Losing Your Temper and Perspective

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

New research from Maurice Schweitzer, Wharton professor of operations, information and decisions, and Jeremy Yip, management professor at Georgetown University, reveals that angry people often lose the ability to see problems from another point of view, which can hamper efforts to resolve conflict. 📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. hello I'm Steve ghulami editorial director at knowledge a warden and today I'm speaking with Mary Schweitzer who is
  2. a pro is a professor of operations information and decisions at the warden school and with Jeremy Yip who is
  3. professor of management at Georgetown University thank you both for joining us today
  4. there's your dangerous and so today we're going to talk about your research on the impact of anger in the workplace
  5. and the title of your paper is losing your temper and your perspective anger reduces perspective-taking so let's
  6. start with just the title of the paper itself and specifically that term perspective-taking so Jeremy can you
  7. define that for us in this context yeah perspective-taking is a cognitive process that involves recognizing
  8. differences and making inferences about how others view a situation when people engage in perspective-taking they often
  9. form mental representations of a particular situation for themselves and for others that overlap enables people
  10. to be able to bridge differences between percent of perceptions interests and backgrounds perspective-taking
  11. is closely tied to conflict in that poor perspective-taking is often associated with conflict and in this paper we
  12. explore an emotion that's commonly associated with conflict anger and it's and examine whether anger may actually
  13. impair perspective-taking and potentially fuel conflict okay and in the paper you talk specifically about
  14. two different kinds of anger one is incidental anchor the other one's integral anchor Maurice could you help
  15. us figure out what the difference is between those two and and why that's important sure
  16. so there we explored two different kinds of anger in federal anger anger that might bleed over from one case into
  17. another so imagine you have an argument with your spouse and then you go into an
  18. important meeting at work those two cases could be completely unrelated but that anger might carry over and still
  19. influence the way you behave and act in that second situation so many of our studies we look at
  20. incidental anger anger that's just carrying over from one case into another it's a more conservative test that we're
  21. just looking at that pure emotion and what we consistently find is that the motions we have from one setting really
  22. do carry over to unrelated settings in contrast integral anger is anger that I feel toward that same person or about
  23. that same issue that bleeds over from one case to another and in that case it might be quite relevant so it could be
  24. that I'm upset with a co-worker and I'm dealing with that co-worker in a second case and that emotion that I'm feeling
  25. could be informative and relevant in how I'm dealing with that person and so here
  26. when we think about conflict settings what we're showing is that even incidental anger anger from an unrelated
  27. source can really impair perspective-taking and it's certainly the case that integral anger that is anger I feel
  28. about a particular situation or a person is going to influence how I deal with that same situation or person okay so
  29. let's get to the why then so to Jeremy why why does anger impact prospective taking in these cases yeah it was
  30. something that we thought very carefully and deeply about what might explain why
  31. anger diminishes perspective-taking and in our work we found that when people feel angry they experience elevated
  32. levels of arousal and that interferes with their ability to think carefully and deliberately which reduces
  33. perspective-taking we can look at emotions according to valence and magnitude and
  34. what we're finding here is that anger is a negative valence high arousal emotion
  35. can I just stop you for a second can you just define what valence means in this context okay yeah valence refers to
  36. whether it's positive or negative and in this case anger is a negative emotion that also
  37. tends to be higher in terms of energy or arousal and when people feel or experience greater arousal they tend to
  38. be more likely to rely on heuristics what's valuable about our work is that we were also able to shed some insight
  39. into the puzzle about how emotions influence cognition prior work has found that when people feel happy they tend to
  40. exhibit impaired perspective taking similarly when people are anxious they tend to struggle with perspective taking
  41. and here our work finds that when people feel angry they tend to struggle with their perspective taking and what ties
  42. this all together is the role of arousal Maurice yeah I just add to that that that that essentially we're finding is
  43. that when people feel angry they're collapsing in on themselves they become far more egocentric and other work
  44. Jeremy and I have done together we're finding that basically anger which is this high arousal that is my heart's
  45. beating fast it's as high Roselyn motion I'm high an alert we're focusing in on ourselves and we're more likely to think
  46. about our own interests and it gets in the way of trying to think about things from somebody else's perspective so as
  47. Jen was explaining before we're trying to disentangle what we know in our heads from how other people are seeing and
  48. experiencing things and it's really hard to make that mental leap to really put ourselves in somebody else's shoes that
  49. perspective-taking requires this cognitive effort and we're finding is that the emotions we feel this anger
  50. that we feel is impairing that process and in fact that leads to what you call spirals correct conflict spirals yeah
  51. exactly right so so and Jeremy eluded this before that is negotiations or conflicts or disputes you know imagine
  52. your neighbor's dog bit a member of your family you might be angry about that angers a common
  53. theme in many conflict situations and what we're finding is that anger hums perspective-taking exactly the kind
  54. of skill you might need to try to resolve a conflict so whether it's at work or at home if you're feeling anger
  55. within a conflict situation it might make it even harder to resolve that so imagine we're going to court and as
  56. we're going to court if I can't take the other side's perspective I might be sure
  57. that the judge is going to rule in my favor and so now I'm gonna be less likely to accept any overtures to try to
  58. settle before we go to court I'm gonna escalate this conflict so I'm curious to know how you would study an emotion like
  59. anger in a lab setting so Jeremy King explained maybe a couple of the experiments that you did sure so
  60. we conducted six experiments in the lab and we our basic approach to these experiments was that we would induce the
  61. emotion and we used many different ways to induce emotion so for example we induced emotion by providing people with
  62. negative feedback or we had them watch a video in which an injustice occurred or
  63. we had them recall a time that they felt most angry and write about it they then
  64. completed measures of perspective-taking and here's where we were able to introduce some new ways of assessing
  65. perspective-taking in particular we assess perspective-taking through a scheduling task we told participants
  66. that they were that they needed to write an email and arrange a meeting time with
  67. a very important client who was based in California which was three hours behind
  68. their current time zone Eastern Time we were we looked at whether they wrote their messages using
  69. meeting times that were in Eastern time or in Pacific time and for those who wrote in Eastern time that reflected
  70. egocentrism on the other hand if they wrote it in Pacific time that reflected prospective taking and what we found was
  71. that consistently participants who felt angry tended to refer in their own eaters or to their
  72. own egocentric time zone Eastern Time we also assess perspective-taking using other measures where we present
  73. either a number which is which from one vantage point can look like a sixteen or
  74. four from another vantage point 91 as well as we ask them questions about who would they side with in terms of an
  75. insurance case when when attributing blame so there's a number of different ways that we induce anger and a number
  76. of different ways we assess anger or I'm sorry assess perspective-taking so so Maurice what do we do then with that
  77. information so we know that anger reduces perspective-taking what can employees and managers do when
  78. anger arises what should they be doing so so so the first thing to recognize is that perspective-taking is always an
  79. effortful and challenging process if not something we do well naturally and in any strategic decision any collaborative
  80. decision we need to work at perspective-taking so the first thing I would say is to is
  81. to be mindful of how important and challenging perspective thinking is and the second thing informed by a work is
  82. to recognize that how we feel can influence our ability to take perspective and when we feel anger in
  83. particular as well as any other high arousal emotion we should recognize that our ability to think about other
  84. people's perspectives is diminished that we're more likely to think egocentric alee that our tendency to focus in on
  85. ourselves becomes exacerbated by the high arousal emotion of anger or other related emotions so so we've got to
  86. check our emotions be mindful of that and recognize that we're going to be more likely to adopt an egocentric
  87. perspective so then all right there any Jeremy are there any specific techniques
  88. that you our manager can can hughes when these situations arise in our research we
  89. examine both incidental and integral anger and we were able to gain insight on how people can manage incidental
  90. anger in relation to their perspective taking what we found was that when people are made aware about the source
  91. of their incidental anger and they're able to infer that their anger is irrelevant to their particular social
  92. situation they're able to block the effects of anger and exhibit more perspective-taking the important point
  93. here or the important point here is to cultivate an awareness of our emotions and the sources and pinpoint the sources
  94. of our emotions so that we can judge whether they're relevant or irrelevant to the social situation at hand based on
  95. your research do you think that this would is does this not work in the case of integral anger as well as for
  96. instance if I'm fighting with someone in the moment about something very specific
  97. nor we're getting into an argument it's getting kind of heated is it useful to say I'm getting angry or you seem to be
  98. getting angry about this is that helpful in that moment as well do you think because I can see how would work in the
  99. case of you know I've had a bad morning and it might be helpful for me to say look I'm reacting this way because I had
  100. a terrible morning and this happened but in the case of integral anger does it does it I can almost see a case where it
  101. might cause a spiral to go further if you recognize the fact that I'm getting really mad do you think that that's true
  102. I I think that it is so I think we have to be careful we think about integral anger the anger could be integral with
  103. the same person or it could be the same situation or both and when we now vent about those issues they could actually
  104. make us angrier so we have to be careful on the other hand in general the more we can be
  105. cognizant of our emotions the more aware we are of our emotions and ideally as Jim was saying what
  106. an internal anger so I know that I'm angry about what my boss said to me at work and now I come home and I recognize
  107. the source of my anger I'm less likely to have that bleed into my interactions at home even when the even when the
  108. sources are integral recognizing what's making me angry can help us deal with that anger and recognize explicitly that
  109. this emotion is likely to influence our cognition that is where our work contributes to this growing body of work
  110. that's linking how we feel to how we think so speaking of that growing body of work 10 years ago maybe you know
  111. someone might have come to work and they would have been told check your baggage
  112. at the door work is work you don't you don't bring your problems here you just focus on work now it seems like the
  113. pendulum is swinging the other way and we are more inclined to acknowledge the power of emotion at work how do you
  114. think that's going to reshape management practice I think managers need to be aware of their own emotions and how it
  115. can affect their behavior but they also want to be attune to the effects of the emotional effects of their communication
  116. so when they use incendiary words whether it is directed at people in within their own workplace or outside
  117. competitors there's an opportunity or there's a chance that that may elicit anger among their audience of workers
  118. and that can have significant effects and consequences for how individuals behave to one another as well as how
  119. they behave towards the leader I think realizing this connection or this link between emotion and cognition
  120. is very important for managers to pay attention to yeah I'll just add to that that I think emotion is really integral
  121. to getting our world done a lot of emotion conveys information so if you have an employee
  122. who's angry about something that helps guide attention to that issue and maybe they're upset because something isn't
  123. working well and we should be paying more attention to that issue or in the workplace the motions that we express
  124. can help us accomplish different kinds of tasks so sometimes anger can be very motivating
  125. we're upset about some injustice and we're now motivated to address it or it could be that the the use of positive
  126. emotions can help us either bond together or serve a client or help us be excited when we sell a product that the
  127. motions that we have are really part of us and rather than trying to check our emotions at the door and assume that
  128. we're unemotional throughout the full day to recognize that there's information here and there's use for the
  129. emotions that we feel so part of this also I mean it seems to me that this could be letting a genie out of a bottle
  130. too for some managers right so in other words if I'm gonna start validating or acknowledging emotion in the workplace
  131. we'll get to a point where all's we're talking about our feelings about things and the works actually not getting done
  132. like we're is there a balance that needs to be found within that yeah I'd say absolutely so so clearly we don't want
  133. unregulated emotions running wild and instead we need to be careful about how we regulate our emotions I think the
  134. first step is just recognizing that we do feel these emotions and if we can attribute where that emotions coming
  135. from I think those two key steps how do I feel and why do I feel that way that's
  136. going to take us a pretty long way the third sort of next up would be figure out hey how do I change my emotions so
  137. it could be that I'm feeling upset about an interaction I had with a co-worker or
  138. a colleague I have to make an important strategic decision I know that if I go for a walk or I go
  139. to the gym or I talked to my other friend down the hall I'm going to clear my head in a way that's gonna allow me
  140. to think differently about this decision so I think it's it's that recognition to
  141. recognize how we feel why we feel that way and how we can change how we feel that can really help us make much much
  142. much better decisions and improve our interactions at work it's so Jeremy what what kinds of questions this research
  143. raised about anger that maybe you would want to explore next we became interested in exploring the role that
  144. anger may play within a team context so we currently have ongoing work that explores another topic of research that
  145. were both that we've collaborated on trash-talking and in particular we look at trash-talking when leaders trash talk
  146. is there a functional benefit to doing so within groups and our evidence suggests that when that in-group members
  147. when in-group members witness a trash-talking leader they actually that trash-talking can build cohesion and
  148. identification with their organization so it really depends on what these aggressive what this aggressive these
  149. aggressive words this incendiary language what it's targeted at when it's targeted at outside of a particular
  150. organization or in-group it may actually have functional benefits and that anger
  151. that is elicited may essentially serve as a call to action to be able to have a group of people coalesce around a
  152. particular cause and pursue it okay Maurice where do you think you would take this research next well I think we
  153. can think about a series of other related emotions so we've done some really work on anger and disgust and sadness
  154. and happiness to think about the sort of broader set of emotions I think understanding how we think about
  155. emotions and recognize our own emotions and the interplay of the emotions that you're expressing and how that interacts
  156. my thinking and cognition those are all areas that were eager to explore and and
  157. I think this trash-talking work is particularly interesting when we don't always behave in a civil way with each
  158. other and it's easy to trigger emotions and other people and sometimes you might
  159. do it inadvertently in ways that cause other people to act in ways that surprised us but in hindsight probably
  160. shouldn't well thank you both very much for joining us today it's a topic that I
  161. think is you know it touches everyone so I think it's a it's a great one to explore thanks very much thank you thank
  162. you for more insight from knowledge at Wharton please visit knowledge Wharton UPenn edu
  163. [Music] you

Brief Summary

Anger in the workplace impairs perspective-taking, affecting conflict resolution and decision-making.

Key points

  • The Impact of Anger. Research shows that anger can impair perspective-taking, affecting workplace dynamics.
  • Understanding Perspective-Taking. Perspective-taking is crucial for conflict resolution, but anger complicates it.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes