The Business of Humor

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Could businesses benefit from a sense of humor? Authors A.J. Jacobs and Peter McGraw say yes. They discuss when humor can be a valuable skill at work. Read the full story: http://knlg.net/1fUts5E 📂 Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'm Adam Grant here at knowledge at Wharton with two authors who specialize in a topic that matters a lot at work
  2. but we don't discuss enough humor we'll start with AJ Jacobs the author of four best-selling books all very funny all
  3. based on life as an experiment the know-it-all reading the encyclopedia for the entire thing start to finish then
  4. thinking about what would happen if I followed the literal word of the Bible in the year of living biblically then my
  5. life is an experiment actually Reinventing everything based on George Washington and most recently asking
  6. could I drop dead healthy how do I reinvent my body along with my mind and spirit AJ welcome thank you for having
  7. me how do you think about becoming funny at work what makes a leader humorist well as my co- interviewee will
  8. tell us that you know analyzing humor can be terribly unfunny but that said I will I will say that I think a lot of
  9. the humorous thinking that has parallels to the way we should be thinking in business it has a lot to do with
  10. creativity taking disparate ideas and mashing them together which I think is a way to get great businesses uh I I was
  11. trying to think of an example I didn't think of a great one but Chipotle you know they took fast food and healthy
  12. food and mashed it together and they got this super business so which is the same
  13. idea as humor taking two things uh you've got things like humor is hard you know you've got to come up with a
  14. hundred ideas before you get one or two that really work and I think that's a crucial lesson for entrepreneurs you
  15. know uh and there's I read him as you know I read the encyclopedia so there are dozens of examples of this you know
  16. Chester Carlson who invented the Xerox machine he pitched it to like 43 companies before someone uh accepted it
  17. I was just listening to a radio show about E Cummings who uh who in one of his books he thanked he acknowledged all
  18. the Publishers the 15 Publishers who had rejected his manuscript before which seemed a little petty to me to be honest
  19. but I thought he was supposed to be such a joyful person uh but anyway that uh that's another lesson so taking ideas
  20. and and working hard and and there are plenty of other parallels well I'd love to pick up on those in a moment let's
  21. turn it over to Peter mcra who's our other author today with Joel Warner has written a book called The Humor code
  22. which will Deb fittingly on April 1st it's about a global search for what makes things funny across the world
  23. Peter talk to us a little bit about what makes leaders or business people funny from your perspective so this is clearly
  24. a difficult topic so I I definitely have had people tell me this is too too hard
  25. to study you should stick to easier subjects but yet as you think about it humor is this really important thing
  26. whether it be at home or at work and there seems to be some good evidence that funny leaders humorous leaders are
  27. going to be more successful at least within certain tasks so uh so take the CEO for example the CEO doesn't
  28. necessarily need to be humorous but there are certain roles that having a good sense of humor is going to be
  29. useful so for instance someone who has to deal with shareholders so how do you appease shareholders how do you present
  30. the good and bad news in a meeting in a way that not only is just aoid being mind-numbingly boring but also might
  31. ease the sting of a little bit of sort of unsteady news along the way or how leaders have to push forth change in
  32. organizations so this is maybe at the very top or a mid-level manager people are really reluctant to make change the
  33. losses out outweigh the gains and having a sense of humor being able to make fun
  34. joke about tease people's reluctance to move forward can be a really valuable skill and then I think
  35. some of it is is just an orientation this idea that business is competition and at times you're going
  36. need to critique your competition whether it be an advert usually in advertising and so
  37. having a sense of humor and having that kind of Orientation May open companies up to Innovative marketing
  38. Communications ones that can Pepsi taking on coke Audi taking on BMW and back and forth so these are a number of
  39. ways that the process of generating humor might actually be useful in the workplace I want to dig into that
  40. process in a little more depth now and let's turn the question to both of you what can we actually learn about how to
  41. become funny from the way that you wrote your books because in a way you've gone
  42. to some pretty extreme lengths to expose yourself to strange experiences that ultimately generate humor do leaders
  43. have to do that to actually live their life as an experiment to go to countries where people are not comfortable with
  44. the brand of humor that you're about to bring and start pitching it and see what
  45. happens or to do standup comedy as a professor wearing a sweater vest is is that the key to becoming funny well I
  46. wouldn't recommend like for instance when I uh live by the year U live by the Bible I had this huge beard like this
  47. topiary and people would avoid me on the streets so not necessarily a great way to go about business but I would say the
  48. idea of taking things to the extreme that sometimes can be very helpful in coming up with business ideas uh so for
  49. instance one of my first articles like 10 years ago in this genre uh I had read Tom fredman's book about the World is
  50. Flat about Outsourcing and I loved the idea but I was sort of a solo practitioner a writer living at home I
  51. was like how can I do this myself so I outsourced my life I hired a team of people in Bangalore India to do
  52. everything for me so they answered my phone and they answered my email they argued with my wife for me did they take
  53. naps for you I wish they did did they did worry for me I had all these worries I said
  54. you worry about them and I felt a lot better but uh but anyway that's taking something and pushing it to the extreme
  55. I think is a great way to generate ideas now you don't want to necessarily uh you
  56. want to pull back from that extreme but as a way of brainstorming ideas take a phenomenon push it to the edge and see
  57. where it goes and then from that uh new ideas will Bloom Peter you're now back from the extreme yes is it worth it
  58. totally worth it yeah so we uh Joel and I went to Tanzania to investigate a laughter epidemic that allegedly
  59. happened in the 1960s who went to Japan to try to figure out these crazy game shows and we even spent time in the West
  60. Bank in um in a what many people consider a really dark place in a place that wouldn't be very funny and yet we
  61. found lots of hilarity in Palestine and one of the things that I think uh is a useful Insight when it comes to humor
  62. is that it it actually arises from potentially negative things uh there's a Mark Twain quote that I think is very
  63. nice he said that the secret source of humor is not Joy it's sorrow there is no humor in heaven because Heaven's this
  64. perfect place it's a wonderful place to be but there's just not many things to laugh at and so my tip is to look for
  65. the things that are wrong that are am miss what we call violations in the world and see sees on those seize on
  66. those moments and find a way to make them okay acceptable or safe and so there's this
  67. delicate dance and it's why humor is this this really appealing skill you got to find what's wrong a violation and
  68. make it okay make it benign so you have to have a safe space you have to create kind of a safe space you have to create
  69. a a culture in which it's sort of okay to fail because if it's not okay to fail then that's going to inhibit these risks
  70. how do you stay on that tight RPP without falling off so you you want to point out something that's wrong but yet
  71. make it acceptable you call these benign violations in the book how do you know when you're not falling off one side or
  72. the other that it's either too much of a violation or perhaps not enough I guess
  73. a lawsuit I guess that's sort of when you realize you've gone over the Ed but yeah it certainly is a tight rope uh uh
  74. but your whole book is about that the idea of of taking something offensive and something inoffensive sort of mixing
  75. them together and finding just that right and it is a skill it is a skill and and yeah humor in business I think
  76. can be very dangerous I mean just look at the office you know with Steve Carell and uh that is an example of a boss who
  77. really wants to be funny and it's just sad so don't try too hard for me it should be organic and it should just be
  78. um uh I for me using humor is is a good way to just come up with ideas like I don't I don't necessarily think of
  79. myself as a humorist even I just try to be creative and come up with ideas and and some of them just by their nature of
  80. being disjointed and un and unexpected and surprising that they're going to hopefully be funny but I don't go into
  81. it saying all right I am going to this is going to be hilarious I um I Echo what AJ says there
  82. are a few things that I think you can do to maximize your chance to be funny and
  83. minimize the potential impact so one is take aim at yourself so so the the target of the joke matters a lot and so
  84. wherever possible the the the humor should be inclusive right something that we can all laugh about together and as a
  85. manager making fun of yourself is a great way to to get things rolling and that's actually a trick that we learned
  86. in Los Angeles when we were hanging out with all these stand-ups when a stand-up
  87. comedian gets on stage he or he he or she excuse me usually makes fun of the thing that's just peculiar about thems
  88. so when I um when I got back on stage again at the end of the book to prove that we've learned something my first
  89. joke was I spend a lot of time with Comedians and I learned you need to get a laugh right away hence the sweater
  90. vest and so so wherever wherever possible keep it inclusive stay away from that list of things that your HR
  91. man manager will send you an email about and be quick to apologize I think that people are really willing to forgive if
  92. someone's attempt at comedy was heartfelt was meant to be positive but somehow failed I like to say this is
  93. what happens when a humor researcher tries to be funny yeah and I guess that's a risk
  94. that some of us are more willing to take than others yes now when when you think about humor
  95. one of the questions that comes up a lot has to do with gender sort of a hot button issue what do both the the data
  96. say as well as the experience say about how men and women are funny in different
  97. ways well I'll tell you I uh I interviewed Tina Fay uh for Esquire WR for Esquire sometimes and you might have
  98. to edit this part but I thought she had an excellent point she said what's the difference
  99. between men and women comedians she said uh that the male writers on the sitcom uh had a jar where they would pee they
  100. would they were too lazy to go to the bathroom and women would never do that but other than that there was not a big
  101. difference thought that was a good answer a little bit of a Dodge so I'm gonna take that and do a little Dodge
  102. but you as a scientist tell us what what is this what is the data on on men versus women yeah so I think what people
  103. like to argue is that men are funnier than women and if you ask them to make a case for it they'll point to
  104. professional comedy and I think that's a a felicious argument and that would be like saying that men are better at
  105. medicine just because there's more male doctors and no one really believes that the literature on regular everyday
  106. people outside this system that seems to prop men Up and Hold women back is that
  107. men and women are more alike than different in both their production and their appreciation of humor and actually
  108. for the humor code uh we ran a study with a couple of my classes where we entered them into joke competition so
  109. the students submitted jokes and they indicated whether they were male or female and then I read the jokes alowed
  110. in class and had all the students rate them on how funny they were but also how offensive they were and what we found
  111. was that men were slightly but not statistically significantly funnier than the women you couldn't make a case that the
  112. men were funnier than the women especially with the man reading the the male jokes exactly stepping the deck in
  113. the men's favor thank you for identifying that compound couldn't have wi so um but what was interesting was
  114. the offensiveness ratings there women won that is the men's jokes went too far so they they succeeded a little bit more
  115. but they also failed a lot more and so what you often see as a difference might just be a cultural difference in terms
  116. of people's willingness to express publicly these displays of Comedy but the literature really is very clear the
  117. ladies are just as funny as as the gentleman and in better taste apparently too usually excellent so another Dynamic
  118. that a lot of people think about when they try to take humor into the workplace is how do you direct it upward
  119. can you make fun of your boss and if so how that is a great question uh have you
  120. got your bonus yet that year let's assume the answer is yes then what do you [Laughter]
  121. do well you know I there is a long history of of Comedy speaking truth to power so if you think about the
  122. trickster The Joker um so we spent time in in the Amazon with Patch Adams probably the
  123. most famous clown today and uh he said that the The Joker was the only person who could tell the king he was an
  124. and I think that that can be true you see this often times with political satire and so on where where
  125. humor used to get attention and to sort of ease the critique and uh I think that that that takes some
  126. skill and it takes knowing that your boss is going to be a willing butt of a joke and I think also who the audience
  127. there who else might be laughing about that situation what I often encourage people
  128. to do is not to joke about their grievances to their boss um but rather to use humor to complain so I have a
  129. project in the humor research lab on humorous complaining and the great benefit of humorous
  130. complaining one problem with complaining to try to change someone else's behavior
  131. and using humor to do so is you might tell the person this is not really a problem because of humor's association
  132. with non-serious situations and so in terms of coping with bad situations humor seems to be very good in terms of
  133. drawing attention to the the problems in the world seems to be very good but if you want to write some wrong you might
  134. want to complain about it in a serious way well pick up then on the theme of speaking truth to power with humor AJ
  135. you once interviewed a man who lives his life by radical honesty where he just tells the truth all the time saying
  136. exactly what he thinks to everyone he meets and you experimented with this yes how does it work well as you say it's
  137. called radical honesty and the idea is that there's literally no filter between your brain and your mouth so whatever is
  138. on your mind comes out so this is a very dangerous way to live because he thinks
  139. like if you have a crush on your wife's sister you should tell your wife and tell her sister and I'm like really so I
  140. did I tried this and wait a minute how about not having a crush on your wife's sister to begin with that is uh that's
  141. an excellent point uh but uh but he he I tried it and you know it was probably the hardest month of my life harder than
  142. living by the Bible harder than living by the Bible because yeah you know we lie all the time you don't you can't
  143. imagine I probably lied like eight times during this interview uh but I will say so I just
  144. very quickly the worst part was when we were in a uh restaurant with my wife and
  145. uh we ran into a friend of hers from college and the they said oh we should all get together and have a have a play
  146. date with our kids and I said what was on my mind I said well you seem very nice but I have enough friends already I
  147. don't I don't really want to ever see you again and it was just horrible like I felt terrible my wife was stormed out
  148. so not recommend but I will say this uh and that is I believe in trans a a sustainable radical honesty like I do
  149. think it taught me to be more honest especially in a positive way for instance like uh mentors you know we
  150. don't often call them up and tell them how much we well maybe you because you've got like 8,000 uh mentees
  151. proteges because you know you help all these people but uh but most of us uh I I don't call my mentors enough and say
  152. thank you for all you've done you meant a lot to me uh and especially as a man you're not supposed to express that in
  153. much emotion but this experiment taught me how valuable that can be both to them
  154. and to me so I do believe in positive radical H honesty like if you have something positive to say you should
  155. just spill it out there don't don't hold back as long as you don't have one of those dangerous brains that would lead
  156. you to want to say things that other people don't want to hear that's right I think that that's a great note to wrap
  157. up on if you if you are uh if you're thinking that having a crush on your wife's sister is positive then yes that
  158. is I'm talking about that's a fear in a in a business situation where someone helped you out yes then you should say
  159. thank you that was that meant a lot to me well thanks to to both of you for joining us I think it's very rare to sit
  160. down with one author let alone to who have the ability to both make me think and make me laugh on the same page and I
  161. think it's it's really wonderful to have a chance to both learn about humor and experience it through the writing that
  162. you both do and can't to continue reading thank you you too thank you [Music]

Brief Summary

AJ Jacobs and Peter McGraw discuss humor's role in leadership and creativity at work, emphasizing its importance in communication and innovation.

Key points

  • The Humor Code. A global search for what makes things funny, exploring humor in various cultures.
  • Humor and Leadership. Funny leaders are often more successful, especially in challenging situations.
  • Radical Honesty Experiment. AJ Jacobs shares his experience with radical honesty and its challenges.

Tension

30/ 100Low tension

Related episodes