Foreign Firms and Immigrants

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Management 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. so in my research i wanted to study the effect that immigrants have on the internationalization process
  2. of firms from their home countries so for example think of a firm from japan or from brazil uh and i was
  3. you know interested in a firm like that for instance when they are going to invest in a country like the united
  4. states do they pick a location where there's brazilian or japanese immigrants and if they do that is that actually a
  5. good choice for their performance and assuming that i find those effects why are they happening what is it that
  6. the immigrants are are providing so to answer those questions i gathered some data on the investments of
  7. firms from 27 countries into the united states during 1998 to 2003 and then i tracked
  8. the performance of those investments for several years thereafter well the key takeaways are basically
  9. three the first one is that there is indeed an effect that immigrants have on the location choices of firms so that
  10. if a firm is going to choose a state within the u.s it was much more likely to choose
  11. a state that had more rather than less immigrants from its home country the second is that
  12. if i analyze the survival or how you know the longevity of those investments whether they continued as a going
  13. concern that also the presence of immigrants was a really strong predictor of the likelihood of
  14. success and the third one is that those two effects that i just mentioned are especially strong for firms that
  15. have some kind of knowledge related need so think of first-time investors in the
  16. us who don't know how to do business here immigrants seem to be very helpful for
  17. those firms or a firm that's in a high-tech industry and needs to transfer knowledge from its home country into the
  18. u.s same thing immigrants had a strong effect on those types of firms so it seems to be that
  19. the driver here is some kind of knowledge or information that the diaspora network is helping
  20. these firms obtain the biggest surprise was actually the strength of the findings and and sort of
  21. how robust they were so if you think about the effect of immigrants you might think it
  22. there might be an effect but it's trivial but actually the effect of immigrants on both location choice and
  23. the survival was much stronger than the effect of other things that we typically think of
  24. as important for firms so think of government incentives say a tax incentive or or something that the government is
  25. trying to do to attract foreign investors or the presence of other firms from the
  26. same industry so that the firm can say obtain knowledge when it goes to that foreign location those things
  27. mattered but they mattered actually significantly less than the effect of immigrants so i
  28. was surprised by that i think there's practical implications for several groups here for instance if
  29. you're a manager the most obvious implication is that diaspora can be an asset as you go
  30. abroad it can help you pick a good location and perform well in that location for example if you are a manager of a
  31. high tech firm and you want to take your technology abroad you want to do research and development abroad
  32. you may be able to hire someone for the diaspora let's say that you're a firm that needs to find a supplier in the
  33. foreign location the diaspora might refer you to a useful supplier so they might give you information or
  34. knowledge that is useful as you go abroad if you're a policy maker i think there's also some
  35. implications in the sense that we don't typically think of immigrants as sort of
  36. being part of the package that firms are looking for when they go abroad so the question if you're trying to
  37. attract foreign investment is how friendly is my place to immigrants is it is it a
  38. place that's open to letting foreign people come and that might allow you to bring foreign capital
  39. and of course it has a huge i think implication as well if you're doing immigration policy we
  40. typically don't think of immigrants as affecting foreign capital and the implication is that they do
  41. yeah so there's several examples of firms that that have done this or either by luck or intentionally so uh
  42. the one of the oldest and most well-known is actually the example of honda right honda uh decided to come into
  43. california uh in the 1950s to sell motorcycles and the one of the main reasons they
  44. decided to do this and the the managers talked about is just because there was a japanese diaspora
  45. that that was there in california and might be able to help connect them to resources
  46. more recently for instance there's a firm from spain called freyjanet they're in the
  47. they're in the wine industry and several years ago they were approached by a spanish
  48. immigrant living in australia that made them aware that australia might actually be a really good place to
  49. sell their product because there was sort of a culture of of wine growing in that country
  50. and they they did actually in this very immigrant became their first distributor
  51. in australia and so that's just an example of even coming up with the opportunity
  52. right because of the diaspora and to me one that's very interesting that was part of the motivation for this
  53. study is that if i told you that what the fastest growing fast food chain is in the united states
  54. you probably wouldn't know that it's a firm from guatemala of all places it's called pollo campero
  55. and it's a competitor to kentucky fried chicken and they've actually broken records in
  56. terms of growth and even sales within a year in a store and their strategy has been essentially
  57. to just follow the hispanic diaspora in the united states so they started in california
  58. they've expanded very rapidly they're in most states now and when you look at where they locate
  59. their operations it's all in neighborhoods that have a high density of hispanic immigrants
  60. so these would all be examples of the diaspora somehow helping provide information
  61. support resources or functioning as customers and helping firms be successful abroad
  62. well i think new strategies for either managers or policy makers are implied by some of what i said in
  63. answers to the previous question but for instance if i were a manager i would think what kind of informational
  64. needs do i have so do i need to hire knowledge workers do i need to learn about the foreign location and i would think
  65. what what's the profile of the diaspora in that location maybe their education level maybe
  66. the industries in which the diaspora tends to work so for instance the indian diaspora has strong expertise
  67. in technology and software especially so is there something about that expertise
  68. that the diaspora has that may help me capitalize on on going to a foreign location
  69. and i think for a strategy to attract foreign investment we might want to think of just how open
  70. and friendly our place is to to foreigners in general right not just to foreign firms
  71. i think that there are other other areas to think about perhaps the best way is to flip the question on its head and
  72. think to which firms or industries might this not apply so this study was a multi-industry study
  73. so it seems to generalize to multiple industries i think though that this is less relevant for
  74. think of an industry where scale or or just pure capital or size is more important right that's
  75. not a very knowledge dependent industry uh perhaps there's not much that the immigrants can provide
  76. you right i mean any benefit you'll get will be just from the sheer size and capital of uh
  77. scale of your operation so i don't think that it would apply to to that kind of setting
  78. i think there's a lot of relevant things happening in some ways that was what motivated me to do the research was just
  79. looking around and seeing for instance the raging debate we have about immigration policy right and there's
  80. lots of disagreement i think that this would be relevant to say look we're talking about you know do
  81. immigrants come and consume all our resources do they take our jobs another question would be well can they
  82. help us attract foreign capital and as much as that's a desirable outcome i think that that should be part of the
  83. immigration debate even though this wasn't written from a policy standpoint but i think that it's there's
  84. at least some facts here that are relevant for policy makers the other thing that we see is there's
  85. two phenomena that are really important one is we see a lot of foreign countries
  86. being open like china and india and brazil sort of the bric countries and there's a lot of interest
  87. in investing in those but these are tricky countries to go into and their spectacular failures reported in the
  88. media and perhaps the diaspora can be very helpful in tackling those countries and the
  89. reverse is also true we see multinationals from these countries we call them the emerging giants
  90. coming out of countries like china and india and perhaps part of the explanation for
  91. this their success is these these tend to be the countries that have actually sent out
  92. large diasporas in the last few decades it might be a little presumptuous to think that you know single-handedly i've
  93. dispelled a misperception but if i had to pick one that i would like to dispel is that
  94. immigrants simply come and consume all resources and don't don't add anything to an economy and i
  95. think we just haven't thought much about their role in attracting foreign capital so i
  96. would hope that that would be part of the debate i think there's another misperception
  97. and there's a sense that the world is flat that information travels freely right
  98. without any constraints and if that were true immigrants shouldn't matter in the
  99. investment choices of firms but yet they do so you know social and formal networks
  100. seem to play a pretty big role in foreign investment i think this goes beyond just immigrants
  101. there's other types of formal and informal networks that firms rely on and these are really important
  102. to the internationalization process of firms and so i think that we we can't be naive about the sense
  103. that the world is is just sort of flat and that personal relationships don't matter
  104. i think that's an important question to explain sort of what does this add i should say this isn't the first study
  105. to establish a correlation or a relationship between immigration and trade or or
  106. investment there are some studies at the country level that that have established this and even a few at the
  107. at the firm level i think what this study adds that that is new is a few things the first one is
  108. actually showing how firms strategically respond to immigration right there wasn't much of a sense of
  109. you know would firms actually pick to do this or is this a spurious correlation and the sense that this paper gives is
  110. that this is actually an intentional choice and not only that but it's actually a
  111. choice that affects performance in a positive way and we didn't know or at least nobody had proved the effect
  112. on performance the other thing that i think it adds is a bit of a sense of why this is
  113. happening right so this could happen for a lot of different reasons it could just
  114. be for instance that places that happen to attract immigrants are also attractive for foreign firms
  115. and this tries to show a little more causally that information and knowledge is why this is
  116. happening that immigrants somehow help firms tap into local knowledge or refer firms to say suppliers or buyers that
  117. there's some kind of informational intermediary between the firms and resources in the
  118. location uh yeah the issue of immigration is an important part of my research agenda
  119. i have a few ongoing projects and several new ones in mind i guess i'll tell you maybe about two or
  120. three of them one of them has to do with actually what might be the downsides of a strategy relying on immigrants
  121. right this this study talks about the benefits and what i looked at as a performance
  122. outcome was survival but if you think about it immigrants typically represent a really small
  123. sliver of the local population so you might be stuck in a really small niche right and you might not be able to
  124. grow and target the broader population because the immigrants either have very different tastes or
  125. provide you biased information and so i'm planning a study that looks at actually the trade-off between
  126. survival and growth when you go to a place where there's a strong diaspora another study actually tries to answer
  127. the question of whether when you establish a foreign subsidiary is it good to have it
  128. managed by a local or by an immigrant and what are some of the trade-offs uh and so that's a study with a colleague
  129. of mine elena colcina at duke university that we have started and then there's a third
  130. study with a colleague seth carnahan from the university of michigan and what we're trying to do is actually
  131. look at the reverse phenomenon and think what's the effect of firms coming in to
  132. a foreign location and what effect do they have on immigrants and specifically we want to ask does the foreign
  133. investment cause immigrants to be more entrepreneurial or less entrepreneurial right because we know that immigrants
  134. typically have a high rate of entrepreneurship but does the foreign investment you know
  135. say a firm from their home country does it make them more likely to start a new firm or market and maybe go work for
  136. that firm and not be an entrepreneur so we're trying to think of those effects too
  137. you

Brief Summary

Immigrants significantly influence firm location choices and investment success, providing essential knowledge and networks for internationalization.

Key points

  • The Impact of Immigrants on Business. Research shows immigrants significantly influence firms' location choices and investment success.
  • Honda's Strategic Move. Honda's entry into California was largely influenced by the Japanese diaspora.
  • Pollo Campero's Growth Story. The fastest growing fast food chain in the U.S. is from Guatemala, leveraging the Hispanic diaspora.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes