From Cracker Barrel to Gap: Navigating Brand Legacy

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Daphne Howland, Senior Reporter at Retail Dive, joins Barbara and Americus to discuss the risks and rewards of legacy brand reinvention, from Cracker Barrel’s controversial logo change to Gap’s viral cultural campaigns and Victoria’s Secret’s ongoing identity reset, offering insights into how companies can balance tradition, modern trends, and consumer expectations.

ABOUT THE PODCAST Marketing Matters is hosted by Wharton marketing professors Barbara Kahn and Americus Reed. Each week they discuss marketing and advertising trends, consumer behavior, data and analytics, the latest in retail marketing, brand-building, and much more with their expert guests. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School.

#branding #marketingstrategy #consumerbehavior #retail #advertising ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Hello and welcome. You're listening to Marketing Matters on the Wharton Podcast Network, our weekly podcast where we
  2. analyze the latest in advertising, marketing, customer behavior, new product launches, branding, retailing,
  3. etc. I'm Barbara Khan, the Patty and JH Baker Professor of Marketing, and I'm joined by my co-host, Americus Reed, the
  4. Whitney M. Young Jr. Professor of Marketing and the brand identity theorist. Hello, Americas.
  5. >> Hi, Barbara. Okay, so uh real quick. So, I've done probably nine interviews on
  6. Cracker Barrel. I have to get your I got I just got to get your hot take real fast.
  7. >> It's amazing to me. You wouldn't believe this, but I'm actually doing research on
  8. those kind of minimalist brand logos, and it's so clear to me that if you have a logo that's steeped in legacy and
  9. history, you don't throw the whole thing away. And I heard your um your talks on
  10. all sorts of media and your basic point is did you test the damn thing? >> Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. But it's amazing
  11. though, Barbara, because I grew up in the South and uh I've been to Cracker Barrel stores a million times and just I
  12. don't know. It just seems as though to your point and this question of not really understanding not only your brand
  13. identity, what's in the DNA of your brand, but also your customers and it just seems like a mistake that just
  14. keeps on getting made over and over again. And then the other point real quick, Barbara, thoughts on this. A
  15. 100,000 person digital board of directors who steps in and says, "You're not doing that. Then you go back." What
  16. do you think about this? This is incredible. >> You know, it's very interesting and I'm
  17. really glad you brought it up because today we have with us Daphne Howland who's a senior reporter at Retail Dive.
  18. Hello, Daphne. >> Hey, it's so nice to be here. >> Hey, Daphne. And we're gonna ask you to
  19. weigh in because what Americas is talking about is like these legacy brands and what when they throw their
  20. their their DNA away and then they go back and when the internet responds and says what the hell are you guys doing?
  21. Come back. We're going to talk today about some stories that you've been writing on legacy brands. We're going to
  22. talk about the gap. We're going to talk about Victoria's Secret. We're gonna talk about Dillards and just regular
  23. malls instead of the fancy malls. And to Americas's point, I don't know Dafany if
  24. you remember, but Gap did the same thing. >> Do you remember when Gap came up with
  25. that streamline logo, but they invested more money in it. It's a very big deal when a retailer changes their logo
  26. because then you've got to change it on stores, on uniforms, on all of these things. And Gap did what Americas is
  27. talking about that Cracker Barrel just did where they had the internet tell them. What are you guys kidding? Go back
  28. to your legacy. And at that time, if I remember correctly, right now, Cracker Barrel,
  29. which by the way, this reminds me of a we there's a McDonald's near us that was really sad. It clearly needed a re
  30. renovation and got one, but now it's a gray box. No golden arches. Wow. >> No golden arches
  31. >> as sacrilege. >> It's weird. Um, >> you know, I started to mention I am doing research on that. We're actually
  32. running some experiments on this new minimalist trend and just, you know, too long don't read, you know, like that
  33. notion of it. The bottom line of our research is these minimalist logos make sense for small brands without any
  34. legacy because they're not well known and if you make it very easy to grasp what's going on which we call fluency it
  35. actually helps the the small brands. Alternatively, if you've built up this big legacy and have all of this
  36. tradition and brand identity, going to a minimalist logo is crazy. You know, it's
  37. just nuts. >> Now, let me let me ask you this, Barbara, and jump in on this as well,
  38. Daffany. Is the research and sort of the boots on the ground telling us that younger consumers like these modern
  39. minimalist uh logos more or what's what's going is there anything that's generational about this in terms of
  40. preferences? >> You know, that's interesting because we didn't test that. We didn't do it by
  41. individual differences. We did it across the board. And what we basically found was that our minimalist logos worked
  42. better for a brand that doesn't have legacy and less good for a brand that does, which just kind of makes sense.
  43. But now you're adding in a new twist, which is what happens if you know the the style, so to speak, is to
  44. streamline. Should the logos chase after these changes in styles in fashion? And
  45. I think that's basically what you're saying in some sense because the younger people are coming in with these new
  46. preferences. You know, are leggings tight or are they loose? You know, are jeans short or bellbottom or whatever.
  47. And if you chase after all of those tastes, I think it's going to be hard for a brand.
  48. I I I would need research like yours, Barbara. But if I had to bet, I would think the younger generation would want
  49. the old man in the logo. >> Oh, interesting. That's what that would be my guess for Gen Z.
  50. >> Interesting. What's the thought process behind that? Yeah. What what why that
  51. hypothesis? >> I I it's totally anecdotal. It's based on the Gen Z kids in my life.
  52. >> Um and like that >> they're I think they're into vintage. I think they're into grandpa.
  53. >> Interesting. >> Maybe. >> Interesting. >> So the the car the character is actually
  54. named Uncle Hershel Barbara. Okay. And uh it turns out that this uncle Hershel was the act was is a real person and who
  55. was the actual uncle of the founder. >> So there's a lot going on there. So your
  56. point and your point as well, Daphne, be very careful >> when you start messing around with stuff
  57. that's been around that has some some equity associated with it. >> But you know, anecdotally, again, I we
  58. can look at the data, but since we don't have it, let's look at anecdotes. I actually agree with what Daffany is
  59. saying about this younger generation because I just recently became a grandmother. I have a twomonth-old
  60. grandson and you know all these cutesy grandmother names like this or that and my daughter-in-law who's just on the
  61. cusp of of Z and Millennial, she's just at that age. She really wants me to be called grandma, you know, like I don't
  62. want a name. I actually want the support of some legacy, some tradition. And you
  63. can see that it might make sense even from that point of view. >> Well, I got to say though, Barbara, jump
  64. in on this, Daffany, you know, Barbara, you do not have grandma energy, okay? You're you're not ready for that social
  65. category label. I'm just going to say that right now and put it on the record. >> I'm going to make it hip. We're going to
  66. make it new. But, you know, let's get into our retail stories because there's actually a lot happening. But it's
  67. really much built on this idea. We've been talking about GAP for a long time, you know, being bad and the shining
  68. light in the GAP portfolio. The GAP portfolio of course is Gap, Old Navy, Banana Republic, and Athleta. And
  69. historically, the Gap portfolio, the shining star was Athleta, but now, ironically, that's the one that's
  70. falling a little bit behind. And they have a new CEO at GAP. um I think well I don't know how new he is but um he's
  71. been trying to make some changes and they've seen some real changes in GAP. Why don't you tell us a little give us a
  72. little background on that and tell us what's happening. So um it must be said that Old Navy is
  73. their sales powerhouse. It's not necessarily the fashion cred that even the probably the other
  74. three, Banana Republic, Athleta, and Gap are supposed to have. Um, Old Navy just
  75. makes the most money, like billions. Um, Gap, you know, kind of lost its way. It
  76. was so important actually in the '9s, and it wasn't just the clothes. I mean, was it ever the clothes? We're talking
  77. about khakis and jeans and sweatshirts and stuff that's very recognizable um essentials. I don't know what you call
  78. them. Basics. Basics. And that basic now is a is an insult, right? >> Um but they they knew how to have a
  79. conversation. Um, I a couple years ago when I when I looked into what exactly happened with
  80. them, where they were and where they ended up, there was a DJ talking about how GAP would actually break songs the way
  81. Tik Tok does now. So DJs would would be hearing requests for songs that Gap would have broken, you know, just
  82. through an ad. >> Oh, interesting. And I feel like they they did it again. This time with Milkshake. It's it's it's
  83. happening again. I have no idea if it's a oneoff, but it has legs. I mean, we're
  84. we're going, if you look at social media, there is it's still a topic of conversation. Gap, the brand itself, is
  85. posting video of ordinary people trying out the dance moves and they're not even
  86. necessarily wearing Gap clothes, but Gap is interested enough in hearing back from people who connected with that ad
  87. that they're they're posting footage of them dancing, even if it's not an item of clothing from Gap.
  88. So it's kind of trying to find its place in the cultural zeitgeist, you know, is
  89. that I mean and that's a lot what we're seeing America is that is kind of part of your whole pitch on brand identity
  90. and things like that. F I believe to find your place in the cultural design. So it's an interesting strategy for GAP.
  91. What do you think? >> So obviously it has staying power but but like how big does that picture go?
  92. Did they crack Did they crack the code finally or >> is this just a really successful one-off
  93. for them? >> Interesting. >> Let me let me pose this. I want to ask you something, America, because you put
  94. me on the spot. I want to put you on the spot with current events and what she just said. Okay.
  95. >> So, one of the things that's interesting in this whole story, this oneoff or not
  96. oneoff, is one of GAP's competitors, of course, is American Eagle. And talk about something that's been
  97. controversial recently. you know, that was the Sydney Sweeney story. Yes. >> And so if you're talking about this
  98. brand identity or tribes or cultural relevance or, you know, what's your take on what happened with American Eagle and
  99. originally Sydney Sweeney, now it's Travis Kelce, you know, and what what what Daphne's saying about Gap, they
  100. were really kind of moving in on this one particular um dance thing. What do you think? How does that all work? Do
  101. these things work in building brands? >> I think they do work, but I think they kind You jump in on this, Daffany, and
  102. tell us does what you're seeing in the from the journalistic side uh affirm this. uh the idea that you know there's
  103. a lot of risk in in what's going on with respect to these cultural moments Barbara because there's a there's a
  104. group of folks that are political actors that are looking for opportunities to to
  105. to ride some of these cultural waves Barbara in a way that can take it somewhere different right so this whole
  106. idea of sort of ideologies and the fact that hey you know Uncle Hersel or you know good jeans wait a minute what are
  107. you saying all of these things that get amplified. And now I would assume that it's it's
  108. it's a it's the decision calculus and the risk analysis is very different. Now to Barbara's point about the fact that
  109. this double edge of trying to ride that cultural zeitgeist or figure it out or crack the code as Barbara's saying has a
  110. lot a lot more risk associated with it. Would you agree with that Daphne or how would you how does that how has the
  111. landscape changed to Barbara's point? The the interesting thing to me is the way so many people interpreted GAP's ad,
  112. which was a very diverse, it didn't lean on one person, right? It it leaned on not just the six member musical group,
  113. but then also this huge dance troop. Um, it was interesting to me how many people
  114. thought that Gap answered American Eagle with this ad. M >> when you look at it, there's no way this
  115. wasn't an ad that had been in production. I mean, it had to have been in production for months and months and
  116. months. >> Happy accident, as they say. >> Yeah, I I do think it was probably unfortunate for American Eagle because
  117. if anyone was confused about why people took the American Eagle, you know, message the way, was it
  118. intended that way? Was it not? There was this argument about it, but anyone who might have been like, "Huh, where' they
  119. come from?" might have >> the Gap ad almost answered that. Like, there's a way to do marketing and show
  120. our clothes showing a lot of different types of people with a lot of different >> style. The some of the Sydney Sweeney
  121. um you know, her messaging was confusing. I'm not going to tell you to wear American Eagle ads jeans. Like, why
  122. not? Um, >> isn't that the job? >> Yes. >> So, yeah. So, so it was sort of very dependent on this one person. I actually
  123. thought of Gap when I first saw the Sydney Sweeney ad before Gap came out with Milkshake because I
  124. had done that story in 2023. If you remember remember those ads with it was there were portraits, black and
  125. white portraits and there were Spike Lee and there was Joan Ddian and there was >> all these different people with the same
  126. tagline. >> Could it have been interesting if you had a diverse panel of superstars saying
  127. so and so has great genes instead of relying on one person. Now >> that whole controversy would have been
  128. more existed >> not. Yeah. >> Yeah. That's interesting. That's very interesting.
  129. >> And it was a funny choice. And one wonders if they, you know, if they did it to generate the word of mouth and
  130. then they could come back and when they did come back after to America's point, it got brandnapped in some sense by
  131. people with a political agenda. Right. But then when you know, so I don't think they meant it that way. Personally, I
  132. actually don't think they meant it that way. And I think it was, as you said, they were going to come out with a bunch
  133. of different versions, but then it got brandnapped, but maybe they were aware that was a possibility. They should have
  134. been if they were thinking about it, and they came back with their response. Wasn't an apology. It was just saying,
  135. "Look, it's about the denim. Like, don't read into this." And what ended up happening is it generated a lot of word
  136. of mouth. Then they follow up with Sydney Sweeney campaign with the Travis Kelsey campaign. I mean, you're talking
  137. about a campaign and an engagement and a new album that broke the internet big time.
  138. >> If the bottom line is generating word of mouth and just talking, getting your
  139. name out there, >> you know, maybe it's all part of a grand scheme. I don't know.
  140. >> Interesting. >> Did it have a vibe of trying to change the the conversation, though? the
  141. the the Kelsey the Travis Kelsey I mean it seemed time to the announcement right
  142. obviously but did it did it also have the feeling of like stop looking over there we've got something new I don't
  143. know >> maybe although you know if you're going to go into the Jean thing having uh
  144. Taylor Swift and Travis K >> I don't see that's that much different than Sydney Sweeney on that mention
  145. right >> um but I do think they're trying to go like look over here not over there.
  146. Let's talk about this. Let's just change this whole conversation and went in a direction we didn't want it to go.
  147. >> I just want someone to write the expose because I think if they had any Gen Z
  148. members on that committee making that decision, they would have clocked that potential response, the Sydney Sweeney
  149. had. So my question is >> interesting. >> How many Gen Z people do you have involved in your marketing and did you
  150. ignore them? >> Yeah. >> Yeah. But you know the problem with that also is if you have a panel of you know
  151. six you that you're not doing a real market research you're not getting the heterogeneity response that's the
  152. problem with you know with anecdotes it's so like >> you it's not that hard to test anymore
  153. so I think America that's one of your big points is like a panel of a thousand's not really that hard to get.
  154. >> Yeah. Exactly. Exactly. Here's a broader question for both of you and this is a
  155. harder question. Give me your framework, your your logic, your analysis of how a
  156. company should who has existing brand equity around its logo around its uh what it does its meaning system like the
  157. Gap or Cracker Barrel whatever. How does it analyze that and move to something new? What's that? What does that look
  158. like? How how does that get laid out? What are the things that >> Yeah, >> that's a that's a question I'm grappling
  159. with, Barbara, because I want to be able to talk to my students about it. Give me
  160. some frameworks. Give me the logic. Give me an analysis about how I should think
  161. about that. Something, >> you know, like that's an interesting question. So, like what turned out, like
  162. you said, the panel of experts on Cracker Barrel said, "No, no, it wasn't a bad logo. It wasn't a bad legacy. You
  163. didn't have to change it. You shouldn't have." That's basically what ended up happening. But your question is a
  164. broader one, I think. What happens when you really do have a bad legacy and you do have to change it? Yes,
  165. >> that hasn't been the case for Cracker Barrel. Wasn't the case for Gap when it
  166. happened to Gap either. That American legacy was really working for them. But if you do have something that's bad
  167. like, and we have seen it with Anchamima, for example, there was nobody who didn't think that that logo should
  168. have been changed. Um, now what they did was what's called a silver bullet. And because they knew it was bad, they just
  169. killed it with a really bold statement. More often than not, it's not that black
  170. and white as bad good, but it's more something it's a little out of date. We got to modernize it. And then the more,
  171. >> you know, the more sophisticated logos, they don't stay the same. Actually, they
  172. move, but they move in very small movements, very carefully thought out. So if you look at their logo at one
  173. point in time and you look 10 years later, it isn't the same one. But it never happened as a really big move. It
  174. happened very slowly, paying attention to things, pulling out the things that are no longer culturally relevant,
  175. putting in the things that are, but doing it kind of under the radar to not generate to not generate this word of
  176. mouth that. But you have to be sophisticated. Yeah. And paying attention to your logo and to your
  177. audience to really manage your brand equity and brand assets appropriately. That's what I think you should be doing.
  178. And that's why you should be paying your marketing CMOs the big bucks because they should be paying attention to this.
  179. It's not easy. It requires a lot of experience and a lot of sophistication. Do you agree with that, Americas?
  180. >> I definitely agree with that. Deafany, what what what are you seeing with respect to, you know, folks that are in
  181. the sea suite? Because I'm hearing a lot of this notion of the chief marketing officer, Barbara, and the sort of the
  182. the the role kind of morphing into something that is much different perhaps than what uh what was thought perhaps in
  183. in the past in the sense that the chief marketing officer has to also be a little bit of the chief tech officer, a
  184. little bit of the you know, the finance officer because the brand is is is an asset. So are is that are you seeing
  185. that to Barbara's point, Dafany, that the the the leadership that is in charge of these things that Barbara's talking
  186. about developing the strategy, putting it out there and executing on it appropriately. Are there are you seeing
  187. these different skill sets and you can talk about AI and all other things as well, but different skill sets that are
  188. required to be quote the CMO, uh the person that's in charge of this very delicate asset that can, as we saw with
  189. Cracker Barrel, can go haywire in an instant. So are you seeing that in terms of the the the the seauite leadership
  190. that you are interviewing and and talking with Deafany? >> We're definitely seeing that. I think
  191. just as a reporter I have more questions of people like you and the companies themselves than you know answers. I
  192. think that especially when it comes to apparel, the merchants are I think there's a a little bit of not
  193. tension, but there's push and pull around who the audience is and what our products actually are. And then there's
  194. the question around not just logos but the kinds of marketing that you saw for American Eagle and GAP where where
  195. you're trying to have a conversation >> and you know that's just so complex. >> Let's switch gears to another story you
  196. wrote because I want to get cover some you have so much to talk about. I want to cover some other things.
  197. >> Wait a minute. Hold on. Barbara, you want to cover Victoria's Secret? I I Wait a minute. I have no problem with
  198. that. Do you want to Sorry. >> Exactly. Victoria Secret. Talk about a brand with
  199. a controversial legacy. Yeah. You know, um, so what's going on? That's an interesting brand, though, because
  200. they're finally kind of getting some of it right. You know, they Victoria's Secrets, their their mainstay, their big
  201. brand, Victoria Secret. Then they have the the trendy brand Pink. Um, so this is another one. Is it good to build on
  202. their legacy? Is it not? What are they doing? What are you seeing with Victoria's Secret?
  203. >> I honestly there it's no accident that Gap has a CEO who's only been there for
  204. two years. Um, and Victoria Secret has a CEO who's only been there for a year. >> Wow.
  205. >> And each of them seemed to understand what was needed and they're starting to
  206. execute. Um, Hillary Super, who used to be at the Fenty lingerie brand, Savage, um,
  207. she seems to understand the the what Victoria's Secret customer wants that it doesn't necessarily mean
  208. not being sexy. >> It just doesn't mean being sexist. And there was uh >> Wow, you just came up with a fantastic
  209. tagline. I think that was really good. >> Well, I think they they got >> sexy, not sexist.
  210. >> They were really over on one end for a while there and just didn't get rid of
  211. those old guys who who couldn't stop talking even when everyone was telling them to shut up.
  212. And then they sort of overcorrected and didn't want to didn't almost didn't want
  213. to um talk about sexiness and underwear, which it's not the golden arches or the
  214. old man on the Cracker Barrel logo, but it's kind of close for Victoria's Secret.
  215. >> Yeah. Um, but then they brought back the the Victoria's Angel fashion show, so that was a little
  216. confusing. I feel like this company now has leadership that understands um what young customers want from a lingerie
  217. brand that is capable of being comfortable and sexy and not sexist. you know, Americas, this is
  218. right to your point, and I'd like to hear you comment on it because this is something with a legacy that's
  219. potentially controversial, but maybe in its original intent wasn't supposed to be controversial. It kind of got in a
  220. little way branded and pushed in a direction that wasn't comfortable for them. And then you got to navigate how
  221. you build on a legacy because Victoria's Secret definitely had a strong legacy. avoid the pitfalls of bad politics or
  222. sexism or things like that that most people don't like, but you don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. You
  223. know, Americans, do you have a framework for that? I mean, in your brand identity, I I imagine it comes up a lot
  224. when you think about it. It's not it's not a simple concept. It is a complicated concept.
  225. >> It's an extremely complicated concept, Barbara. I think that, you know, we're
  226. starting to lay out some of the key key areas and issues, right? And I think it's the general notion where you have
  227. you've developed something and there's a core group of people who are with you on
  228. that something and now you're trying to grow and do other things and you know that the same customers to Barbara's
  229. point Daphne do not stay in the market forever. So you you can't be sitting there thinking that okay you know this
  230. this is going to I have to be doing the same sorts of things. And so I think part of it Barbara is how do your point
  231. which is how do I think about my core and how do I think about expanding my core but doing it in a way that's the
  232. the folks who are the OGs if you will uh embrace and and want to actually may maybe that's part of it Barbara where
  233. you get the core and you help and you have them help you bring in new people based on kind of their credibility with
  234. the brand and so it's becomes like a kumbaya moment maybe Barbara to to help sort of, you know, grow in a way that
  235. doesn't create factions where you got people who are like, "No, we're old school Victoria Seeker." You got the new
  236. people like, "No, we're we're the sexy but not sexist group." >> So So how do you how do you I I think
  237. that's part of it, Barbara, is like trying to again stepping back and trying to say we let how do we how do we keep
  238. the community whole and grow it at the same time? How do we make sure that everyone that's involved in the
  239. community feels like they have some psychological ownership and that kind of thing as we grow forward? What are you
  240. guys thoughts on that? Does that sound like it might be? Yeah, you know, I just want to weigh in and then I'm going to
  241. let you have the last word on this, Daphany. But I think that that's actually the the advantage of this
  242. community building because it is a little messy and you got to kind of think about it and you got to work it
  243. and you got to build on what's good and figure out what to throw out and but give everybody some ownership. And if
  244. you allow people to participate in creating this community, I think the end result it, you know, a couple misses,
  245. hopefully mostly hits, you know, but you get a lot more loyalty. I mean, if people are part of the community, part
  246. of creating what this brand means going on. I think you're going to get a much stronger community, a much stronger
  247. ownership than in the old days when you would hire, you know, the advertising guru who sat on the hill and threw
  248. things down and everybody just had to accept it. I think people like the community building and maybe because of
  249. that they embraced some of the messiness. The messiness is almost part of it as long as you can come out of it
  250. in a good way. >> What are your thoughts, Daffany, on that analysis? My thoughts are actually
  251. questions to you for you know the the decline of Victoria's Secret and their jumbled messaging there their jumbled
  252. maybe their loss of their own sense of self um really opened the door to a lot of DTC companies that took literally
  253. were taking share. I mean we know that they know that. Um now DTC sort of learned some hard lessons. it's not that
  254. easy to sell online, blah blah blah. And so I feel like there is an opportunity to for Victoria's Secret to yank some of
  255. that back. But what do you do if you're a DTC company? You do have a little bit of name recognition, but you didn't
  256. maybe get it over the hill like >> Yeah. That's a really good >> That's a good point. I mean, talking
  257. about throwing the baby out with the bathwater, GAP had incredible scale. I mean, some people thought they
  258. overstored and had to pull some of that back, but they had the scale. So did Victoria Secret have the scale. And
  259. these little DTC brands, they are, like you said, they didn't get over the hump.
  260. That's the really big deal. If you don't build your niche big enough to get over
  261. that hump so that you continue to have a stake in the ground, you're gonna be out
  262. when everybody starts coming for you and for your market share. So for the small
  263. brands, maybe you get that brand identity, that loyalty with a very small sliver of customers, but if you can't
  264. grow that >> when the big guys come after you and learn their lessons, you're not going to
  265. survive. So it's kind of war out there. >> America, you got a take on that? Like
  266. this? >> Well, you know what? I was going to actually I I think this is a perfect
  267. moment to talk about the con matrix because I I think this is part of what your analysis looks at right Barbara in
  268. terms of what are the quadrants that define growth and and this is huge because I just got finished Daphne
  269. listening to Barbara's uh ripple effect podcast with Dan Looney on the same Wharton podcast network and the idea
  270. your point Dafany about DTC not having an experience to now leverage is huge, right? In the sense of, you
  271. know, perhaps being a disadvantage. So maybe Barbara, C, could you what what does that analysis say? If you're in the
  272. DTC quadrant, what are you how are you thinking about these different sorts of things to be able to get over that hump
  273. and what are the what are the next steps to be able to do that? And one of the things we are seeing Deafany and I know
  274. you're seeing this too. You're making a different point on scale but one of the things we're seeing with the DTC brands
  275. typically they were online brands and they didn't have the physical store presence that Gap has that Victoria
  276. Secret has where you can and Lulu has for example where you're creating these brand communities these instore
  277. experiences in person. Uh, and if you don't have some kind of experience like that and you're not big enough to really
  278. scale, you kind of get caught between the crosshairs. And I think we are seeing a you we are even though there's
  279. stores are closing we are seeing a emphasis on building the right instore experience the right retail experience
  280. that merges with a very strong brand identity that kind of has to tinker with the changing times but you really want
  281. to create that physical instore experience for a lot of these brands. Yes. um which you don't really get if
  282. it's all online. Most of the more successful DTC's have managed their store experience
  283. um appropriately. Some of them opened too many stores and that was bad. Some of them didn't have enough stores and
  284. that was bad. But building some kind of real physical community experience I think really helps these retailers.
  285. Well, you know, we could talk about this for a long time. And I know we had another story we were going to talk to
  286. you about, Dapany, so we're gonna have to bring you back, but we're out of time right now. So, let me thank you for
  287. joining us today and remind us where our listeners can go to keep up with you and
  288. your stories and what's happening in Retail Dive. So, great to be here as always. Um, you can find my stories at
  289. retail dive, retaldive.com. Um, we're all advertising um, supported, so free to read. Sign up
  290. for a newsletter. U, we're a daily, so we've got a lot >> and talking to people like you. So,
  291. we've got a lot of good stuff in there. >> Excellent. >> That's great. Thank you very much.
  292. That's all we have time for today. I'd like to thank our producers, Dion Simpkins and Marissa Rena. Thank you all
  293. for listening today. We'll be back next week. Till then, this has been Marketing
  294. Matters on the Wharton Podcast Network. I'm Barbara Khan here with America's Read.
  295. [Music]

Brief Summary

Legacy brands like Gap and Victoria's Secret adapt to modern consumer preferences while grappling with their historical identities.

Key points

  • The Legacy of Brand Identity. A discussion on how brands like Cracker Barrel and Gap navigate their identities in a changing market.
  • The Minimalist Logo Debate. Exploring the effectiveness of minimalist logos for brands with legacy versus those without.
  • Generational Preferences in Branding. A look at how younger consumers perceive brand identities and logos.
  • The Risks of Brand Identity Changes. Discussing the risks associated with altering established brand identities.
  • Cultural Relevance in Marketing. The importance of staying relevant in the cultural zeitgeist for brands like Gap.
  • The Role of the CMO. The role of the Chief Marketing Officer is evolving to include more diverse skill sets.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes