Understanding Organ Donations: Insights, Challenges, and Solutions

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Judd B. Kessler, Howard Marks Professor at The Wharton School, offers an in-depth discussion on the state of organ donation in the United States. Drawing on extensive research and compelling statistics, he examines strategies to increase the number of donors. Kessler highlights key studies on what motivates individuals to register, the impact of different messaging techniques that can lead to meaningful increases in organ donor participation.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

#BehavioralScience #BehavioralEconomics #DecisionMaking #OrganDonation #NudgeTheory #PublicPolicy #DonateLife ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. There are currently more than 100,000 people on organ donor lists right now here in the United States and every 8
  2. minutes another person is added to one of those lists. Approximately 48,000 transplants took place in 2024 but the
  3. numbers of people saying that they will donate organs continues to be a an important topic to look at. Data shows
  4. that about two in five people uh say that they are registered to donate organs. But how do you get that number
  5. higher so that we can potentially help those in need? Pleasure to be joined here in studio by Jud Kesler, professor
  6. in the business economics and public policy department here at the Wharton School. He has done some research deeper
  7. dive into this and he joins me here in the studio. Great to see you. >> Thanks for having me.
  8. >> The focus of this research was around how you can connect with those people, but in part the vehicle, pun intended,
  9. of doing this was through the DMV. >> Yeah. So, if you have gotten a driver's license in the United States, you almost
  10. certainly went to your state's Department of Motor Vehicles and filled out a form. And on that form, kind of by
  11. historical accident, we ask people uh if they want to register as an organ donor,
  12. right? Um and you know, as you said at the start, there's lots of people who are waiting for a life-saving organ
  13. transplant. A lot of people in particular are waiting for kidneys because you can live for a long time
  14. with kidney failure if you get on dialysis. Um, and so these people are waiting for somebody to die in a way
  15. that will allow their organs to be made available for transplant. But part of that is the person or their next of kin
  16. saying, "Yes, you can have my organs uh when I when I die." And historically, the request to get on this registry of
  17. basically saying in advance before death, I would like to be an organ donor was done at the DMV because the DMV
  18. gives you a piece of plastic that you put in your wallet and uh will probably be on you in the event of an untimely
  19. demise and and that can say, you know, that you're an organ donor on it. for a long time before there were databases
  20. that that stored this information that was going to be how people um were kind of identified as donors. Now we have
  21. other ways to check whether they're a donor or not but we still ask people do you want to register as an organ donor
  22. at the DMV, >> right? And so how is the best way then potentially to go about this because is
  23. the DMV the right spot? So this is uh a question that folks have been thinking about for a long time because this list
  24. of folks waiting for a life sa saving organ transplant is long and you know is not not getting shorter. Uh you know
  25. people are getting transplants but enough people are being added to the lists that uh they're not really
  26. shrinking. Um so uh how folks get asked at the DMV is something that we have thought about for a long time and one of
  27. the things that people thought was look only you know two you said two and five some some estimates put it closer to 50%
  28. of people are registered as donors have said yes at the DMV right >> um but if you ask people do you support
  29. organ donation the rates at which people say yes I support organ donation are north of 90%. Right? And so the thought
  30. was maybe people support organ donation but we're not asking them to become donors in the right way. And there was a
  31. thought for a long time that uh what we should do is change the way that we ask at the DMV. Now those who've heard about
  32. you know organ donation before might think oh we should do opt out like that's what a lot of countries do and
  33. and that is basically assuming everybody's an organ donor and then the question is do you want to remove
  34. yourself? >> Turns out that doesn't fly under uh US law. So, you know, US law organ donation
  35. is uh falls under the gift act and so you have to like make an affirmative statement that you want to be a donor,
  36. right? >> Um so, in that case, you basically have a more limited set of options of how to
  37. ask. >> One way is to do what's called an opt-in where you just, you know, give people
  38. the option to check a box or sign a form or sign, you know, sign on the form to say yes, I want to be a donor. Um, and
  39. if you leave that section blank, then you, you know, that's fine because that's just saying, you know, I'm not
  40. doing it today. >> Um, another way you could ask is with a yes no question where you say, do you
  41. want to be a donor? Yes or no? Or maybe no, not at this time. Um, but the idea behind that is in that case, you have to
  42. say something. You have to answer. And you know, theoretically, you know, if you if you fill out the form at the DMV
  43. and you hand it in and you haven't answered that question, the the uh DMV officer could say, "Actually, you
  44. haven't, you know, answer question seven. Could you could you do that?" And the thought was for for a while uh that
  45. if you asked as a yes no question, it would force all that 90% of people who say they support to kind of think about
  46. it, pay attention, um and and say yes. And and there was some hypothetical data that supported that. And we were curious
  47. if that was in fact true. What I find interesting is that and you mentioned about you know there's support for organ
  48. donation in general north of 90%. But are people recognizing the information as they're going through
  49. this process of either doing that yes no question or or opting in? >> Yeah. and and the possibility that the
  50. way you ask the question, you know, might affect how people decide to to say yes or no kind of relies on this idea
  51. that the way that we ask kind of conveys something or communicates something or gets people to think carefully about the
  52. decision in a way that they would not otherwise do it. And the the prior research that I mentioned had in fact
  53. found if you ask people in a hypothetical situation, you've moved to a new state, the default is, you know,
  54. there's no organ, you're not an organ donor unless you you opt in. Do you want to opt in?
  55. >> Um, you know, in that data, they found it was, you know, about 42%. Kind of close to the number that we we get now.
  56. Um, when when you ask people that way, but in their hypothetical study, if you asked, would you like to be a donor?
  57. Yes. No. you know, you're in a state that that doesn't have a a optin but has a yes no question. Um what what do you
  58. want to do now? They found that the rate skyrocketed. It was like in the high7s if you if you made them say, you know,
  59. yes or no, right? >> Um and so then that led us to think, oh wow, like that would be that would be
  60. great if it worked like that in practice when people's real organs were at stake.
  61. Um, and a lot of states based, I think, in part on that research had kind of done legislation to to change the way
  62. that the question was asked at the DMV. Um, and so then we decided, all right, we're going to test this out. We're
  63. going to look at the changes that have been made in practice, and we're going to do a a more controlled experiment to
  64. see if the question wording matters. >> And the results were >> uh not great uh for folks who thought
  65. that the question wording would would be important. So, it turns out that there's
  66. no effect. That's the topline result. we do not find any effect when it's real organ donor registration decisions,
  67. >> right? >> We don't find any effect of the question wording. Um, and we we did this in two
  68. different ways. Uh, the first way was designing a kind of uh front-end interface for the Massachusetts Registry
  69. of Motor Vehicles. Um, so subjects would come into the laboratory. This I did when I was I started this project long
  70. long time. Started when I was still a PhD student at Harvard. So, they'd come into the lab at Harvard and uh they knew
  71. that they needed the last four digits of their social. They knew they needed their Massachusetts ID number. Um but
  72. they didn't know that it was about organ donation. So, they show up and then we say, "Okay, you're going to log into the
  73. Massachusetts Registry of Motor Vehicles. You're going to see your organ and tissue donor status and then you're
  74. going to have the chance to change it if you want." >> Sure. Um, but we built a front end that
  75. let us change the specific way in which the question was asked. So, uh, you know, you got the same kind of
  76. information that was on the Massachusetts website. Um, but when you had a chance to decide if you wanted to
  77. register, we framed it either as a checkbox and opt in or as a yes no to see, you know, randomly assigned whether
  78. that would make a difference. >> What do you think then this tells us about what we need to do around organ
  79. donation? So the fact that our study revealed that it didn't matter how you asked uh was kind of disappointing to
  80. the you know h question framing mattering and I should say when we looked at the state data we found the
  81. same thing. So when California changed their wording on the form and when New York changed the wording on the form
  82. like it did not lead to an increase uh in donations when they went from opt-in to yes no. um and we compared them to
  83. other states to kind of do a kind of fair comparison over time and um you know the the did the best methods we
  84. could with that data and found no effect. But what was interesting and what was reassuring in our study um is
  85. that folks came in some of whom had already registered as donors, some of whom had had not registered. So, we got
  86. to see both groups and in our study, you know, you got asked, do you want to change your donor status? And so, you
  87. could change it in either direction. If you were already a donor, you could say,
  88. you know what, I thought more about it and I actually don't want to be a donor anymore. Right?
  89. >> Um, or if you weren't a donor, you could say, oh, you know what? I think I will
  90. register. >> And one of the things we found is that folks were dramatically, I mean, like 30
  91. times more likely to add themselves to the registry than remove themselves. Um and so you know what that meant to us
  92. was that look when you say you want to be an organ donor it's kind of you know you sure you can reflect on it and
  93. change your mind and there were you know I think two people out of the you know few hundred who decided they wanted to
  94. remove themselves but uh that kind of decision is stickier like deciding you want to be an organ donor it's like
  95. something that you do and and you're unlikely to to change your mind >> but if you're not a donor you know you
  96. may not have thought carefully about it when you were first asked you might have
  97. been rushing through at the DMV. You might have kind of or your position might have changed. You might have heard
  98. a story about somebody who got a life-saving organ transplant, but you haven't been back to the DMV or been
  99. asked about it. And so, you know, just by asking again, we netted, you know, many, many more donors uh because we
  100. were just giving them another chance to reflect their preferences. >> Jed, great to talk to you. Great work.
  101. Thank you very much. >> Thanks so much for having me. >> Thank you. Jud Kessler, professor in
  102. business, economics, and public policy here at the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Jud Kesler discusses organ donation rates and effective registration methods at the DMV, revealing surprising research findings on question framing.

Key points

  • Organ Donation Statistics. Over 100,000 people are on organ donor lists in the U.S., with 48,000 transplants in 2024.
  • Research on DMV's Role. Jud Kesler discusses how the DMV plays a crucial role in organ donor registration.
  • Question Framing Impact. Changing how we ask about organ donation could significantly affect registration rates.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes