Valuing the Customer

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Many businesses will say that their customers are their most valuable assets, but few understand how true that is -- or how accurately a measurement of customer-based value can price their whole enterprise. More: http://knlg.net/1RiNWH2 📂 Finance & Accounting 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. this paper brings together two topics one very old and well established and one that's new and emerging the old
  2. topic is Corporate valuation everybody's talking about how you look at a corporation and value it the new topic
  3. is customer valuation can we look at individual customers or groups of customers and say what they're going to
  4. be worth in the future what this paper's all about is bringing the two together in a really rigorous and and practical
  5. Real World Way can we do corporate valuation from the bottom up by looking at the value of current and future
  6. customers adding all that up and saying that's the value of the corporation that
  7. basic idea has been around for a while it's been done by a few marketers in the past but it's never had the real rigor
  8. to win over the the respect of let's say Financial people and accountants uh that's what we're trying to do the right
  9. way so it's it's customer-based corporate valuation but done with with all the rigor with all just the really
  10. high standards and careful use of data that accountants and and financial professionals would respect of there
  11. really have been kind of two silos of of work here you the one in the marketing domain and the one in the financial
  12. domain and the financial domain has really kind of hammered home you know how you value a business by you know
  13. projecting forward free cash flows discounting those back doing all those kind of nitty-gritty little Financial
  14. details all in a in a very precise and theoretically correct way so we want to make sure to really draw upon that you
  15. know know take this problem that really has been solved in finance and apply it in this you know marketing domain you
  16. know where you perhaps uh some of the financial details have been a little bit looser one of the really interesting
  17. aspects of This research is that we did this valuation exercise for Dish Networks big publicly traded company
  18. many people especially in the US would have heard of it the most interesting part about it is that we have had no
  19. contact with anyone at Dish Network I have never exchanged emails phone calls gotten data from anyone at dish this is
  20. using purely publicly available data so the data that we use anybody could get access to uh and in fact the methods
  21. that we're using are fairly common and transparent as well so there's really no secret sauce black magic here it's just
  22. taking publicly available data reasonably wellestablished methodss but just combining them in what one might
  23. call a clever but at least thoughtful way in order to come up with this kind of valuation and because we've done it
  24. in this case for a company again that we've had no contact with there's no reason why we couldn't repeat this
  25. exercise for other companies that make similar kinds of data available yeah the other thing that we're going to do to
  26. kind of capitalize on you know we think is a very fundamental methodology here is make all this available you know both
  27. we're going to be collecting data not only on Dish Network but also on many other companies that also disclose uh
  28. the sort of metrics that we need to perform customer-based corporate valuation so we're going to release the
  29. data make that available to everyone so they can perform the same exercises themselves and also release the
  30. methodology so that people can actually Implement these models too you we really
  31. want to democratize this and make this kind of core concept of valuing the company by valuing the customers of
  32. widespread yeah so we decided to perform work on Dish Network really kind of by happen stance uh there was no cherry
  33. picking involved we didn't say let's find all the companies that this works for and then Whittle it down to the ones
  34. where our model fits no you we basically just pick dish just because it was one of the first companies that you know we
  35. happened to find a decently long time series for we actually didn't even know how long the time series was when we
  36. first began uh working on the company so we definitely have a very kind of I almost call it like a pipeline type
  37. procedure for whittling down and identifying companies that you know you could perform this analysis on uh I
  38. think that process in and of itself has been quite interesting basically we identify Universe of companies there's
  39. all the compan in the stock market and some percentage of them basically say words in their filings specifically the
  40. 10K and the 10 q that indicate that they may release customer data the sort of customer metrics that that we would need
  41. so we identify all those companies and we then go down and perform this validation step where we kind of Whittle
  42. those companies down to the list that actually disclosed the metrics and now we have a team of uh great Wharton
  43. students here in undergrad as well as a a few colleagues in India who've been working with us to actually turn that
  44. into raw data sets for each of those each of those companies so dish is just one example but uh there's many others
  45. we found at least 35 that um also disclose the sort of data that we would need to to fit these models for so the
  46. real key here would be what kinds of statements companies put out about the the number or the nature of their
  47. customers it could be how many customers they've acquired or how many customers they have at the end of the period some
  48. companies will go further and say something about their retention rate or their churn rate and and some kind of
  49. derived measure that that take some of the raw count data and turns it into some kind of more diagnostic metric we
  50. would rather work with the raw data we just want to know how many customers came in how long they stayed around how
  51. many were there at any given point in time uh right now there are absolutely no standards for disclosing any of this
  52. data or how it would be disclosed one of the things that we want to do is to start toate create some of those
  53. standards it's not the objective of this particular paper but if we can shine light on the value of these customer
  54. metrics and how they can be useful to marketers to finance people to people throughout organizations then maybe
  55. we'll start to have a conversation about which metrics would be reported how they
  56. would be defined how often they would be reported uh and standards around the the
  57. derived metrics that come off of them as well so it's very very early and none of
  58. that has really happened yet in any kind of formal way but we're hoping that this
  59. is the first step in that direction uh I'd say the big one is the procedure really does work you know you can
  60. perform this you can project out the cash flows but now we're augmenting that you know kind of core financial model
  61. that you would use if you were just working at an investment Bank incorporate this customer metric data
  62. and use that to get an even more precise estimate of how much these companies are
  63. worth we arrived at a price that was within something on the order of 5% of what the company had been trading at at
  64. the time they disclosed uh the filing that we would have used to train our model on so we were very happy with the
  65. fact that you know without really any sort of jimming around with the numbers uh we were able to come up with a very
  66. sensible valuation for the firm uh there were a number of other interesting findings you know for example you really
  67. do need to allow for the fact that different customers are are different from each
  68. other you have some who are valuable some who are are not so valuable you some who want to leave immediately and
  69. some who are going to stay around for for a very very long period of time so even though these companies don't
  70. disclose this sort of data you know we were able to infer that dish for example they had a kind of a hardcore loyal
  71. segment of about you know 15% of the customers that have been around for over 10 years just very very long term so by
  72. allowing for different customers to have different values uh we arrived at a much
  73. higher valuation than we would have had we done kind of the standard thing within marketing which is to kind of
  74. assume that all customers are kind of like the average customer customer that would kind of leave you with a price
  75. that's much much lower than you know what the company had been selling for at the time anyone who knows my work knows
  76. that I celebrate heterogenity I love to find and exploit and explain and talk about the importance of differences
  77. across customers this project is quite different because we have no direct indications of heterogeneity we have no
  78. ability to track individual customers to say oh this one left after a month this
  79. one left after 10 years we have no data like that we just have aggregated counts
  80. of how many customers came in at a given time and how many were present at at the
  81. end of a given period we need to infer the heterogeneity we need to fit models to this very poor very sparse overly
  82. aggregated data and infer our best guess about how the customers differ from each
  83. other not only is that essential for us to come up with accurate valuations but it leads to all kinds of very very
  84. useful Diagnostics that managers whether it's of Dish Network or another firm could really make great decisions from
  85. so for instance we think about the 8020 rule that a small fraction of our customers are going to capture a
  86. disproportionate value from the corporation it's it's a really valid concept I spend a lot of my time trying
  87. to take a company's internal data to try to uncover the 8020 rule is it really as
  88. concentrated as 8020 or maybe it's it's less concentrated than that in this case
  89. we don't have the data to do that but we do it anyway because we're building really good models on the sparse data we
  90. can still make inferences about how long different kinds of customers have stayed
  91. around we find out in this particular case our best guess is that it's it's far less concentrated than 8020 but
  92. still there's a good deal of het gen8 and if we ignore it our valuations and our ability to make kind of action
  93. oriented statements about the company would be way off one of the most interesting
  94. conclusions from our work actually doesn't appear in the paper in a lot of the work that I do we like to make hold
  95. out forecast let's look at the models that we've built and project what sales or whatever is going to be in the future
  96. and see how well we do and we tend to do pretty well but in this case besides just coming up with with forecasts on
  97. our own there already exists a universe of forecasts which is to say Wall Street
  98. analysts so we have thousands of of Wall Street analysts or at least dozens of people who on a very regular basis are
  99. making statements about what the earnings of Dish Network or any publicly traded company is going to be one
  100. quarter two quarter sometimes two years from from now well we can compare our models against their own models or
  101. judgment or forecast and keep in mind these are people whose jobs depend on coming up with reasonably accurate
  102. forecasts so one of the things that we did and again because the paper is so rich there's so much going on we
  103. actually didn't include it in there but we're always happy to talk about it is we compared our own forecast to those of
  104. the Wall Street analysts and on average they were actually considerably more accurate uh as showing that not to say
  105. that the Wall Street analysts do a bad job but some of these very simple marketing models applied to relatively
  106. simple sparse data can do at least a good a job as folks who have access to the CEO and and and and uh and data that
  107. that we couldn't even imagine having yeah the Crux of this work is really coming up with customer lifetime values
  108. so we're going to take our crystal ball out and we're going to project forward what every customer is going to do into
  109. the infinite future and you know really that's kind of what's driving this model
  110. for you know what revenues are going to be and thus what the stock price is going to be and what's most surprising
  111. is that even when we're making such short-term forecast we're able to do so well you know so essentially to come up
  112. with a stock price that's more of a long-term game but we're actually able to do very well uh kind of doing
  113. short-term predictions as well so that was definitely very striking to me I've been spending a lot of time
  114. lately talking about customer centricity trying to get companies to understand there's gold in them their Hills when it
  115. comes to the customer data and it can not only improve their marketing practices but pretty much every part of
  116. the organization we can make better decisions about how our sales people are doing about what kind of products we
  117. develop how well our production people are doing and on the finance side as well so for me this idea of
  118. customer-based corporate valuation has been kind of a a Holy Grail I've been going after that if I can win over the
  119. CFO and other people who are running the finance accounting and and control parts
  120. of the business then I can get these strategic ideas of customer centricity to spread much more broadly much more
  121. impactfully throughout the organization so for me it it really is reaching out and saying hey Finance guys a lot of the
  122. stuff that I've been talking about to the marketing people it's relevant for you too and it will help you make better
  123. decisions about your company and maybe your competitors and so there I've been really happy to see the results but of
  124. course it's much more than just that yeah one of the other kind of practical implications is you kind of just
  125. speaking from a financial standpoint I've been a hedge fund for a number of years before coming back seeing the
  126. light and going to to Academia so you can take the warten kit out of Finance but you can't take the finance out of
  127. the Wharton kid uh but you could definitely construct some sort of a trading strategy to be able to exploit
  128. this data systematically across all the companies that disclose it so again there's on the order of you know say 00
  129. companies let's say uh in the entire universe who disclose enough data to be able to construct some sort of
  130. customer-based valuation model uh the idea would be you could find some companies that seem overvalued and some
  131. that seem undervalued uh just by the results that the models entail for each of those individual companies so buy the
  132. ones that are cheap sell the ones that are expensive you know you're not taking on any any real risk U I think such a
  133. strategy could be potentially very interesting and in turn that makes it very interesting for the executives of
  134. those firms knowing that you know people are buying and selling their stocks based on this information so the whole
  135. idea of standardizing these metrics making sure that you're improving the the health of your business kind of from
  136. a a Bottoms Up way you know making sure your customer metrics are strong I think
  137. it just reinforces something that they really probably know they should be doing in any case as Dan mentioned
  138. there's all kinds of interesting hedge fund possibilities and a lot of folks who are managing hedge funds or working
  139. with corporate valuation other ways have been looking very carefully at this work
  140. I want to say right now that I'm a marketing guy I have no intention of developing a hedge fund if other folks
  141. want to take this research and do it that's great I'll find that really rewarding even if I don't have a piece
  142. of it for me it's it's more about corporate strategy more generally it's more about making better use of the data
  143. assets that we have for me the big payoff would be if if folks with hedge funds and other investors go pounding on
  144. the doors of other public corporation saying You must reveal some of these other uh customer oriented metrics that
  145. we can't make the right decisions unless you do so and maybe for accounting standards boards to start to to Make
  146. Some Noise about that as well so if we can change the kind of data that's being put out there and the kind of
  147. conversations that are having Beyond just the making money thing I want to change business practices and and the
  148. kinds of data that we look at and the way that we use it say one other very practical implication is there's a whole
  149. stream budding stream of research about basically if I'm going to spend uh marketing dollars to acquire customers
  150. should I take that hit on my income statement immediately or should I capitalize that as an asset because I'm
  151. acquiring these customers who are worth a lot of money uh you know part of our research is showing just how valuable
  152. these customers are and one of the implications is they're going to stay around for a very long period of time so
  153. we come up with an estimate that the average customer at dish is going to remain a customer for about 5.5 years
  154. that's that's very very long and you have some customers who are going to be around for over 10 years so if I'm going
  155. to spend subscriber acquisition expense dollars yeah I really I'm investing in an asset you know these customers are
  156. assets but they're not acknowledged as such so I think over 80% of Dish's subscriber acquisition costs are
  157. immediately expensed um and as a result you know they kind of take the hit and of profits don't look as good in the
  158. short term so you know there's been work by people like Shuba shason at Boston University uh who are kind of saying
  159. that doesn't really jive with the underlying economics of the business if I'm going to spend money and I'm going
  160. to basically acquire an asset uh I should be able to recognize the asset and kind of have the expense associated
  161. with the asset bleed away as the as the assets value bleeds away so you know we think that this kind of dovetails very
  162. nicely with that stream of research we see these ginormous Acquisitions taking place in many cases
  163. where where one company is buying another largely because of their customer base so you can think about
  164. when Facebook bought what's app or just endless rumors about Yahoo and AOL we're
  165. just buying the customer base but what are those customers worth well that's what this research is all about and it's
  166. interesting to see sometimes in the Press you'll see kind of back of the envelope calculations about what One
  167. customer base is worth and they're appalling the the the analyses that they're doing are terrible the numbers
  168. that they're coming up with are way way off so we like the idea that people are are having that kind of conversation but
  169. we want to make it a little bit more educated we want the answers to those questions to be as rigorous as the kinds
  170. of things that we would expect to see in a conversation about Finance and Accounting not kind of lightweight
  171. approximations that might be Associated more with marketing yeah so one example that's been in the news lately is kind
  172. of on the topic Dish Network uh they're in the news about potentially being acquired or merging with other company
  173. so you know they've been in the news themselves of you trying to find a partner in some way to move forward so I
  174. think this is a perfect example of how customer-based Corporate valuation could be useful actually for the company that
  175. that you know we specifically are looking at now our research is all about valuing the customers so all these other
  176. assets that the company may have that you know really aren't coming from the value of the customers we'll leave that
  177. to the to the finance guys but specifically for the value of the customers we think there's real gold in
  178. basically looking at them kind of the way that that we are and all the better if we had internal company data we could
  179. just make those you know uh forecasts even more precise but you know we think even with this Network itself there's
  180. definitely real potential to think about it in this way yeah I'd say perhaps one of the
  181. biggest misperceptions that we've seen is not acknowledging the Paramount importance of the value of the customer
  182. to the value of the firm really establishing that link and then just focusing on the value of the customers
  183. I'd say perhaps one of the most striking examples of this is just in the accounting rules themselves so if a
  184. company was to buy a chair and put it right down over here like we're sitting in now they would be able to capitalize
  185. that as an asset on their balance sheet and they don't recognize an expense immediately but if I was to spend money
  186. to acquire a customer that customer doesn't show up anywhere they're called an intangible asset and one of the
  187. interesting byproducts of our research is that for Dish example for example these customers are expected to
  188. basically stay with the firm for about 5.5 years so they have very very long useful lives and in fact dish in
  189. particular their example of the chair is is the actual dish itself so the money that they spend on these dishes that you
  190. see uh they're able to capitalize and they have a useful life of only four years so actually you have this kind of
  191. striking example It's Like A Tale of Two Worlds that you have this kind of inert
  192. object that has a short useful life I'm able to capitalize that but you know here are these valuable customers that
  193. are generating cash flow over very long periods of time and I need to expense that immediately so we think that's
  194. you know really something that should be looked into more carefully another important point that the paper addresses
  195. would be the the gap or I'd rather say the Synergy between marketing and finance that that marketers will often
  196. talk about this idea of customers as assets we often say almost just in a purely conceptual way if we add up the
  197. value of the customers boom we get the value of the corporation and and while it's it's a nice idea we haven't seen
  198. work so far that has really won over the Finance and Accounting Community say yeah you know what there there really is
  199. something there now I'm happy to say that there have been a few Mavericks in Finance and Accounting who have been
  200. saying some of these words but it hasn't really become mainstream yet we're hoping that this paper not because it's
  201. coming out of marketing but just because of the of of the rigor involved on the data side on the analysis on the
  202. substantive implications is going to win over broad interest from folks in all different business disciplines and say
  203. you know what the marketing folks really do have something to add to the Finance
  204. and Accounting conversation and of course Finance and Accounting have a lot to add to marketing if we can break down
  205. stereotypes if we can break down silos and make everybody across the organization not only smarter but but
  206. looking at the same kinds of metrics then that's got to be a great thing for shareholders so all the work thus far
  207. has basically been to value a single company so we lay out a framework and then we apply it to a company we want to
  208. show in the next paper that essentially you can apply this across many many many
  209. companies along two Dimensions you know one it's not just rehashing the same analysis that we did for one company you
  210. know a 100 times over it's really that there's a whole broad spectrum of data availability these different companies
  211. some that have disclosed a lot some that have disclosed very little and there's actually a whole heck of a lot of
  212. information that you can learn about those companies that may not have disclosed very much when you kind of
  213. look at the patterns across companies so we want to bring all those companies together in what they call a basian
  214. hierarchical model and be able to fill in a lot more of the blanks for companies where the data is not so good
  215. and apply this in a systematic way across all of them simultaneously another big question is
  216. what metrics should be disclosed right now we're limited by what companies such as Dish Network choose to disclose but
  217. are those the right kinds of metrics that investors should be demanding and would it be the same kinds of metrics
  218. for every kind of business so an important caveat of this work is that we've only looked at companies that
  219. operate in a contractual setting where we sign customers up they pay on some regular basis and then they go and the
  220. company knows that they left it's observable churn so this model applies to pretty much any contractual setting
  221. and that's great but there's many companies out there such as Amazon or a grocery store where there's no formal
  222. contract where people just kind of buy things on an occasional basis and then there's this long Gap and the company is
  223. left wondering is that customer gone or are they just taking a snooze between purchases if you're in a non-contractual
  224. setting what would be the right kind of data that should be disclosed again if you're an investor in a non-contractual
  225. company and you're pounding on the door to that company uh what data are you going to be demanding for them to
  226. disclose it's going to be different kinds of metrics so we want to have a broader understanding about what are the
  227. right kinds of metrics that should be disclosed in different kinds of business settings and then of course what kind of
  228. analysis would we lay on top of it in order to do the corporate valuation [Music]

Brief Summary

The episode covers integrating customer metrics into corporate valuation using Dish Network as a case study.

Key points

  • Customer-Based Corporate Valuation. This paper combines corporate and customer valuation to determine a company's worth.
  • Democratizing Valuation Methods. The researchers aim to make their valuation methods and data available to everyone.
  • Valuing Customer Lifetime. The research estimates the average customer at Dish will remain for about 5.5 years.
  • Rigorous Valuation Standards. The goal is to establish rigorous standards for customer data disclosure in finance.
  • Valuing Customers vs. Assets. The discussion highlights the disparity in how companies value customers compared to physical assets.
  • A Tale of Two Worlds. An intriguing comparison between the valuation of customers and physical assets.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes