right? And
  64. I've been at Wharton for 40 years. I've got a pretty good idea how the place works. Doesn't hurt me that much. It probably
  65. does hurt my junior colleagues that I'm not there more often. I should confess I'm on sabbatical now, so I'm not required to be
  66. in the office. But that's a big issue, a generational divide. Senior people don't want to be there. They don't need to, but
  67. junior people need them there. - Well, and this goes a little bit to another topic that
  68. you and I have talked about on a variety of occasions, is that of workplace culture and how valued that component has become for
  69. the office, not even, you know, after the pandemic or during it, but before that it was starting to really gain in
  70. value, in terms of having a successful office, partly was because you had to have a great culture.
  71. - Yeah, I think, for sure, employers at the top have recognized that's something they're supposed to do is build
  72. the culture. When we say culture, we really mean, what are the rules, unstated, that tell you how you're supposed to
  73. behave and what's important? And you learn those rules by watching, right? Seeing who gets rewarded for what, who gets in
  74. trouble for what. What do the senior people do? What do they seem to value? And it's not the sheet of paper that comes around
  75. and says, "This is our culture," right? Those things are all aspirational, and they all kind of say the same thing.
  76. But it does matter if people understand the same unwritten rules about how things are supposed to work, and you can't
  77. learn that if you are remote, at least not now, the way things are operating now. - But
  78. we do occasionally see companies calling back employees full time. Is the expectation that it's going to continue that way kind
  79. of in dribs and drabs? That firms will kind of reach some kind of boiling point, or some, you know, component, and they
  80. feel like they need to bring employees back full time? - Well, there's a stunning survey done by KPMG this year where
  81. they say that they've surveyed C- suite people, and that 83 percent, I think, say they expect everybody to be back in the office within
  82. three years. Are they right about that? You know, these forecasts are rarely very accurate. But for sure, there doesn't seem to be
  83. any uptick in push to get people out of the office. And by the way, for people who think this is all just about cynical
  84. managers, if they were really cynical and just cynical and cost conscious, it's way cheaper to not have an office,
  85. right? It's way cheaper to just push everybody out and send them home and try to get things done, because you save all that office
  86. space overhead costs, right? And the fact that they're not doing that means they must see some kind of value.
  87. - But are there scenarios where hybrid is maybe the best option for an individual
  88. employee? - Well, for sure, for employees. I mean, this is why this is so politically charged, right? For employees, many of them have
  89. built lives around hybrid work arrangements. Unfortunately, they've also built lives around the lack of enforcement of
  90. hybrid arrangements, you know? Like, you have anchor days, but nobody's expecting you to be there, and nobody's enforcing
  91. them, right? And then you adapt to that, and then, of course, you're all irritated when the companies do start
  92. enforcing those rules. But you could get a lot -- I mean, this is mainly what our book is about. You could get a lot of the
  93. advantages of in person, and not have everybody there four days a week or five days a week, but you have to be a lot more
  94. purposeful about it, you know? If employees are only there two days a week, and by the way, it's not going to be the same
  95. employees all the time now, because companies have shrunk their office space. They can't even get everybody back
  96. anymore at once. So if that's the case, and I'm a new employee, it's going to take me a long time to figure out even
  97. what my peers and bosses are kind of like as people. And that all has a cost, right? You could speed that up, but you have to
  98. be purposeful about it. You could speed up social interactions, but you have to be purposeful about it. And so far,
  99. the problem, and one of the motivations for this book, is that we haven't been purposeful. We basically just sort of
  100. assumed that people who are in remote and hybrid are really just the same as they were in the office, and it's not.
  101. - How do you, then, do you expect to see this play out over the next several years ahead? You know, where does
  102. this -- when we revisit this in a decade, where are we looking? - Yeah, I try not to make predictions, because I'm rarely
  103. very good at them. One thing which is quirky, though, about we have an equilibrium, that view, which we hear a lot. You know,
  104. just the equilibrium keeps changing, right? Is that employers, and particularly human resource people, you see this a lot,
  105. really, really want to fit in with what everybody else is doing. And right now, quite unusually, we have just a big
  106. variety of practices across organizations. Is that going to be stable? Are employers going to grow, used to the fact that
  107. what they're doing is not what everybody else is doing? And I don't think so, right? So if you saw, after Amazon announced at the
  108. beginning of this year, they were bringing everybody back, there was suddenly an uptick of other big companies doing the
  109. same thing, right? When Jamie Dimon announced that, not only are they bringing everybody back, but they're building a new
  110. building sort of suited to everybody being in the office, ears perked up around Wall Street, and that started to
  111. shift there too. So I don't think it's going to be stable, but I also don't think that by next year everybody's going to
  112. be back in the office either. I think it'll be a years long change exercise. - So then when a new employee gets an offer and it includes a
  113. hybrid component, how do you think they should view the offer and how they should view going into that job? Because I think
  114. you and I both, I think, feel that the value of being in the office, if it's four days a week, if it's five days a week,
  115. it is really valuable, especially for a new employee. - Yeah, well, I guess what I would say is, to some extent, nobody will
  116. prevent you from being there more than the anchor days, right? But if you've got an organization with say, oh, it's hybrid, but it's
  117. only two days a week, and you ask them, you know, "How is that determined?" Well, every local manager gets to decide,
  118. which is often the case. I would, other things equal, not go. And the reason is because, even if you're going to go in,
  119. people are not going to be there, right? And you won't get the benefits of being there, right? So, you know, I would say
  120. when you're beginning your career, you need to meet people, you need to learn, and you're going to learn by watching and
  121. asking questions. That's really hard to do if it's not face to face. So if you think it's not going to work, even if you can
  122. go in, unless other people are there, it's not going to help you. - How do you hope that this book resonates
  123. in the workplace moving forward? - Well, you know, I hope what would happen is that employers
  124. take this more seriously. That is the question. But also, okay, we want to be hybrid. How can we do it better? And will they be
  125. willing to do that? I don't know. To be honest, I'm not the most optimistic person. But it requires effort and time from
  126. the senior people in the companies. And I guess the trend I've been seeing over the recent years is that they're less and
  127. less interested in hands on management, and more and more interested in being the kind of outside boss who's cutting deals, who
  128. is doing M&A's, is working on finance. And the inside of the organization doesn't have a lot of direction, you know? And this
  129. will take a lot of direction to make this better. Now, maybe there's a way to delegate that. If you have a Chief
  130. Operating Officer, for example, maybe there's a way to delegate that. It's not going to -- by the way, human resource people do
  131. not volunteer for this job, because if they give it to you, you don't have the power to execute it. You're just going to
  132. end up looking bad. So, you know, it can't be delegated to lower level people. It can't be delegated to people who don't
  133. have power. And it's not going to work if you let each little group decide what they're going to do. You're quickly going to
  134. get a race to the bottom, because nobody wants to be the bad guy telling their employees they're the ones who have to
  135. come in. - Peter, always great to talk with you. Congratulations on the book, and look forward to chatting again. - Thank you, Dan,
  136. and happy birthday. - Thank you very much. And the book is titled, <i>In Praise of the Office: The Limits of Hybrid and Remote</i>
  137. <i>Work</i>. Peter Cappelli, our guest, is the one of the authors, Professor of Management here at the Wharton School, and director
  138. of the Center for Human Resources. - Thank you for listening to the Ripple Effect. We hope you found this episode
  139. informative and engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight
  140. from the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Peter Cappelli discusses the importance of in-person work for new employees and the challenges of hybrid work arrangements.

Key points

  • Employers Control the Work Environment. Cappelli discusses how employers dictate the terms of hybrid work, impacting employee experiences.
  • Career Advancement and Office Presence. Cappelli reveals that being in the office significantly impacts career growth and opportunities.
  • The Importance of In-Person Work. Peter Cappelli emphasizes the critical learning that occurs face-to-face, especially for new employees.
  • Hybrid Work Requires Intentionality. Cappelli highlights that to reap the benefits of hybrid work, companies must be purposeful.
  • Skepticism About Future Changes. Cappelli shares his doubts about the effectiveness of hybrid work arrangements moving forward.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes