Hero or Helper?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Consumers aren’t always looking for a “miracle product” to fix their problems — sometimes, they want to work hand-in-hand with a brand to succeed, Wharton research shows. Read more: http://knlg.net/1qkgLCR 📂 Marketing 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. what my colleague and I have been interested in is understanding what types of products people like to buy
  2. when they're pursuing different goals so for example you're trying to lose weight
  3. you want to get fit you have different professional goals and in particular we want to know do you want the product
  4. that tells you hey we'll do it all for you we'll make this very easy for you or do you want the product that says will
  5. help you will be a nice compliment will help you down this path but you have to work really hard as well and so that's
  6. our question so which do you want the kind of the hero or more of just the helper and we think that one important
  7. determinant of this is your feeling of control over outcomes in your life so the extent to which you feel as if you
  8. can make positive things happen and avoid negative things in your life and we find that when people feel low
  9. control over different aspects of their lives they actually want the brand that's more of the helper not the hero
  10. so they want the brand that says you have to work hard and we'll be here to help you but we're not going to do all
  11. of the hard work for you so they'd rather nike come in and say you put on our shoes if you work really hard will
  12. help you towards this goal of losing weight or getting fit they don't want nike to come in and say put on our shoes
  13. and it'll do all the work for you so they want to feel as if they have to put in the work because this gives them a
  14. sense of empowerment and makes them feel as if eventually they can actually control outcomes in their lives again so
  15. that's what we've studied over a course of several studies and have found this same effect very reliably
  16. now we focus on two different groups consumers and marketers and for consumers you know the one thing we'd
  17. want people to take away is the idea that you may not want the product with all the bells and whistles of the
  18. product that says it will make things as easy for you as possible you may actually be more satisfied by picking up
  19. the product that you believe you have to put in a little more of the effort to see the same outcome and for marketers
  20. it's a similar idea is that your consumers may not want you to tell them that your product is so fantastic that
  21. it will do everything for them and that they don't have to put in so much work you may not want to emphasize so much
  22. ease in using your products or getting the benefit from your product you may want to instead focus on the idea that
  23. consumers have to put in a little bit of the work as they use your product and then they'll get the desired outcome
  24. for example if you know that you are dealing with consumers that have low control instead of automatically telling
  25. consumers that hey our products will make this as easy for you as possible let's say cleaning for example you have
  26. a Swiffer instead of focusing on how easy it is to clean with Swiffer for your low control consumer you may want
  27. to say hey this is a very effective product but it needs you so if you put in the hard work our product is there to
  28. help you along the way to make sure you gain these fantastic cleaning outcomes in your home and so in both cases you're
  29. talking about the product being great and getting a quality outcome but in one situation you're focusing more on the
  30. value of the consumer there so you're saying that the consumer has a role in delivering this outcome that they're
  31. looking for you know so marketers we already do a lot of psychographic research and so to
  32. your point we can understand who our targets are in general and we can start by you know throwing in questions about
  33. personal control just very basic questions to see how much control our target consumer feels over their
  34. outcomes in life and so that will give you a general sense a place to start when you're focusing on your particular
  35. target consumer we also know that there are different demographic trends that predict feelings of control so for
  36. example the lower you are in income oftentimes the lower your feelings of control or the more elderly in our
  37. population often have lower feelings of control or others who don't have as much
  38. control over their health or just physical abilities and mobility in general often have lower feelings of
  39. control so some of those trends can give you cues and clues as to whether or not
  40. you may be dealing with consumers that have low feelings of control but it does require more targeted psychographic
  41. research to really understand your particular target consumer to see if this is important for them
  42. that's our research you know over several different experiments we focused largely on manipulating people's
  43. feelings of control so I'll have people write about a time when they had low control to make people feel this sense
  44. of local control or you know I looked at intramural basketball players and I would recruit people after they won and
  45. after they lost and I get a sense of control based on you know whether or not you want to lost your game and so in all
  46. of these cases I'm making people feel low or high control or using natural environments to test this but we know
  47. that there are lots of situations where people just chronically feel lower high control and I think our research is
  48. particularly applicable to those groups so for example the low-income populations or the folks who are older
  49. and age and have health issues I think for those groups who have these chronic issues with control issues with feeling
  50. as if they can really alter things in their environment I think for those groups is particularly important to
  51. think about the types of products that they want and how you can be more empowering in your products for them
  52. for people who always have a very high sense of control we find that they don't really care how you talk to them about
  53. their product so we didn't see much of a difference in their reactions as to whether another product was empowering
  54. for them or not so whether or not you said it required a lot of effort or not where it really mattered was for
  55. consumers when they experience low control so I mean it could be a consumer who typically feels high control but
  56. then they just had a very bad day and they you know turned on the news and read about or saw a story about a lot of
  57. violence in their neighborhood that would be enough to trigger a feeling of low control over their lives in that
  58. moment or maybe it's the recession that's making them feel lower control than they might normally feel so even
  59. those high control people if you can find moments in which they feel though control that's the place in which you
  60. can try to target them or you can try to manipulate even your communication with
  61. them to remind people that hey you may not have as much control over your life as you like so if you can get people to
  62. think about local control then they see this preference for the high effort products if you have consumers who never
  63. for some reason ever think about the fact that they may have low control then the results don't seem to differ much
  64. they don't seem to care yeah well you know I think there are a lot of interesting and tidbits and maybe
  65. buzz about high-intensity workouts nowadays so you know CrossFit programs or p90x and insanity all of these things
  66. where you see lots of people who love to work out to the point where they puke right and so it's very hard for many of
  67. us to understand this but I think that our research suggests in some ways that working so hard this high intensity type
  68. of training gives people a sense of control it's the one part of their day a part of their lives where even if
  69. nothing else is going right even if they have no control over anything else that
  70. happens when they step into the gym or when they turn on their video to work out this is the one thing they have
  71. control over this is the one thing that they say you know I can make my body do what I needed to do and so I think that
  72. in a lot of ways these are examples of people trying to reassert control through their effort
  73. on one hand I hope that it just allows people to see that we may all try to reassert control in different ways ways
  74. that we may not expect in ways that don't necessarily seem always logical or rational to others but it's our way our
  75. piece of kind of establishing control in life I think also there are sometimes stereotypes or beliefs that folks who
  76. typically have lower control so folks with lower income or physical disabilities we tend to think that they
  77. want us to make things very easy for them and that may not be the case they want to be able to exert some levels of
  78. effort so that they can empower themselves and achieve outcomes and so hopefully this research will help to
  79. shed a bit of light on that so there's been research done for a long time looking at low feelings of control
  80. and a lot of the research suggests that low feelings of control leads people to give up more quickly so if I give you a
  81. puzzle and you have low feelings of control you won't spend as much time on it or if I put you under certain amount
  82. of pain you'll be less likely to be able to deal with that pain or to endure and
  83. what our research is suggesting is that if you give people a tool or a prop like
  84. brands that just gives them the sense that there's someone here something here to help you that you can get low control
  85. people to actually want to put in the effort because now this is their chance they've got nike by their side right so
  86. now they have a chance to say let me put in his hard work I know I can do it I have support here and now i can feel
  87. empowered and so they're not as likely to give up as what we've seen in prior research
  88. so we've been thinking a bit about this idea of effort and we're wondering how feelings of control may impact things
  89. like cheating for example so you know both in an academic context but also in a more business-related context it could
  90. be cheating on taxes it could be stealing if flow control folks are more interested in effort when they feel as
  91. if they can engage in effort how does this impact cheating might we see differences between low and high control
  92. we think that'd be interesting we're also interested in learning more about what aspects of our environment
  93. particularly our shopping environments influence people's feelings of control so what is it about you know going into
  94. a target or a Walmart that might inspire low feelings of control or high feelings
  95. of control so we think you know understanding more systematically about feelings of control and the retail
  96. environment would be interesting you

Brief Summary

Consumers with low control prefer products that require effort and empowerment over those that promise ease.

Key points

  • The Role of Control in Consumer Choices. Research shows that consumers with low feelings of control prefer products that require effort.
  • Empowerment through Effort. High-intensity workouts provide a sense of control for individuals feeling powerless in other areas of life.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes