Are Colleges Failing to Prepare Students for Work?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Are colleges failing to prepare students for work? Or do employers have an unrealistic view of their labor supply chain? Wharton professor Peter Cappelli’s research finds fault on both sides. More: http://knlg.net/1l8ElN1 📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so I'm finishing up a book project and the book is uh tentatively titled parents as Venture capitalists because
  2. uh the idea is to see if we can trick parents into reading this book and think about what's going on with uh education
  3. in particularly college and the context for this is that there's an enormous amount of complaining going on in the US
  4. now by the employer community about difficulty in hiring people finding people with the right skills and
  5. much of that complaining seems to be directed at education and uh one of the things we
  6. wanted to look at was to see whether this is actually true that is whether there's any Merit to these complaints
  7. and when you look carefully it appears that there really isn't any Merit to it that the big change seems to be that
  8. employers are not training people that uh entry-level jobs have largely gone away way and that what employers are
  9. really after is hiring people who can do the job as soon as they walk in the door
  10. and the proof for that has to be that you are currently doing the same job someplace else for a competitor that's
  11. what everybody wants to to hire nevertheless uh the pressure has come around to students and to colleges to
  12. try to get more vocational and so I'm trying to look at what that means and whether it's actually a good idea and
  13. the conclusion I think pretty clearly is no it's not a good idea and you can see
  14. obviously that it's taken to Extremes in some places there are courses at most every state university on turf
  15. management for example which is you know about golf courses and there are courses
  16. and majors in things like Adventure tourism and casino management and every little weird niche in the market and I
  17. think the uh ultimately I think the issue here is that higher education postsecondary education is just not well
  18. suited to deliver job training and getting your first job is probably not ultimately what your college education
  19. is supposed to be about uh but for parents of course it's a big issue of how much money you're spending for this
  20. and whether there will be a payoff at the at the end of it so I'd say at the moment there's an awful lot of concern
  21. parents are wearing my kid going to get a job the employers are complaining we want to hire people with a particular
  22. set of skills the colleges are kind of in the middle uh but it's a peculiar supply chain problem I think at the
  23. moment the the parents and the students potential students are so far removed from where the employers are in terms of
  24. information but also just in terms of timing the employers are saying here's what we want but it'll be five years
  25. we're not making any promises and the kids are trying to pick majors and colleges to go to based on the job
  26. market and it's it's really a mess right now I think is the punchline so I think the the takeaways
  27. at the moment maybe the first takeaway is that there's an incredible amount of variation in how well different colleges
  28. prepare you for all kinds of things uh when we hear policy makers talk about the need for more people go to college
  29. and um you know everybody President Obama says Needs at least a year of some sort of
  30. college the variation is so astonishing that talking about college in general doesn't really make very much sense you
  31. know there are maybe 10% of colleges in the US where going there actually hurts your rate of return if you look at what
  32. you have to pay to go there and what you're likely to learn from that afterwards in terms of your Market
  33. market value the best thing you could do is drop out that you're really not gaining anything at all from those
  34. schools uh and there are others that you know you have a terrific even immediate
  35. return um and still there are others where we think the long-term value of the education is way better than the
  36. first year job you're going to get out of this so I think the big return is that there's a huge variance the
  37. information is really poor about which schools are good ones or maybe even how to think about the problem and so it
  38. does suggest there's a real opportunity for information to make a difference and
  39. a little more careful thinking to make a difference as well I think the the thing that I found
  40. most surprising and disappointing I guess really is how messed up the system is I mean the extent to which uh kids
  41. are borrowing enormous amounts of money and going into debt um chasing what they
  42. think are job opportunities that may or may not be their years in the future I think the focus on very practical Majors
  43. um is I think ending up really turning around to bite people if you happen to graduate in a year when there's no
  44. Casino management jobs what do you do I think you're probably worse off uh than you would be with a Classics degree you
  45. know sort of equally unprepared for anything but at least um you know literate and understanding good
  46. arguments and critical thinking um but you know a lot of very vocational um experiences in College
  47. learning a lot of very practical things in the long run I think is very much a waste of time so I think the uh maybe
  48. the surprising conclusion first how messed up the system is and secondly the idea that being very
  49. vocational probably actually hurts you so I think a practical consideration here start starts with the maybe the
  50. first assertion and that is there's a heck of a lot of uncertainty and so planning today where you think the job
  51. market is going to be in five years is probably a Fool's errand it's just not going to work very well so uh one of the
  52. things we know in general from all aspects of business is shortening the forecasting time works a lot better so
  53. one of the obvious takeaways is delay your choice of major and delay your specification
  54. uh as long as possible and so in practice one of the things that also means is if you go to a college where
  55. it's going to be difficult to change Majors that's a real problem because it's quite likely that the student will
  56. end up being stuck there longer maybe having to do a fifth year as a way to try to get the courses that allow them
  57. to graduate with the new major they would like I have a son who did exactly that it ends up being a lot more
  58. expensive if it takes 5 years to get a degree as opposed to four well you know some obvious ones are
  59. if you can cut down the cost UPF front it's easier to get a better return on your investment and the information on
  60. what kind of school pays off is not um maybe not completely clear but uh it it's it may not be the case that it
  61. matters so much if you don't get into these super Elite schools so if you're level below there it might not matter
  62. very much uh there's a big area of maybe 50% of the distribution of colleges based on quality that if you're in there
  63. anywhere in there it doesn't matter all that much I'd say the other maybe most interesting thing that I seem to be
  64. finding is that there's kind of an emerging model where um your employability after you graduate is
  65. driven by things that don't have to do with your college education per se they have to do certainly with the
  66. internships you've gotten and there are even a a network of vendors now that will give a recent college graduate work
  67. experience in some field where perhaps they never majored in college or know nothing about so there are places that
  68. will turn you into an IT person in six months for example uh and it's not classroom training so much it's real
  69. work experience you learn by doing as an appr model might might teach you and at
  70. the end of that experience what you get are uh references basically that say you
  71. know this person did the website for me this student solved this it problem for us they managed this project whatever it
  72. is so it might very well be that you're better off thinking about your employability being driven by
  73. experiences which are extracurricular as opposed to curricular things that go on
  74. in the classroom you know I think there are three sets of stakeholders in this discussion about
  75. colleges in the workplace there's obviously parents um and we've been talking a little bit about the parents
  76. uh concerns here about getting their kids jobs and the importance of thinking longer term there's also schools
  77. colleges in the middle which have been playing something of a brokerage role uh but may not have been doing a very good
  78. job of it to to be honest it's not clear that they are um you know really engaging the
  79. employers especially and that they're necessarily doing the best for the for the kids and then there's employers on
  80. the other end and I think the lessons for employers is that if you think about this as a supply chain you would never
  81. manage any other supply chain like this where you just complained loudly uh that
  82. you weren't finding what you wanted from your suppliers and you're just hoping they're going to produce it um at a
  83. price you want to pay they're just going to deliver it to your right but that is the way most employers
  84. seem to be thinking about the labor market that somehow the right people will just show up when they want them
  85. with the right skills I'd say the way to think about this as a supply chain problem is the employers who are the end
  86. users here really have to get closer to their suppliers which is the very least of the schools and maybe even before
  87. that uh the parents you know one of the interesting things we see um in other countries especially in India is the
  88. extent to which which employers are reaching out to parents uh even when they hire people you know they make the
  89. pitch to the parents not to the kids and try to make the pitch at the school level before kids pick their Majors
  90. maybe even at the high school level before they pick their colleges about what the opportunities are like with
  91. their company or maybe even in that field President Obama has had this effort for a little while a few months
  92. on about accountability and higher education and the scorecard they're trying to produce for higher education
  93. which is a good idea as a parent or any kind of student or anybody you could go on the website and try to see what does
  94. it cost to go to school here what are the job prospects like if you graduate with this degree or that degree and I
  95. think it's a it's a good start you know I think we've still got a problem that there's so much variation in the
  96. experience uh of individual students students depending on when they go and which major they choose at which school
  97. um that it's not a perfect solution but at least it's a start uh to get some sense about whether you're sending your
  98. kid to a an expensive college that's going to do them any good or not uh and I think it's really hard to know you
  99. know schools have gotten very good at marketing or at least better than the parents are at understanding the
  100. marketing and where do you go for objective information so you know it's not a bad
  101. start well one of the things we hear a lot is about the stem skill problem and stem
  102. stands for science technology engineering and math and the idea that we need lots more stem graduates well uh
  103. there's no real evidence for that and if you look at where they actually get jobs
  104. for example uh in the real Sciences like like biology about 20% maybe 25% of students who graduate with a degree in
  105. biology get a job that uses biology and even in fields which we think are hot like it
  106. only about 2third of people who graduate with an IT degree get a job in it and when they're asked why they don't the
  107. main explanation is they couldn't find one right so the idea that if you get a stem degree you're suddenly going to be
  108. fixed your problems are solved really is does not seem to be true you know there's a lot of reason
  109. research on labor markets and there's a huge industry in higher education but you know one of the issues in research
  110. is that research tends to fit within disciplines within paradigms where they don't talk to each other very much and
  111. so one of the things I'm trying to do here is to look across these different fields so you can see what the highered
  112. folks are saying about educational quality you can see what the labor market folks say about the wage outcomes
  113. from different jobs um you can can see what people in learning say about you know what sorts of contexts teach people
  114. the most and you know you can start to see maybe some patterns across these things you know I think this is a uh
  115. this is kind of a Capstone production right so I've done uh and doing some pretty focused studies and things like
  116. financial aid and student outcomes uh but you know a book like this which is pulling together a lot of things know is
  117. kind of it so my guess is I'm not following up this with anything um following this this is kind of it this
  118. is sort of what I know on this topic certainly the the current generation of kids in college have lived through a
  119. really difficult time worst labor market since the Great Depression and it's understandable that people would be
  120. anxious about this and especially parents of kids who are entering college now and those are about to leave I think
  121. the the good news is the economy is getting better and it's unlikely to look the way things look now in four or five
  122. years it's more likely to look like the way things did 10 years or so ago so I think the current circumstances are
  123. pretty unusual I think the other thing is it isn't clear that obsessing about jobs um now when you're in early in
  124. college or in high school for sure for sure it does you any good right uh it isn't clear that simply getting into the
  125. best college you can is going to make a defining difference in your life afterwards and particularly your
  126. economic prospects afterwards that there's plenty of time you got the rest of your life to worry about your uh
  127. about your career and your success is going to have more to do with how you manage those points than anything you
  128. can do about it in high school or or even in college for that matter so I I think the the advice for parents is
  129. things are going to get better they're already starting to get better and I'm worrying about it right now doesn't do
  130. very much good cuz there's not much that's going to [Music] matter

Brief Summary

The episode critiques college education's effectiveness in preparing students for jobs and suggests parents rethink their approach to education.

Key points

  • Parents as Venture Capitalists. Exploring how parents can engage with education and job readiness for their children.
  • The Vocational Degree Dilemma. The risks of pursuing vocational degrees without guaranteed job opportunities.
  • Uncertainty in Job Market Planning. Advice on the unpredictability of job markets and educational choices.
  • A Hopeful Outlook. Encouragement for parents about the improving job market.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes