The Emotion That Leads to Deception

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton research shows that spillover anger -- not sadness or another emotion -- leads to deception. More: http://knlg.net/2j1fUt9 📂 Management;Human Resources 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'd like to introduce Maurice Schweitzer and he is a professor here at Wharton of
  2. operations information and decision-making and his co-author of This research paper uh Jeremy Yip and he
  3. is a research scholar here at Wharton and they're going to talk about a very intriguing I think paper uh that they've
  4. just completed and it's called mad and misleading incidental anger uh promotes deception which is is
  5. not something you read about in a research paper every day matter of fact you'll tell us how this is the first
  6. time this particular topic has been looked at uh but it is intriguing and it's about how emotions influence
  7. ethical Behavior Uh or the potential influence of anger on deception and you look at the workplace in particular
  8. which uh which is especially relevant to our viewers so please um one of you describe in in brief terms the overview
  9. of that research sure I'm happy to um so our work establishes this link between feeling angry and deceiving others
  10. deception is a common behavior that occurs in organizations and poses a significant Challenge in a variety of
  11. interpersonal interactions for example in job interviews candidates May provide misleading statements in order to create
  12. a positive impression or in negotiations negotiators will Lo about their bottom line in order to claim more value and so
  13. what we investigated here was whether incidental anger anger that's triggered by an unrelated situation can promote
  14. the use of deception and what we found was that people who feel angry are more likely to lie to others we also find
  15. that empathy mediates this relationship between feeling angry and deceiving others such that when people are angry
  16. they' become less concerned about how their actions impact others and this disinhibits them to engage in
  17. self-serving deception so one of the interesting ideas that I think I picked up uh
  18. reading the study was that it's not as if someone did something to you and you're mad at them and now you you have
  19. an incentive to to be deceptive about something it's it's some other free floating Anger from over here that gets
  20. transferred to another situation is is that right yeah so that's a really important point
  21. so what we study is what's called incidental anger so anger that's triggered by some unrelated event so you
  22. might have had an argument with your spouse and then you have a meeting at work or you might have had a
  23. disagreement with one partner and then you end up meeting with a different partner if the situation is completely
  24. unrelated that anger should not influence our Behavior but we find that it actually does so what turns out to be
  25. important is that here this this anger bleeds into this unrelated situation and we become more likely to engage in
  26. deception just because we were angry before and that anger still influences and guides our
  27. Behavior why does it lead to deception and not just you know being hostile or or well maybe you're also hostile but
  28. what is it that about anger that leads to that behavior what's interesting is that we found is that the anger as
  29. Jeremy was explaining before disinhibits us we become less empathetic so we care
  30. less about other people in general and we're now more free or liberated to pursue our self-interest so it's really
  31. a self-interested behavior and across our studies we find that when people feel anger they're really less concern
  32. con ered about other people and they're not interested in retaliation or just randomly harming other people it's
  33. really just a diminished concern for others and the pursuit of self-interest now just gets carried away and it's no
  34. longer checked by our empathy for others that's how we usually operate we're feeling angry we just care less about
  35. others and what we find is that now anger becomes much the the deception becomes much more
  36. likely to occur so being angry makes you more egocentric in a way and less sensitive absolutely that's okay well
  37. that's interesting um what were the key takeaways from the study Jeremy in your view or at least
  38. the the main ones in our investigation we focused on self-serving deception these are lies that Advantage the liar
  39. at the expense of a Target when people are telling self- serving lies they're often engaging in
  40. this calculus between what are the costs and benefits for themselves but also what are the costs and benefits for
  41. others what we find is that anger influences these calculations where angry people are become more focused on
  42. themselves or the benefits to themselves and they discount the harm that they may
  43. cause others and that leads them to engage in deception so our key findings are that when you feel angry even when
  44. it's triggered by an unrelated situation you're more likely to lie we also find as Maurice mentioned that angry people
  45. are less empathetic and that uh disinhibits them to engage in self-interested Behavior such as
  46. lying and then we also found that the influence of anger on Deception is unique to anger and not to just any
  47. negative emotion so we contrasted the influence of anger with the influence of sadness on Deception
  48. and we actually found that only angry anger predicted deceptive Behavior it's interesting because when I think of
  49. deception um maybe this is just my impression it it's it seems more like a little devious it's like something you
  50. you pre-calculate and you know have thought about as opposed to like an immediate reaction but but anger is
  51. emotion that I could see would make someone just act more quickly without thinking and so so it's like a little
  52. disconnect there for me how does how does that work how did that come out um in your research because I know you did
  53. four studies actually to to come up with your conclusions is that right yeah yeah
  54. that's right so so we did a series of studies and in all these s we find the same pattern this anger is triggered by
  55. an unrelated event you get very negative feedback or you watch something that's very disturbing uh across several
  56. different inductions we find that this anger that's triggered that triggered immediately then does bleed into this
  57. somewhat more strategic behavior that is it changes our calculus and the key idea
  58. as jermy was explaining we just become less empathetic we care less about others and we're more focused on our
  59. self-interest and that narrowed focus is what guides us to to exhibit this self-interested Behavior which in our
  60. case was deception it's ethical but it's also advancing our self-interest at the
  61. expense of others that's what we found so it's easy to see how that would apply in so many areas of life and politics
  62. and World relations and everything else but in the workplace in the HR office what what are the implications and and
  63. is there anything that people can do about this I mean is this just an interesting observation but what do we
  64. do with the observation well we urge leaders managers and employees to recognize that
  65. in our angry moment moments we may lose our moral compass we suggest that managers pay
  66. close attention to monitoring their employees when they notice that they're angry because their angry employees are
  67. more likely to cheat so so check the stationary closet if there you have someone angry on the
  68. floor for missing pens and that sort of thing uh but that's that's I mean I'm joking of course but that's that's sort
  69. of the idea is that that there's a propensity now in someone who's angry to to do
  70. something that isn't going to be good for the organization well I think yeah I think as Jeremy's pointing out it's
  71. important for us to recognize it's true for us that is our own moral compass becomes less clearly pointed North when
  72. we feel angry and it's true for others that is other people are going to behave more strategically more self in a more
  73. self-interested way and in a less ethical way when they're feeling angry and again it could be some unrelated
  74. trigger that has made them feel that way but you're suggesting that there's a there's a benefit to developing
  75. organizationally some kind of a self-awareness in people that will benefit the organization is that right
  76. maybe you could elaborate on that idea a little bit right so I think the goal is
  77. to make people themselves aware employees themselves aware of their inclinations when they are feeling angry
  78. it um deceptions conceptualizes a cognitive process and what we're showing here is how emotions can have a profound
  79. influence on that process uh but we also want to urge leaders and managers to recognize this behavior in their
  80. employees and perhaps intervene in that there's other related research that's shown that when people become aware that
  81. their emotions are incidental or irrelevant that that can also diminish the effects of that emotion on behavior
  82. and I know I guess maybe we touch on this but this is different than a retribution where someone actually does
  83. something to you and you have a specific reason to be angry at that person and might seek to have some kind of
  84. Retribution but what what in the study in all of your research in this area what surprised you what surprises came
  85. out of it that you didn't expect I think one big surprise was when we looked at the so we contrasted how
  86. people angry people with neutral people when there was an incentive that was present and when there was an incentive
  87. that was absent and what we found was that we were able to disentangle the motive to harm others from the motive to
  88. pursue the self-interest so when people are angry they're not being punitive and
  89. harming anyone around them instead what we're finding is that when people are angry that anger curtails empathy
  90. and that leads to more self-interested behavior in this case self- serving lies that's interesting
  91. um what sets This research apart from other research in these areas well I think I think one key idea here is this
  92. this link is Jimmy was explaining between emotion and cognition so how we feel even if it's unrelated to the
  93. current situation influences how we think and how we Act and in this case we're linking anger
  94. with deceptive unethical Behavior so this is the first work to do that we often feel angry in the workplace we
  95. often feel angry when we're in a conflict with somebody else and our work is the first to demonstrate that when we
  96. feel an anger it could actually lead us to engage in underhanded and more self-interested behavior in ways that we
  97. might not normally condone and certainly as an organization we should be highly aware of so I kind of suggest that
  98. conflict resolution interventions and courses uh would benefit an organization in a couple ways not just that you have
  99. less conflict and maybe more cooperation but also you could ctail some of the deception that might come out of the
  100. conflict yeah acceptive Behavior right absolutely so that is we should recognize the the feelings that we have
  101. the that others have are going to guide their behavior in predictable ways and we should be sensitive to that J
  102. mentioned Rec recognizing emotions might help diminish their effects but we should also be sort of broadly aware of
  103. how we're feeling is likely to influence how we think and behave and in some cases it we might be able to curtail
  104. unethical Behavior by by muting that that that that anger so before I ask you what you'll be
  105. looking at next if you're going to look if you're going to pursue this further uh let me just ask is there anything I
  106. haven't asked that would be of major importance in this study that we haven't covered that you can think of or did we
  107. do such a great job that that's a great question we actually think about that one I think one of the questions that
  108. you asked was really important that is it's not that when we're feeling angry we want to retaliate against other
  109. people or that we want to pay it forward that somebody was angry you know angry at me
  110. or somebody blocked my goal and I want to go take it out on somebody else that's not what we observed what we
  111. found was that people just became much more self-interested self-serving and became less constrained
  112. by concern for others in advancing their own goals and I think that's one of the
  113. things that I think was most surprising about this work so if that's the way things work around here then I'm going
  114. to look out for number one is that is that kind of it that's right okay so in terms of what you might look at next
  115. then what what are the possibilities well these findings have informed uh some of our current work where we're
  116. investigating the relationship between anger and perspective taking and what we're beginning to find that's
  117. consistent with some of the work that we've just discussed is that when people feel angry they become more egocentric
  118. perspective taking is a different type of cognitive process where people adopt another person's Viewpoint in a
  119. situation and we are learning that people who feel angry tend to view a situation an to anchor on their own
  120. Viewpoint and not adjust to or accommodate other people's viewpoints all right well thank you both
  121. for coming in thank you that [Music]

Brief Summary

Incidental anger can lead to increased deception in workplace interactions, reducing empathy and ethical behavior.

Key points

  • Anger and Deception. Research shows that feeling angry can lead to increased deception in various situations.
  • Key Findings on Anger. Angry individuals are less empathetic and more likely to lie for self-interest.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes