Knowledge@Wharton Interview with Sydney Finkelstein

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Great leaders develop talent on a continuous basis, according to Tuck School of Business professor Sydney Finkelstein. In a conversation with Wharton’s Peter Cappelli, he explains why that’s more important than ever. 📂 Leadership 🏷️ COVID-19

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. folks good morning my name is Peter Capelli I'm professor of management here at the Wharton School and director of
  2. our Center for human resources my colleague Mike Useem was also a professor here and director of our
  3. leadership Center the faculty Center at Wharton and I are hosting this series of
  4. interviews this is our virtual version free annual Leadership Conference and it's also a joint program with our
  5. knowledge awarding partners or beening this around the world and it will be available later for you on podcast
  6. version with us today to talk about leadership every year we try to bring in some people who are not just leaders but
  7. people who study leaders and observe them and it's a great pleasure to have sidney finkelstein with us in sydney as
  8. a professor at the Tuck School at Dartmouth Tuck School of Business even wrong professor up there he also heads
  9. their executive education program he's a longtime observer and expert in the field of leadership but we're going to
  10. talk to him a little bit about his book super bosses and the more recent addition to this the super boss playbook
  11. that he's developed has come out recently Sydney is joining us form Dartmouth up in New Hampshire sandy
  12. welcome thank you very much Peter great to be talking to you and now the folks are beaming in saying you want to talk
  13. just a little bit about your book could you spend a fair amount of time not just
  14. in this book but in your classes and generally talking to leaders and let's start with the book if you could just
  15. tell people a little bit about why you wrote this book superbosses is a great title and I think it does suggest to
  16. people what you're after here but you went around interviewing these folks in spending some time with him and watching
  17. him tell me a little about why you were trying to do this book as opposed to something else about corporate leaders
  18. right now it's a great it's a great question I had written earlier a book called why smart executives fail which
  19. is about failure and what goes wrong and one of the things that came out of that
  20. research as I went to work with a lot of companies and gave speeches around the world is you know this is
  21. we understand what can go wrong but what what do you really need to survive and thrive into the long term as an
  22. organization and it got me on a path to think about you know what really is the most important thing and I and I came up
  23. with a hypothesis and hypothesis was to survive and thrive to be successful into
  24. the long term you need to be able to generate and regenerate talent on a continuous basis and I set out to find
  25. people who have that track record and then do deep dives into them and all of their protégées and colleagues to try to
  26. see what is it that they did that's different than typical leaders even successful leaders and what can we learn
  27. that maybe we didn't know before you know it's a really interesting hypothesis and I think in the past
  28. generation one that probably didn't get a lot of attention when you talk to people about leading and being
  29. successful in business you get a whole lot of discussion about strategy you get a whole lot of discussion about managing
  30. financial markets and you don't really hear that much about developing talent from within what kind of reaction did
  31. you get from your publisher or other people when you first started to do this you get a sense of people say yeah
  32. that's really important they say what that have you talked about yeah it's really interesting it was almost like
  33. they were they were waiting for this deep dive because any CEO you talk to fact when I talk to them as you had 20
  34. years ago and ten years ago and you asked what keeps you up at night what are you worried about it's always the
  35. same thing right how do I find the world's best talent on our way how do I develop them at or how do I retain them
  36. and they keep having the same problem year after year decade after decade now why is that because we haven't come up
  37. with solutions that really move the needle very much and that that's the reaction I got people said okay some of
  38. this some of these ideas around super bosses are not kind of standard but maybe that's what we need and so the
  39. reaction was wow this is a way to think about things mm-hmm you know I just wanted to pause on that one for a second
  40. because when you look at these surveys of CEOs they say exactly what you said right now that the top concerns are
  41. about talent but that perception never gets passed never seems to get out there my guess is if we polled our listeners
  42. right you know what they thought was keeping executives up at night that would probably not be top of the list but as
  43. you say in practice it is and it is in all the surveys the conference board survey why do you think that is why do
  44. you think this topic and your dive into this is something that is not more broadly appreciate it is it just not as
  45. much fun to talk about this as I just talked about strategy or something what do you think no I think the idea that
  46. people count that people are our most important asset amia we've heard that forever in people's eyes glass over and
  47. I think that and because it hasn't really happened because work is just not easy and it's been more and more
  48. pressure put on rank-and-file to managers to senior managers I think I think many people will say yeah they're
  49. that they might say that but they don't really believe that what they really believe is is hitting the numbers and
  50. pushing us harder and making us work work harder and give up more and there's a lot of cynicism and I think that that
  51. could be us behind this yeah yeah that's interesting so let's talk a little bit about about your book and maybe you
  52. could tell us a little bit maybe first about the people that you interviewed and how you picked them because there's
  53. a huge list that one could draw from you're trying to find some best s players here so tell us a little about
  54. who and how you got to him so I was I started off kind of small looking at one or two industries that I that I care
  55. about that I'm interested in so the high-end foodie industry you know chefs and restaurants and I looked at the
  56. National Football League there's another thing I'm interested in so it was kind of like just playing around at the
  57. beginning to tell you the truth and what I what I did is as for example Nana Fells a really good example I was
  58. interested in head coaches and the development of head coaches and who is really good at it and the NFL is a great
  59. example because there's really good data and what I did is I looked at the Super
  60. Bowl winners and losers the winning team and a losing team each year for the two
  61. best teams I looked at their head coaches and I did kind of a a genealogical study of them not of course
  62. their parents but who they work for and I created these kind of trees of talent and when you do that you discover that
  63. there's one or two names at the very very top over over decades and actually the name of the very top is Bill Walsh
  64. the legendary and longtime coach of the San Francisco 49ers now now passed away and so I was able to actually quantify
  65. it in that it's you really really well in other industries I have to do a lot of grunt work a lot of hunting a lot of
  66. qualitative research but it turned out in every literally every industry I looked at I was able to find the one
  67. sometimes two people that have this outsized influence development of talent so for example in hedge funds Julian
  68. Robertson from Tiger management tiger cubs mentioned you know high-end foodie restaurants Alice Waters from chef
  69. Penny's the creator of the California cuisine and many of the friends and food that we see today from farm-to-table the
  70. organic the local sourcing endowments and universities and other nonprofits David Swensen from Yale University who's
  71. kind of legendary has many of his protege involved in in running funds and running endowments now in an in fashion
  72. in the fashion industry American fashion history Ralph Lauren in the comedy industry Lauren Michaels from Saturday
  73. Night Live I mean goes on and on and and you go and look at these people and you say wow
  74. they have they have a track record of generating and regenerating talent really on a continuous basis and and the
  75. other thing you discover about them is not only that they create these opportunities for people and help people
  76. be more successful in their own lives and their own careers they actually perform much higher than everybody else
  77. and and this is actually really interesting Peter because sometimes people ask me you know they say you know
  78. Sid we don't have time to spend all we don't have all this time to try to develop our people they got to figure it
  79. out I went through the school of hard knocks they gotta figure it out and and I and I
  80. said can you imagine a situation when your team is getting better and better and better where you yourself won't
  81. benefit is there such a situation where you will be punished for helping the people around you get better and as a
  82. result making you better it doesn't make a lot of sense but that's kind of what what happens so not only developing
  83. talent but being among the highest performers in their industry I must say I'm really envious of the idea of
  84. picking high-end restaurants as a subject to study that's a smart one I'll try to remember too
  85. a lot of fun a lot of fun research I have to say let's go back to that I think one of the points you made which
  86. is which is really important for people listening around the world is that your legacy matters a lot and presumably you
  87. got to these and identify these people because their descendants people who would work for them we're willing to say
  88. you know this is the person who really helped me right which is a really important thing to at the end of our
  89. careers I'm going to a lot of retirement parties you know older executives and they always talk about that you know who
  90. who I thought I helped and how important that was but let's move back to the book
  91. here a little bit and so get to the heart of this so what did these folks do to develop talent I imagine it's not
  92. just sending them to the Tuck School or to the word in school and that sort of stuff what is what do they do there was
  93. fundamental adieu yeah well there's a lot but let me highlight maybe two or three things real real quick number one
  94. is how they source town how they find talent they're very they're very open minded these super boss leaders they're
  95. looking for a talent all the time I almost I called them almost entrepreneurial in how they think about
  96. talent anywhere they go everywhere they go their antennas are up to look for potential for potential talent and as a
  97. result they they often find people have been bypassed by by others which i think
  98. is really interesting because it creates opportunities for for people so that there's a lot more I could say about
  99. that but they cast a wide net and they're very open minded there they're also creative they value creativity I
  100. say they unleash creativity the people around them and this is particularly important from Millennials but I think
  101. it's important for everyone know what do we want we want a seat at the table we want to have a chance to have an impact
  102. the best people think that way pie aspiration people think that way you don't have to be again an MBA graduate
  103. from a top school to think that way and and so super bonds leaders will give you
  104. that seat and and they'll give you that seat and therefore expect a lot from you
  105. and that goes hand in hand it's not a you know get tenure in that seat you have to produce and and you're expected
  106. to keep coming up with new ways of thinking along with doing whatever you day job happens to be it's it's kind of
  107. it's kind of standard and how they and how they think about how they think about things and then you go ahead what
  108. you gonna say they get accountability right so they get some ability and accountability they really they really
  109. do and you know in kind of related to that is when you talk about motivating people so a lot of ways to talk about
  110. talking about motivation but there's two major things we found among super boss leaders number one is they push you hard
  111. they raise the bar it's not an easy place to work with respected the demands and the expectations not for it's not
  112. for everyone but if you're a high aspiration person that wants that opportunity are you gonna jump at it and
  113. then the second thing they do is they inspire you it's kind of you know kind of a weird we hear all the time right
  114. but they really do they inspire you to believe that you're the person you're the that you're the team that can
  115. accomplish this that you're that that with you we can do these great things and sounds maybe sounds a little soft
  116. but you combine both of those together and at the hard core you know we're gonna be tough we're gonna have these
  117. high demands and at the same time you know we I'm inspiring you to feel like and really believe that you that we
  118. together can do anything that combination turns out to be pretty powerful but maybe we should just tell
  119. people a little bit about the kinds of people that you were talking about can you tell us who these folks were yeah so
  120. when I mentioned a couple Bill Wallisch the the head coach from the San Francisco 49ers and you know Ralph
  121. Lauren who you know people know the name Ralph Lauren but the number of people that work for Ralph that went on to
  122. tremendous success in their own careers really unbelievable perawang Tory virgin
  123. Abood and John Barr bozos and I mean goes it goes on and on the CEO of Michael Kors John Idol that's another
  124. that's another great example in the in the food business high-end food is I mentioned Alice Waters it turns out that
  125. there are over 250 people that worked in her restaurant at some point that have become significant players in that
  126. ecosystem and I don't mean just you know a sous chef becoming a chef but someone
  127. who may have been baking too that creates a big bakery companies to even this people that were involved in
  128. running the running her restaurant are now some of the people involved in private equity
  129. and venture investing in some businesses really it's really kind of kind of amazing though it's lots and lots of
  130. industry industries ami frist and healthcare is another is another good example Larry Ellison at at Oracle which
  131. a lot of people give me grief over because there's no tougher executive that we know of
  132. CEO former CEO that we know of than him but if you could survive working for for
  133. Ellison the upside was unbelievable many of his top people ended up running gigantica you know I wanted to ask you
  134. about my favorite category out of your category of four personality types of these folks and that's the glorious
  135. bastards as and as Ellis in one of those just tell it tell us what sir please my
  136. postive like that else is my this is the thing keep in mind the word glorious is
  137. in front of bastard right there's plenty of bosses there that qualify for a team
  138. of the ladder the ladder adjective but what makes some glory and what makes these people glorious like a Larry
  139. Ellison is they understand that to be successful they need to have the world's best talent around them and they need
  140. those people to keep getting better and better so while they might not care a lot about you into personally if you can
  141. handle that pressure they're just gonna accelerate your career it's almost like somebody I think said this to me in one
  142. of my interviews working for Larry's like we counted in dog years one year of working for Larry's like seven years
  143. working for somebody else yeah and I could certainly see that let's see if we can switch topic a little bit because
  144. we're mindful of your time and the audience here and and you've been watching this world for a long time and
  145. in the last year particularly with respect to the pandemic it looks like the context of business is changing
  146. quite a bit can you tell us a little bit about what you think businesses business
  147. leaders will be like after well I mean from now on the we're in the middle of this pandemic now what's a demand from
  148. these folks different isn't it you know this is this is obviously a watershed moment and we
  149. can we can also talk about the the racial crisis that has come that has come in front of the country and cannot
  150. be denied anymore and leaders are and CEOs in particular but leaders more generally are really
  151. expecting to are expected to step up and do do things maybe a little bit differently than they have and and that
  152. starts with transparency being completely transparent about what it is you're saying as opposed to kind of
  153. manage as opposed to you know we're in an era of fake news but the stand-up leader has never been more important
  154. that's why you know so many people resonate with Governor Cuomo from New York it's become such a star
  155. and we've been far from perfect but he's up there day after day with a message that conveys action and seriousness of
  156. intent and and maturity and and what's the result it generates trust and it boosts the confidence of the people of
  157. the people around you and so I think that that attribute of what it takes to be an effective leader to gain the trust
  158. of others is going to be even when it's always an important but it's gonna be even more and then then the other thing
  159. I'd say and there's a lot more to say but the other thing I'd say is how is business changing and going to change
  160. because of this I'm I'm talking to you and everyone from my dining room right now people are home people are working
  161. from home and and that's not gonna disappear when we eventually get get back to get back to work as normal and
  162. what does that mean for managers how do you manage a team when they are much more likely to be virtual some or all of
  163. the time and and learning how to do that I think is going to be is going to be more is going to become more important
  164. than there's some kind of nuts and bolts think supply chain management we've discovered because of the the problems
  165. with PPE that these long complex the highly efficient supply chains didn't give us any flexibility to be able to
  166. kind of step in and and and produce what we needed in real time and that's our note to be a big that turned out to be a
  167. big big problem and then speed of work I'm going to say I think it's really is really important you know the the
  168. pace that decisions are being made we didn't have to talk about the the pace of you know aunt antibody treatments and
  169. other treatments and vaccines of course which you know hopefully will we'll get there but the pace that it's going on it
  170. says is tremendous and and and so we've kind of knocked away a lot of bureaucracy and a lot of oh we better
  171. study this and study this and study this well now the alternative is something really really bad so we're doing less
  172. studying and more action and many CEOs I've talked to over the years they some have said something like you know I
  173. don't have to be right all the time nobody's right all the time but if I'm if I'm right more than half the time
  174. that's pretty good as long as I know when I'm not right I step in and do something about that and try to fix it
  175. that's that's gonna be I think a central part of what makes for an effective leader moving we're gonna get to our
  176. questions in just a second here matter one more for you before we get there and that is if you think about the CEO today
  177. and a lot of challenging social questions of black lives matter issue is right on the table right now and what do
  178. you think about CEOs who are in a position where maybe their personal beliefs and what's going on in society
  179. are not particularly well balanced though for example we saw this earlier on gay rights for example LGBT community
  180. issues about all the CEOs were in favor of those but maybe their employees were what do they do there is they just
  181. better to keep their mouth shut or do they have to articulate positions that make sense for the organization even if
  182. it's not their personal positions what do you see happening so this is really a big big challenge because it goes
  183. against it puts in conflict to kind of core things that every leader is told by one is you got to be authentic you got
  184. to be true to yourself and and so there's one then the other which is even bigger is how business goes which is
  185. customer focus we're all about customer focus well you know we're not going to sell our customers what we think is the
  186. right thing to do the right the right product unless we believe customers and we have to convince them no Steve
  187. Jobs is kind of this people say what about Steve Jobs he created this stuff nobody knew we needed a knife and iPad
  188. or pod for that matter well there's one Steve Jobs and there's probably a hundred thousand others
  189. that'll fail trying to do the same type of the same type of thing we can't make you know leadership practice based on
  190. Uglies ultra exceptions so to follow your own beliefs I think when that's not what the your ecosystem is demanding is
  191. is gonna be a really is gonna be a real problem and it might it might fall on boards of directors to start to think
  192. about value systems at a very personal level when they start hiring and evaluating CEOs because there there is a
  193. fit and you know if employees are in revolt if the managers are not happy with the way the CEO is running business
  194. because of certain values that are out of touch that's that not just that's not gonna work yeah that's a really
  195. interesting point I think we are at the point in the show here where we turn to questions and answers and I hope I've
  196. got this at the right point so great pleasure to have with us the Eagle Yomi who is our knowledge of Wharton partner
  197. the executive director there and Steven been listening to what people in the audience have been asking and I'm gonna
  198. get all the way and turn it over to Steve thanks Peter hi Sidney we have time for a couple of good
  199. questions we got lots of questions here about talent development attracting talent so so let's I'll ask this one how
  200. can leaders develop talent effectively while people are working remotely does that pose more of a problem and the
  201. other question was should maybe talent development be sidelined for the time being during this crisis take the second
  202. question first the answer is absolutely not it's the sideline talent development
  203. is to send a signal of people around you that you know what your future is not is
  204. actually not that important now we got to do something else how do you motivate people you motivate people when they
  205. feel like they're part of something they are contributing something so I don't think I would I don't think I would do
  206. that and by the way that's not just about spending money which is some what motivates that type of mindset we
  207. got to cut back we don't have money in training budgets are often among the very first things that get that get that
  208. cut when when times are tough the best way to develop talent is for in an individual boss or an individual leader
  209. to work directly with the people that work for her one-on-one though that's the best way that's what super boss
  210. leaders do and it's not necessarily going offer training and and the first the first question was again see how do
  211. you develop what can we do to develop talent this situation and present barmen yeah given the fact that people are so
  212. dispersed and working on the other end does that post more of a challenge for talent development yeah well it does the
  213. fact that it the fact that that's the way we are doing work and we'll continue to do work even more it's it's just
  214. raises the degrees of difficulty I always say know that before all this happened when everyone's working from
  215. home or almost everyone is working I used to say well there will be time times when you're face to face and when
  216. you face the face that becomes gold and that's an asset that's really valuable you got to leverage that time so for
  217. example you don't want your powerpoint presentation so you don't want the updates from from teams when when you
  218. finally have a chance to be face to face that could all be done offline you just
  219. got to be smart about when you're face to face it's about it's about talking it's about learning it's about
  220. interacting it's about pushing and challenging and so I'd say using your time much more effectively and thinking
  221. about you know of all the things that we do what could we actually push offline and what do we absolutely need to be
  222. doing face to face so even though it's more difficult it doesn't mean that it's going to go away it just means it's got
  223. to get done and and this is another thing to keep in mind the managers that figure it out the leaders have figured
  224. how to do this more effectively are going to have a competitive manager that's a pretty good sense try to put
  225. your energy into that right right it also during this time do you have any advice for how managers can best lower
  226. employee anxiety while they work remotely because I think that it's a very anxious time not only because
  227. what's going on in the world but because things changed dramatically most people are
  228. kind of in a zone now but but how can a managers help to lower employee anxiety during this time yeah I think there are
  229. two things one one is communication and more general level the best leaders as managers know that they need to be
  230. communicating communicating often and effectively I think the bar has been raised on that too you don't want to use
  231. up everybody's time all the time people are working and their kids are running around the house and not everybody else
  232. childcare etc but communicating what you're doing and and what people are up to and where and where you're going and
  233. inspiring people a little bit I think is is important and that the second thing is more of an individual idea which is
  234. for each individual on your team carve out some time to have that one-on-one conversation not the big zoom
  235. thing or the Blue Gene thing or whatever it is and one of the best ways you can signal that you really care about
  236. somebody and this will alleviate or help alleviate their anxiety is if you if you
  237. if you if you try to understand what it is they need and they want in their own careers at this point in time and and
  238. that could be you know starting to think about well you know within that within a
  239. year hopefully we're we're on the other side and here's what I'd like to do and how we're going to continue or I have an
  240. aspiration to be you know a senior VP or a c-suite executives here to actually spend the time I hesitate to use the
  241. word coaching because coaching is a word to use all the time that's a little bit
  242. weak I prefer almost like partnering as a better as a better word where you're not only providing advice but you're
  243. actually helping them execute on on this so for example if somebody needs certain
  244. skills to get to the next stage you help them figure out how they can get those skills with them and if that means a new
  245. assignment a new opportunity you do that so that's just good kind of managing people activity but I think when you
  246. when you do that especially now you're demonstrating in a real way not just with words which I think are important
  247. but not just with words in a very real way that you know you care about each individual person and you
  248. want them to succeed and you want to understand what's going on in their in their lives now and work together to try
  249. to get them to the next stage whatever that happens to be right right and I I think that one one issue that does come
  250. into play in these scenarios is micromanaging or a tendency to micromanage look what is that if what is
  251. it in effect due to employees yeah so micro managers the definition is someone who does your work for you or does tells
  252. you so much detail that it's as if you're just filling in the connecting the dots and you know some jobs that
  253. that makes sense automation actually does that to some extent but for managerial jobs for
  254. leadership jobs for people that want to have a bigger impact want to have some of their own personal capability it's
  255. the last thing you want to do and and I found you know that super boss leaders they were hands on it's kind of one of
  256. these paradoxes I'm hands on delegate errs there were very big delegate errs which means they're not micro managers
  257. but they were also hands on they were involved with people they they did some of that partnering that I just that I
  258. just described but if you're if if you fall into this trap I mean it's a losing formula if you're gonna start doing
  259. other people's jobs for them how are you ever gonna survive all right you know when people tell me that you really well
  260. the number one thing when people tell me you know I don't trust my team or I've run out of time or I I'm working day and
  261. night it gets down to trust doesn't it that you don't trust your team you're not delegating enough and usually not
  262. always but usually it's self-inflicted right right so Trust is the main issue there well I think we're actually out of
  263. time so I'll switch back over to Peter but thanks so much thanks Steve thank you but thank you Steve and I
  264. think we are at our times and now we should probably first of all do a virtual thank you for Sydney for being
  265. with us Denny Finkelstein is the Steven Roth professor and have the executive education program with the Tuck School
  266. at Dartmouth and joining us today like everyone is by video thanks very much for being with a Sydney and we will have
  267. this up shortly I hope on YouTube you'll see some of this in knowledge of Wharton
  268. as well and we look forward to following up with you when we do this again and sending out those enough thank
  269. you all very much for being with us and I hope to see you again soon you

Brief Summary

Sidney Finkelstein discusses leadership, talent development, and evolving expectations in a post-pandemic world.

Key points

  • Super Bosses: The Book. Sidney Finkelstein discusses his book 'Super Bosses' and the concept of leadership.
  • Leadership in a Pandemic. Exploring how business leaders must adapt during the pandemic.
  • The Challenge of Authenticity in Leadership. Leaders face a dilemma between personal beliefs and organizational demands, especially on social issues.
  • Developing Talent Remotely. Leaders must find ways to develop talent effectively while working remotely, despite challenges.
  • Managing Employee Anxiety. Effective communication and one-on-one conversations can help lower employee anxiety during tough times.

Tension

50/ 100Some tension

Related episodes