How Phones in School Policies Shape Learning and Mental Health

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Angela Duckworth, Rosa Lee and Egbert Chang Professor at The Wharton School, joins Dan Loney to discuss cellphone policy in schools, drawing on recent research on the topic. They explore current data on existing cellphone policies, their implementation, and their effects on students’ mental health and academic performance. The discussion also touches on broader technology-related factors, education policy, and next steps for research in this area.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#EducationPolicy #StudentMentalHealth #ClassroomManagement #DigitalDistractions #K12education ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. The topic of smartphones in schools has become an important one in the last couple of years. School districts are
  2. trying to set proper policy that has a positive impact on students and their learning. The problem is that many in
  3. education feel that cell phones hinder that process. Pleasure to be joined right now by Angela Duckworth who's a
  4. professor of operations, information, and decisions here at the Wharton School. She is part of new research
  5. coming out about this topic specifically and what we're seeing in our schools at
  6. the moment. Angela, great to talk to you again. How are you? >> Thank you for having me. I'm good.
  7. >> It's interesting you and I were talking about this before we started this interview. This has obviously become a
  8. very important topic in and around the school right now. I think not only is school cell phone policy an urgent
  9. topic, it may be one of the last bipartisan topics there is in the universe. So whether you are red or
  10. blue, whether you are pro- teacher union or pro-charter school, like we have not
  11. found the educator who doesn't care about this issue and who doesn't feel like we should be doing more than we're
  12. doing right now, >> right? And and so obviously the the the component of learning is a big one here,
  13. but as you just alluded to, there's an element of this is is how the teachers are dealing with this and being able to
  14. try and work through their normal process during a day. >> You know, the policy the default policy
  15. for um you know, several years just I'm talking about nationwide, right? Just sort of like what are K12 schools doing
  16. about phones? Um, in America, you know, for a long time, the default is that every teacher reigns supreme over their
  17. classroom and that includes phones. So, if you are a teacher who says, "I don't care." And you can have your phones on
  18. your person, great, that's your classroom. But then when the students go to the next period, they might have a
  19. teacher who does care and then you have to put your phones in a cubby and and so
  20. forth. And that is actually how much of American education works, right? uh but in the case of phones I think what we
  21. have is what some scientists call collective action trap um that is where individual decision-m individual
  22. willpower is no match for the problem and I think what teachers have been saying in our survey data which I know
  23. we're here to talk about is that they need help just legislate cell phone policy as a teacher on their own
  24. separate from what the school is doing as a Okay. So, let's dig into the research
  25. because this is part of a larger research project that you're on is ongoing right now. This first part was a
  26. survey about some of these policies. >> So, there is a national survey that is up and running right now. We we we're
  27. like a convenience store, you know, 247. We never close. And it lives at www.phonesinfocus.org.
  28. and any school teacher in the United States, we're looking for public school teachers, K12, can can log on and in a
  29. confidential way share in a matter of minutes what the policy is at their school and from their perspective, you
  30. know, how's it going. We're really interested in looking for changes in policy that predict changes in outcome.
  31. So on the same survey, you're also asked you whether your policy at your school has changed in recent years, and if so,
  32. how. And what we're seeing in the 20,000 plus responses that we've already received from public school educators
  33. across all 50 states is an important pattern, which is that the stricter the policy, the happier the teacher. And
  34. again, in this cross-sectional snapshot, the stricter the policy, the less distraction there is for students uh in
  35. in terms of their academic work. >> One of the things you brought up to me beforehand, and it's an interesting
  36. component of it when you're thinking about these rules, the proximity of where a student can hold their phone is
  37. also a factor in this as well. You know, one way to appreciate the importance of
  38. physical distance on psychological distance and there really is a a kind of a law in psychology that you know more
  39. physical distance creates more psychological distance from from temptation. One way we can appreciate
  40. this is to consider our own relationship with our phone. I don't know any adults
  41. who have a completely unconlicted, you know, um I' I've got this um relationship with their own phones. This
  42. is not a teenager problem. I think it's not just a kid problem. And if I have my
  43. phone, you know, one ft away, one foot away, like that's a different level of temptation than if I, for example, have
  44. my phone in another room or if you really want to get me off my phone. If you put my phone upstairs and I have to
  45. walk up eight stairs to get it, of course, it's trivial, right? Like, well, how hard could that be?
  46. >> But but yeah, that makes a huge difference. And that may be why we're finding that schools, for example, who
  47. require their students to keep their phones in their hallway lockers, which are not, you know, 1 ft away from them
  48. when they're in class. They're typically more than 30 feet away from them. And in
  49. fact, they can be on a different floor. You know, those schools perform extremely well in the outcome data that
  50. we are collecting. And one of the other components of the policy angle on this is uh not just how from potential
  51. classroom to classroom that different teachers have different thoughts about cell phone policy but within the school
  52. structure itself K through 12 that you may come up with one policy in grade school, one policy in middle school and
  53. another one in high school. >> We find a pattern again across the United States that actually I I can't
  54. speak for the whole team. It surprised me. So when you think about cell phones, you typically think about teenagers and
  55. you think about social media again, you think about teenagers. And when you worry, you worry about teenagers. But
  56. we're finding that the schools that serve teenagers, which are the high schools, right? That's grade 9 through
  57. 12, 14 to 18 years old, those schools paradoxically have the the least strict rules. So perhaps arguably just when
  58. students need the most support in regulating their attention, their impulses to stay focused on academic
  59. work, which in prior research shows teenagers recognize that academic work is good for their long-term future. This
  60. is true across the board across socio economic status. A students, F students, everybody knows that school is good for
  61. them. And so it is in the teen years perhaps when students need the most support and when temptations are
  62. strongest that we give them the least support in terms of school cell phone policies. Only one in four schools in
  63. our sample at the high school level has a bellto bell policy meaning you can't use it from the first bell of school to
  64. the you know last bell of school. So all day all away that's only one in four high schools. But when you look at the
  65. younger grades it's flipped. So when you look K8, that's more like three out of four schools in our sample.
  66. >> But still the component of mental health is part of this discussion as well because this is going back to just
  67. screen time in general with our kids. >> Yeah. The the the fact that I want to, you know, begin with and is just to say
  68. it is a fact that there is a mental health crisis among youth. Sometimes I'm asked like is it just an artifact of the
  69. data? You know, is there something in report? I'm like no. kids today really are struggling. They're struggling with
  70. anxiety. They're struggling with loneliness. Uh and they're studying they're struggling with the the symptoms
  71. of depression relative to other generations of kids, you know, in in years past. So, so the connection
  72. between teen mental health and screens is a big topic that we're not going to have uh time to discuss entirely today,
  73. but I will tell you this now that we have thousands and thousands of educators and hopefully um hopefully and
  74. by the way, if you're listening to this and you know anybody who's a school teacher, please send them to our phones
  75. and focus.org survey. But now that we have some responses, we can find these schools and talk to them. And I will
  76. tell you what the principles and the teachers are telling us. They say that yeah, test scores, you know, are
  77. influenced by by uh cell phone policies. So are the number of books checked out of the library going up in schools that
  78. have uh lower or I should say more restrictive policies, but social emotional outcomes, how are kids feeling
  79. and how are they relating to each other? Um that's the primary outcome for many of the educators that I'm speaking with.
  80. They say when we started a policy that really restricted phone use during school hours and that includes where
  81. kids keep it, they made eye contact with each other more. They talked to each other more. You actually hear noise in
  82. the cafeteria. The noise the den of young people interact with each other. Before it was like you could you could
  83. hear a pin drop because the kids would just be silently, you know, scrolling through something with their thumb and
  84. shoveling food into their mouths. So, so I I really, you know, I don't want to sound like a lite because I think the
  85. role of technology is complicated and it's certainly got a lot of affordances that we don't want to ignore, but I
  86. worry about young people not interacting with each other, not having realistic, sensible ideas about, you know, what is
  87. expected of them and I worry about their attention. >> So, as you're collecting this data right
  88. now, what are the next steps in the process for this research? Well, you know, there are tens of thousands of uh
  89. middle schools and high schools in particular. As I mentioned before, a lot of the action is at the higher grade
  90. levels because that's where the policies are the least restrictive. And as a developmental psychologist, I will tell
  91. you that these are our most impulsive years of life. So, so we are thinking that maybe just maybe every middle and
  92. high school in America might participate in our survey. That would be at least one educator from every middle school
  93. and high school in the United States going at some point this month, this week, maybe today to phones
  94. andfocus.org. And if we really do that, if we accomplish that goal, then we will have
  95. a census of what is going on in this country. We're going to match that to standardized test scores, to attendance
  96. data, also to measures of climate and student engagement and well-being. And then we are going to deliver the results
  97. to the educators who answered the survey and you know to legislators who are making important decisions about the
  98. specifics of cell phone policy and how to optimize youth well-being, youth engagement and yes, youth achievement as
  99. well. >> Angela, great to talk to you again. Thanks very much. >> Always good to see you.
  100. >> Thank you. Angela Duckworth, professor of operations information and decisions
  101. here at the Warren School and again that website phonesinfocus.org. O RG

Brief Summary

Angela Duckworth discusses smartphone policies in schools and their effects on student engagement and mental health.

Key points

  • The Urgency of Cell Phone Policies. Angela Duckworth emphasizes the bipartisan nature of school cell phone policies.
  • Stricter Policies Lead to Happier Teachers. Survey data shows that stricter cell phone policies correlate with teacher satisfaction.
  • Mental Health Crisis Among Youth. Angela discusses the alarming mental health issues faced by today's youth.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes