Will AI Actually Replace Jobs?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE AI is changing the workplace, but is it really replacing jobs yet? Peter Cappelli, Wharton Professor of Management, breaks down why artificial intelligence has not led to widespread job loss, how companies are approaching AI investments, and what workers and new graduates should understand about the future of productivity and employment.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#ai #futureofwork #productivity #jobs #artificialintelligence ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Well, as we are in the middle of graduation season, everybody thinking about that next job,
  2. and one of the components that they will be dealing with as we move forward is the impact
  3. that artificial intelligence is having and will have down the road. Pleasure to be joined by
  4. Peter Capelli, Management Professor here at the Wharton School. Peter, great to talk again. How
  5. are you, sir? I'm good. Dan, how are you? I'm doing well. Let me start with this time of the year,
  6. and you having been at Wharton so long, in the conversations you have with students, what is
  7. kind of the expectation you give of them of what they're going into? Well, I mean, this won't surprise anybody. There's just tons of uncertainty, right? And
  8. the reality of AI is lagging, or perception is lagging the reality by a lot. So I've been
  9. spending a fair bit of time just trying to talk to organizations that have actually introduced AI,
  10. as opposed to people who are just talking about what it will do. Right. And, you know, the gap is
  11. just enormous. I mean, one of the things that you learn from even looking from survey data is
  12. there's not nearly as much effort to really introduce AI into the work stream of organizations
  13. as you would think. That it's mainly people using it at their desk to draft better memos and that
  14. sort of stuff. But they're not taking over tasks, except for that simple stuff that you would do,
  15. like, you know, write letters or answer email or something, or summarize documents, right?
  16. Yeah. We've seen a lot of that. Yeah. But really putting it into the workplace where it would take over tasks, we're not seeing that. The evidence about it taking over jobs,
  17. there's really, like, no good evidence of that. And lots of evidence that it's just not happening.
  18. Here's the latest one I just saw. And that is a survey of chief financial officers who you would
  19. think might have an incentive to exaggerate this because Wall Street likes the idea that you would.
  20. Right. Right. And they report that AI has reduced jobs by 0.4%. So four-tenths of a percent.
  21. Yeah. Much. And unfortunately, it's become the story that is kind of the hot-button topic out there.
  22. And so when you hear a company cut jobs and there is something attached to it saying,
  23. well, it's because of the advent of AI, how do you respond to that? Well, there have been sort of three stages of the explanations, right? And I don't think any
  24. of them have been true, to be honest. The first was, you know, that AI has cut, is reducing our
  25. headcount. And if you look at that, you discover, and if you ask, you know, has it actually taken
  26. over jobs? The answer there has been no. Right. And then the second one was, Amazon in particular
  27. was very upfront about this with its 14,000 layoffs. We anticipate that it will take over
  28. jobs, which if you think about it is kind of a very bizarre thing that you would cut jobs now
  29. in anticipation that eventually they'll be taken over. So where's the work going to get done?
  30. Right. Right. That didn't sound right either. The thing we have heard now is a third explanation. And that is
  31. that the layoffs are because we need to save money to invest in AI. Right. Yeah.
  32. Mark Zuckerberg said this about Meta the other day, quite literally, and you're hearing it
  33. elsewhere as well. So I did a little look into that and whether that sounds credible
  34. and just run it through for you a little bit. Most of the big tech companies that are making
  35. these kinds of arguments, they've got over a hundred billion dollars in cash or so. They're
  36. cash generators, right? Yeah. And they've got market cap of three, $4 trillion. I mean, they're enormously valuable companies.
  37. And they're talking about making big investments, over a hundred billion dollars
  38. of investments in AI. If you ask the investment community and the analysts, where's the money
  39. coming from? They say it's going to come from their revenues, which are at record levels.
  40. And then if you look at what you're going to save from these layoffs, some estimates,
  41. you lay off 10,000 managers, you might save $2 billion. $1 billion has got to go to basically
  42. help them leave the cost of severance and things. So upfront, you're saving a billion dollars
  43. on an investment of a hundred billion, where you've already got a hundred billion dollars
  44. in cash sitting around. Come on. It's not that big a thing. It's just a drop in the bucket.
  45. And the only reason it is happening is if you believe you really didn't need these people in
  46. the first place, right? Right. And I think that's the reality. And why that is, is a much more complicated question.
  47. So then, is some of this then potentially still a little bit of a leftover from the pandemic time
  48. when we saw companies adding bodies and adding bodies and adding bodies, and they kept people
  49. on to a certain point? And maybe now is this point where they're starting to trim a little bit?
  50. Ooh, that's a really good point. And I just was trying to float that argument to some people. I
  51. was at a conference of HR people yesterday, and we were trying to figure out why are these cuts
  52. happening now? Because business is booming, right? I mean, one of these companies are arguing we're
  53. in any financial trouble. And there was an undercurrent of kind of belief that what was
  54. going on here was kind of payback. Because it's not just that we're getting layoffs. It's the
  55. pushing people to come back to the office. It's squeezing budgets. You may have seen this story
  56. about Deloitte and Zillow and some other companies cutting paid time off days. Yeah.
  57. In the middle of, you know, what is a business boom? And so, you know, why is that? And that
  58. sounds like a credible explanation, at least to a lot of HR people. But going back to what you were talking about before about AI, it's obvious from so many people
  59. using AI in their regular life, the benefit that it can provide to a lot of those, as you said,
  60. smaller tasks to be able to make sure that you're, you know, you're able to get work done faster and
  61. cleaner. And that's going to be the benefit for companies moving forward in that their, you know,
  62. profitability is going to rise over the course of time because things are moving smoother.
  63. Yeah. I think to the extent to which it raises, you know, productivity and saves you some time,
  64. which translates into productivity increase, this is exactly what an economy wants to happen,
  65. right? We've gone a very long time with pretty low increases in national productivity. And this
  66. is exactly what we would like to see. What I can tell you, we're looking at these companies that
  67. introduce it, though, is that it takes a lot of effort to put these tools into the workflow. It's
  68. a lot of organization change stuff. It requires a lot of help from your employees. You know,
  69. even in white collar jobs, the idea that you're just going to pop an AI agent into it, or you can
  70. sprinkle it like pixie dust over the organization, you know, you got to figure out where to do it.
  71. You've got to get those employees to help you train even a chat GBT like instrument so that
  72. it's giving you the answers that really are useful. You got to check it to make sure it's not giving
  73. you stuff that's dumb. Every time you change the question a little bit, you got to be checking that
  74. stuff. So you do need employees help on this. And if you're not getting it, it's not going to work
  75. very well. What does that mean then for the younger generation coming into the workforce?
  76. I think what you're basically saying is if you're more AI proficient, the better off you're going to
  77. be as you move forward here. Well, you know, I think there's a couple of myths about that. The
  78. first is in none of these places that I see that there was any skill involved in using AI tools.
  79. Right. Right. I mean, the reason that they're so prolific is they're so easy to use.
  80. What you do have a shortfall in is on the management side. This is really organization
  81. change stuff. And one of the things we've heard on the tech consulting side is their need and their
  82. willingness now to bring in management consultant help to try to get them to figure out how to make
  83. this stuff work. You know, there's another thing that also I'm seeing fairly often now, and that is
  84. that, you know, this notion that the simple jobs will all go away because AI can take them over
  85. is not looking true. And the reason for that is because to take over simple jobs, the first point
  86. is it doesn't save you much money. A simple job don't pay much. So if you eliminate a few minimum
  87. wage workers, you're not saving a lot of money. And often the tools that you need to take over
  88. simple jobs, which are kind of yes, no jobs, you know, is this an application? Is this an appeal?
  89. You know, stack them, that sort of stuff that requires machine learning tools. And those are
  90. quite expensive to build. And if you're the CFOs, we're starting to hear CFOs now no longer writing
  91. a blank check for AI stuff on the hope that it will cut headcount. Right. And so now they're saying,
  92. OK, show us what the return is really going to be here. The complication there is the costs are all
  93. up front and the benefits come later on with increased productivity. But that might be years
  94. down the road. And it's really a burden to get an ROI that's going to be reasonable if you're front
  95. loading cause benefits come years later. Especially if you're talking about the difference in years and
  96. seeing the benefit being 10 or 20 years down the road to take that hit at the front end of your
  97. statement and not see it for such a long period of time. Oh, yeah. I mean, I mean, I think in this
  98. case, you know, you might see it in two, three years, something like that. Right. Start to see it.
  99. But, you know, the upfront costs can be really big, especially if you're including the costs of
  100. organizational change and the time and effort to try to get these things to work. It's it's, you
  101. know, sometimes really hard. So I think the idea that all simple jobs will be automated, it's not
  102. looking like that. In fact, the big opportunity is really in white collar work. It's not so much in
  103. frontline work. Right. And I think the assumption was and I'll finish up on this is that this was
  104. going to have a greater impact on blue collar jobs, especially ones that had that connection
  105. with the public. But for many companies, they want that still they need to have that connection with
  106. the public. Having that human being, you know, conversation, it's valuable or else they're going
  107. to lose customers. Yeah. Wait staff are not going away. Right. And store owners, you know, they
  108. still need clerks and those sorts of jobs. I think one of the reasons there is so much panic about
  109. this stuff is precisely because it was it had the possibility to affect middle class jobs and
  110. college graduate jobs. And I think what what we are seeing is the slow adjustment of employers
  111. to realize that, OK, maybe I like in consulting or accounting can take over the tasks that we
  112. initially had college graduates do. And so and at first they said, OK, well, we don't need these
  113. people. And then somebody maybe smarter thought, OK, if you don't hire people this year, you won't
  114. have any two year veterans next year. Right. And why don't we just give them more to do now?
  115. So I can do a lot of these things. All right. Have them do the tasks, manage those. Let's
  116. give them some smarter things to do. Right. And that's what we're seeing. The consulting
  117. companies have already come around to doing. Peter, always great to talk with you and get
  118. your insight. Thank you, sir. Thank you, Dan. Nice to see you. Always great to see you as well.
  119. Peter Capelli, management professor here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Peter Capelli discusses AI's limited impact on job loss and the importance of human roles in the workforce.

Key points

  • The Reality of AI Integration. Despite expectations, AI is not taking over jobs as anticipated.
  • AI's Impact on Jobs. A survey reveals AI has only reduced jobs by 0.4%.
  • Layoffs and AI Investment. Companies are cutting jobs to save money for AI investments, but is it justified?
  • Future Workforce Skills. Being AI proficient is crucial for the younger generation entering the workforce.
  • AI's Role in White Collar Work. The biggest opportunities lie in white collar jobs, not blue collar.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes