Is Every Lie ‘a Sin’? Maybe Not

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

When is honesty not the best policy and deception morally correct? More often than you might think. Read more: http://knlg.net/1s3w5I7 📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. in our work our lives ethical on the tension benevolence and honesty what we do is we look at deception a little
  2. differently than people have in the past we look at deception that sometimes can
  3. be helpful to other people we typically think about deception as selfish deception so I lie to gain some
  4. advantage at the expense of somebody else and we typically think of honesty is something that might be costly to me
  5. but helpful to others in our research we actually disentangle those two things we think about
  6. deception that can help other people and honesty that might be helpful to myself
  7. and may be costly to somebody else we really do this we separate honesty and deception from pro-social and pro self
  8. interests what we do is we find that people actually don't care that much about deception we find that the
  9. aversion to lying when people say don't lie to me what they really mean is don't be really
  10. selfish broadly the advice on the table until now has been you know always be honest
  11. honesty is the best policy we're suggesting that maybe we had revised that advice and make the statement lie
  12. sometimes the key takeaway is to understand when we should lie when does honesty actually harm trust seem immoral
  13. and when does dishonesty when can deception actually breed trust and be seen as moral so we could think
  14. about how that might be used in delivering feedback because managers often have to balance this tension
  15. between benevolence giving kind supportive feedback and honesty giving critical harsh feedback so we might
  16. suggest that managers actually err on the side of benevolence if their goal is really to promote trust and
  17. relationships what surprised us was that when we really separated dishonesty from
  18. selfishness we found that what's driving all of this behavior what-what people judge me moral or immoral when people
  19. trust somebody or they don't trust somebody we find that what really matters is how kind how benevolent
  20. somebody is and that deception plays a very small role that is when we tell people never lie to me
  21. what we really mean is don't be selfish we studied this tension between benevolence and honesty using economic
  22. games we had people come to a lab and watch someone or interact with someone who had an opportunity to lie about the
  23. outcome of a coin flip or a die roll some objective fact in order to make money for their partner so they could
  24. lie and be dishonest in a way that would help a counterpart and then we had participants judge this dishonesty
  25. versus truth-telling which would harm the counterpart and we found that when participants are lied to in a way that
  26. helps them they actually really appreciate that dishonesty it boosts trust and it causes them to think that
  27. their counterpart is moral also when they simply observe somebody who's lying to help someone else to earn someone
  28. else more money they also trust this person more I think this person is more moral than someone who is just always
  29. honest we ran three different experiments in our paper our Liars ethical and each
  30. experiment had about 200 participants so each experiment builds on one another the the first one just looks at lying to
  31. help someone else first being honest which harms others and then the second experiment which had another 200
  32. participants looks at the effect of lying to help someone else even when it actually causes harm
  33. so we disentangle intentions from outcomes and then in our third experiment which again had another 200
  34. or so participants we start to disentangle the role of the effect of lying on the self verse the effect of
  35. lying on others we think about interacting with other people it could be our customers it
  36. could be subordinates we're giving people feedback or we might be explaining why we're terminating a
  37. contract the the interactions we have with other people are often influenced not just by brutal honesty that we want
  38. to communicate but also important concerns about demonstrating the care we have for other people when we for
  39. example tell a client that we're gonna go with a different vendor sometimes we want to phrase things in a way that is
  40. different from the complete unvarnished truth we find is that we often really care about the benevolence that people
  41. signal through their communication and that's often more important than the harsh and complete truth so the advice
  42. here is to think about ways in which we might balance these two things and our findings suggest we want to tilt toward
  43. benevolence and we often do this intuitively and one key takeaway here is some of the codes of conduct some of the
  44. exhortation --zz we tell people when we say that honesty is a supreme concern or
  45. all honesty is always the best policy but what we're finding is that that's not really what we mean
  46. they're really two key ideas that that we have about new ideas for implementing some of these findings why does it
  47. change codes of conduct that is when we talk about codes of conduct and we have honesty in there for the sake of
  48. hypocrisy I would take that out because it's not what we mean it's not what we do and second when we think about
  49. training we think about the rules that we implement when we interact with our colleagues at work and our external
  50. clients we don't always strive to be completely honest it's not a core value really and our argument is to be
  51. consistent both in the codes of conduct and the way we train and teach other people so we want to think about the
  52. demonstrating concern and other elements of morality they're going to be really important in guiding the institution so
  53. I think ultimately we can become more consistent and less hypocritical when we think about the role and this tension
  54. between honesty and benevolence and how we don't always mean that the complete truth is what we're after I think
  55. instead of saying we should always be honest with others we should think about always treating others the way we'd want
  56. to be treated we should think about creating a caring community and we should think about this
  57. tension that is as we as managers as executives we want to think about balancing this in our training programs
  58. and we deal with other people and explicitly acknowledge that we're making trade-offs between honesty and care for
  59. others that's the key idea there are a lot of domains in which individuals face this conflict between
  60. honesty and benevolence very very intensely one examples in healthcare right so doctors frequently have to
  61. deliver very negative news to patients and actually prior research has found that oftentimes doctors do lie they
  62. inflate the positivity of these prognosis and we we seem to think this is bad and we and I think doctors feel a
  63. lot of tension and conflict around how to handle this situation but our research suggests that perhaps doctors
  64. and maybe teachers and parents should be explicitly acknowledging this tension and this trade-off and thinking about
  65. and talking about how to navigate it when might benevolence and kindness and maybe a little dishonesty be right or be
  66. appreciated and how could that enhance you know the delivery of medicine another case where we manage this
  67. balance between being completely honest and managing being benevolent is when we
  68. interact with children this is true as parents and it's also true as educators so teachers will need to give feedback
  69. to students and they have to balance this tension between being completely candid and being benevolent and kind
  70. demonstrating kindness and concern for the child as parents we frequently tell our kids never lie but that's not all
  71. what we mean for example before we go over to Grandma's house we might tell them say you remember thank grandma for
  72. that sweater and tell her how much you liked it even though we both know you never wear it
  73. for centuries we've been talking about honesty as a virtue and dishonesty as a vice so that's an idea that's been
  74. around in philosophy for centuries starting with Immanuel Contin actually before that but also empirically there's
  75. a wealth of research on deception documenting that deception harms trust that deception makes us angry the
  76. deception is immoral but these studies have really just looked at selfish deception it's the lies that we tell
  77. that hurt others and help ourselves we're trying to overturn this idea because we find that when we actually
  78. disentangle deception from selfishness people don't care all that much about dishonesty per se they really care about
  79. helping others so I think this the sheds new light on this idea that deception is
  80. bad prior work that studied deception has really confounded deception with selfishness what we know about deception
  81. is really we know about selfish deception and our work separates this out so we can actually learn about
  82. deception per se and we find is that the way we feel about deception itself is actually not all that bad and it
  83. challenges this enormous body of research that's made these broad claims about what deception does or doesn't do
  84. really what we know is what deception that selfish does or doesn't do so I'm really excited to look at the
  85. effects of pro-social lying how this tension between benevolence and honesty plays out in the feedback process how
  86. does it affect performance and how does it affect relationships when we give feedback I mean so a lot of people they
  87. might say that honesty is the way we improve honesty is important to get accurate feedback to become better you
  88. know employees better students but it's very possible that we need benevolence we need kindness sometimes we need
  89. dishonesty to be given the confidence to improve so benevolence and honesty don't
  90. only have effects on trust and character perceptions but might actually affect performance in organizations so I'm
  91. excited to take a look at that next you

Brief Summary

The episode argues that deception can be moral if it promotes trust and kindness, challenging traditional views on honesty.

Key points

  • Revising Honesty. Challenging the notion that honesty is always the best policy.
  • The Ethics of Deception. Exploring how deception can sometimes be benevolent rather than selfish.
  • Balancing Honesty and Benevolence. Understanding the tension between being honest and being kind in communication.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes