Valuing Non-Contractual Firms Using Common Customer Metrics

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

📂 Management;Marketing 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here today to discuss some new Wharton research about customer lifetime value and company valuation here to talk
  2. with us is wharton marketing professor peter fader Pete thanks for being here always a pleasure Rachel and Wharton
  3. doctoral student Dan McCarthy Dan welcome back yeah thank you very much for having me so Pete first of all could
  4. you give us a quick summary of a research now this is a bit of a follow up from something you've done previously
  5. where you looked at company evaluation of companies that have customers that buy subscriptions and this is a little
  6. bit different so could you tell us a little about that old research and then how you're building upon it in this way
  7. sure well there's no such thing as old research here this is all brand new there's this idea of customer based
  8. corporate valuation it's actually a concept that's been floating around but Dan and I are taking it very very
  9. seriously and we want to bring just just a tremendous amount of rigor and breadth
  10. to it in the previous work we looked up euerle on the contractual or the subscription-based side so if a company
  11. knows when a customer's leaving it's kind of easy to put to project what the rest of their life is gonna be and and
  12. the payments tend to be kind of steady but most businesses are what we call non-contractual which is the you're just
  13. buying things on occasion and then there's a long hiatus between them and and if you think about this is the kind
  14. of behave you have with with a retailer or with a travel firm or even pharmaceuticals or media consumption
  15. most businesses are non contractual and that makes it much more difficult to understand who's doing what and to
  16. project it into the future so a big part of what we're doing here is trying to take this this broader concept of
  17. customer based corporate valuation but make it just as palatable in the non-contractual setting as it has been
  18. in the contractual subscription-based one and and everything add yeah that's a it's exactly right I'd say one of the
  19. key challenges in this work is really the the data that we need to be able to perform this estimation and then project
  20. forward you know how many purchases customers are gonna make and how much they're gonna spend on each of those
  21. purchases so again we want these methodologies to be as broadly applicable as possible the vantage point
  22. of this work is really someone who's on the outside looking in and so maybe it's
  23. a shareholder a hedge fund private equity firm any number of financial institutions that are kind of everyday
  24. looking at the public markets and trying to say so I want to buy this company do
  25. I want to sell this company and those those those people they don't have access to the internal transaction logs
  26. to the company and what they have access to are usually the sort of information that a company would put and its
  27. quarterly or its annual filings and so basically we went at this problem by saying imagine that a company was to
  28. disclose a certain very small set of common customer metrics what are the ones that would really enable us to be
  29. able to perform this first estimation procedure for the various model components and use those to project
  30. forward eventually what total revenues are going to be and Dan tell me a little bit now
  31. once you've how did you figure out what those were and then what did you do with
  32. them yes we figured it out by doing a large-scale simulation analysis so kind of the step one was saying this is a set
  33. of metrics that we think could be usable and really they needed to kind of satisfy two main criteria the first is
  34. that they're actually used by companies so we found many metrics that essentially we have found public
  35. companies that are using them in disclosing them regularly and then the second criteria is really that they
  36. actually help inform our model and so the way that we answered that was we said imagine that I was to generate data
  37. from all these different possible types of worlds basically any different type of non
  38. contractual company and just let these metrics kind of Duke it out so we took every possible collection of this set
  39. and said imagine that I only got to see those metrics let me try to predict the future and then essentially see which
  40. combinations of metrics kind of percolate to the top absolutely I think it makes sense to talk about the metrics
  41. themselves so as Dan said we've done a lot of scraping of financial statements listening to CEO conference calls seeing
  42. what third-party firms are saying about the size and age of customer bases and we came up with six metrics so metric
  43. number one the most common one that a lot of companies will report is what we call active users so how many people
  44. have made transaction used our product or service sometime within the trailing 12 months
  45. number two is what we call heavy active users so how many people have made a repeat purchased have engaged with us at
  46. least twice over that trailing 12 months number three would be this idea of a forward repeat rate of all the people
  47. who made a transaction with us back in 2015 how many came back and did it again sometime in 2016 the the fourth and
  48. fifth would be kind of the flip side of that so of all the purchases that we had
  49. today what percent of them are from customers who did something with us in the previous year and that one we can
  50. either do on a customer by customer basis of all the customers who bought with us what percent were with us
  51. previously or all the orders that were placed with us this year what percent of them are by customers who bought
  52. previously and then last and least reported is the idea of frequency of all the customers who have done anything
  53. with us in the past year how many things did they do how many purchases did they make or so
  54. on so that's the big six and as Dan said we went into it without a really strong
  55. sense of which one or ones would win out but it was really interesting to do this
  56. grand bake-off across lots of different worlds as you said and to see there actually were some very strong
  57. consistent results so when you did when you did this bake-off what was the winning what was the winning metric here
  58. what was what are some of the conclusions that you were able to make from this sure of course it's always
  59. easy in hindsight and I'm kind of stalling right now because I want our listeners and viewers to think that
  60. among the six metrics that I just listed if you had to pick say two of them which
  61. ones would bubble up to the top and would give you the ability as Dan said to to kind of uncover the repeat buying
  62. pattern as if you had the granular data at your fingertips well it turns out that far and away the
  63. number one metric is the least commonly reported one that I mentioned which is frequency so if you can tell us among
  64. the people who did anything how many things did they do on average that now by itself any one metric isn't going to
  65. get you far but if you take that frequency metric and you come with any of the other five it doesn't
  66. even matter frequency plus anything gives you really good predictive capability just winning by a nose among
  67. the five was the first one I mentioned just active users so if you can say here's the number of people who have
  68. done anything with with us and here's the average number of things that they've done you take that one-two punch
  69. and it's remarkable how well you can uncover future purchasing and then benefit from all the the the other good
  70. things that you can do with those insights yeah I think that really sums it up I'd say one thing that was a bit
  71. surprising was the fact that when we went from two metrics to three there was virtually no improvement in our ability
  72. to predict future purchases that really the bulk of the the benefit that we got was by moving from kind of the best
  73. single metric to the best pair and what was almost equally interesting was you can't have too much of a good thing so
  74. as we kind of kept that process going you know what's the best quartet what's the best combination of five that we
  75. went when we went from the best combination of five to the best combination of six performance actually
  76. got slightly worse and it got a bit more variable from scenario to scenario and so actually you know sometimes less is
  77. better yes I think it was kind of an interesting example of Occam's razor with the data so Dan tell me if now I'm
  78. a company or I'm a customer I'm anyone that might be interested in this sort of data what's the best way to take your
  79. findings and apply them in the real world really I would just demand that companies disclose these metrics I think
  80. emphasizing both to the company itself and perhaps even to regulators whose responsibility it is to ensure that
  81. investors have the information that they need to you kind of make informed investment decisions we're basically
  82. saying that these metrics are really informative so I think it would be wonderful to just kind of speak up and
  83. get people to disclose the metrics on the back end we have this you know fairly complex estimation technique
  84. that's needed to really kind of take that scattered bunch of customer metrics and be able to kind of map it down to
  85. the underlying parameters of these models that we have for how customers are acquired over time how
  86. many purchases they make and the spend associated with each of the purchases so there is some you know some math
  87. involved and some have heavier duty computation than we saw you say in the subscription-based paper but it is
  88. certainly quite doable and I think as these method methodologies kind of take hold we'll see them you know be kind of
  89. made more readily available do you have anything to add it also I guess I'm curious like what do companies have
  90. reasons not to release this data I mean is there a reason why they wouldn't want
  91. to and how do you get over that so first let's talk about some of the other benefits then we could talk about some
  92. of some of those strategic aspects as well so obviously the motivation here is customer based corporate valuation so
  93. can the investor make more informed decisions about the current and future health of a company's customer base and
  94. therefore the value of the enterprise but it can be useful in other ways as well so this could be a great source of
  95. competitive intelligence so given that these metrics are not that hard to get say from a third-party firm or from a
  96. company's first-party disclosures you can start to see of rival companies playing this game about other
  97. competitors in the same sector to understand where they stand not just in terms of overall sales but in terms of
  98. the nature of the customer base so so we think that there'll be quite an imperative to be reporting these things
  99. not only out of some kind of fiduciary responsibility but for some of these kind of competitive activities as well
  100. which goes directly to the other part of your question this idea of should there
  101. be some sense of when you disclose which kinds of metrics right now it seems kind
  102. of haphazard there are some companies that disclose some metrics all the time others that do it never there seems to
  103. be no logic as to why certain companies do or don't and which ones they disclose
  104. there's some companies out there that just just boast about disclosing metrics may because it makes them look a little
  105. bit more rigorous or sciency but no one ever looks at these things and can really make heads or tails out of them
  106. or map them back to actual or projected future revenues so we want to see much more
  107. Smart's about who discloses what when and and maybe companies would then start to say so
  108. are they revealing these metrics now because that they're trying to signal something or or maybe they're gonna stop
  109. revealing them because they're trying to hide something so there's gonna be this
  110. whole chess match about who discloses what when that'll be kind of interesting when we get to that point right now it's
  111. just so early on that if companies are doing this is all it really seems that gets more kind of the ceo's ego as much
  112. as any kind of real information value we want to see just again much more a rigor
  113. and discipline about who's disclosing what when and why do you feel like this is gonna become people are gonna become
  114. more interested in doing this and more interesting talking about it as their becomes more of this realization that
  115. maybe you're not saying everything there is to say about a company by just disclosing its financials that there is
  116. this other element there that may have nothing to do with earnings or revenue at least not for that quarter that
  117. that's right so I so for many companies that they they go to Wall Street on a quarterly basis and Wall Street's kind
  118. of look at them saying your earnings aren't up to snuff but they say you know what we're investing in the customers
  119. well so far it's just been a trust me but now we can provide definitive proof so now investors can say is that if
  120. that's really true then show us these two metrics so that we can make that assessment for
  121. ourselves so I want that the companies to be more forthright about it I want investors to demand it I want
  122. competitors to be kind of curious regulators as Dan said I just want just a more active conversation about this
  123. this concept of customer based corporate valuation I think it's in everyone's best interest and of course I'm a
  124. marketing professor I think that if we can establish that there's something here then it will also trickle down
  125. through the rest of the organization as well and start to impact other kinds of decisions that the company is going to
  126. be making I say the one other thing I would add to that it's a very legitimate concern that some companies would have
  127. that as soon as they start disclosing these metrics that you know there's some sort of negative you know repercussion
  128. from that and I think there's been some very interesting recent work that was just put out and one of the top
  129. marketing journals by a colleague of ours Bern Ciara that basically came to the conclusion that when companies
  130. disclose forward-looking metric it really helps investors make more accurate projections of revenues thus
  131. lowering their kind of perception of the uncertainty about what's what's to come
  132. in the future and that actually can help increase the valuation of firms and so all else being equal disclosing
  133. forward-looking metrics can actually be beneficial to the stock price so it can help just kind of overcome some of those
  134. concerns that companies might have so dan do you feel like that there are other misperceptions that might this
  135. research might dispel I've I'd say yeah for one just the competitive concerns you know we're showing that these
  136. metrics can be actually very helpful for projecting what will happen in the future I'd mentioned the one about you
  137. kind of too much of a good thing but it's a another kind of spin on that would be just the overwhelming kind of
  138. influence of quality over quantity that it's an extremely important it's extremely important to have the right
  139. combination of metrics and oftentimes having a very small set of very good metrics can be much more beneficial than
  140. having kind of the wrong set of very numerous metrics so in that large-scale simulation analysis we actually found
  141. that if you gave us the right set of two metrics it could do much better than another set of five metrics so that kind
  142. of surprised me in terms of misconceptions I'd say the final one that comes to mind is up until this
  143. point most people have been using customer metrics as kind of a dashboard that every month or every week the
  144. company will have a spreadsheet that sent out to the organization and it's got this long list of all these
  145. different customer metrics and how each of them has gotten better or worse over time and usually people are looking at
  146. each of these different metrics is kind of you know in its own world yeah that essentially if it went up it must be
  147. good if it went down it must be bad and let's figure out why here we're kind of saying we don't just need to look at
  148. these metrics kind of on a standalone basis they're not ends unto themselves essentially we can be able to kind of
  149. tie them up and summarize the you're kind of effective you know what happened over the past week or month on the
  150. overall valuation of the firm by kind of putting them all together and weaving them into this integrated model
  151. now Pete I guess anything from you but also do you feel like cus the companies that don't operate on a subscription
  152. model do you feel like there was the percentage out there that maybe they couldn't do something like this that
  153. that was just for the subscription-based businesses of the world it's not for us
  154. do you think this dispels that if it well it does dispel that but actually was a worse problem that there were a
  155. lot of these kinds of non-contractual non-subscription firms out there and they would just kind of make metrics up
  156. to make it seem like they could use some of these subscription oriented approaches so for instance in the
  157. subscription world you have a formal retention rate you know of all the people who had a subscription with this
  158. last period how many of them renewed you know whether they did it or not there is
  159. no equivalent metric in the non-contractual world there's no way that you that you kind of actively raise
  160. your hand or a worse yet if you're not present if you don't make a purchase if I didn't buy anything from Amazon in the
  161. past twelve months doesn't mean that I'm gone as a customer it just means that I'm a light buyer so what a lot of
  162. non-contractual firms were doing is they would take some of these metrics like the one I mentioned before the for word
  163. retention from the for word repeat rate among all people bought in 2015 how many
  164. also bought in 2016 this you know what that's kind of like a retention rate let's just treat it that way and then
  165. pretend that we're a subscription company well that's just wrong and and not only is it conceptually incorrect
  166. but if you were to follow it all the way through and some of the earlier published research showed this that your
  167. ability to assess the overall value of the customer base is going to be way way way off and the Diagnostics that you get
  168. around it would be off as well which takes me back to the other part of your question one of the other benefits of
  169. doing all this is to create credibility for the marketing organization if we can
  170. say here are the really meaningful metrics and here's the way that we can tie them together to make statements
  171. about valuation instead of having these things being little trophies on a shelf where the rest of the organization say
  172. the people in the CFO's office would say that's nice let the marketers play with
  173. their toys if we can show the CFO and again other folks to the organization that these metrics can actually help
  174. with day-to-day operational decisions as well as bonafide long strategy it's going to cast the entire
  175. marketing organization under a very different light and to me personally getting that kind of respect getting the
  176. kind of common language is more important than taking some of these valuation models and trying to find a
  177. little bargain here or there as a hedge fund might do they're both interesting they're both important but for me it's
  178. that the common language and respect for marketing that that's number one now P can you tell me what's next for
  179. this research where you go where are you gonna go from here well right now we're
  180. just establishing these the basic methods like here are the metrics you'd want to use here's the way you tie them
  181. together to get the overall valuation but it starts to lead to all kinds of other questions including some that
  182. we've already touched on this idea of so strategically what kinds of metrics should I disclose when but I really
  183. should defer to Dan McCarthy because this is his dissertation work and he's been thinking of a lot of other
  184. different directions to take it that will be part of what he does when he graduates from here and becomes a
  185. professor down at Emory so so Dan you tell us what's next yes in terms of the boxes that have already been checked we
  186. kind of think of it along a few different dimensions you know what's the sort of data that we have you who's
  187. performing the exercise what is the goal and what's the type of firm and right now we've primarily focused on external
  188. stakeholders you know like the shareholders or the private equity firms or the hedge funds who are their goal is
  189. really to make an accurate estimate how much the value the firm should be and we've done that for both contractual and
  190. for non contractual firms so in terms of where we go from here I'd say one of the
  191. big questions is can we move beyond measurement imagine that I'm inside the company is there anything else that I
  192. might want to do so maybe we can be able to kind of manage value not just measure
  193. it and kind of part and parcel with that we'll be using internal data as opposed
  194. to external data instead be one example another is in both the subscription based valuation paper and a non
  195. subscription valuation paper we were kind of only looking at one company at a time yeah so whether it's Dish Network
  196. Sirius XM or this apparel retailer and in the current paper we didn't really focus on any any come
  197. Pettit --iv effects or anything like that so I think an interesting area of future work would be imagine that we had
  198. multiple companies in the same industry could we learn something you know that we wouldn't have learned about if we
  199. were looking at each of the companies individually make better predictions or just learn about competitive effects so
  200. I think the sky's the limit you know we're just really scratching the surface and I'm very excited to see
  201. where we can go from here dan thanks so much for being here with us again always
  202. great to talk with you Rachel thanks yeah thank you very much for having us [Music]

Brief Summary

Peter Fader and Dan McCarthy discuss customer lifetime value metrics and corporate valuation, emphasizing the need for transparency in non-contractual businesses.

Key points

  • Customer-Based Corporate Valuation. Exploring the concept of valuing companies based on customer metrics, a shift from traditional methods.
  • The Winning Metric. Discovering that frequency is the most predictive metric for future purchases.
  • Demand for Transparency. Encouraging companies to disclose customer metrics for better investment decisions.
  • Future of Research. Exploring the next steps in research and valuation methods, including internal data use.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes